Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sell my car to pay off debts?

37 replies

Kindfulness · 10/03/2022 08:25

Hi all!

Knowing that second hand cars are worth quite a bit at the mo (Ours is probably work £6-7k from research)...

Would we be unreasonable to sell our car to pay off debt and then take out a new lease car on finance? (Debt of around £3.5k)

Our original plan was for me to get a few pay days behind me and pay off a chunk of our debt, and then look into a new car. However, is time of the essence? Should we look to sell our car sooner rather than later to cash in on the inflated values of second hand cars?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
declutteringmymind · 10/03/2022 12:20

Put the monthly payment for the pcp or hp towards the debt and pay it off. Then get a new car as normal.

It's a car, not a commodity, so to swap interest free debt for debt that costs money is a folly on the face of it.

Kindfulness · 10/03/2022 11:51

@TimeForTeaAndG

Remember that utility prices are only going up at the moment so will you be able to keep up a car payment?
I know! My spreadsheet is constantly getting updated at the mo with everything going up.

We wouldn't take on a lease car if we couldn't afford it.

I worked my butt off retraining last year and have a well-paid job now! Hence why we are wanting to lease. We want a bigger car and a more reliable car as we'd like to drive to north france with our daughter but don't trust our current car!

OP posts:
Kindfulness · 10/03/2022 11:49

@brainhurts

I think if a new lease car is in your long term plan, then yes selling your car while prices are high is a good idea. I would make sure the car you want is available first
That's a good idea! I can see others have said there's issues with availability of new cars 🚗
OP posts:
TimeForTeaAndG · 10/03/2022 11:44

Remember that utility prices are only going up at the moment so will you be able to keep up a car payment?

brainhurts · 10/03/2022 11:41

I think if a new lease car is in your long term plan, then yes selling your car while prices are high is a good idea. I would make sure the car you want is available first

TimeForTeaAndG · 10/03/2022 11:41

Since you need the car and you're going to be debt free in 6 months and you aren't paying interest then I'd just keep doing that. Then you have a car that you own and no debt.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/03/2022 11:37

If you're going to take a new car for a set period and then hand it back, what do you plan to do for a car after then?

Will you be afford to save to buy your next car outright or will you need to keep on paying to get another new car and are you happy with this?

BarbaraofSeville · 10/03/2022 11:34

Regardless of selling our car(it is owned by us) we wanted a car on lease (I've previously used pcp and wouldn't do it again) because we like that we can have a new car, more reliable, and not be lumped with a balloon payment at the end

I don't think, practically, there is any difference between leasing or PCP for a car. With both, you're paying a monthly fee, and possibly a deposit, for the use of a car over a set period, with similar limits/rules on mileage and return condition.

With a PCP, you have the option at the end to pay the balloon payment and keep the car, or hand it back and pay nothing more.

I'd just compare the cost of the payments over the contract payment, by either way and obviously availability of a car is also a big consideration at the moment.

Kindfulness · 10/03/2022 11:29

@Foxyloxy1plus1

Get an interest free credit card and a direct debit to pay the debt off that way.
The debt is on a 0% CC Smile
OP posts:
Kindfulness · 10/03/2022 11:26

Hey everyone - thanks for the sensible suggestions!

To answer a few questions:

We need a car to do the nursery run, to get to work etc. so going car-less isn't an option.

Regardless of selling our car(it is owned by us) we wanted a car on lease (I've previously used pcp and wouldn't do it again) because we like that we can have a new car, more reliable, and not be lumped with a balloon payment at the end. We don't want to own the car.

I think we would consider HP, but again, by the end of the term, the car isn't worth that much and things can start to go wrong.

The debt will be paid off regardless of selling our car within the next 6 months. But I wondered whether it was sensible to push the sale of our car forward to now, to get the most money for it?

If that makes sense Smile

OP posts:
Foolsrule · 10/03/2022 09:57

@drawingpad - yes, true. You’d need to think about what to do once the first three/four years on the lease are up. In the short term it could help but longer term you may end up back where you are now, OP.

drawingpad · 10/03/2022 09:50

I do see what you’re thinking though and in some circumstances, it could makes sense, eg if the interest rate was lower on the lease scheme than what you’re paying to service your debt now

The interest rate isn't really relevant here when you are talking about a debt of £3.5k which is very little in comparison to the cost of a new car - even with a basic budget car it's still going to more then double the debt.

I agree, also if you're one of those people who spend a lot on fuel and could lease an electric car, so the saving on fuel goes a long way towards the cost of the car.

The cost of an electric is much higher then a petrol/diesel equivalent, with less options available so the car would ultimately cost much more then the debt, even with a fuel saving - which only really works on high mileage motors just now

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 10/03/2022 09:39

Get an interest free credit card and a direct debit to pay the debt off that way.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/03/2022 09:29

I do see what you’re thinking though and in some circumstances, it could makes sense, eg if the interest rate was lower on the lease scheme than what you’re paying to service your debt now

I agree, also if you're one of those people who spend a lot on fuel and could lease an electric car, so the saving on fuel goes a long way towards the cost of the car.

Otherwise, it's just increasing your debt significantly, if you can get a car at all.

If you could swap to a much cheaper car, pay the debt off and then save so you don't have to borrow to buy cars, that would be a good plan, otherwise it's keeping you in debt to maintain your lifestyle, which isn't a great position to be in.

Thinkingblonde · 10/03/2022 09:24

I’d sell the car, pay off the debt and buy a cheaper car with the cash left over.
I wouldn’t get a lease car/PCP , in three years time or however long the contract is for, you’ll be in the same position you are now.
My friends son got a car on one of those schemes, he didn’t have the cash to pay at the end of the contract so he had to return the car.

Foolsrule · 10/03/2022 09:20

I see what you’re getting at. If you’re paying say £300/month to clear current debt and could pay that on a lease on a new car, having cleared the pre-existing debt, you’re sort of in the same position but driving round in a shiny new car. And if you make money on the old car, that’s great. The only issue is - can you actually get hold of a brand new car? It’s the scarcity of supply that’s caused the uptick in second hand car prices in the first place. I do see what you’re thinking though and in some circumstances, it could makes sense, eg if the interest rate was lower on the lease scheme than what you’re paying to service your debt now.

drawingpad · 10/03/2022 09:20

@SpiderinaWingMirror

If you can find the lease deal you want AND the car is actually available then yes, sensible. We gave up though because after 1 go of paying deposit and then being told its now 6 months, we simply bought another second hand car

Can you explain what is sensible? Selling a car you own to pay off debt and then taking on a higher debt in the form of a lease car is the opposite of sensible.

Jmaho · 10/03/2022 09:18

The best plan if possible would be the sell your car, pay off debt. Put the rest into premium bonds maybe and do without a car until prices come down. Then buy a second hand cheaper car with the money

SpiderinaWingMirror · 10/03/2022 09:15

If you can find the lease deal you want AND the car is actually available then yes, sensible.
We gave up though because after 1 go of paying deposit and then being told its now 6 months, we simply bought another second hand car

balalake · 10/03/2022 09:15

I'd suggest you sell and then live without a car. Or if getting another one, get a smaller car.

LampLighter414 · 10/03/2022 09:12

Do you own your car outright now?

And you mention you plan to lease. So you realise in 2 years or however long the lease is, you will not own a car. Similarly all cars are expensive, not just second hands one, so that lease will not be good value compared to what you could have leased a couple years back. I get the impression you are just thinking ooh we can get the debt cleared AND a shiny new car (with a corresponding debt attached) without really thinking about it.

If you own the car, keep it and pay off your debt with your income as it comes in. You will have a car you are not making monthly payments on and will have it to use for years to come with no need to hand it back to the dealer.

Doveyouknow · 10/03/2022 09:11

The reason that the prices for second hand cars are so high is because the supply of new cars is limited. If you sell your car now, can you wait 6mnths + while you wait for the new one?

frownaminute · 10/03/2022 09:08

YABU, it's not going to help you if you pay off debts but take on another big financial commitment.

You need to look at how the debt built up. Are you living above your means? Is there any other way you can reduce outgoings to prevent you getting in debt again?

Nobody needs a brand new car or a lease car. If you need a car then sell the one you have and buy a cheaper one, preferably smaller that will also cost less on fuel and insurance. Think about whether you even need a car if you live somewhere with decent public transport.

MRex · 10/03/2022 09:06

It depends how much you need your car. Depending on where you live and how much you use it, a combination of public transport and taxis might well be cheaper for a few years while you get finances in order. From the prices, it sounds like your plan include downgrading the car for something cheaper, which definitely makes sense. Check that you can pay off the lease finance if you choose to, and that rates are fixed for whatever period you'll need to save up.

3ormoredogs · 10/03/2022 08:59

We had a 9k car and a 5k loan/finance.

Sold car, paid loan and bought a 2k car. Kept 2k as an emergency fund.

The cheaper car is much more efficient than the expensive one ever was and it makes me happy knowing I haven’t wasted a fortune on it. I would never get a lease or PCP again.