Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make a historic complain. Trigger warning: abortion

66 replies

kindredsp · 10/03/2022 13:09

Hi guys,
Just looking for a bit of advice please. I fell pregnant unexpectedly (told I couldn't have children so we eased our contraception) when I was 25. I was not long out of University and I had just started my first job in my new career. I didn't live with my boyfriend, he was still studying for his Masters Degree and I was house sharing with friends in a different city.

It came as a huge shock, we literally weren't in a position to have a baby and we just didn't know what the right course of action was for us. So I booked an appointment with my GP to go and talk it through with them with my boyfriend in tow, and hopefully get some information to help us.
At the appointment the GP refused to talk to us about it, she told me that most people have unplanned babies and that we just needed to get on with it, and in 10 years time we'd look back and be glad we kept the baby. I explained that I had only just started a job and my boyfriend had no job because he was still studying full time, and she waved it away and said in 10 years time we'd financially be fine and what a ridiculous reason not to have a baby. She looked me in the eye and said, I won't support an abortion.

It was a small rural practice and she didn't offer to let me see another GP who might not be so opinionated (I didn't even know that was an option) and we walked away with a feeling of embarrassment and tails between our legs. I literally felt that I'd been told off by a parent and I felt ashamed of myself for being so selfish. We looked at each other and said "I guess we're keeping it then." We had no idea there was other support we could access ourselves, she didn't tell us anything.
Now our son is now a strapping 11 year old and of course I wouldn't be without him, but cannot also deny that this last decade has been extremely difficult for us. We were not financially viable for years and without the help of our families we quite frankly wouldn't have been able to meet all our financial needs and put food on the table.

My boyfriend and I moved in together just before our son was born. He still had no job so I had just 2 months off before returning to work. I didn't qualify for MAT leave because I fell pregnant too early into the job, so I missed out on much of that precious time which I feel really sad about even now. The stresses and strains of raising a child in a situation where no matter what you do, it's not enough money wise is definitely not the way I wanted to raise a child.

Now I want to make it very clear, I don't regret having him. Even if 11/12 years on, we are still struggling and we're not looking back and laughing at the past. But I now realise how horrifically we were treated by the GP. I'm wondering if I should look into making a formal complain. I'm not looking for compensation, that would devalue my son's existence, but just to make some noise to ensure that another couple who naively go to talk to their GP are treated fairly and impartially, and given all the options and information available before making an informed choice.

If I was to make a complaint, does anyone have any advice as to how I should go about it? I obviously know the GP and practice (although I'm no longer a patient there), but it was a significant period of time ago. Has too much time passed? Should I just let it go? What do you think?

OP posts:
CheltenhamLady · 10/03/2022 15:29

@x2boys

I am not sure what you mean?

I know it was only ten years ago....which was why I said there were other avenues available and that it was unlikely to happen now. It was unlikely/unusual then I suspect, but there were other options such as BPAS, Marie Stopes etc.

Rosehugger · 10/03/2022 15:27

When I was 17 (in 1993- pre internet) I got two buses to the other side of town to go to a family planning clinic to get the Pill, to avoid going to my family doctor. And they would have also been able to point me in the right direction for an abortion if I'd needed one.

You might have been given very one-sided advice but you could have gone elsewhere for another opinion. Equally if you'd had the abortion you could have been badly affected by that (though I'm not saying it's a natural consequence of abortion but some people don't get over it).

As others have said I'd recommend some counselling to accept the decision you made and count your blessings re your son. Plus by having a child when you did you will still be quite young when he is an independent adult, which is in only a few years time. Plenty of time to make more of your lives yet.

Noglassjustthebottleandastraw · 10/03/2022 15:27

OP I really feel for you but agree with the previous advice on getting counselling. The GP practice won't entertain this at all. You would at best get a we apologies and our practice has since changed etc.

I had my dd at the same time and the amount of information all around me was huge. The internet, family, friends, dh, gp practice on posters/leaflets then my midwives all through appointments/scans etc.

Yes of course the gp you seen definitely didn't give you person centred care. But she wasn't the only health professional you encountered through your pregnancy. You can't blame this gp for you and your partner both deciding to keep your child.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 10/03/2022 15:24

I'm sorry you felt so unlistened to. In all honesty, I think I'd leave it due to the time that has passed. It was of course wrong of the GP to dismiss you the way she did, however so much time has elapsed, it'll be a case of them looking at the notes, which probably only give very basic info, then speaking to the GP who won't remember the conversation, then case closed.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 15:22

Don't worry about other 25 year old couples...very few would be as "naive" as you. And if you don't want compensation (yeah right) that's then isn't it.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 15:18

You were 25, not 15. Were you incapable of going to a Marie Stopes Clinic?

I really am shocked at you.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 15:17

What on earth do you think your son is going to think...now, when he's 30. when he's 80?

For God's sake.

DistrictCommissioner · 10/03/2022 15:16

OP, this was clearly a failure on the part of the GP, and you are clearly struggling with things, but at best all you could do it write an email to the practise manager asking for reflection on this by the GP.

As others have pointed out, it was 2012, & anyone reviewing a complaint from you work point out that as an educated capable person you could have accessed abortion services elsewhere, so I don’t think it would get very far.

Derbee · 10/03/2022 15:13

I’m sorry your GP was shit. But 10 years ago, there were copious amounts of resources available to you, if you’d used the internet. There would have been multiple options, rather than just going along with whatever one lady told you.

The mention of compensation is horrible. Even thinking about the concept. And I don’t know how you could complain, or launch a campaign against the NHS for their lack of help in aborting your son, without him finding out. That would be devastating.

I think you have to try and move on. Accept that for whatever reason, you were passive in your life choices rather than active, and allowed yourself to be easily talked into something you didn’t want. Enjoy your son, and try to put things behind you, for his sake.

JunkIsland · 10/03/2022 15:11

I can see how such a vehement response from a GP would lead the op to feel she had no option but to accept what she was told. Sounds like she and her dp were made to feel very foolish. Not everyone would be confident about approaching another professional or organisation after that.

I think the idea of telling the practice what happened and how it has affected you is a very good one. The letter could be anonymous so no chance of your son coming across a response.

MelCat · 10/03/2022 15:10

My advice would be to let this go. It was over 10 years ago. I can tell you the response you will get now:

  • They don't remember the appointment given the passage of time
  • If you had complained at the time then they would have invited you back in to discuss/been able to address the issue better
  • They are sorry if you are unhappy with the advice given that would not of been their intention

I guarantee you will not get the response you want or the resolution you need. I think it will cause you more distress because not only will you have had the first appointment, but now a response which you feel doesn't address your concerns.

Boogera · 10/03/2022 15:07

@InkySquid

I'm amazed at the number of mumsnetters who are told that they absolutely 100% can't have children and then get pregnant accidentally. I've had various gynaecological issues and it's always been couched as it's unlikely but not impossible.
Me too! If OP complains to anyone it should be whoever told her she couldn’t get pregnant. Seems to be very common for clinicians to be telling women they absolutely can’t have children only for them to get pregnant.
Blossomtoes · 10/03/2022 15:03

When I was 18 I knew about the Pregnancy Advisory Service - and that was 50 years ago.

It’s much too late @kindredsp. You need to move on.

x2boys · 10/03/2022 15:02

Alsio having a child is a life changing experience,even in the best of circumstances ,things are not always plain sailing

ChateauMargaux · 10/03/2022 15:02

I think you should write to the GP involved and tell them how you feel and also contact PALS and ask them to find out what the process should be if a doctor has a conscientious objection to abortion and how you might go about requesting that the doctor in question is advised of the process.

SlashBeef · 10/03/2022 14:58

I honestly can't see how you didn't know there were other avenues to use to seek help. It wasn't decades ago. The internet was very much a thing. I'd seek therapy rather than complaint. You don't want to resent your child.

x2boys · 10/03/2022 14:55

@CheltenhamLady

I agree with *@LottyD32*, no matter how much you insist that you 'wouldn't be without him now' he will definitely wonder when he finds out about the complaint.

I would get some counselling and try to put it behind you. That way, you will get closure privately and your son will be unaware of the angst.

Things are very different now, so you can be assured it wouldn't happen today. Also, you could have taken many other routes at the time. You chose not to do so.

I am not sure what you hope to achieve, but making a formal complaint will open a can of worms you cannot retreat from.

It was only ten years ago.
x2boys · 10/03/2022 14:54

It was ten years ,not thirty years ago this info was readily available then ,I have thankfully never needed to consider abortion but I am aware that whilst a Gp doesn't have to refer you ( for religious beliefs etc) ,they should give you the information as who else can refer you

Suzi888 · 10/03/2022 14:48

I don’t think the G.P was the place to go, they set up the scans etc and confirm a pregnancy.
If you want to end a pregnancy you go to a clinic? That’s my thoughts anyway.

I’m sorry you’ve struggled Flowers

SummerHouse · 10/03/2022 14:47

I really think you need to shift the focus to you and change your feeling on it. Right now, if you could be transported back, would you make the same decision? I couldn't make a compliant against something that resulted in my son. Although no question, this GP was very wrong.

Can you look into counselling? Your feelings are valid but it's like holding on to hot coals, i.e. only hurting yourself. Counseling might help you see this in a more positive way. Yes GP was wrong, yes it was hard, yes you struggled but look what you came through. How brave you were, how you made it work. And look at your son! You did that. Flowers

CheltenhamLady · 10/03/2022 14:45

I agree with @LottyD32, no matter how much you insist that you 'wouldn't be without him now' he will definitely wonder when he finds out about the complaint.

I would get some counselling and try to put it behind you. That way, you will get closure privately and your son will be unaware of the angst.

Things are very different now, so you can be assured it wouldn't happen today. Also, you could have taken many other routes at the time. You chose not to do so.

I am not sure what you hope to achieve, but making a formal complaint will open a can of worms you cannot retreat from.

InkySquid · 10/03/2022 14:44

I'm amazed at the number of mumsnetters who are told that they absolutely 100% can't have children and then get pregnant accidentally. I've had various gynaecological issues and it's always been couched as it's unlikely but not impossible.

Crunchymum · 10/03/2022 14:43

I'm not looking for compensation, that would devalue my son's existence

What sort of compensation could you possibly think exists for this kind of situation?

Are you sure you'd be able to keep your son away from any evidence of this hypothetical complaint?

I find your post very bizarre to be honest.

I managed to help a friend arrange a termination in 2004 without the need for a GP at all (she didn't want to see her family GP so went direct to Marie Stopes)

LottyD32 · 10/03/2022 14:38

Imagine how your son would feel if he found out you launched a campaign against the NHS for not assisting you in aborting him Shock

I'd leave it and move on.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 10/03/2022 14:35

GPs are frequently awful and tell patients all manner of things that will adversely impact their lives for years to come - this sometimes results in death and disability. Unfortunately, it's just one of those things until doctors are no longer regarded as mini gods, which they still are.

You could have accessed a termination elsewhere, it was only a decade or so ago.