Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not choosing a flat with a garden for children

342 replies

whatsay11 · 10/03/2022 19:31

AIBU to think children do not need a garden as they grow up? My husband and I really can’t agree on such a minor issue. Bearing in mind he knows so little about raising kids anyway. e.g. he was surprised when I told him how many nappies a newborn will get through! He believes that a child needs a garden. I am 3 months’ pregnant. Both of the flats are in our budget. Sadly v expensive as we have to live in London. We are currently renting a 1 bedroom flat on the second floor of a Victorian terrace with awful upstairs neighbours, I’m worried about our baby as they have loud parties and smoke weed etc. we need to move quickly.

Flat 1 £550k
Downstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. Two small double bedrooms, one bathroom with a bath, living/dining/kitchen in one room and a small garden with no grass…only stones.

Flat 2 £600k
Upstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. One normal flight upstairs from the main shared front door. Split level as there is a loft conversion. Three double bedrooms, two bathrooms, separate living/dining room and kitchen.

Both properties are about a 20 minute walk away from several parks and in good school catchment areas. Thoughts?

OP posts:
SoftSheen · 10/03/2022 21:21

Get a garden if you possibly can, even a very small one makes a big difference with young children.

Forumqueen · 10/03/2022 21:19

They both aren’t very ideal for a growing family. I would seriously consider moving into zone five you could get a lovely detached house - 4 bedrooms with plenty of garden space.

Beautiful3 · 10/03/2022 21:18

I'd get a ground floor flat with a garden.

Hollowtree3 · 10/03/2022 21:17

Garden. You will not regret it. However small they can grow things and dig and it is there patch with their outdoor toys, and being outdoors is just calming fit kids and adults.

Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 21:14

If you are ill or need to do dinner chucking the kids into the garden for half an hour will really help. As pp pointed out, even if there are parks close by you still have to pack all your shit to go there. Toddlers need a lot of exercise, I now have a slide in my apartment. I also have a baby yoyo and love it but its a PITA to collapse with one arm for me. A garden wouldn’t replace parks but would help.

Heronwatcher · 10/03/2022 21:13

Garden essential, definitely. Otherwise whenever you see the sun you’ll end up schlepping to the park which is a massive PITA. In London a garden, however small, is a godsend and you can do brilliant things with even small gardens for young kids (outdoor kitchen/ climbing wall/ mini trampoline). Nothing better than letting a child mill in and out on a sunny morning.

NightOwl6 · 10/03/2022 21:13

Our first place was a first floor flat, it was difficult with one baby/toddler (we moved when he was 2). The lugging shopping/his trike/pushchair up and down the stairs was a nightmare. When he got bigger and became more active, it was difficult to not have any outdoor space and also washing was dried around the house or put into the tumble drier. We eventually moved into a house with a garden and it made such a difference. Option 1 is your best option for now.

MadKittenWoman · 10/03/2022 21:12

Garden every time.

Doyoumind · 10/03/2022 21:11

Getting to an upstairs flat with a baby/small child isn't good. I've done it. Also lived without and with a garden with small DC. I would always go for a garden. Even just having somewhere to dry washing can be a godsend.

ittakes2 · 10/03/2022 21:10

It completely depends on the personality of your child/children. My daughter never puts a foot in the garden and would value more internal space. My son prefers to be outside

Felicity42 · 10/03/2022 21:08

People might suggest areas if you give an idea of where you need to be located.

user1493494961 · 10/03/2022 21:07

Bigger flat.

Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 21:07

We went through lockdown in a big apartment, its 3500 sq feet with 1 toddler. A garden with a smaller apartment would have been better,

But best option is to move out and get a house.

Oriunda · 10/03/2022 21:03

Whereabouts in London? It’s a huge city! £500k is a lot for a flat. In my area of very leafy, excellent schools Zone 4 London (but on central line) £600k would get you a small house with garden.

ThirdElephant · 10/03/2022 21:03

Definitely ground floor with garden. Plan to move in a few years.

TheSunWillComeOut2moro · 10/03/2022 21:03

Move to the North, even with the silly price hike you'd get a large 5 bed detached with a large garden for that, in fact you could shave 150k off your budget and still get a huge 4 bed. As you obviously wont go north, flat 1 for the outside space and easy access, but I highly doubt you could manage with 2 children in such a small space.

kitcat15 · 10/03/2022 21:02

@Fupoffyagrasshole

People saying neither flat is suitable

We live in a 2 bed flat with our 1 year old - no garden in London in the basement

It’s totally fine

I go out to the parks there’s loads within walking distance.

I’ve honestly never missed having a garden

Also the stairs has never bothered me either I got yoyo buggy and can easily lift it up the steps when needed if the baby was asleep when I got home

If we have another child they can share the bedroom!

I’d chose a smaller place every time over leaving London tbh

I guess you don't miss what you've never had
HerRoyalNotness · 10/03/2022 21:02

It’s a pain with no garde n but as you want more children and can’t move easily for a while I’d go with the bigger flat

Changechangychange · 10/03/2022 21:00

We’re in an upper floor maisonette in south London, no garden. DS is 5.

I’d go with flat 2, because inside space is probably the most important. Nothing worse than being cooped up in a small flat in the rain. We used a sling more than our buggy (and used it for longer than average - DS was still in it intermittently when he was 3). We had a single-hand fold buggy (Babyjogger CityMini).

We go out to the park, swimming, or something outdoorsy, every day come what May. And we live somewhere with a wide variety of parks and soft plays. We also made sure we picked a nursery with a really lovely garden and a Northern European forest school “no bad weather only bad clothing” attitude, so DS was outside more than he was inside during the daytime.

kitcat15 · 10/03/2022 20:59

...and the fire pit? You need somewhere for the fire pit ...to toast those marshmallows

kitcat15 · 10/03/2022 20:57

A garden isn't 'essential' ...but cannot imagine bringing my 3 up without one....we spent so much time out there when the kids were small...without a garden there would have been no trampoline....no rabbit....no guinea pig....no dog....no garden shed made into a den.....no veggie plots....no sunflower competitions for the kids....no sitting on the patio when the kids were in bed enjoying a drink and the last of the sun.....no where to line dry your washing.....I could go on and on....but you get the picture....I LOVE my garden

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 10/03/2022 20:56

It’s hard to know now how you’ll feel once you have kids

We lived in a 2 bed flat in a city centre, no garden but some parks and playgrounds within walking distance

To be honest, it was hard, as every outing had to be planned. When my boys were 6 and 4 we moved to a 2 bed house with a small garden, in a village, and it was such a difference!

But J only could appreciate it after years in a flat. In a heatwave, snow days, during a pandemic… that outside space is precious

But once they are teens you can move back to that urban flat Grin

allfurcoatnoknickers · 10/03/2022 20:56

I'm a city center flat dweller with an almost pathological hatred of the suburbs (NYC, not London) and I think neither sound ideal. I'd go for ground floor though, just because schlepping all your stuff up and down even one flight of stairs is a total pain. 20 minutes is a long way from a park.

I have a garden flat now and it's great - DS is a toddler and can play outside for ages with his water table. I also have a little container garden out there and grew my own veg and herbs last summer. We were even out the BBQing at the weekend and had an over-the-fence NYE party with our neighbors this year.

FloraPostePosts · 10/03/2022 20:56

Always downstairs to avoid problems getting out of the house, and preferably with outdoor space for all the reasons which have come up before. And if you have an upstairs flat with toddlers, it’s a recipe for poor relations with your downstairs neighbours.

Housinghelp321 · 10/03/2022 20:54

Also my child couldn't be a child without a garden.

I mean get a grip on yourself. You do realise that there are millions of children being raised in flats in this country, let alone the rest of the world? And I'm sure they manage to 'be children' just fine.