Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To continue correcting DD?

106 replies

Nosnogginginthekitchen · 10/03/2022 10:14

Will try and avoid drip feeding, but also keep this to the salient points so fingers crossed I give the right/enough info.

Exh is in a new relationship (well, 2.5ish years, but newer than ours as it were), has got engaged to his girlfriend, she is still married to her exh as he won't agree a divorce.

Exh's fiance has two children and my DD gets on well with them, esp her DD.

Here's the AIBU - DD has been referring to this girl as her step sister. When I gently pointed out that daddy and X aren't married yet, so she will be your step sister, but isn't yet, DD got huffy and said that daddy, X and X's daughter all said they were stepsisters. I repeated that they're future stepsisters, but that X needs to get divorced and married to daddy before they're actually stepsisters.

Other potentially relevant facts:
DD is 6 and can be very dogged about things she thinks are true. DS, who's older, has ADHD and ASD traits and gets very literal about things, so I don't want to set DD up for spouting facts contrary to the truth as DS will argue and neither of them will it go.

However I am also just pissed off that exh and his new family are, essentially lying to my daughter, so I admit I am not 100% sure ianbu because I admit that there are emotions in this.

YABU - let them say stepsister. It'll happen one day and why not let them use the term now?

YANBU - stick to the facts and keep correcting her gently by saying future stepsister - you can't even be sure they'll get married until it happens.

OP posts:
ArnoldBee · 10/03/2022 11:39

Yes its not technically correct and might grate but you don't necessarily want a 6 year old getting out a PowerPoint presentation and pointer everytime she explains their relationship.

I've connected with a group of people I refer to as my cousins. They are my 5th cousins so many times removed but I just call them my cousins.

CatherinedeBourgh · 10/03/2022 11:36

My mother and step-father never actually got married. But seeing as they lived together from when I was 5 until my late teens and had two dc together, the piece of paper seems immaterial. 35 years on, I still consider him my step father, as that is the role he has played in my life.

Nosnogginginthekitchen · 10/03/2022 11:35

@incognitoforthisone

DD is 6 and can be very dogged about things she thinks are true.

Do you think she gets that from you? Because to me, you seem very dogged about something that's purely semantics. Saying 'She's not your stepsister' because DD's dad and his partner aren't married seems very old-fashioned to me.

Lots of couples never get married - there will be plenty of kids who have lived in the same house for 15 years and have never known anything else but the other child being around; it would be weird if they felt obliged to describe them as 'Dad's partner's sister' instead of 'my stepsister'.

It doesn't really matter whether your ex and his new DP are married or not, and I think it's nice that they're making your DD feel like part of a family unit. I completely understand why you might feel a bit resentful of that, but it's perfectly OK and healthy for DD that she has a secure family unit with you and your DS, and also one with her dad, his new partner and her 'stepsister'.

I think it's pretty clear from your post how you feel about your ex living with someone else and how you feel about his new partner and that, rather than the dictionary definition of 'stepsister', is very obviously at the root of your annoyance over this. I completely understand why you'd feel resentful and insecure about your kids being part of more than one family, but I think you need to set that aside for the sake of your kids because ultimately it's in their interests not be worrying about this.

If anything I think it's a trait she's inherited from her dad who can be a bit rigid about things he believes. Thank you for your thoughts.
OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 10/03/2022 11:34

I can see where you are coming from Op. I dislike factual inaccuracy. There’s no such thing as technically still married - your ex is living with a married woman and can’t actually be engaged to her. I dislike when newspapers report a child has been killed by their stepfather 99% of time it’s mum’s boyfriend not their stepfather. But it is accepted shorthand hand now like men call their girlfriend their missus when not married or partners refer to their ‘in laws’. It’s important your dc has a good relationship with them and shorthand of stepsister seems best fit. If she was older or asked directly I don’t think you are wrong to clarify but day you day for all intents and purposes she is her step sister.

incognitoforthisone · 10/03/2022 11:31

DD is 6 and can be very dogged about things she thinks are true.

Do you think she gets that from you? Because to me, you seem very dogged about something that's purely semantics. Saying 'She's not your stepsister' because DD's dad and his partner aren't married seems very old-fashioned to me.

Lots of couples never get married - there will be plenty of kids who have lived in the same house for 15 years and have never known anything else but the other child being around; it would be weird if they felt obliged to describe them as 'Dad's partner's sister' instead of 'my stepsister'.

It doesn't really matter whether your ex and his new DP are married or not, and I think it's nice that they're making your DD feel like part of a family unit. I completely understand why you might feel a bit resentful of that, but it's perfectly OK and healthy for DD that she has a secure family unit with you and your DS, and also one with her dad, his new partner and her 'stepsister'.

I think it's pretty clear from your post how you feel about your ex living with someone else and how you feel about his new partner and that, rather than the dictionary definition of 'stepsister', is very obviously at the root of your annoyance over this. I completely understand why you'd feel resentful and insecure about your kids being part of more than one family, but I think you need to set that aside for the sake of your kids because ultimately it's in their interests not be worrying about this.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/03/2022 11:30

I think it’s really important for children to have sense of permanence and belonging, and knowing where they stand. Calling this girl her Ss is going to help with this.

I wouldn’t tell my kids not to call exh’s partner their step mum just because they aren’t legally married - it makes them feel secure to say that. Likewise I’d never call their little brother a “half-brother”.

GlitteryGreen · 10/03/2022 11:29

I couldn't care about this. Lots of people never marry these days but are just as established a family unit/couple as if they were.

I think it's fine for her to say step sister. I call my DP's children my SCs even though we aren't married, just for sake of ease. It's the easiest way to denote our relationship quickly.

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 10/03/2022 11:29

You're being completely ridiculous.

You should be doing everything you can to help your daughter feel that she is a part of that family, the family her dad will be living with. She should feel completely part of that and you shouldn't be trying to drive a wedge by not picking with bloody terminology.

She has step siblings. She likes them. She feels part of the family her dad has formed. That is how it should be. Stop messing with it.

Keladrythesaviour · 10/03/2022 11:27

My DH's father has never married his partner, who he has been with for nearly 25 years. He didn't grow up with her children at all but they still refer to each other as step sisters/step brothers. It's just a technical title. I don't think marriage really has anything to do with it. My DB doesn't plan to ever marry his partner, I still call her my SIL because she's as much part of the family as she would be if they married, just without the legal bit. I'd say you don't need to split hairs and just help your DC with prclocessing these new relationships.

Leftbutcameback · 10/03/2022 11:27

I wouldn’t worry about it at all. I sometimes refer to my parent’s partner who is sadly no longer with us as my SM (or late SM) for ease, and because it was that type of relationship.

RachelGreeneGreep · 10/03/2022 11:26

@Gobrookeyourself

Oh come on. The OP asked for opinions, we’ve given them to her and she’s accepted them graciously and admitted her views might have been skewed. No need to call her petty or jealous, it’s not an easy situation to be in.
Exactly. I see this happening more and more on MN. It doesn't seem to be enough for some to give their view without making some unpleasant remarks to go along with it.
FlippyFloppyFlappy · 10/03/2022 11:26

Aww OP you sound like a lovely mum ❤️
Just ignore the inevitable comments from posters who never bother reading the full thread 🤷🏼‍♀️

Nosnogginginthekitchen · 10/03/2022 11:23

@Just10moreminutesplease

YABU. She has enough to get her head around without worrying about the legal definition of step sister. She’s trying to make sense of her world that includes a blended family.

I get it might be hard for you but, speaking as someone who was once in your daughter’s shoes, minimising her new relationships is likely to make it harder for her to adapt.

Thank you. This is really helpful and has made me cry a little bit. She's had the hardest time of all of us adjusting to the new situation and it breaks my heart a little bit every time she cries for daddy or wishes he still lived here. I will keep this perspective in mind and apologise to her for correcting her when she's home from school. x
OP posts:
Viviennemary · 10/03/2022 11:22

I think it does matter. She is the daughter of your ex's girlfriend and in no way a step-sister. The girlfriend isn't even divorced yet. Mad.

Nosnogginginthekitchen · 10/03/2022 11:20

Ever since he left I've had to do a lot of biting my tongue to protect the kids and maintain a civil coparenting relationship. I'll just add this to the list and keep hoping he'll try and do the same occasionally. Which would be nice.
Thanks all. Not sure what I'm being accused of being jealous of, but I freely admit I was possibly being a little petty and will stop.

OP posts:
SartresSoul · 10/03/2022 11:17

If your DD wants to call her a stepsister then leave her to it. It’s 2022 so I’d say it’s fairly common to be referred to as a step-parent/sibling before marriage and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with this.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 10/03/2022 11:17

@VainAbigail

Your sound petty and jealous.

In fact very jealous of all the relationships your ex has around him now.

Why don't you read the thread before sniping at the OP. She's accepted she's wrong so there's no need for the nasty comments
Just10moreminutesplease · 10/03/2022 11:16

YABU. She has enough to get her head around without worrying about the legal definition of step sister. She’s trying to make sense of her world that includes a blended family.

I get it might be hard for you but, speaking as someone who was once in your daughter’s shoes, minimising her new relationships is likely to make it harder for her to adapt.

CushionSpiral · 10/03/2022 11:11

It sucks, but the fact they want to refer to each other a step sisters is a good thing. Whether the parents are married or not will not make any difference to how they view that family unit.
But will be hard with him saying he didn’t want to live with kids.

FlippyFloppyFlappy · 10/03/2022 11:10

@Gobrookeyourself

Oh come on. The OP asked for opinions, we’ve given them to her and she’s accepted them graciously and admitted her views might have been skewed. No need to call her petty or jealous, it’s not an easy situation to be in.
Well said. Sorry you're finding it tough OP (no snark).
RussianSpy101 · 10/03/2022 10:58

YABU this sounds really petty in the kindest possible way OP.

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 10/03/2022 10:57

You sound like the ex wife of a friend who insists that her kids don’t refer to their step sister as half sister, singling her out from all the others as she’s the only one who isn’t a half sibling. It’s just semantics.

TheOrigRights · 10/03/2022 10:56

I'd let this one go. It's better than she refers to her as her step-sister than not, all things considered.

I still refer to my now ex ILs as FIL, MIL and SIL. I have absolutely nothing to do with my ex, but am very close to my ILs. It's harming no one and "hello, I'm Jim's ex daughter in law" sounds daft!

Gobrookeyourself · 10/03/2022 10:56

Oh come on. The OP asked for opinions, we’ve given them to her and she’s accepted them graciously and admitted her views might have been skewed. No need to call her petty or jealous, it’s not an easy situation to be in.

JulesJoules · 10/03/2022 10:55

Only on MN do people get so wound up about marriage = step relations. They are engaged, they are to all intents and purposes a married couple, so ex's fiance is your DD's step mum and her children are her step siblings. Don't get wound up about labels. If everyone is being treated properly let it go it doesn't matter.

Why does this stuff come up time and time again on here.