Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - help me with some perspective on this?

489 replies

floatsomeandjetsum · 10/03/2022 20:50

Ok, here are the main points,

Unmarried to partner, 20 years. 3 children with him.
I've always earned well but in a career that's been hard and incredibly stressful. It's been a slog and come at a cost to my health.

He's a fairly low earner, more a lifestyle business than anything.

I've paid all childcare and school fees, all holiday clubs, music lessons etc. basically everything for the children I've paid for. All hobbies etc.

We've rented for 10 years whilst property prices have almost escaped us.

I've always saved hard, at great personal expense in that I've gone without in order to do that.

Here's the problem - I've bought a house, which was always our plan. It's almost bought with cash from my savings (no inheritance and no contributions from him) and I've secured a small mortgage.

He hates it and will not get on board, he's basically saying it's him or the house.

Can I have a reality check please? He's contributing absolutely nothing to a big, beautiful detached 4 bed house, with a small mortgage (that I'll pay off in a few years) but it's costing me our relationship!!

I feel so beaten. What's going on here???

OP posts:
NameGoesHere · 11/03/2022 06:01

Choose the house but protect it from him.

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 06:00

Jealousy
Pride
Ego
Realisation of limitations

RealBecca · 11/03/2022 04:37

What on earth do you mean "he didn't explicitly say no".

How did that conversation go exactly.

wildseas · 11/03/2022 04:33

I think that there is a bit of compromise to be made on your side, without giving up the house.

I think that you could hear him more, that he doesn’t want to be in the village and wants more land. So, for example here you could agree to look at any property within your budget that he suggests but explain that you won’t pull out without another option.

I think that you could do a better job of explaining to him why a bought house gives better security for your children- the difference between an owned and leased farm described above is a really good analogy. I think you could compromise here by thinking of the village house as a temporary move, until his farming is in a place that he’s saved the difference (by putting aside the rent he would have spent) to buy the house he wants jointly.

I think you could listen more and focus less on solutions- as you know there isn’t a solution to what he wants - so I think you could sit with that and just hear his worries more without trying to fix

I think that at the moment he is waiting for you to fix this, rather than fixing it himself. Once he tries to fix it himself I think he’ll come round to the idea of the house. But ultimately that’s for him to do not for you to do.

Valeriekat · 11/03/2022 04:11

He doesn't have a job he has a hobby which you have to subsidise.

marvellousmaple · 11/03/2022 04:04

I'd rent the house you have bought out for now whilst you decide what you want to do. For starters give notice on the job you hate. You said you've already got enough for the school fees so just need to pay the small mortgage which the rent you get will cover. You get the house, and you both get some time to do decide where you go from here.

HoppingPavlova · 11/03/2022 03:42

Don’t think he would be much of a loss tbh. How is HE planing to finance these ponies when he currently contributes fuck all?

expat101 · 11/03/2022 03:37

Just touching on the farm rent bit, we lease land as well as have our own. It is so frustrating when things need to be done repair wise that improves the property but:

  1. Its not your own to be improving.
  2. When your tools are down the road at home and you need them at the rental property.
  3. Dealing with the owners of the rural rental property. In our case they want full market lease but are not prepared to put in decent stock handling yards and loading ramp. They bought a run down property.
  4. Not knowing if you should increase stock numbers as its always possible the land owners will cancel the agreement at short notice and then where do you stick your stock.
  5. if you are into regenerative farming, that comes at an expense and is a long term proposition. Refer to item 4.
  6. Farm theft. Stock, equipment, fuel, implements you name it. People seem to think its ok to walk across paddocks that are not their own and take what is there. Whereas if you live on farm, you can be out in a flash to deal with an issue.

Anyhow, perhaps its time you sat down together and went through the farming accounts. Perhaps he does earn enough (I doubt it with fert cost increases) to be able to support a joint mortgage.

Just my two cents worth and experience...

expat101 · 11/03/2022 03:29

Is it not possible to build a house on the land you already own?

That way you get something you like and its new, he gets to live on the land you already have with the ponies for the kids (who will certainly do more work and handling with them living on site, we have 4 so I have a fair idea about this).

And its a win win for all concerned..

bebarkered · 11/03/2022 03:16

I think he's an ungrateful fucker to be honest with you OP. He sounds entitled to me. You're the one buying the house, you're the one paying for your children's private education, etc etc. He should be thrilled about the opportunity to live in the home that you've paid for! Has this man never heard of the saying 'count your blessings' ?!

timeisnotaline · 11/03/2022 02:39

A rented farm can’t be handed on. He knows you can’t afford to buy what he wants. I’d only give up the house if he immediately changed career to plan to earn enough to provide you the security to buy what he wants. So I’d buy the house basically. I’d point out he’s made serious choices for a long time that benefit him, yes he works hard but you work hard too and haven’t been able to make those choices. Not buying a house because he’s both chosen not to earn enough to help and set his expectations higher than you can afford is not an option. Nor is spending above your budget, as you are already working to your maximum to afford it. Not being able to talk to you about it before the deal is done is absolutely ridiculous from a grown man. (I would pettily add at this point if even remotely true ‘and frankly I love the idea of neighbours but you’ve never cared what I think’) I’ve made a lot of compromises over our entire life together and now I’ve bought all of us a house. We are moving to it, and if having to make one compromise of your own is too much for you it’s not the relationship I thought it was anyway.

UniversalAunt · 11/03/2022 02:36

After 22 years of slogging your guts out at something you really don’t like for the benefit of other people, no wonder you are a bit pissed off.

Something has to give, your health? Your sanity? Your relationship? Your plans? Something has to change otherwise you will all loose out.

His digging his heels in is not helping the pair of you work this out. You are a partnership, a team, yet you both are pulling what you have worked for together apart. Do you want this ? Does he?

The fall back position for you is to rip up the current plan - yes, you can let this house go, unless you have completed obvs, & as a third of all house purchase fall through before completion there is no loss of face or dented pride. You can pull back from this brink by a few phone calls. This buys you both some time.

Time? Because you are going to need this, both of you, to look at how you both brought your long relationship with a family to the brink. Look at this together. If cannot make progress together, then try Relate to help you develop your shared communication patterns.

There are undercurrents in your relationship that do not bode well. You ‘tiptoe round’ him, his obdurate passive resistance & that you are both slogging your guts out…for what?

OP, you are burying yourself to service other people’s wants (needs of children are a given) & you are not paying full attention to your self. You seem to have a checklist that allows & encourages you to charge ahead & pay as you go, so going for this house without having him entirely on board was business as usual?

Your OH seems to live as a ‘gentleman farmer’ with you as the financial engine. This is not sustainable. For what he says he wants, he has to pull up his fiscal socks & make the contribution real for what he says he wants. Pulling back & giving you the silent treatment is coercion.

First thing you do is read his accounts & tax returns. In effect, you are the silent partner in his business, providing the cash that underpins his business, why do you not know the ROI on your effort & goodwill?

As you have presented your dilemma, it’s either him or the house.
I think this house is not right for you, with or without him, so withdraw the offer to give yourself some space & save yourself from a massive investment that does not actually serve you well or meet your needs.

What do you need? Probably to get out of working at something you really do not like doing, irrespective of the pay. You have the incredible good fortune to have enough saved (well done, btw) to take a break to look at what you would really like to do & that meets your needs for an enjoyable life & productive work. Jump sectors, retrain, develop your creativity, travel, study, whatever?

If you choose to stay in post, can you cut your hours/days, to take up something you really enjoy for yourself?

Your fallback position is to get yourself a home where you can relax & live well, enjoy the fruits of your considerable labours. Your children will be OK with their basic home needs met & a happier mother who has a life she enjoys. An everyday nice house & garden is achievable

Bogeyes · 11/03/2022 02:10

Pick the house

Inertia · 11/03/2022 01:36

You’re not married, and you have separate finances.

Why can’t you buy the family home in your name, and he buys or leases the farmland he needs via his business? It’s not fair of him to expect you to earn the majority of the income, buy the family home, do and pay for everything the children need, and then subsidise his business (which you and the children have no benefit from) on top.

AiryFairyLights · 11/03/2022 01:20

@AiryFairyLights

The fact you’re buying in your name only I think is the problem op - what do YOU want to do? Can you afford to go it alone? It sounds like it so you have to ask yourself what you really want x You could call his bluff if you’re prepared for him to walk away? I personally think he’s being a twat and don’t like the fact it’ll be in your name only!
Please IGNORE my previous post - I posted before getting past the more enlightening posts and have kind of changed my opinion! I get what you’re saying, but are you in a JOINT relationship where feelings and decisions are of equal value and worth to the other? He’s still a bit of a twat for agreeing to you putting an offer in and then changing his mind - but I wonder if it’s become a battle of wills between the two of you because he doesn’t feel valued (and you don’t actually come across as valuing him) and you don’t feel he values you! Your problem isn’t the house as such - you need to work on finding some mutual respect for each other because I really don’t see any from what you have posted!
KenAdams · 11/03/2022 01:18

Hang on, why are you working your stressful job (and who are you working for) if you've sold your business, virtually bought a house outright and set aside money for the school fees?

What does he farm? Is the house you currently live in attached to the farm, so if you move, would he still have to pay the rent on it to continue to work?

tkwal · 11/03/2022 01:13

It wouldn't be in either the OPS best interests or that of her partner to buy a farm and work it together. She could lose everything she has worked so hard forIt makes sense now that he paid the rent 10 months out of 12 as farming is a business and the cost of rent is a business expense. If he's a hobby farmer then it's a very expensive hobby. As a one man band he would need a lot of kit and looking after animals is very hard work and again very expensive. Its also next to impossible to make any money

madroid · 11/03/2022 01:08

You need Kirsty and Phil.

They would tell you that you both need to compromise and draw up a list of must-haves and nice to haves. Then do a reality check of location/price on houses on the market.

Withdrawing from house sale is neither here nor there. Happens all the time for a whole host of reasons.

AiryFairyLights · 11/03/2022 00:59

The fact you’re buying in your name only I think is the problem op - what do YOU want to do? Can you afford to go it alone? It sounds like it so you have to ask yourself what you really want x
You could call his bluff if you’re prepared for him to walk away?
I personally think he’s being a twat and don’t like the fact it’ll be in your name only!

FavouritePi · 11/03/2022 00:58

It sounds like he doesn't want you to have this house of your own/in your sole name. After 20 years, to him it might seem unreasonable that he'll be living in 'your house' and that's why it's the house or him.

I don't see it that way and see it that you're contributing to everything and have a right to buy this for your family as a whole. He hasn't had an issue with you shelling out for everything until now, has he? Alternatively, you could get him on the mortgage/deeds and have a tight trust deed drawn up as tenants with unequal shares if that's what you want to do and if you think he'd even pay the mortgage.

If he's not bringing much to your relationship and this is a crossroads for you, highlighting some deep seated resentment and there's no redeeming factors, I'd press on anyway. He can continue being a great dad when he sees your children if he carries out his ultimatum.

Anoooshka · 11/03/2022 00:51

Is there any way that you can rent out the house you're buying and continue to live in your rental property? Then you have the best of both worlds. Your DP can continue to farm, and you get to keep the house.

TedMullins · 11/03/2022 00:41

You could’ve saved yourself years of stress and a job you hate by not sending the kids to private school. That’s an entirely unnecessary choice. I’m sure you could’ve lived just fine on an average wage job and his farmer’s earnings. That said, he’s being ridiculous about the ponies. I think you’re both BU and both sound too single minded to find a compromise. My sympathies lie more with him though, I think it’s admirable he actually is doing what he wants with his life.

user1487768885 · 11/03/2022 00:39

I'm probably going to be unpopular in posting this. Is it absolutely out of the question to put his name down as joint owner of the house even it means that you will have a bigger mortgage?

When my dh (dp then) & I bought our first property I paid my half in cash & we took out a joint mortgage. That's the only way he could afford it & I wanted him to be a part of it & my life of course. When we bought our current home, I paid for 80% of the deposit & we again got a joint mortgage. He's been paying the mortgage over the years but obviously if he decided not to I will suffer financially. I don't think my dh would ever want to live in a property just in my name & rightly so in my opinion.

Similarly situation with our neighbours. She told me that she paid for most of their house (city lawyer & teacher dh) but it's joint ownership.

I also do most of the house work & 99% school runs, not quite with the neighbours. I'm 1000% OK with it. I did not choose my dh because of money. I want him to be a part of my life, hence give him a chance being a part of the house.

Op, if your dp can afford rent then surely he can afford to pay the mortgage. Is it absolutely out of the question you let him get a mortgage & be a part of it? BTW you never know what the future might bring. My dh is now earning enough to pay off the mortgage in cash (we took out a massive 1 for my current house). Just give him a chance to be a part of it ...

BadNomad · 11/03/2022 00:33

I do wonder how much of anything was discussed and agreed on together. Did he push you into a career you hate? Did he expect you to earn lots of money? Did he want the children privately educated? The music lessons? Holiday clubs? It doesn't sound like he's a lazy person. He might just have different goals and ambitions in life. It's clear though that you resent him for that and think you're better than him because of it. You're the boss and he can either like it or lump it.

BluebellsGreenbells · 11/03/2022 00:31

I think you do need to call his bluff!

Ask him to sit down and talk about how he’s going to manage 50/50 childcare and rent, work, school runs housework cooking etc and see what happens when the reality sets in.

He can’t have it all off your back.

Ask yourself this, if you were a single parent would you still make this choice of home? Can you afford it along with everything else you financially support? If yes, go ahead because all you’re losing is a dead weight, and with him responsible for the children 50/50 you’ll actually get a breather.