Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think history will judge the U.K. over ukraine

260 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 10/03/2022 07:01

I am so ashamed at how the U.K. is the only country in Europe effectively closing its doors to Ukrainian refugees. These are mostly women and children fleeing a country that has collapsed in the space of 2 weeks. A maternity hospital was bombed yesterday.

The rest of Europe is opening its arms and helping in every way it can but the U.K. had pretty much slammed the door, made it as difficult as possible to come. The U.K. signed the refugee convention in the 50’s that said that people fleeing war don’t need tons of paperwork and yet that’s exactly what they are asking people for.

I feel so embarrassed when everyone else is helping that we are doing nothing- we are an outlier in Europe.

I hate what this country has become under this disgusting government. I see so many posts on social media or brits wanting to do more.

OP posts:
OchonAgusOchonOh · 10/03/2022 10:59

Historically The UK has always welcomed immigrants with open arms clearly. That is something to be proud of.

Yeah. That's why my parents encountered "No Blacks, No Dogs, No Irish" in London in the 1960's. They certainly felt welcome.

raspberryjamchicken · 10/03/2022 10:57

I see the usual fallacy is being peddled of all refugees wanting to come to the UK ahead of anywhere else. Nigel Farage and his ilk really did a great job of spreading their lies. Here are a list of the top 25 refugee-hosting countries and guess what, the UK isn't on it! The only European countries on there are Germany, France and Sweden.
www.statista.com/statistics/263423/major-refugee-hosting-countries-worldwide/

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/03/2022 10:54

The xenophobia and British exceptionalism is strong. The UK abandoned the Afgans, our shunning of Ukrainians will be an addendum to that. I do like the idea of housing refugees and homeless folk in properties belonging to Russian oligarchs.Grin

Putin is a cunt and he looks like this Envy.

PurpleCarpets · 10/03/2022 10:54

Far be from me to criticise a woman in a senior government position but Ms Patel is quite simply not up to the job and it would seem that others in the Home Office are not either.

To be promoted in government now you have to be on the right side of the brexit argument, which has utterly poisoned British politics. In other words you must either truly believe that brexit was a good idea (very few senior politians do) or be prepared to pretend that you do. In other words you must either be incompetent or a liar. This explains the appalling mess in all other areas of politics.

loutoofoo · 10/03/2022 10:51

Yet this is the government you lot in England voted for.

madbadrad · 10/03/2022 10:48

@Rinatinabina absolutely plus the whole process will be made much smoother by already having family here who speak the language and understand and can guide loved one through the system. I don't think many understand the psychological trauma that comes will being a refugee there are a whole set of issues on arrival in a new unfamiliar country. Settling people where they already having connections makes sense for everyone.

millymae · 10/03/2022 10:46

It beggars belief to me that anyone can think the UK is handling the refugee situation well and can defend the Home Office in the approach it is taking. It seems to me that the right appears not to know what the left is doing especially at ground level ( and I don’t mean that in a political sense at all).
Far be from me to criticise a woman in a senior government position but Ms Patel is quite simply not up to the job and it would seem that others in the Home Office are not either. The arrangements ( if you can even call them that) that have been made in France for those wanting to cross the channel are an utter disgrace. Anyone that thinks they can defend these is defending the indefensible and I will be interested to hear what Ms Patel has to say in parliament later. No doubt she will absolve herself from all responsibility, plus she has form for telling lies so I’ll be taking everything she says with a pinch of salt.
Even accepting that some reports we see and hear about in the media may be biased I am truly ashamed that we as a country are showing ourselves to be so lacking in empathy and understanding for the position that those Ukrainian refugees who want to come to the UK. now find themselves in when other countries have been so much more welcoming. We may be able to talk the talk, but our actions let us down
Its all very well for those saying that the red tape surrounding visa applications needs to be complied with and that staff in the Home Office are working all hours to ensure this can be done speedily but as far as I can see whatever they have done so far hasn’t achieved the desired result.
Common sense tells me that the vast majority of the refugees wanting to join family in the UK are the elderly, children and woman with no ulterior motive other than they want to be safe, yet for some reason we are expecting them to jump through hoop after hoop to ensure this is the case.
Where is our compassion?

Suzi888 · 10/03/2022 10:44

@BeHappy91818

We are a tiny island that already has over 67 million people living on it with a huge homelessness problem.

How about we house all the people that live here first before welcoming more.

A lot of other countries are far bigger and don’t have remotely the same amount of people living on it already.

We are indeed a tiny overpopulated island whose infrastructure can’t support its own ever growing population in my opinion. BUT people are dying.

During covid there was no homelessness- everyone was temporarily housed (in this LA in any case). Some people don’t want to be housed, they don’t want to live by the rules, often due to other factors such as drugs, alcohol, their employment, restrictions etc. Some are housed but the properties aren’t nice, it’s emergency accommodation and they have to stay there and bid on flats and houses or find private rentals. It’s too complex for this thread and yes, more needs to be done, more money is needed BUT and it’s a HUGE BUT it’s completely separate from people fleeing for their lives.

The lack of compassion on this thread is astounding. There for the grace of God … and all that! Let’s hope the U.K is never in this position eh? Hmm

Blackbird2020 · 10/03/2022 10:44

Why is the UK a practical alternative?
It is 1500km and a ferry from Ukraine.
Is it because benefits will be easier and more generous and permanent?

No! Germany has good benefits for refugees too (maybe even better than the U.K.!) Why is there this myth that the benefits are better than some other European countries???

It’s because of the language. You can get back on your feet again quicker (and get off benefits!) if you can speak the same language as the country you’ve fled to. You can WORK. And maybe not just as a cleaner. Maybe in your field!

Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 10:43

Also if primarily visas are being issued on the basis of family connections I assume those families on the whole will be trying to fit their loved ones into their homes. If my sisters were fleeing a war in their home country I would get them into my house with their kids, if it meant we had to sleep like sardines then so be it.

Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 10:40

Yes the refugee response has been pitiful. Really pitiful.

However I am incredibly proud of the fact that the UK was one of the few countries to arms and training to Ukraine in advance of the invasion that everyone could see coming and armed well (no late helmets and as PP pointed out unsafe to use weapons) we are also sending the most advanced anti aircraft missiles available (which we should of we can’t help with a no fly zone) we acted in a timely and generous fashion. Not that you would think that from reading mumsnet.

Tell you who I’m judging pretty fucking hard right now, Germany is refusing to complete the block of Russia from swift. In the big scheme of things as these things are written in history books it won’t be lost on future generations that Europe is STILL buying russian gas and oil. The UK and the USA has said they will no longer buy.

madbadrad · 10/03/2022 10:38

@BeHappy91818 Im wondering do you have young Children? If so would you stay and still stay to defend your country? I can tell you that I would do anything in my power to get my child to safety.

madbadrad · 10/03/2022 10:35

@Jonjim

The refugees are spreading across Europe not just coming here. Those coming here are primarily reuniting with family who are already settled here through a family scheme. When displaced by its logical for many reasons to join family already in safe countries.

Suzi888 · 10/03/2022 10:34

@AmbushedByCake

Don't need to wait for history. The UK government is being judged internationally and by a large chunk of the UK population already.
^ The U.K government have admitted that they misjudged how the U.K would feel about refugees. Probably because we have a strong history of NOT welcoming refugees. But these are white refugees so it’s different.
BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 10:33

[quote madbadrad]@BeHappy91818
Id really like hear your answers to the below

So because we have issues with homelessness we shouldn't take in refugees? Are you serious? Homelessness isnt an issue that is unique to the U.K. it's is a problem throughout the world any across most other wealthy nations too. Both need addressing not one or the other. So if there is a problem with homelessness everywhere, where should refugees go?

I am very interested to know what you'd do if you life was in danger due to war or persecution? If everything you had worked hard to achieve was destroyed? Whether that be your home, your business or your career?

People in this country are far too complacent about the safety and freedom they enjoy. That's not saying some people don't have it tough here. But there is a very mean minded inward looking segment in our society and it's very sad.[/quote]
Clearly I’m serious or I wouldn’t of wrote what I did.

I’d personally stay and defend my country like the women who are over there and help out. I wouldn’t flee.

There’s your answer.

Jonjim · 10/03/2022 10:32

Why is the UK a practical alternative?
It is 1500km and a ferry from Ukraine.
Is it because benefits will be easier and more generous and permanent?

Hellorhighwater · 10/03/2022 10:30

@THisbackwithavengeance

"Angry and ashamed". Get a grip. Yes, it's obviously the UK's fault that Putin has invaded Ukraine.

I used to work with refugees; the UK accepts plenty. You need to come off social media.

There is a process which needs to be followed. Technically, refugees should stay in the first safe country they enter, not pick and choose. That's a European policy, by the way not a UK policy. If you allow an undocumented and unprocessed free for all, you will get thousands of people claiming to be Ukrainian just to get in.

Some people on here are so full of bile and resentment because their political party of choice didn't get elected, they will never agree with anything the Government does on the principle of it. It's ridiculous.

That isn’t correct. They should register in the first safe country, but the papers are then valid anywhere in Europe, so they can, and are encouraged to, go on to disperse the exodus and reach family or friends, or countries where their skills will be valuable. (Like maybe somewhere they speak a little of the language?!) That was the whole point.

Anyone who’s ever been over a border in Europe knows you can just drive/walk/hopscotch over them anyway. Except Switzerland, where you need to pay a modest fee. Although I imagine they waive it if you walk, as it’s for using the motorways.

MikeandDave · 10/03/2022 10:30

If the UK had just let the people with family ties or some kind of sponsorship that they have agreed on but made it a quick and easy process there would be much less judgement. Its a long way to the UK for people with no connections here and many of them would probably prefer to stay somewhere closer to home. It's the elderly parents and young relatives of UK citizens who are waiting in the cold for days, maybe running out of funds, for a visa they are entitled to that looks terrible for the UK. Even Torys are appalled by this chaos.

BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 10:30

@PenStation

This absolutely isn’t true in my area *@BeHappy91818* There is one rough sleeper who chooses to do this. The council employ a team who house everyone who wants to be and supports them to claim benefits. Often the housing used isn’t very good. But it’s a roof over the head.
Maybe try walking through some other areas of the UK then.
madbadrad · 10/03/2022 10:29

@BeHappy91818
Id really like hear your answers to the below

So because we have issues with homelessness we shouldn't take in refugees? Are you serious? Homelessness isnt an issue that is unique to the U.K. it's is a problem throughout the world any across most other wealthy nations too. Both need addressing not one or the other. So if there is a problem with homelessness everywhere, where should refugees go?

I am very interested to know what you'd do if you life was in danger due to war or persecution? If everything you had worked hard to achieve was destroyed? Whether that be your home, your business or your career?

People in this country are far too complacent about the safety and freedom they enjoy. That's not saying some people don't have it tough here. But there is a very mean minded inward looking segment in our society and it's very sad.

Iggly · 10/03/2022 10:28

@x2boys

I think the point is we already have a huge homeless problem ,I realise it's complex and there are lots of people who have drug and alcohol issues and can't maintain tenancies etc. But there is also a hidden homeless problem ,with families living in B&B,s and other inadequate accommodation for far too long and this isn't being dealt with
It’s not being dealt with because there is the lack of political will.
jytdtysrht · 10/03/2022 10:27

The UK has taken some of the strongest measures and heavily encouraged other countries to do so as well, in pursuit of stopping Putin but without provoking WW3. So I don't think our efforts will be negatively viewed from that perspective. Our prime minister has spoken out far more strongly than others.

But
People struggle to get healthcare here, our NHS is literally bursting at the seams. It's undeniable that it's in total crisis. Every year people struggle with school places, classrooms are overcrowded. What about mental health services? People kill themselves before they can get help. Housing demand massively outstrips supply. I honestly do not think that we are the right place for refugees, despite the fact that I would want to have them come here and that they deserve to be able to come here.

bozzabollix · 10/03/2022 10:27

I’m disgusted too, but have been since 2016 when racism effectively became the driver of this country.

BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 10:27

@Lesperance for the size of the uk we are overpopulated.

It doesn’t matter if you don’t like it or not or think it’s shameful. It’s fact. We are overpopulated! We have a huge homelessness problem which needs sorting before we house thousands of other people and why shouldn’t we have green space for our kids to run about!

The world is also bigger then just Europe and the UK! Lots of country’s have far more space and can accommodate them better.

I’m not ashamed of my opinion that I think we need to sort out the huge problems we already have here housing the people on our streets I see daily over taking more people in.

Bollindger · 10/03/2022 10:27

Let's be truthful about this.
If I invade your home and threatened you at gun point, you would want to get me out and return , NOT move into a castle in Scotland.
Anyone who wants to come and live in the UK with no contact to the UK and travels across that many countries to be refused at the edge of France is not a true refugee.
They are using the War and targeting the UK as trade up destination.