Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not choosing a flat with a garden for children

342 replies

whatsay11 · 10/03/2022 19:31

AIBU to think children do not need a garden as they grow up? My husband and I really can’t agree on such a minor issue. Bearing in mind he knows so little about raising kids anyway. e.g. he was surprised when I told him how many nappies a newborn will get through! He believes that a child needs a garden. I am 3 months’ pregnant. Both of the flats are in our budget. Sadly v expensive as we have to live in London. We are currently renting a 1 bedroom flat on the second floor of a Victorian terrace with awful upstairs neighbours, I’m worried about our baby as they have loud parties and smoke weed etc. we need to move quickly.

Flat 1 £550k
Downstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. Two small double bedrooms, one bathroom with a bath, living/dining/kitchen in one room and a small garden with no grass…only stones.

Flat 2 £600k
Upstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. One normal flight upstairs from the main shared front door. Split level as there is a loft conversion. Three double bedrooms, two bathrooms, separate living/dining room and kitchen.

Both properties are about a 20 minute walk away from several parks and in good school catchment areas. Thoughts?

OP posts:
SpikeySmooth · 11/03/2022 00:07

Brought up my only DD in a first floor flat. But we have a lot of green space nearby, two parks, a wood and lots of playing fields. Only thing was, I had to made conscious decisions to take her out, rather than just have a little space out the back. Also, we didn't have all the things I had as a child, like a paddling pool, or a sandpit. We can't afford anything bigger on a mortgage. There are other families in my block too.

Aaaabbbcccc · 11/03/2022 00:05

Flat 2. The weather is so crap in this country what would anyone need a garden for? Although I would buy somewhere with parks that are closer.

Lorw · 11/03/2022 00:03

Neither of those flats are right for you OP. I’d think you’d need atleast a 3 bed, even if you have 2 children, what if you had one boy and one girl? You said no moves for atleast a decade? Some girls start their periods at 7/8, don’t think she’d want to be sharing with her brother.

There is so much stuff that comes with children that you’ll need the space and defo no lugging stuff upstairs. I’d say keep looking, still got plenty of time 😁

TeaAndBunsPlease · 10/03/2022 23:57

I had no garden and had to lug things up in lifts and up stairs when the lift broke. It was hard going. There's nothing like just being able to open your back door and bring a coffee or bring someone to the loo.

londonmummy1966 · 10/03/2022 23:57

Plan D would be to rethink your search area

Two bedrooms, huge communal garden and Clapham Common at one end of the road and Wandsworth Common at the other. Easy commute on Northern Line or train from Clapham Junction
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/119091023#/?channel=RES_BUY

Three beds, decent sized garden close to Clapham Common and 2 nice parks (one we used to drive to when our DC were small it was so nice) - easy commute on Northern Line and train from Clapham High Street

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/84032016#/?channel=RES_BUY

Small but it is a house in a nice area and close to Balham Station for the train and tube and Tooting Common is on your doorstep.

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120255176#/?channel=RES_BUY

TeaAndBunsPlease · 10/03/2022 23:54

@SarahWoodruff

A small garden can still be a godsend, particularly if parks and playgrounds are not round the corner. 20 minutes' walk at adult speed translates into an eternity with a 3 year old. You could have a sand and water table and a mud kitchen, and your kids would be entertained for quite long periods (at least until they're old enough for the 20 mins walk to be no issue).
This a million times over. Very young children are exhausting. Parents are sometimes knackered. Having a mud kitchen/paddling pool/sand table/tiny slide and somewhere to potter will just be a massive relief. It's really nice not to have to walk to a park with all your crap and then have to take someone to the loo or return home. This will make your life easier.
SleepingStandingUp · 10/03/2022 23:48

If you want three kids then you can't take the two bed house. Solved.

Doveyouknow · 10/03/2022 23:46

We had a large flat with a toddler and it was fine. We now have a small garden which I love (because I love gardening) but if I am honest I am not sure it makes much difference to the DC. I would say 20 mins is a long way to a park, I would look for somewhere closer to a park.

Potentialscroogeincognito · 10/03/2022 23:37

So lived right by South Park Gardens for years. So lovely lots of classes going on, mother and baby groups etc. Easy walk to either Colliers Wood or Wimbledon.
No problem with Hayden’s road area, frequent visitors of The Garden Shed Pub on Hayden’s road which was great.
Go and look for yourself and see what works.

RainbowMum11 · 10/03/2022 23:36

Flat 1 for 2 reasons
Just a little bit of safe outside space can be an absolute god send
Secondly - no stairs to lug shopping, pram/pushchair etc out is a huge winner with a young family.

Flat 2 would be better with older kids

Tumbleweed101 · 10/03/2022 23:36

I lived in a flat without outdoor space when my eldest children were 3 and 5yo. We were 10min walk from nearest park and 20min walk from a nicer park, river etc.

I would not recommend it. In the summer you will find it difficult without the option of just opening the door and being able to let them play. The walk to the park was so hot midsummer. No option for paddling pools and water play. The flat was boiling and had poor air flow.

If you decide on a flat without a garden then choose somewhere with a much nearer outdoor space to play. It is also difficult if you want to get on with house jobs and it's gorgeous out and the children want to go and play. You have to take them everywhere for fresh air.

Personally I wouldn't choose to live without a garden with young children. Your life changes so much when you have children that it may seem easy in your head right now but reality will be different.

nettie434 · 10/03/2022 23:35

I would go with Flat 1. Apart from avoiding the need to carry a pushchair upstairs, there is lots you can do with a small courtyard garden (eg paddling pool, sand pit) that would make life a lot easier with children. There are lots of ideas out there about how to make the most of small gardens.

I can really empathise that if your husband works shifts in the NHS, you want to minimise the journey time for him and still be able to get to your parents. I don't really understand the 'no terraced' rule but as I've just read a thread in which the OP's partner was objecting because the house she was proposing to buy had no room for horses and a house that did would be beyond their budget, then it puts that preference into context. I see a lot of posters suggest moving out of the area but Wimbledon has great transport links which is one of the reasons why it's expensive. Kingston is lovely but it would be a dreary journey to Notting Hill. The roads are busy and the trains are far less frequent than the tube.

WhoppingBigBackside · 10/03/2022 23:25

How have I caused slight offence with just one word?
Not offence, but kerb and curb have different meanings and curb appeal looks weird

user1487768885 · 10/03/2022 23:21

Definitely garden unless you want to move again a few years

ThanksItHasPockets · 10/03/2022 23:21

I used to hate his Americanisms but now I speak and type like him too unfortunately. You know what I mean though??

After reading all of your posts I think that I do. There's an awful lot about what your DH simply must have. I hope you are in there somewhere too.

Nogoodusername · 10/03/2022 23:17

Your DH is being very silly. I’d like to live in Wimbledon too but we can’t afford a house big enough for our 2 children so we don’t - simple. There are way more reasonable areas with brilliant schools much closer to your childcare in Esher. Getting to Notting Hill in half hour vs an hour doesn’t really make that much difference when you have children you would probably need to drop off at other grandparents to go and assist anyway!

beck01 · 10/03/2022 23:15

You could easily find a 3 bed small house with garden for £500k in many areas on London. I think neither of them are ideal options for the amount of money you have available

mathanxiety · 10/03/2022 23:10

Go with the bigger flat. Indoor space and especially a room where you can put toys or use for a playroom is priceless.

If your parents will have the baby while you're at work, then they'll be the ones taking him or her to parks or maybe they have a garden to run around in.

I had three children when I moved into my house. Up to then I lived in second floor apartments. Schlepping baby, toddler, and groceries upstairs wasn't easy, and the buildings I lived in had basement laundry facilities ( none in the apartments themselves) so that was another bother, but very honestly, if you put your mind to it you'll manage fine.

The two storey flat sounds nice for children and you could stay put for many years as long as school catchments don't change.

A garden is nice if the aspect is south, not overshadowed by trees, no creepy or grumpy neighbour next door keeping tabs on your child, or someone who sits out smoking weed or cigarettes, or BBQing all day at the weekend. Lots of people can't put their washing out because there's always smoke coming from next door. Lots of people let cats roam and they'll stink up your baby's sandbox or poop in your little herbaceous border. Be very careful about the garden if you're inclined to opt for the flat with one. It's not an automatic plus in a flat.

Quartz2208 · 10/03/2022 23:09

The thing is yes you need to be in the general London area but you dont need to be in the specific area.

There are many family friendly areas that would suit and give you much more money - children dont need a garden and a house but you have the budget to give it too them

Strawberry33 · 10/03/2022 23:07

It’s always better to have a garden if you can- beleive me. When they are little and you can just open the door and have it open like an extra room and they can play in a way they can’t in the house. Even just hanging washing out and getting a good breeze through the house are all benefits.

Woollystockings · 10/03/2022 23:03

If you’d consider Streatham, there’s a lot: three bed split-level flat with private garden, converted from Victorian end of terrace, share of freehold: on at 560.
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/119646911#/?channel=RES_BUY

Anoooshka · 10/03/2022 22:59

I lived in a flat without a garden for 4 years with a kid, in the middle of a city. We had access to parks and museums, and it was great. I'd personally go for the bigger flat without the garden. If things don't pan out and you have to stay in the flat for longer than a few years, you'll have room for another kid.

woody87 · 10/03/2022 22:56

Flat 1 sounds like hell on Earth.

Flat 2 sounds identical to our current setup minus the second bathroom (although we do not live in London and we do have a decent size park within walking distance)

We have DS3 DS2 and DT on the way and it's our intention to make this flat last us with 4 kids if we can.

Downsides - Yes the concrete flight of stairs up to the flat isn't ideal with young kids but soon they will all be safely walking up and down. The parking isint great but we only have one car.

Upsides - main thing for us is the low mortgage but we have no neighbours above us so no noise, it's really cheap to heat given it's an old tenement and sandwiched between two properties, we only need heating on upstairs in winter (dormer conversions are really cold) it's allowed us to live in literally the best street in town and walking distance to the best primary school without having to pay through the nose (houses in this street are obv pricey but also old so money pits)

Eventual plan for us is to remodel upstairs to put in another bathroom and potentially third bedroom. With the rising cost of living we are happy to see how long we can make this last (forever hopefully) and if it means we can afford more holidays and day trips by sacrificing a garden then fine by me'

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 10/03/2022 22:52

YABU. Get the garden. Our kids are out there all the time. One trampoline or swing set gives hours every week entertainment

1910username · 10/03/2022 22:52

The Haydons Park road @KirstenBlest is linking to is a great option.

Near the shops in Merton High street and good commute for your husband (if I’m correctly assuming he works at St George’s?).

I think You would be in the catchment area for All Saints Primary school, I volunteered there for a while, it’s a nice school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread