Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not choosing a flat with a garden for children

342 replies

whatsay11 · 10/03/2022 19:31

AIBU to think children do not need a garden as they grow up? My husband and I really can’t agree on such a minor issue. Bearing in mind he knows so little about raising kids anyway. e.g. he was surprised when I told him how many nappies a newborn will get through! He believes that a child needs a garden. I am 3 months’ pregnant. Both of the flats are in our budget. Sadly v expensive as we have to live in London. We are currently renting a 1 bedroom flat on the second floor of a Victorian terrace with awful upstairs neighbours, I’m worried about our baby as they have loud parties and smoke weed etc. we need to move quickly.

Flat 1 £550k
Downstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. Two small double bedrooms, one bathroom with a bath, living/dining/kitchen in one room and a small garden with no grass…only stones.

Flat 2 £600k
Upstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. One normal flight upstairs from the main shared front door. Split level as there is a loft conversion. Three double bedrooms, two bathrooms, separate living/dining room and kitchen.

Both properties are about a 20 minute walk away from several parks and in good school catchment areas. Thoughts?

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 10/03/2022 21:40

Have you considered Colliers Wood? The road is a bit gritty but it has a fantastic community, lovely parks and coffee shops (try coffee in the wood) and excellent schools- the one by the park (Sherington?)
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120169025#/?channel=RES_BUY

Whoamireally22 · 10/03/2022 21:39

No, I don’t think garden is essential. It’s nonsense, IMO. Even pandemic didn’t change my mind. We are conveniently located near several wonderful parks, have got a communal garden (noone’s ever there) and have great transport connections to the city. I have no idea what I would do in the tiny garden I could have possibly afforded.

Airyfairymarybeary · 10/03/2022 21:39

Get a cheaper house outside of london and commute!

Merryoldgoat · 10/03/2022 21:39

I was knavkered today. Both boys straight on to trampoline for an hour whilst I got dinner and sat for a bit. A garden is a godsend with children.

waterrat · 10/03/2022 21:38

Eg when they have a friend over and the flat feels crowded. Garden comes into its own for hosting playdates . Also you are often exhausted as a parent. Really really exhausted with babies and toddlers. Being able to just put toddler in garden to play is a world better than having yobget baby and toddler out to park every time they need fresh air or change of scene

waterrat · 10/03/2022 21:36

God no way to choosing to give up q garden. My two have spent literally hours upon hours in our garden. You just can't compare to having to take them to the park every single time. The amount of extra outdoor play they have had from us having a garden is just huge

My son plays football in our garden My daughter has done endless doll playing on blankets in the sun or bouncing on the trampoline. We do have a decent garden though.

I have to say both thr flats you suggest sound imperfect and I would look at cheaper areas

BTW. 20 minutes is a long way from a park when you have young children. !

Merryoldgoat · 10/03/2022 21:35

www.zoopla.co.uk/for-sale/details/60559827/

You’d get a house on Haydon’s Road

mushroom3 · 10/03/2022 21:34

I would suggest looking in SE London, zone 2/3 for a 3 bed garden flat or ex LA house

NumberTheory · 10/03/2022 21:33

I think either flat will work quite well for one child and okay for two while they're small. Unless you have physical limitations, a light buggy isn't so bad to lift up a flight of stairs, you soon get used to it. But you may want to space your children so that you only have one that can't get up under their own steam. (Alternatively, have them close together and suffer for a few years. It is only temporary).

I do think a garden can be useful, it doesn't need to be grassy (in fact, grass can be a bit of a pain). It's somewhere for messy play and safe exploration. When they're a little older a trampoline would give them a way to burn off plenty of energy even though it's not a big space. And a bit older than that and a garden room can be somewhere to hang out (or for you to escape to). However, it's not a necessity. You can do messy play in the house easily enough and if you walk everywhere they will burn off energy too. A 20 minute walk to the park isn't a disaster though it may well get wearisome when you're sleep deprived especially if you have a small one on foot with you.

Either way, in London, neither is terrible. Personally I would choose parking or proximity to a fast link into the centre over a garden or no stairs.

Your issue will be number of bedrooms as they get older. A two bedroom place for three kids is never going to be great and it won't work even for two when they're older if they aren't all the same sex. So if you're pretty sure you won't move for a decade I would be inclined towards the three bed.

Merryoldgoat · 10/03/2022 21:33

Look a bit further out towards Worcester Park, New Malden, Merton Park.

Still easy to St George’s and near A3 for Esher.

Heronwatcher · 10/03/2022 21:31

You might also want to google- there’s lots of great ideas online about things to do with gardens- might give some ideas about what an asset even a small garden can be.

for not choosing a flat with a garden for children
for not choosing a flat with a garden for children
for not choosing a flat with a garden for children
godmum56 · 10/03/2022 21:30

I'd vote garden but I would like to point something else out....If your partner is on shifts and you are planning children, being 30 mins away from your parents is not going to mean that you will be able to get there in an emergency....especially when you have more than one child. I do think this needs more thought about what you parents' actual needs are and how they might be met and (and I mean this nicely) how they can be met without giving you problems in your own life.....If you really really feel that you could respond reliably to an emergency at your parents and need to do so, have you looked at what is an hour away? 90 minutes away? If they need that kind of response then have they considered supported housing or an alarm monitoring system? I honestly think that this aspect of your decision making criteria is not realistic.

RedHelenB · 10/03/2022 21:30

Yes, a garden is definitely needed if you have the choice. YABU.

KirstenBlest · 10/03/2022 21:28

Think long and hard about the resale value.

Flat 1 sounds best for now, as you won't be lugging a baby and stuff upstairs and it has an outside space so you could dry laundry and get some sun

Bornsloppy · 10/03/2022 21:27

We've got a "yarden" rather than a garden and it's been a godsend. We've made it as nice as we can, put loads of pots out, grow veggies in the summer, few trays for sand and water for the kids to play with. We were out there today for an hour. We live less than 5 minutes walk from a park and that makes a huge difference - I think 20 minute walk with 1 child is ok because you shove them in the buggy and that's it, but it gets more difficult with more children, especially when you realise that scooter/balance bike which seemed like a good idea on the outbound leg is actually a really bad idea homebound.

FantasticFebruary · 10/03/2022 21:27

Would it be possible to buy a house a little further out with your parents?

Jacketandbeans · 10/03/2022 21:26

OP I have 2 DS's, one is 2 and one nearly 6 and we have a baby on the way. We live in a split level flat without a garden (1st and 2nd floor) with 2 bedrooms.
We live in zone 4 London and we do have a car which we put the buggy and bike/scooter into so no lugging up and downstairs.
Honestly I've loved living here and the kids love it. I personally would love a garden but thats for ME, the boys are absolutely fine. After school in the summer we go to one of many parks with friends (also about a 20 minute walk so we often drive, no biggy) and at weekends we are OUT! But I love being out and about, thats why I love London as there is so much to do and we also see friends a lot. When we are in the boys have plenty of space to play, my 6 year old has never asked for a garden and is sad that we might move.

One great advantage I've noticed is that when you are in, you're in, so my toddler doesn't constantly want to go in and out traipsing mud in and making me take his shoes on and off. I'd personally choose more space than a tiny pebbled bit of garden especially if you want 2-3 kids.

whatsay11 · 10/03/2022 21:25

We’re focusing on Wimbledon for the area and schools. Husband works in a South London hospital which will be one bus journey away. My parents are in Notting Hill and husband’s parents are in Esher - especially important to be as close as possible to them as they are very keen to help with childcare and I would plan to drop baby/toddler off on the way to work. So not too early to make sure baby gets enough of a rest before being woken up and dropped off to grandparents.

OP posts:
PeachesVonBeach · 10/03/2022 21:25

Also, for all those saying where will you dry your laundry. You can use the money you'd spend on garden tat garden furniture, toys and actual maintenance on a laundry service.

Blinkingbatshit · 10/03/2022 21:24

A postage stamp garden is pointless - go for the 3 bed. When we lived in London our house has a tiny garden - didn’t get used most of the year and then when the weather was good you couldn’t exactly cycle or play football in it. You will be grateful of the extra space year round!

PeachesVonBeach · 10/03/2022 21:24

Lugging pram upstairs = deal breaker. Especially if you decide to have more babies.

Flat without garden, meh. It's not the end of the world. You'll get out, do interesting things and probs find a new mummy bf with a garden. Take wine. You'll always be popular and it will end up being much cheaper than maintaining your own garden 😉

AnnaSW1 · 10/03/2022 21:23

Get one with a garden

MsChatterbox · 10/03/2022 21:23

Honestly the amount of times I've said to my husband I'm so grateful we have a garden is ridiculous. They use it every day. It's great when they're getting crazy but I don't have time/energy to go somewhere.

LowlandLucky · 10/03/2022 21:23

Garden flat all the way. A park 20 minutes away is no use if your toddler needs to run around like a lunatic while you are on an important phone call, trying to cook or soothe baby number 2. Just think of all the extra washing you will have for the next decade, where do you intend to dry it without a garden ?

BenchBench · 10/03/2022 21:22

When you say small garden, what are the exact measurements? Is there a picture you can share from the listing? Does it matter to you if it gets any sun etc or is overlooked? Does it have a gate/is it secure?