Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - help me with some perspective on this?

489 replies

floatsomeandjetsum · 10/03/2022 20:50

Ok, here are the main points,

Unmarried to partner, 20 years. 3 children with him.
I've always earned well but in a career that's been hard and incredibly stressful. It's been a slog and come at a cost to my health.

He's a fairly low earner, more a lifestyle business than anything.

I've paid all childcare and school fees, all holiday clubs, music lessons etc. basically everything for the children I've paid for. All hobbies etc.

We've rented for 10 years whilst property prices have almost escaped us.

I've always saved hard, at great personal expense in that I've gone without in order to do that.

Here's the problem - I've bought a house, which was always our plan. It's almost bought with cash from my savings (no inheritance and no contributions from him) and I've secured a small mortgage.

He hates it and will not get on board, he's basically saying it's him or the house.

Can I have a reality check please? He's contributing absolutely nothing to a big, beautiful detached 4 bed house, with a small mortgage (that I'll pay off in a few years) but it's costing me our relationship!!

I feel so beaten. What's going on here???

OP posts:
tkwal · 11/03/2022 13:56

I just read OPS posts again and had earlier missed her point that they decided jointly to offer on the house she is currently buying. Case closed. He is being unreasonable

iPaddy · 11/03/2022 13:39

@Alliswells

"I know if I was a man and did this there would be outrage. I get that."

Yes if a high earning man did that to his dp who was a hardworking nurse there would be an absolute outcry

If they weren't married, he carried all the children in his body for 9 months, did the majority of housework and childcare and the nurse demanded that he buy her a hospital then yes, I'd add to that outcry Smile

tothemoonandbackbuses · 11/03/2022 13:23

Farm land is relatively cheap to rent.
If you wish to build on farmland you own generally you need to keep breeding livestock, live in a caravan for 5 years on site and prove you can make a living from the farm.

Blossomtoes · 11/03/2022 13:00

@Viviennemary

Of course he isn't happy with you making all the decisions because you are the one with the money. That's what is going on here.
That’s ever so tough because that’s how the world works. He who pays the piper calls the tune.
Grenlei · 11/03/2022 12:47

So you DON'T live on the farm - then your DP is paying the rent on his farm AND on a house?

Why couldn't you buy the house you currently live in if it's so beautiful and presumably your DP is quite happy there?

I don't know why I'm asking these questions as I expect there will be a smoke and mirrors answer.

As for doing things for the sake of our kids - I worked 12 hour days from when mine were tiny. But that wasn't to pay for private schools, it was to cover my mortgage and other bills, providing my children with the bare essentials. Not so that I could accrue over half a million in savings and pay 3 sets of boarding school fees.

Nickwinkle · 11/03/2022 12:47

A little sad that you're counting your marriage status as a main contributor towards your decision.

You've been together 20 years so I'm really struggle to understand why marriage would now become important at this point.

You're a long term committed couple and should be acting as such, married or not.

It's a family home so it's a family decision. If you can't see that then I do think you're BU

pickingdaisies · 11/03/2022 12:47

Good luck OP you've got some thinking to do.

floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:37

Thanks everyone- I'm checking out of this now as I think everything's been said.

Some really good advice in there which I shall reflect on. Thank you.

OP posts:
floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:34

@Grenlei

IF any of this is true...

Most farmers rent their farmhouses/ farmland I think - I only know one personally but they're tenant farmers and the farm has been in their family for several generations. It's not usually the same as renting a house. A couple of other examples I can think of, on Clarkson's Farm IIRC Jeremy C took on the running of the farm himself because it had been tenanted for years but the previous tenant got too old...ditto the family on the Yorkshire Farm rent their farm long term.

So assuming (because I can't see this has been clarified) OP and her family currently live on the farm, there's no reason why they couldn't have continued to do so indefinitely.

If the OP wanted financial security, then why not buy one or more smaller houses 10+ years ago (maybe with the money from the sale of the business as a deposit, or her first £100k of savings) and have these as BTLs? Rent would probably have paid off the mortgage by now, giving an ongoing income plus an asset which they could retire to/ sell to fund retirement.

Doing that OP wouldn't have needed to work so hard, and being around more could have dispensed with the boarding/ private school thereby saving even more money. By now she probably could have given up work entirely and just used the income from the houses.

We do not live on the farm. We rent a separate (beautiful) property that has given the kids an amazing childhood.

I wanted to do my best for the children and to give them, and my DP the best lives I could.

Them having a good life is worth my misery at work. Don't we all do things we don't like for the sake of our kids??

Honestly I just don't get why people think I'd make this up, what do you want, my full name, address and payslips? Company number? Last set of accounts? Doctors records?

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 11/03/2022 12:34

Of course he isn't happy with you making all the decisions because you are the one with the money. That's what is going on here.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 11/03/2022 12:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/03/2022 12:30

He wants more than I can give him.

Does he, though, or does he want different things?

Does he want to move and buy a house or would he choose to continue living where you are with a rent he can pay?

Does he want to dc to be boarding at expensive schools and doing expensive hobbies with the price tag that comes with this, or would he be happy with a more modest lifestyle?

If he is paying all the rent and half the bills, then his career is adequate. He is not being supported. There is nothing wrong with choosing to do a job you love that pays enough.

If he is the driving force behind the expensive lifestyle, and he expects you to half kill yourself providing this, then I agree this is very unfair and you should not have to do this.

floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:28

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave

Genuine question?

Yes, you've been asked a lot of those over the past couple of pages but are avoiding them. I wonder why. I don't really, I know why

Why not be a bit kinder? I'm a stranger to you. I was looking for help in a difficult situation, that's all.
OP posts:
Grenlei · 11/03/2022 12:27

IF any of this is true...

Most farmers rent their farmhouses/ farmland I think - I only know one personally but they're tenant farmers and the farm has been in their family for several generations. It's not usually the same as renting a house. A couple of other examples I can think of, on Clarkson's Farm IIRC Jeremy C took on the running of the farm himself because it had been tenanted for years but the previous tenant got too old...ditto the family on the Yorkshire Farm rent their farm long term.

So assuming (because I can't see this has been clarified) OP and her family currently live on the farm, there's no reason why they couldn't have continued to do so indefinitely.

If the OP wanted financial security, then why not buy one or more smaller houses 10+ years ago (maybe with the money from the sale of the business as a deposit, or her first £100k of savings) and have these as BTLs? Rent would probably have paid off the mortgage by now, giving an ongoing income plus an asset which they could retire to/ sell to fund retirement.

Doing that OP wouldn't have needed to work so hard, and being around more could have dispensed with the boarding/ private school thereby saving even more money. By now she probably could have given up work entirely and just used the income from the houses.

JoieDeLivres · 11/03/2022 12:26

I couldn’t disagree more. Like**@floatsomeandjetsum*, our money has remained separate throughout our 22 year marriage. Nobody tells me how to spend my money.

Look how inflexible he’s being - limited location, huge unaffordable wish list, no financial contribution. He wants a unicorn and is throwing his toys out of the pram because*@floatsomeandjetsumis buying a racehorse.

Yes and no, looks like there's a lot more to this, emotionally, than that (and would caveat my last post with a big fat 🤨 at OP's earlier comment that she would've liked to have married DP but he never asked. That's some BS and I might have walked a long time ago if I were OP, for that reason alone).

I'm all for separate finances and wouldn't be held over a barrel by my DH either if I was putting down 100% of the cost, but a) this isn't as cut and dried as that because DP does work and earn - just a lot less than OP - and b) purely pragmatically, what's your quality of life going to be as a family with a faultline like this running down the middle of it? Can predict enjoyment of the house going sour quite quickly if one partner just resents it top to bottom. Maybe the solution is that they just split, if it would be like that, but doesn't sound like OP wants that.

Agree with others that the house needs parked and some serious talking done, if the overall goal is to stay together.

floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:25

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave

Genuine question?

Yes, you've been asked a lot of those over the past couple of pages but are avoiding them. I wonder why. I don't really, I know why

Erm, I've got things to do other than be on Mumsnet! I was having a cup of tea and got sidetracked!
OP posts:
floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:24

@Bubblesandsqueak1

Why not use some of the bought land and build a house you both like? It would work out cheaper to build them buy basically they whole tread is about your wants and needs not the kids or dps
Because I have enough on my plate to log through this. I'm tired and I want a break, not more stress.
OP posts:
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 11/03/2022 12:24

Genuine question?

Yes, you've been asked a lot of those over the past couple of pages but are avoiding them. I wonder why. I don't really, I know why

floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:23

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave

Of course I can get a mortgage, a massive one if I wanted it!

Then why did you say you "simply can't afford" a more expensive property?

How do you do eight school runs per week when your children board?

How do you have time for all these school runs for your boarder children when you're in such a stressful job?

A suitable property would upwards of £1m easily.

Why should I, approaching 50, stretch myself and saddle myself with this debt, to buy a property I don't want or need?

Genuine question? What's your reason?

OP posts:
floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:21

@Bookworm20

I don't think YABU OP. From what I've read he wanted to go into farming because he loves it, and this has meant you had to earn more money to enable him to do this and live the life the do.

So heres a scenario which I think might sum it up, but in reverse.

When I met DP after getting my degree, I really wanted to bake cakes. DP, wanting me to be happy said go ahead. I love baking. I love my job, but it doesn't pay very much. I could've gotten a much higher paying job, but I wanted to do someting I love instead. DP decided he would get into a career where he could earn great money, but I know he hates it and its very stressful to the point he has suffered health wise over it.
But I didn't want to get a different job to help out more because I love baking cakes.
We have DC and DP takes on 100% of the childcare, with the exception of maybe a couple of school runs a week, as I work 7 days a week at my baking. He does all housework, sorts home admin and buys everything for the dc including private school and pays half the bills. The rest he is saving so we can buy a house. I pay most of the rent though and half the bills, but I don't mind because I really love my job and dp pays for everything else.
Because of my baking, we don't ever get to go on holiday as a family so DP takes the dc away so I can carry on baking, as it gets busy in the summer. He pays for their holidays but I think they have a nice time without me.
DP has had a pay increase over the years and recently sold a business so we're really fine financially. But he wants to buy a big house with the money he has made. We looked at it and it was ok, but there is no room for my cookers and I don't want to live in a big fancy house where I can't bake. Even though I can carry on baking where I currently bake.

I want DP to spend more money and buy a house with a big kitchen so I can be happy baking. he says he can't afford it and hes really tired and doesnt want a big morrtgage because wants to stop working so much as the years go by , so this would be security for our future.

I think hes being really selfish. I want to bake. It makes me happy. I think he should spend more money on a house that I want. AIBU to tell him to buy a house that I want with a kitchen and everything or I'll just leave.He enabled me to work in a job that I love, by doing one he doesn't, but why should I sacrifice my kitchen just because he doesn't want to take out a big mortgage? he's being selfish

Exactly.
OP posts:
floatsomeandjetsum · 11/03/2022 12:19

@TedMullins

There's nothing wrong with a woman protecting her financial interests (or a man, despite what some think) or maintaining separate finances, but what you're doing seems to go beyond that and into the realm of thinking he's inherently wrong for choosing this career as a farmer. As many have said, it is absolutely not an essential that the kids go to private school (and part board!) have ponies, or live in a huge detached house in a village. I don't know what farmers earnings are, but I don't believe it's true that he simply COULDN'T provide for the family on them - maybe not give them the heights of privilege you have, but a roof over their heads, food and necessities - well, clearly he can because he paid the rent for the past 10 years!

I also do think as a partner of 20 years that you claim to love, you morally should want to put something in place for him as the lower earner as well - whether that's adding his name to the mortgage or making provisions for him in your will that he gets the house should you die. Yes, it sounds like he could do more parenting, but it also sounds like you're a martyr. If your career pays so highly, why couldn't you work part time and hire a cleaner or a nanny? You knew he was passionate about farming when you met him, and if you didn't think this was suitable for providing for your kids, why have a family with him? You could've got an easy 9-5 admin job and lived a perfectly nice life, but your benchmark for what is necessary to provide is ridiculously high. A lot of these problems you've created for yourself.

It's not really about the farm though, it's about him not accepting living in a 'normal' house, and me being able to relieve myself of pressure.

He wants more than I can give him.

OP posts:
TedMullins · 11/03/2022 12:17

There's nothing wrong with a woman protecting her financial interests (or a man, despite what some think) or maintaining separate finances, but what you're doing seems to go beyond that and into the realm of thinking he's inherently wrong for choosing this career as a farmer. As many have said, it is absolutely not an essential that the kids go to private school (and part board!) have ponies, or live in a huge detached house in a village. I don't know what farmers earnings are, but I don't believe it's true that he simply COULDN'T provide for the family on them - maybe not give them the heights of privilege you have, but a roof over their heads, food and necessities - well, clearly he can because he paid the rent for the past 10 years!

I also do think as a partner of 20 years that you claim to love, you morally should want to put something in place for him as the lower earner as well - whether that's adding his name to the mortgage or making provisions for him in your will that he gets the house should you die. Yes, it sounds like he could do more parenting, but it also sounds like you're a martyr. If your career pays so highly, why couldn't you work part time and hire a cleaner or a nanny? You knew he was passionate about farming when you met him, and if you didn't think this was suitable for providing for your kids, why have a family with him? You could've got an easy 9-5 admin job and lived a perfectly nice life, but your benchmark for what is necessary to provide is ridiculously high. A lot of these problems you've created for yourself.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 11/03/2022 12:16

Why not use some of the bought land and build a house you both like? It would work out cheaper to build them buy basically they whole tread is about your wants and needs not the kids or dps

Blossomtoes · 11/03/2022 12:15

an investment this size needs to be a joint decision, doesn't matter who's paying

I couldn’t disagree more. Like @floatsomeandjetsum, our money has remained separate throughout our 22 year marriage. Nobody tells me how to spend my money.

Look how inflexible he’s being - limited location, huge unaffordable wish list, no financial contribution. He wants a unicorn and is throwing his toys out of the pram because @floatsomeandjetsum is buying a racehorse.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 11/03/2022 12:15

We're not married though.

In your position, no matter how the immediate difficulty with the house resolves itself, I'd keep it that way.

Wanting land for ponies when he's contributing nothing would clinch this for me. That's quite some level of nerve.