Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - help me with some perspective on this?

489 replies

floatsomeandjetsum · 10/03/2022 20:50

Ok, here are the main points,

Unmarried to partner, 20 years. 3 children with him.
I've always earned well but in a career that's been hard and incredibly stressful. It's been a slog and come at a cost to my health.

He's a fairly low earner, more a lifestyle business than anything.

I've paid all childcare and school fees, all holiday clubs, music lessons etc. basically everything for the children I've paid for. All hobbies etc.

We've rented for 10 years whilst property prices have almost escaped us.

I've always saved hard, at great personal expense in that I've gone without in order to do that.

Here's the problem - I've bought a house, which was always our plan. It's almost bought with cash from my savings (no inheritance and no contributions from him) and I've secured a small mortgage.

He hates it and will not get on board, he's basically saying it's him or the house.

Can I have a reality check please? He's contributing absolutely nothing to a big, beautiful detached 4 bed house, with a small mortgage (that I'll pay off in a few years) but it's costing me our relationship!!

I feel so beaten. What's going on here???

OP posts:
MrKlaw · 11/03/2022 10:47

you split bills but pay for everything for the kids. But he pays most of the rent you said (10 months out of 12). If you're doing private schooling, have a cleaner, have land for ponies I'm guessing you're renting a nice house which won't be cheap.

If he has mostly covered rent, that can have allowed you more capacity to save towards the house purchase, so despite you paying for it, he's at least partly helped facilitate that yet you're the sole owner, he gets little choice in the matter. I can understand his frustration. But I would try and get over it as a roof over your head even if only 80% ideal is something that make sense and it doesn't have to be a forever home

PineappleSundays · 11/03/2022 10:40

It's hardly a hobby if he's managed to pay 90% of the rent on what I assume must be a farm (?) AND contribute toward bills.

He should definitely be more involved in parenting but all this "I've paid for all the school feels and ponies" just sounds ridiculous to me personally no one NEEDS private school and all the rest of it. It's not a necessity that OP HAD to pay for. If she's chosen to spend her huge wage on private school and horses that's fine but it's a choice. One that I don't think you can then get mad at your average earning partner for not contributing to. Most people on an average wage can't afford that!

Babyroobs · 11/03/2022 10:40

It's an odd situation. Firstly that their doesn't seem to have been any joint finances despite 20 years together and 3 kids. If he is the lower earner has he had more input in terms of looking after the kids/ stuff around the house etc ? If a man had done this and the woman was the lower earner there would be outcry that her name should be on the house deeds etc.

diddl · 11/03/2022 10:37

@BoodleBug51

It'd be the house for me.

I think he sounds horrendous, sorry.

Yup!
Kadge3042 · 11/03/2022 10:36

I don't think enough detail has been given in your op.

To me it sounds like you think you can make all the decisions because you have all the money. Many relationships have a wide gap between earnings, some people don't earn at all where the other does. It sounds like you aren't communicating, it sounds like you aren't working as a team. it sounds like you think it's all up to you. Has he contributed in other ways? Has he looked after the kids whilst you've worked? It's not all about money!

What if this was the other way round? When the male was the high earner. I think people would be calling him financially abusive!

In this house mine and Dp's money all goes into one pot for whatever we need - we aren't married either but still a team!

blueshoes · 11/03/2022 10:36

OP, think back to the time he decided to take up his all consuming hobby farming. Did you agree to that, knowing that it would take all his time away from the family without any financial benefit?

If farming is what is preventing him from going ahead with the house purchase, why shouldn't you be equally aggrieved that he boxed the family's lifestyle up into supporting his farming 'hobby' at the expense of your killing yourself at work to allow him to continue to.

If the only thing you ask for is to live in the surroundings that you have worked hard for (despite his negative financial and negligible domestic contribution), I'd say you have earned it.

Otherwise if you give up your dream house, I think it is fair that he gives up his 'dream' farming hobby and both re-visit the split of labour and duties in the marriage contract. I think this is long due and you have been bearing the brunt of it.

I would be deeply resentful of him if I were in your shoes.

PineappleSundays · 11/03/2022 10:32

"Keeping going to I can keep the show on the road" makes it sound like you're struggling to house and feed your kids on the poverty line.

The show in this instance is an extravagant lifestyle which you have chosen to lead. No one needs private schools and ponies. You're not a martyr for funding these things.

PineappleSundays · 11/03/2022 10:29

@Pluvia

I am resentful I can't help it. I'm exhausted. I'm on anti depressants because my job is so hard. I keep going so that I keep the show on the road

Oh come on, stop this martyr number. You must be earning something like £200k in order to pay for three children in school, cleaners, ponies, holidays and everything else, plus saving £50K pa. The private schools and ponies are lifestyle choices.

You say he pays the rent on your current home. I'm wondering how much that is? I'm betting you're not living in a former LA property in a grotty area. So I bet he's paying £3k+ each month in rent for you all. Which given the current average salary doesn't mean he's bringing in mere peanuts.

If you were a man, OP, complaining that your wife was only earning £30k a year at her hobby-job, you wouldn't go down well here.

This!

Sorry OP if you're so stressed with your super high earning and stressful job then scrap the private schools, ponies, cleaners and huge savings. They aren't necessities, they are choices. Choices which cost a lot of money.

I can't believe the comments on here about farming being a hobby job and the rest. How insulting.

My husband owns a successful business, he earns very well. I stay home with our DC. If he ever bought a house I wasn't on board with that I was just expected to move into without complaint I'd be off.

Dishwashersaurous · 11/03/2022 10:28

You need to separate out the issues.

  1. Your job, you're exhausted and stressed and therefore need to stop your current job.
  1. WHERE you live as a family.
  1. The finances involved.

You need to sit down as a couple and discuss what to do as a team. You need to be clear that you are quitting your job and you won't be earning anything for a while and then not much for ever after.

Therefore you need to agree, as a couple what to do.

You can't afford to carry on renting where you are.

Could you move geographically to a cheaper area to get a farm?

Could he increase earnings somehow etc etc

But you need to agree as a team

MrKlaw · 11/03/2022 10:25

lots of people don't have land for ponies - they rent stables and visit.

I'm slightly confused how long you rented for then just bougtht a 700k house with only a small mortgage paid off in a few years. sounds like you could have bought much earlier with a more normal mortgage? I mean its a good problem to have - almost fully paid off nice detached house?

Maybe its just a nose out of joint thing but its a huge purchase to have made fairly quickly and maybe he doesn't feel part of the process.

If it ticks enough boxes for you, him and your family then any small disadvantages for a 'first' house should be understood and accepted

Subbaxeo · 11/03/2022 10:23

@implantreplace

There is something very “off” about this But I can’t put my finger on it
I think that too. Who saves up 700k but still does housework, shopping, childcare, dental visits and can pay for ponies and private school but bizarrely is only just thinking they can buy a house?
bumblefeline · 11/03/2022 10:23

@implantreplace

There is something very “off” about this But I can’t put my finger on it
Yep and I don't know why people respond to this crap.
Tippexy · 11/03/2022 10:23

He's a wonderful Dad.

This actually made me chuckle out loud. He is far from a wonderful dad. Are you not reading what you’re writing in your posts??

Alliswells · 11/03/2022 10:21

@implantreplace

There is something very “off” about this But I can’t put my finger on it
Definitely.

OP couldn't buy a house because of house prices and spent money renting, buying land and ponies and paying for private schools. She works 5 evenings a week.

And now says she's saved 700k for a big swanky house that her low earner farmer dp doesn't want to move to.

Pile of shite

HappeeInParis · 11/03/2022 10:20

Not one of the women on this thread squawking about how spoilt he is would be happy if their higher-earning DH made a huge decision like this over their heads. It's not how you treat a life partner - married or otherwise.

True but equally I think people would be equally critical if someone posted on here that they had threatened to leave their higher-earning spouse unless he bought them a house with a pony paddock.

OP, everything you've posted seems so conflicted and confused. You claim to love and respect your partner but also describe his farming as a "lifestyle business" (I assumed he was selling crystals on Etsy or something!) You say he's a good dad but he never does anything. You're completely independent financially and you'd buy a house without him but are only not married because he hasn't asked...it's very odd.

It sounds as if you have perhaps got mismatched values and ways at looking at work and that your relationship has pushed you each into a more extreme version of yourself. So eg you think work is valuable if it makes money whereas he thinks it's valuable if it takes effort or fits with a particular set of values. And because of this you've had to take a more extreme position- working very hard doing a job you don't enjoy, which only makes you resent his approach even more. Meanwhile he's lost touch with the link between work and remuneration- he works hard at a job which is meaningful for him and the money is secondary- and sees you as the person who provides the cash. I wonder if he just assumes that you're naturally money-focused when actually it's in part a response to his lack of focus.

If it's worth making it work, I'd put the house on the back burner and get some couples counselling to try to understand where each of you is coming from. It sounds like the house is just a symptom of the underlying problems. OTOH if you don't feel it's worth making it work, maybe it is time to go your separate ways.

Sarcobaleno · 11/03/2022 10:19

@GabriellaMontez because she was asked why she wasn't married and her response was because he didn't ask?! She could ask if she wants to marry him?

Phobiaphobic · 11/03/2022 10:11

No, I do bulk of housework and organise and pay the cleaners.

I do all shopping.

I do all kids admin.

I pay into the children's savings, he's not even put in a tenner towards them.

I have them at the weekends when he works (he works 7 days a week because of his job).

I make sure the children have shoes on their feet and food in their bellies.

I take them to the dentist.*

OP, you know why you came here and you know what you need us to say. This is insane. Why have you been carrying this fucker for 20 years?

You know exactly what you need to do.

implantreplace · 11/03/2022 10:11

There is something very “off” about this
But I can’t put my finger on it

Natfemale · 11/03/2022 10:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/03/2022 10:07

Why should he have to be thankful you've prioritised money and private school over other life choices. Why should he have to be thankful you're working a job that stresses you out. You're not doing that for him, you're doing that because of what you want for your family and DC. STBXH blames me for his stressful job and for going into more stressful higher managerial levels because he's doing this for us. I've told him many times I'd be happy with a lot less, that I think he should take a step back if he hates his work that much. It's his view of what our life should be, his choices that are keeping him in a stressful job, I'm supposed to be grateful for something I never wanted and put up with his moods and anger, because it's caused by stress from the job he's working for us, that's not really for us, it's for him.

museumum · 11/03/2022 10:06

This thread is so sad because I see here a couple who love each other but just do not share a vision or dream of the future.

He wants a farm and I see no evidence he wouldn't be willing to live with the lifestyle/income compromises that entails.
You want a nice house and private school for the children etc. and fair play to you you've worked hard to make that happen. But I do understand how gutted he must be to see you spending your money on a house when in his mind a farm is the dream.

You both need to talk, really talk, possibly with a mediator or life coach to get this out in the open. It doesn't sound like he'll ever not dream of a farm, and that's just not your dream.

Delatron · 11/03/2022 10:04

It doesn’t make much sense. You say in your OP ‘that the property market has almost escaped you’ Yet you had a very well paid job and were squirrelling away £700k and then wasting years and money renting. Why didn’t you buy a house years ago??

Agree a lot of bizarre financial decisions.

SockFluffInTheBath · 11/03/2022 09:57

The ‘honour’ of farming aside, the OP is not seriously expected to drop her hard saved £700k into her DH’s barely profitable business is she?

SockFluffInTheBath · 11/03/2022 09:54

We went to view the property together. We made the decision to offer together.

Now he's changed his mind massively but I've started the process!!

I feel like he's dropped me in it.

So you haven’t secretly chosen and bought a house, he played along then got cold feet. I think this is important.

And I’m sorry but if he has chosen to do long hours for no money- and not for childcare reasons- then he forfeits the right to 50:50 on financial decision, read: the right to say how you spend your money. Women on here are constantly advised to maintain financial independence, he should heed that.

Pluvia · 11/03/2022 09:53

I'm astonished that farmers are given so little credit and that the lifestyle that living on a farm affords children is overlooked. What happened to all the people longing for the Yorkshire shepherdess' lifestyle?

I don't know how much it costs tenant farmers to rent their farms, but it's honourable work. Living on a working farm will give the children a good grounding in life and freedom and fresh air and independence.

Sounds to me, OP, as if he's wedded to the farming lifestyle and love of the land and you're not. It's not easy to look after animals well if you live a couple of miles away from the land you're farming. It sounds as if there's a fundamental incompatibility between you and no clear way to find a compromise.