Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to wonder what Russia is up to in Ireland..

463 replies

Chamomiltea · 10/03/2022 21:59

Reading this was a shock, given recent events... www.rte.ie/news/primetime/2022/0310/1285699-russian-embassy-orwell-road-irish-government/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
DownNative · 11/03/2022 09:05

@Blackcatsocks

ROI, Ireland and Éire are acceptable names for Ireland. Southern Ireland is not. We are not defined by the partition of our island.
Except for two things:
  1. there are many who insist that only "Ireland" is acceptable.

  2. the people of the entire island ARE defined by partition.

SoItWas · 11/03/2022 09:04

When Boris Johnson didn't know he was at a party Hmm

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 11/03/2022 09:04

@donquixotedelamancha

Am I the only one surprised that Orwell Road is in Dun Laoghaire Rathdown? I thought it was in South Dublin.

Please don't call it South Dublin, that's offensive. There is just North Dublin and Dublin.

Grin Grin Grin

That reminds me of the time I met someone from Dublin (while I was living in London) and I mentioned something about a north/south divide in Dublin. She said she'd always thought there was an east/west divide. So I asked where she originated from in Dublin and she said "Howth". Grin

Blackcatsocks · 11/03/2022 09:01

ROI, Ireland and Éire are acceptable names for Ireland. Southern Ireland is not. We are not defined by the partition of our island.

MargaretBall · 11/03/2022 08:59

Bit of a tangent there but to answer the OP’s question, yeah they are spying for sure and setting up interception systems but then diplomatic staff don’t just sit around eating Ferrero Rocher all day , they gather information, set up networks etc. it just becomes a problem when it’s a nefarious embassy of a country with a policy of whipping up public dissent to create division to destabilise, undermining European economies and union etc

DownNative · 11/03/2022 08:57

Vis a vis "occupied 6". This is something I simply ignored as it's ahistorical and pretty transparent what the poster was trying to do.

Adults can ignore such things, you know.

Most people don't use official names if countries. They use popular shorthand.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/03/2022 08:55

[quote Bintymcbintface]@ochonagusochonoh The island of Ireland is two different countries, Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland[/quote]
Good God. I can only assume geography was not one of your better subjects at school.

To paraphrase - There are none so ignorant as those who will not learn.

DownNative · 11/03/2022 08:51

[quote borntobequiet]At any rate, its the ROI posters who've derailed the thread

Facts are important, and the naming of the separate parts of the island of Ireland particularly so given the general ignorance of the UK population, some of whom still think that Ireland is part of the UK.
Andrew Bridgen, Tory MP and prominent Brexiter, claimed in 2018 that being English entitled him to claim an Irish passport.

[/quote] The example of Andrew Brigden is irrelevant here as the derailment has occurred precisely because several ROI posters took "offence" at the name used by a Northern Ireland poster. Hmm

The South started calling itself "Ireland" as part of its "One island, one country" mantra. In fact, the constitution of the South from 1937 to 1999 maintained that Northern Ireland is their "national territory" which is illogical in international law contexts. Russia and China have the same kind of logic vis a vis Ukraine and Taiwan.

Despite the change in the ROI constitution, many citizens in the Republic continue to insist on the old, outdated territorial claim over Northern Ireland. This is seen in the name they use - "Ireland".

Hence, it's pretty inappropriate to call the southern state "Ireland" which I don't.

Rather amusingly, there are a good number of Irish Republicans who logically assert that the Republic of Ireland is NOT "Ireland" since partition is still a political reality.

Gerry Adams is one - "The Louth TD called on "the government and others to stop describing this state as Ireland".

"This is not Ireland. Its title is the Republic of Ireland. Ireland is the entire island as we all know," Mr Adams said."

www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/republic-of-ireland/the-republic-is-not-ireland-gerry-adams-tells-coveney-38303311.html

So, the insistence on "Ireland" from the DeValera Government onwards is based on a sense of territorial claim over Northern Ireland itself. And is rather contrary to the GFA.

Furthermore, it's ridiculous some ROI posters assert that it's Éire only if one is speaking Gaelic. This convention doesn't exist anywhere else in the world and anyone can continue to call it Éire if they wish.

It's in the ROI constitution after all.

SunscreenCentral · 11/03/2022 08:51

I suppose it makes a nice change for him from mowing down homeless people in tents 😑

LookItsMeAgain · 11/03/2022 08:50

@SlatternIsMyMiddleName

“Occupied 6 counties”. Give me strength!
I wrote it specifically that way to see if it was picked up by anyone as to how it could be perceived as being offensive. It's not correct to call the 6 counties of Northern Ireland as 'occupied', nor is it correct to call the remaining 26 counties "Southern Ireland". That is all.

I'll get my coat and try and cross the moat to Cork Grin

In an effort to get the conversation back on track I love the idea of Dermot Bannon doing "Rooms to Improve" and going WAYYYYY over budget and I loved it when the Garda car was parked across the gates of the Russian Embassy, all decked out in it's vibrant blue and yellow colours which happen to be the very same (if a bit more vibrant) as the flag of Ukraine!!!!

SunscreenCentral · 11/03/2022 08:49

I'm shook that Eoghan Murphy, Minister for Absolutely No Housing, Like None actually managed to do ONE useful thing in his political life before he slid back under a rock "moved on" to new pastures

FlyingIsEasy · 11/03/2022 08:48

There are international standards for how to refer to countries so as not to upset or disrespect anyone.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/open-standards-for-government/country-codes

The global list has
United Kingdom
Ireland

Within the United Kingdom the break-downs are
England
Northern Ireland
Scotland
Wales

Anything else depends on the context and who is doing the talking, but using "Ireland" and "Northern Ireland" is the way least likely to upset or disrespect anyone so it is what I use.

MargaretBall · 11/03/2022 08:45

Ireland absolutely did not pay any ransom to the hackers, that’s a total piece of fake news.
Ireland has limited exposure to Russian money/ investment
It’s not credible to suggest any government party has links to Russian money or have acted in their favour , have a think about what the Irish government have been up to in the past few weeks in terms of supporting sanctions, visas and using their role on the UN and diplomatic links. And of course Ireland currently holds influential positions in the EU.
Certain independent MEPs have more have more questionable voting records if you have a look.
Ireland has always been a fertile space for spies - it’s perfectly placed geographically and socially between USA, Britain and Europe with strong personal and political connections to all three . The activity for example during 2nd WW - on one side quietly providing information to help with d day landing, code breaking , communications for the allies, then on the other there were some nazis running around Dublin trying to get a foot hold.
And finally the name - as PP have pointed out the name is Ireland, may be described as Rep of Ireland . It’s well recorded why using diminutive names is designed to diminish the status of states ( putting the in front of Ukraine is the obvious example of misnaming)and why the use of Eire/ Southern Ireland or even the free state is loaded with sensitivity.

LizzieAnt · 11/03/2022 08:45

Completely understand where you're coming from Puppalicious, haven't at all forgotten that the name was originally for the 32 counties (though I don't think the intention was ever to confuse as DownNative suggests?) Still, Southern Ireland is one that rankles, so best avoided I think.
This is quite the derail, isn't it?

Owieeee · 11/03/2022 08:35

@SlatternIsMyMiddleName are you trying to dispute the fact that northern Ireland was occupied by British forces, that Catholics had, until relatively recently very little rights in their own divolved parliament which was predominantly Unionist?

Owieeee · 11/03/2022 08:32

Southern Ireland isn't an acceptable term, the south of the island are counties in the south ....
This is the legacy of British forces who invaded and occupied Ireland , a bit like Russia and the Ukraine.

SlatternIsMyMiddleName · 11/03/2022 08:30

“Occupied 6 counties”. Give me strength!

DownNative · 11/03/2022 08:29

[quote Chamomiltea]Reading this was a shock, given recent events... www.rte.ie/news/primetime/2022/0310/1285699-russian-embassy-orwell-road-irish-government/[/quote]
Nothing to worry about given the ROI Government has stopped those plans.

It's clear the Russians were planning for a cyberware base to target the UK and the EU as well as cutting them all off from the United States via the Transatlantic cables.

Prevented. Nothing much can be said.

Puppalicious · 11/03/2022 08:26

I don’t really care about a United Ireland or get upset about the “occupied 6 counties”, just explaining why it is not intuitive for Northerners to use Ireland to refer only to that part of the island of Ireland where they do not live.

Puppalicious · 11/03/2022 08:24

If Putin gets his way and Ukraine is partitioned, with one side called Ukraine, and the other (Russian controlled) part called Eastern Ukraine, would posters here have a go when those in the Eastern Ukraine struggled to use Ukraine in a way that excluded where they lived? I do always use Ireland when in (RO)Ireland, but when in NI, intuitively, it always needs a distinguisher. Usually, down South, in the South, or….Donegal….Those posters who regularly derail threads like this forget that originally in the Constitution, which called the state Ireland, it was referred to all 32 counties. The country was not renamed when the claim to the 6 counties was relinquished, maybe it should have been?

borntobequiet · 11/03/2022 08:22

At any rate, its the ROI posters who've derailed the thread

Facts are important, and the naming of the separate parts of the island of Ireland particularly so given the general ignorance of the UK population, some of whom still think that Ireland is part of the UK.
Andrew Bridgen, Tory MP and prominent Brexiter, claimed in 2018 that being English entitled him to claim an Irish passport.

MaudieandMe · 11/03/2022 08:22

@Frazzled50yrold

'P.s. Southern Ireland is generally not considered an acceptable term to refer the the country of Ireland' Considering I live in Northern Ireland I consider Southern Ireland to be a perfectly acceptable term.
I live in County Cork in southern Ireland within the REPUBLIC OF IRELAND.

Maybe you failed geography at school?

Crocodilesoup · 11/03/2022 08:19

"Southern Ireland" is commonly used among Protestants in NI. It's not the correct term.
Just as "the North of Ireland" is commonly used among Catholics, even though it's not the correct term.

kittensinthekitchen · 11/03/2022 08:17

Btw I've mostly lived in SE England

@ScrambledSmegs

Surely you mean SE Southern Scotland Grin

DownNative · 11/03/2022 08:16

@Feelingthepinch22

The military drills, hse hacking & now this... Sounds like the Russians are very prominent on our lovely island... Did anyone hear Christy from Alan on the late late last Fri? He said our position (as in geographical location) was very precarious & we could be used as a launch pad for nuclear weapons! Scared the bejaysus out of me... Why do the 30 odd russian diplomats need what's effectivly a bunker? Why seperate water & ESB? What the hell are they planning? They couldn't invade us & take over, we're a neutral country...
They couldn't invade us & take over, we're a neutral country...

Do you think the Russians would care about that if they wanted to invade the Republic of Ireland?

No, the reason they won't think about invading the south is because the skies and waters there is protected by the UK's RAF. The Royal Navy also protects the ROI seawaters.

There is an agreement between the UK and ROI Governments on this. Therefore, any Russian attack would constitute an attack on a NATO member state.

Simple.