Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - help me with some perspective on this?

489 replies

floatsomeandjetsum · 10/03/2022 20:50

Ok, here are the main points,

Unmarried to partner, 20 years. 3 children with him.
I've always earned well but in a career that's been hard and incredibly stressful. It's been a slog and come at a cost to my health.

He's a fairly low earner, more a lifestyle business than anything.

I've paid all childcare and school fees, all holiday clubs, music lessons etc. basically everything for the children I've paid for. All hobbies etc.

We've rented for 10 years whilst property prices have almost escaped us.

I've always saved hard, at great personal expense in that I've gone without in order to do that.

Here's the problem - I've bought a house, which was always our plan. It's almost bought with cash from my savings (no inheritance and no contributions from him) and I've secured a small mortgage.

He hates it and will not get on board, he's basically saying it's him or the house.

Can I have a reality check please? He's contributing absolutely nothing to a big, beautiful detached 4 bed house, with a small mortgage (that I'll pay off in a few years) but it's costing me our relationship!!

I feel so beaten. What's going on here???

OP posts:
Plinkyplonkyplonk · 11/03/2022 07:22

Farming is a lifestyle, no cash in bank. I understand he would struggle to give that up,it's just something in your blood- which is usually why farmers pair up with other farmers as it takes another similar person to tolerate it, it's not about money.

I don't think you are suited- you have different aspirations, you'll never agree on this I don't think.

Ikeptgoing · 11/03/2022 07:18

If he wasn't paying any rent towards their current rented property he would indeed be a cocklodger. He clearly can't afford even his fair equal share of their current lifestyle and housing/ family costs anyway.

Did everyone miss the very witty "crop lodger" phrase used earlier by a PP?! I thought that very apt.

Ikeptgoing · 11/03/2022 07:15

rebekuh where did OP say he pays all the rent on their current property and that he is subsiding her? She didn't. She said the opposite, she explains she is financially supporting him by far the bulk.

Ikeptgoing · 11/03/2022 07:13

I mistyped I meant

She's buying as much as she can afford and it's still less than her unrealistic DP who isn't financially contributing wants. That's a totally ridiculous position that he is taking.

spotcheck · 11/03/2022 07:13

@Valeriekat

He doesn't have a job he has a hobby which you have to subsidise.
He's a FARMER!!!!! He pays most the rent on the house which is attached to the farm. He is helping OP be in a position to save, which is not acknowledged.
rebekuh · 11/03/2022 07:13

After making sacrifices to put thee
Kids through private school you need to look after your own future too

You cant rent forever. The house is an investment for your future life beyond kids and your retirement

You cant keep cash in the bank. Your partner sounds as if he is burying his head in the sand and dragging you down too

Ikeptgoing · 11/03/2022 07:10

I think what some recent PPs are missing is that OP can't afford to purchase a more expensive property with wish list of land that her DP wants her to. It's weird that some PPs are suggesting she pays less for a house !!! She's buying as much as she can afford and it's still less than her unrealistic DP who isn't financially contributing can afford (he doesn't pay all the rent on their current property btw where did PPs get that from?! She pays all schooling and childcare, and significantly other rent/bills rent and She's subsidising him already for the lifestyle he wants).

It's irrelevant that she has chosen Quality of life private school and ponies for their family as DP and DCs wanted that too and that is about providing good life tor their DCs, as they grow up that she funded. He's not even a SAHP. She does most of it in every area.

This is about a man who hasn't had to financially plan, now unreasonably wanting what he can't have and cannot afford and isn't paying anything towards anyway.

He is in no position to torpedo his children's future stability and should not try to do so as someone who should put his children first over his whims, like a good parent would do.

Life is about accepting there are sometimes compromises and making the best of what you have. OP is doing so, DP is not. Gosh a £700k 4 bed home in a lovely village is not a huge compromise!!! I'm sure OP would love same unrealistic wish list as DP, but someone has to be the adult and reasonable parents here.

Blinkingbatshit · 11/03/2022 07:08

Why are people piling on to say it was OP’s singular decision to send the kids private? - her DP could’ve been equally insistent, we haven’t had that clarified! Is his fantasy farm in a specific area? This would also demonstrate his lack of realism - farms don’t come up that often and the opportunity to buy what he wants (even if you had the money) may never present itself.

rebekuh · 11/03/2022 07:05

You sound awesome. Well done for your achievements

Would he have preferred to buy a bigger house and have a joint Mortgage? I suspect he feels inadequate that he's totally dependent on you but that's not your fault

Also remember that men always resist change so he may soften to the idea of your house

I think you should mentally prepare yourself to separate from him. You cant rent forever

Mummadeze · 11/03/2022 07:04

I get it. My relationship dynamic is the same and in your position I would just buy the house, put up with the sulking and do what you know is best for you and the children. He can still do his farming. He will probably come round. When you have worked this hard and taken responsibility for everything you get to a point where you do want to do what’s best for you because you have earned it.

HopelesslyOptimistic · 11/03/2022 07:03

He contributes nothing, remind me why you are with this guy?

GabriellaMontez · 11/03/2022 07:00

The problem is he wants to rent forever. (Buying what he wants isn't feasible)

You want to live in your own home.

If you'd presented your question like this you'd have had different responses.

Is there a compromise for him? Another house? Can you buy a property as an investment but continue to rent? Would that satisfy your need for security?

Would a less expensive house leave you with less pressure? Who is pushing you to buy such an expensive house? (Not him? He doesn't like it)

You say he's a good dad. But also that he does nothing for the children and is never there on holidays etc what does he do that's so great?

You'd be totally reasonable to leave him at this point. Sounds like he has his own goals and interests.

But do you want to find a compromise? If so back out of the house. It doesn't matter what your friends and family think.

UsernameInTheTown · 11/03/2022 06:58

The house would win no question. Well done on all your hard work paying off. Xxx

LAMPS1 · 11/03/2022 06:56

It’s unreasonable if you want him to change to a soul destroying (for him at least ) 9 to 5 career when he doesn’t want to.

But, and it’s a big but, maybe he has to if he wants to stay in a relationship with you.
It sounds like farming rented land isn’t financially sustainable.
Or is it ?
Maybe he’s knocking himself out working all hours and is financially a bit daft allowing you to always pick up when he can’t pay all the rent or maybe he has saved more than you know about.

You have to accept that you can’t have the relationship with him you dream about. By moving to the new house and leaving him to continue to farm the land and make ends meet without your financial support, you will both find out if he can make it pay or he can’t.

It’s sad after all that time together, you aren’t really together at all.
So, if he won’t talk and plan properly for a good future, I think you do have to make this move to the new house to force the issue and find out where you stand with him. He has to realise he can’t keep following an unrealistic dream at your expense and ill-health. Continuing to enable him to waste your hard earned money has to stop now. You need a break. Go for the new house.
Good luck !

Sarcobaleno · 11/03/2022 06:53

@sadpapercourtesan

So you're resentful because you're flogging yourself to earn more and more and more money, and he's resentful because you treat him like another child instead of an equal partner.

You should take responsibility for your own exhaustion - your career is your choice, not his. Nobody needs a £700k house or ponies or private education. They're your priorities and your choices.

If you don't like or respect your partner, who clearly doesn't share your drive to amass as much cash as possible for he dies, then do the decent thing and split up with him.

100% this. You need to take responsibility for the impact of your choices. If you're lifestyle based choices are causing you so much stress then change them, and if you choose not to that's on you.

It sounds like you are doing way more than your fair share, that must be really frustrating. But how you can buy a house without explicit agreement from your partner and justify by saying you are not married is mad. I can fully understand his upset, he's your partner not your child. If you don't like the dynamic of your relationship, change that too.

Shoxfordian · 11/03/2022 06:50

It sounds to me like you’ve sacrificed a lot for him to do what he likes all these years: yes farming is necessary, it’s not necessary for him though. Have you told him how stressed and unhappy your work makes you? It seems like you do all the housework and childcare as well- he really doesn’t contribute much. Buy the house op

Hurrylittlefroggy · 11/03/2022 06:49

I'd love a farm and not have to go out to work. I'd love to look after animals all day BUT I CANT because we can't afford it, it's just not a realistic ambition

Yep. You definitely look down on him. Farming is work. Really, really hard work for very little financial reward. Surely you'd know that after being together 20 years. Perhaps that would have been a realistic ambition if you hadn't prioritised luxuries like school fees, ponies and music lessons. Nobody made you make any of those choices. It's a bit shit to punish him because you chose to lead an incredibly expensive lifestyle. Are you annoyed because he prioritised job satisfaction over earning pots of money to pay for luxuries and you didn't?

Ikeptgoing · 11/03/2022 06:45

Gosh for an AIBU this is fairly evenly split in replies, which I find surprising. I guess that's what makes AIBU really helpful sometimes.

My view is YANBU OP. Your DP wants you to purchase something that is way beyond your means and unrealistic, you involved him in choosing the house and he agreed and is now sulking as himself has changed his mind. You have taken on bulk of all childcare and life's work, as well as bulk of supporting family at cost to you and he has had a wonderful life with a low paying career he chose. So he doesn't get to throw "baby out with the bath water" and make unrealistic demands now. He's not even a SAHD that enabled you to pursue your career, it's the other way round! ! You do the bulk of childcare and housework!!

I would 100% continue with this house purchase as it was the best of all the available options, you love it, and you need to buy rather than face insecurity of continuing to rent. It is what is best for the family and DCs. You will only resent losing this house and never being able to please him and his unrealistic demands. The death knell of relationship will toll anyway, so let it toll from a position of you and DCs being in a lovely secure home.

Your OP and updates are all about DP his suddenly changing his mind and demanding his wants come first at expense of your and DCs needs. He may seem a great father but that is not what a good parent does- as everyone has to accept compromise sometimes- especially when it's not their money as you operate financially separately and are not married. He didn't want to get married.

He either gets on board with this house purchase and is grateful to have a wonderful home he can live in with his family, albeit it not his dream list (gosh wouldn't we all love land and a wish list but we accept when we can't afford it!!) or he carries out his manipulative threat to leave.

I suspect DP will back down when he realises how poor a quality of life and housing he will have living back on his own again, without being financially subsidised by you. ! And it will be of his own making. But I would take that risk and think, if he leaves me over this this he is showing how selfish a man and parent he is, who puts himself before our family and I couldn't live with that . I would resent his behaviour and sulking too. And it would be a deal breaker for me.

I think you are in a few breaker situation regardless. So let him leave and he can regret it at his leisure but don't be blackmailed. You'll get over it and may find someone who is more appreciative & respectful of the independent woman you are.

Hurrylittlefroggy · 11/03/2022 06:39

I was on your side until you revealed he's a farmer and called it a lifestyle business. It's bloody hard work and the country needs farmers more than they need bankers and stuff.

You've made your choices over the last 20 years to work yourself into the ground to pay for luxuries like private school and music lessons. You didnt have to do that. Nobody made you. Unless you're scared the kids are going to waste their potential by becoming a farmer like you evidently feel your partner did. It sounds very much like you look down on him for not earning as much as you feel he should have. Sounds like you're not a partnership at all to be honest.

1AngelicFruitCake · 11/03/2022 06:33

To me it reads like

Him
Pros
Hard working
Passionate
Great Dad

Cons
Low earner
Rigid ideas
Not noticing your sacrifices

You
Pros
Hard working
Provides a lot for your family
Driven

Cons
Your own High expectations (private school)
Resentful
Martyr?

Who wanted your children to go to private school and ride ponies?

You’ve made some expensive life choices here, 3 children, private school etc. Have you both made them or have you driven them more?

Rosehugger · 11/03/2022 06:25

How about you buy a house and rent it out? Could be a good investment/security, especially if the mortgage is small.

But seriously, there needs to be a big discussion about your future together or not together. It sounds like you want different things. It sounds like your current home, though rented, is his job as well as home, which puts a totally different spin on things and I can understand the ultimatum. Decide whether you actually want any financial ties, as you have none at the moment.

lborgia · 11/03/2022 06:20

I'm interested to know what your lives were like when you met.

When you started talking about the future, living together, children, did you say what your wanted and he agreed? Obviously he told you that he wanted to be a gentleman farmer, and you agreed, but was this right at the beginning?

Because, as far as I can tell, neither of your has checked in with each other over the years, to listen, and see if it's still working.

Did he know that you were aiming for private schools, holidays, ponies? Did you grow up with those things and assume this was a basic level of expectation?

Did he do something different when your meet, and you agreed to continue with the career, promotions etc without stopping to say "I can't keep doing this, at this level"? Not when the first child was born, or after the next?

He may take 3 days off a year, but you do know that it's possible to plan ahead even if it's a long way ahead, and have others hold a farm together for a week or 2 over the years? Has he got to a point where he can't imagine spending that much time with you or the children?
Has he maybe discovered that he finds "people" difficult, and actually finds a solitary life on the farm far easier to deal with.

If he could pay the rent 10 months out of 12, what made you feel that you had to keep working to the point of breaking all those years? Most people would be happy with that, if you're both working.

If we were talking about a mortgage, and he was able to cover 75% of it, and then your job could cover the other part, plus utilities, food, presents, etc...

If you all went away for one long weekend a year, and then you took the kids away a couple of times (to family, camping, something low key), how much would you have needed to earn?

Because if you've sold a business that covers land, school fees, you only need a small mortgage now... how easy would your life be right now if you had continued to rent the place you have now, and just had a small rental property, or put some in a pension etc etc.?

I think your husband has kept quiet in a desperate hope that things would just stay the same, despite the blindingly obvious that your bar has been raised and raised, or I should say changed.

Your expectations aren't necessarily better, but they take you away from where you both started. That's fine. But obviously he just wants to keep doing what he's doing, whatever the cost to you. And you wanted, and got, a f ton out of earning so much, but now it's too much and you're barrelling on in a different direction. Only this time he's really panicking.

It's a mess.

The only answer might be to leave, but you need to acknowledge that your did all these things that you thought were important, and now you're here.

Oh, and you should know, your children would probably still be a credit to you, even if they hadn't gone to private school, or had ponies.

If the answer is that you need to sit down and talk, otherwise you're splitting up, then I hope you would both make time and space to do that. In a way that SO finds possible. If he is scared or finds it difficult to articulate his thoughts, you may need to be creative. I def recognise a lot of this from my DH, loathes confrontation, but creates confrontation by not saying what he wanted up front.

I think you may need to reconsider some of your goals too.

You very excited to tell everyone about the house, of course, it's aspirational, it's fabulous, it represents so much.

But if you genuinely want it to work with your partner, maybe you need to practise saying "oh, we've decided to leave it for a while, we've got some new ideas, and just want a bit of space to mull over a different plan". That's not embarrassing.

Good luck OP, it's a good job you're capable of being tough, you've got a way to go before your can call this sorted.

CrunchyCarrot · 11/03/2022 06:13

OP I'm afraid you've made a huge decision without first discussing it with your DP. Him just liking the house on first viewing is certainly not enough for you to go ahead and buy it without telling him! Surely you must see that? If it were me that had happened to, I would be furious and would also refuse to move.

GreenFingeredNell15 · 11/03/2022 06:09

How can DP be everything to you? You've just bought a house which he doesn't explicity want.

Grow up

Looubylou · 11/03/2022 06:04

I've read up to page 5. It's very much a drip feed. I thought it was a reverse at first. He works very hard in a low earning job. He has paid the majority of the rent for 10 years.i imagine this removed any opportunity to save. You already have ponies, that he cares about. He needs outside space for his "stuff". He doesn't sound like he has time or spare money for expensive hobbies - so is this "want" actually a need, for work stuff? I wish he had a thread, so we could hear his side of this OP. You don't get to call all the shots in a relationship, just because you earn more. He probably feels worthless and used to pay the rent and 1/2 the bills, to end up with nothing that is his, or that he has even had a choice in. I doubt he saw this as his future.

Swipe left for the next trending thread