Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for not choosing a flat with a garden for children

342 replies

whatsay11 · 10/03/2022 19:31

AIBU to think children do not need a garden as they grow up? My husband and I really can’t agree on such a minor issue. Bearing in mind he knows so little about raising kids anyway. e.g. he was surprised when I told him how many nappies a newborn will get through! He believes that a child needs a garden. I am 3 months’ pregnant. Both of the flats are in our budget. Sadly v expensive as we have to live in London. We are currently renting a 1 bedroom flat on the second floor of a Victorian terrace with awful upstairs neighbours, I’m worried about our baby as they have loud parties and smoke weed etc. we need to move quickly.

Flat 1 £550k
Downstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. Two small double bedrooms, one bathroom with a bath, living/dining/kitchen in one room and a small garden with no grass…only stones.

Flat 2 £600k
Upstairs flat in a semi-detached Victorian house. One normal flight upstairs from the main shared front door. Split level as there is a loft conversion. Three double bedrooms, two bathrooms, separate living/dining room and kitchen.

Both properties are about a 20 minute walk away from several parks and in good school catchment areas. Thoughts?

OP posts:
Gizacluethen · 11/03/2022 11:21

Although being from the NE I cannot get in the mindset of spending half a million pounds on a flat.
Our house was 100k. Big three bedroom, good sized garden, 2 minute walk from a huge park with play area and skate park and ice cream shop, 1 minute walk to outstanding primary school. I could sell this and put a deposit down on a 2nd floor flat with no garden a 25 minute walk away from a park? Okidoki.

Gizacluethen · 11/03/2022 11:14

Neither.
1st is too small for 2 kids.
2nd is too inconvenient for any kids. How are you going to get a baby and a pushchair and your shopping upstairs? Then when you've got multiple kids? No thanks.

And a 20 minute walk to and from a park with 2-3 young kids? That is not going to a 20 minute walk and it is going to be hell.

If you don't have a garden you need a park within less than 5 minutes walk ideally.

Blondeshavemorefun · 11/03/2022 11:13

*home

And I’m in the south east so know prices are insane

Blondeshavemorefun · 11/03/2022 11:04

Tech you can add fake grass to the stoned garden for a few thousand drowning on size

How big /small is garden @whatsay11 in first flat

I do agree with hubby that a garden is essential

Yes many will say they survive without one but spending half a million plus on a hole that doesn’t have one is insane , esp if move slightly away and get more for money

ukborn · 11/03/2022 10:10

I'd get the bigger one, but you will find yourself going to the park most days in the summer, especially if more than one child! There's a reason properties with outside space were so desirable in the wake of covid and lock downs. Being inside with two or more boisterous kids is a major headache, and getting them all ready to go out is a PITA . Also as pp pointed out - dealing with stairs with one child is fine, more (and is there room to leave a pushchair downstairs?) and those stairs will soon become the bane of your life.
So, I'd go with the bigger flat now but I think you will be moving sooner than you think if you have another child.
The ground floor flat seems barely big enough for one baby, not big enough for two and the small outside space not good enough to make up for not having a third bedroom or more living space.

daisybrown37 · 11/03/2022 08:41

Downstairs is also good for now worrying if their running around is annoying the downstairs neighbours!

daisybrown37 · 11/03/2022 08:40

I did a downstairs flat with no private garden and it was difficult to store scooters/bikes/footballs as they got bigger.

The garden to me is a bit of extra storage area - you can put the buggy out there, clothes rack so it is out the way. Not sure I could go back to no garden (and ours is small)

HardyBuckette · 11/03/2022 08:33

There is not a chance in hell I'd go for either of these expensive, clearly unsuitable and undesirable properties to indulge my ridiculously fussy partner.

puffyisgood · 11/03/2022 07:58

in terms of the variables you list, my list of priorities would be:

  1. having enough indoor space (measured by square footage, not number of bedrooms - you can cut the same pizza into 16 rather than 8 slices, but this won't make it bigger);

  2. not living up stairs without a lift;

  3. having a garden.

of course other things such as the area etc can be as or more important than the above.

my advice to you, as others have said, would be to go a little bit further south-west & get a small three bed terraced house that's within budget.

EarlGreywithLemon · 11/03/2022 07:49

We have a similar set up to Flat 1 - split level, first and second floors, shared entrance. We do have a small garden we can access from our kitchen via a set of steps though.

I’d strongly advise against it! Garden debate aside, living up a flight of stairs with a pram is a real pain in every way. Even if there was space in the shared hallway and the neighbours agreed to storing a pram there (not the case for us) you’d still have to lift the baby out of it, take him or her up the stairs, if it’s winter, remove their layers, leave them somewhere safe, and then come back down to pick up whatever else you might have in the pram - and possibly fold the pram. That’s even without the extra step of then bringing the pram upstairs (if you have to do that). If the baby nods off in the pram, as they often do, you can’t just wheel them in and let them sleep whilst you sort yourself out. You have to disturb them every time - cue sometimes a very grumpy baby.
We’re expecting number 2 and looking to move ASAP, as I don’t think it would be doable at all with two children.

Moancup · 11/03/2022 07:36

If your parents own in Notting Hill then they are sitting on a goldmine and could sell up and move closer to you if they need to.

This. You are having to compromise for parents who are in an enormously privileged position.

You’re husband needs to get real. You can’t afford his tastes so you need to compromise. Is he actually engaged in the work (including emotional labour) of house hunting? He’s coming across as someone who hasn’t been exposed to enough of the reality.

user1476277375 · 11/03/2022 07:17

Take a look at the Cannon Hill area of Morden. Very leafy and green.

Joinedforthis22 · 11/03/2022 06:57

If you want three kids (which may well change after the reality of having one) I'd move out to an area where you can afford a house nearer to in-laws (though again there are so many threads on mumsnet about in laws and aging parents changing their mind on babysitting duties after second child is born as if becomes to much).

If your parents own in Notting Hill then they are sitting on a goldmine and could sell up and move closer to you if they need to.

ufucoffee · 11/03/2022 06:51

A garden isn't essential, lots and lots of families live in flats with no outside space and live more than one story up. I'd get the bigger flat.

zaffa · 11/03/2022 06:49

I'm put off the garden by the stones. They are really dangerous with small children and the garden becomes bit of a hazard - DD was really keen to put the decorative stones in her mouth (we ended up fencing off the gravel path at the side of our house to prevent this). In general I think kids need outside space, but if the space isn't usable then look at what's around like parks etc.
I think a 3 bed with separate living space will be better for multiple children. And get a very compact pram!

londonrach · 11/03/2022 06:46

Honestly if you can you need A garden. You won't stay long in either flat if you had more than one child despite what you think now. A baby in a flat is easy ....a toddler less so. Throw another child into the mix and lots of toys and you be climbing the walls. I'd go for flat 1 now and plan to move again in a few years.

Bingbangbongbash · 11/03/2022 06:45

Where I am in Z3 there are 3 bed houses with sizeable gardens in your budget. We have a playground at the end of the road, and another a 10 minute walk away which adjoins acres of green space. All the local primaries are outstanding or good and there is a strong community feel. The compromise is being a little further from the tube but it’s the best line in London so the extra minutes getting there balance out.

If I were you, I’d look further afield as neither flat sounds that appealing to live in with kids.

To answer your specific question - I don’t think a garden is essential, but if you’re spending such a lot on a home, shouldn’t it be more than just the essentials?

danishkids · 11/03/2022 03:26

I lived in a first floor flat for 5 years with 3 kids! It is hard Work lifting up the kids, the pram, the shopping etc.

I Would 100% choose the smaller properly on the Ground floor. Also a garden is amazing especially when the kids are old enough to play alone.

TheCatterall · 11/03/2022 01:32

There’s these public spaces you can access called parks. Even better you don’t need to do the gardening on them or maintenance or fix fences etc. No weeding. No storing gardening shite somewhere.

Your child would manage without one and you can access so much!

I’d rather have a comfier more spacious home for a growing family than worry about the cold, wet space outside that will only be used 6 weeks of the year.

WhoppingBigBackside · 11/03/2022 00:36

@Aaaabbbcccc, drying washing, growing plants and vegetables, having a pet, getting some vitamin D, somewhere to put a paddling pool or trampoline or play on ride on toys or ball games, just somewhere to be when feeling cooped up inside the flat...

Merryoldgoat · 11/03/2022 00:32

You want a Wimbledon property with Morden money.

Good luck with that.

Notcontent · 11/03/2022 00:23

I lived in a lovely flat with my toddler but really hated the inconvenience of having to carry everything up stairs and having no direct access to even a small garden. Also - you mention that you currently have horrible neighbours. This is a real risk in your next property so something to think about.

Therealdealio · 11/03/2022 00:12

Having little kids in a flat with no garden is hell.
A garden saves my sanity!

tricky29 · 11/03/2022 00:09

If you want 3 kids and don’t want to move for 10 years I’d say b, not least for the space/storage. Kids have loads of shit that take up so much space.

But you’ll be annoyed with the dragging under 5s upstairs for a while and the 20 min (more like 30) drag to the park and back.
I’d look further out if you can for something that ticks more boxes.

friedbeans · 11/03/2022 00:09

We live in a flat with no garden in central London with a 3yo, and it's been fine although it would definitely be nicer to have some private outside space. We have some communal outdoor space where we've been allowed to use garden toys like a Little Tikes playhouse and ride-on car, but DD needs to be supervised as we're on the third floor and access to the space is outside the building and in another entrance down the street. We're lucky that we can afford to move to a house later this year, and it will be lovely to have our own play equipment, paddling pool, trampoline etc.

But at the moment living without a garden means that we get out more - I don't understand the comments about having to get ready to go out to the park, that's just something we do every day. I think even if we had a garden we'd prefer to go to the playground as the play equipment is bigger and there are other kids there, and I'd get cabin fever just staying home and only going out to the garden all day. A 20 min walk is quite far for a toddler but you'd probably be pushing them in a buggy or jump on a bus for that distance. There may well be other small playgrounds and gardens closer - there are loads within a 10 min walk to us, although the nearest proper park is about 12 min walk away. In bad weather (the past few months) we don't spend 20 mins walking to a park, we get on the tube and spend the day at a big soft play or museum where DD has loads of space to run around.

We're in a 3rd floor modern flat with a lift, and having to deal with stairs would be really frustrating as DD still naps in her pushchair, so we push her around the block until she falls asleep and then bring her up in the lift so she can continue napping at home. Being in a flat with stairs but no lift would mean that's not possible.

To be honest, as a London parent, I would say the most important consideration for a flat/house purchase is the distance from a good school (if you're not planning to move again before school application deadlines). That means close enough to be well within the last cut-off distance in the past few years - just living within walking distance is not enough, and you need to check the information from the LA, not rely on estate agents or Rightmove. To me that's far more important than having a garden or stairs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread