Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think history will judge the U.K. over ukraine

260 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 10/03/2022 07:01

I am so ashamed at how the U.K. is the only country in Europe effectively closing its doors to Ukrainian refugees. These are mostly women and children fleeing a country that has collapsed in the space of 2 weeks. A maternity hospital was bombed yesterday.

The rest of Europe is opening its arms and helping in every way it can but the U.K. had pretty much slammed the door, made it as difficult as possible to come. The U.K. signed the refugee convention in the 50’s that said that people fleeing war don’t need tons of paperwork and yet that’s exactly what they are asking people for.

I feel so embarrassed when everyone else is helping that we are doing nothing- we are an outlier in Europe.

I hate what this country has become under this disgusting government. I see so many posts on social media or brits wanting to do more.

OP posts:
Thewindwhispers · 10/03/2022 11:43

@Papertyger

Unfortunately I think history will judge NATO, the western democracies very badly indeed. We said after Hitler, never again. The endless endless rope we've given to Putin, entertaining him on the world's stage, giving him credibility.

He's done so much prior to Syria but at that point ,he crossed lines.

This monster is on all our shoulders.

Yes, this.

We knew Putn was an evil murdering dictator who hates democracy and the West. But we paid him $500mil/day anyway because oil and gas are convenient. And now he has lots of weapons. 🤦‍♀️

x2boys · 10/03/2022 11:37

@MsFogi

Forget history, the rest of Europe is already judging the UK on its response to Ukranian refugees.
Again such a typical Mumsnet response ,the rest of Europe is rather more concerned about Putin and what he will do next .
TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 11:37

I worry about the logistics of it.

No-one would refuse a child refugee shelter but last night on Question Time, it was said there will be a 100,000 child refugees coming to the UK.

Taking emotion out of it, where will the school places come from? It would mean at least 100 new large schools of 1000 pupil capacity each. And yet, we have had recent threads from posters complaining that they are having difficulty finding secondary school places.

Around here, I have not been able to get my child to see a doctor and dentist's appointments have to be made 6 months in advance.

How is all going to be managed?

So yes, we shouldn't turn away child refugees but where are they going to be educated?

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/03/2022 11:36

@ClaudineClare

I don't know the details for Scotland but in the Westminster elections, Labour won more seats than the Tories. We also have a Labour government here in Wales, which was re-elected last year with an increased share of the vote.
Yes it's a labour government in Wales, but you still have 13 tory mps there. Just Labour is more preferred but they do still get votes. Scotland prefers snp, the government is snp, but we still have 6 tory mps. And when you look at the results in some constituencies, some of the votes were bloody close for it to swing to tory instead, or another party. But the most votes wins. I dunno how close the votes were for Wales though, whether Labour won easily in some constituencies or it was a close contest.

It's annoying, but they do have support.

MsFogi · 10/03/2022 11:34

Forget history, the rest of Europe is already judging the UK on its response to Ukranian refugees.

Angrymum22 · 10/03/2022 11:33

Are you more worried about our/reputation when travelling abroad in the future? Or are you genuinely concerned for the refugees fleeing a war torn country.
You come across as being more worried how you will be judged as a British citizen in the future rather than a humanitarian.
I have had a few days away from the news, my DH had a stroke on Friday so I’m afraid I’m a little more concerned about our immediate future.
My first thought on seeing the news re the refugee issue was that it was important not to allow people to abuse an immigration free for all. I have been horrified, recently after watching programmes about people who profiteer from disasters such as the Manchester Arena bombing and Grenville tower fire.
The UK is very much the preferred destination for refugees, possibly it’s a geographical thing. Like it’s residents having a bad dy of water between us and mainland Europe does give us a greater sense of security.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 10/03/2022 11:33

I'm not sure it's surprising is it? The government and media have demonised refugees for years and the UK have implemented a hard line approach, this is what people apparently wanted. We voted in a Tory party who are hardly known for their amazing humanitarian response, what did anyone expect?

I also agree with pp in regards to Russian money, its corrupt as anything. I fully disagree with how we treat refugees so obviously am disgusted by this but I'm shocked that people are shocked.

ClaudineClare · 10/03/2022 11:32

I don't know the details for Scotland but in the Westminster elections, Labour won more seats than the Tories. We also have a Labour government here in Wales, which was re-elected last year with an increased share of the vote.

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/03/2022 11:22

@ClaudineClare

So did Scotland and Wales. It was what the majority of the entire UK wanted, don't try and say that certain areas didn't want them. The only area that doesn't have them actually is Northern Ireland

Your ignorance is really showing.

There are tory mps in Scotland and Wales, and even in areas they didn't win, they got a fair amount of votes. Its first past the post unfortunately, the majority wins and they got the majority. They'll continue getting it too. Where am I wrong?
Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 11:21

Lets be honest whether its Corbyn suggesting the russians should be invited to investigate the skripal poisoning or tories taking russian money or european governments going ahead with nordstream 2 DESPITE the annexation of Crimea and Donbass (Ukraine has effectively been at war for 8 years already) we have enough idiots to thank for the current situation. Even Biden was running around trying to secure oil and gas from other countries to fill the gap for the europeans while the europeans did pretty much nothing.

The idea that Britain is uniquely bad is am odd one to me, if you look at what countries have actually done the UK is doing ok DESPITE all of the above shamefulness from the political establishment, despite the mess we are making with the refugee situation. Given that the UK is pushing the hardest on SWIFT at the moment I don’t think the Russian government is feeling like they got their money’s worth.

I am definitely not saying that the UK is covering itself in glory all the time here but it would be good if people had a clear view of what we are and are not doing. There was a thread before lauding the EU response vs the UK - the level of misinformation was astounding, genuinely would believe no-one reads a newspaper.

bossox · 10/03/2022 11:21

Some have raised the matter of UK being full and lacking basic resources like schools, healthcare and housing. Therefore there is no room for anyone to get sanctuary.

So..... is that the fault of those seeking asylum? Or is it the result of bad Governance and lack of investment by such governments in a good quality of life for all, not just the few.

Life in the UK is dire for many of its citizens at the moment. But those with resources don't and won't notice.

So by their actions shall you know them I say. And as for racism, I do believe it is widespread, silently so maybe but it is there in spades. And I also believe that not everyone that voted for Brexit is racist, but every racist did vote for Brexit.

ClaudineClare · 10/03/2022 11:19

So did Scotland and Wales. It was what the majority of the entire UK wanted, don't try and say that certain areas didn't want them. The only area that doesn't have them actually is Northern Ireland

Your ignorance is really showing.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 10/03/2022 11:15

@Bollindger

If your running away from a war, should you not stop in the nearest country and help be provided to that country to help you? Not cross many countries to get into the one that offers the most benefits to you. After all the is so much space in The EU to help settle people...
And the EU is accepting them. Given the numbers, it is not feasible, practical or humane for all the refugees to stay in the first country they arrive in. Ireland has already accepted over 2.5k, with the expectation that we will accept up to 100k. That is in a population of 5m.

This notion that the Uk provides amazing benefits is utter nonsense. I expect one of the main reasons illegal immigrants (note: I am not referring to refugees here) want to go to the UK is the lack of identity card which makes it very easy to work under the radar.

For refugees, things like language, family connections and so on will play a factor in where they want to go.

With refugees, they generally want to return home when the crisis is over so it is a temporary situation, unlike that of economic migrants who are moving for a better life and will remain long term. They want a safe place to stay where they can look after their families until they can return home.

wink1970 · 10/03/2022 11:14

My Uncle is Border Force and he's saying that already hundreds of "young men of fighting age" (ie the dinghy migrants) are turning up and claiming to be Ukranian. They're angry & entitled and fights are breaking out with genuine Ukrainians.

So it's a shit show, but that's partly why they're trying to keep it away from Calais and asking them to go to Paris etc.

This doesn't in any way excuse the paperwork shambles, by the way.

Brainwave89 · 10/03/2022 11:14

Reading some of the comments on this thread with considerable disappointment. Most of these refugees will be women and children. There is support for hosting them. their position is dire. My spare room is available. I cannot in conscience act differently.

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/03/2022 11:13

@loutoofoo

Yet this is the government you lot in England voted for.
So did Scotland and Wales. It was what the majority of the entire UK wanted, don't try and say that certain areas didn't want them. The only area that doesn't have them actually is Northern Ireland.

Unfortunately though, they will get in again at the next election. So it's not like we will be rid of them any time soon.

ClaudineClare · 10/03/2022 11:11

@Jonjim

Why is the UK a practical alternative? It is 1500km and a ferry from Ukraine. Is it because benefits will be easier and more generous and permanent?
You really think that is going to be uppermost on someone's mind when they have just fled their country, leaving everything they have behind? Do you seriously think they are going to research which countries have the best benefits systems?

I am ashamed to live in country that has people who think like you in it.

Brainwave89 · 10/03/2022 11:09

The UK record on military support is actually not bad. On refugees we have considerable catching up to do and in IMO this is not policy, it is simply a lack of competence. We need people with appropriate systems on the ground at a good range of hubs in Poland, Paris, Berlin and Romania. We need to provide transport to the hubs if required and we need to make sure we are clear on where refugees will go when they get to the UK. Most will stay with family, but I am happy to open my spare room as are many more- no coordination of this type is ongoing so far as I am aware.

BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 11:08

@RoseGoldEagle

I would like some forests and green spaces for my childrens future also. I guess it is a balance

Can you imagine it the other way round- your children are at risk of dying, but a country that could offer them safety shrugs and says ‘well yeah I’d LOVE to help, but you know- we need to preserve our green spaces too, it’s a balance isn’t it, am sure you get it’

We can’t help everyone all the time. We are helping in other ways vastly. Sometimes we need to think of the people already in this country. The 67 million people here.
BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 11:05

@Suzi888

Correct… people are dying and there’s lots of other option then the UK.

Like New Zealand.. the last I read NZ has so far refused to change its visa rules in response to the crisis.

QuentininQuarantino · 10/03/2022 11:05

"The UK and the USA has said they will no longer buy."

It's very easy for them to make a song and a dance about that to get votes though when they barely used any anyway, it distracts the common man from the fact Boris has received 2 million from oligarch since becoming PM. Some countries import up to 40% of energy form Russia, and have committed to getting rid of this reliance in an achievable timescale. Whataboutery doesn't work well when your government sells peerages to ex KGB...

There are enough Brits who voted for a party steeped in Russian corruption and anti immigrant rhetoric to get them into power. NABALT (Not all Brits are like that) but yes, history will judge us.

Bollindger · 10/03/2022 11:02

People are always willing to rant about our Government not doing enough to help, but really your passing the buck to someone else to make yourself feeling virtuous.
Do you let the homeless put up a tent in your back yard, do you feed them and provide food. NO. But what you can do is provide money or help. Which is actually much better, as it helps more people to recover.
Paying towards a shelter just across a boarder with free food and clothing helps many, and allows them to return if possible to reclaim their life's.

RoseGoldEagle · 10/03/2022 11:01

I would like some forests and green spaces for my childrens future also. I guess it is a balance

Can you imagine it the other way round- your children are at risk of dying, but a country that could offer them safety shrugs and says ‘well yeah I’d LOVE to help, but you know- we need to preserve our green spaces too, it’s a balance isn’t it, am sure you get it’

purpleboy · 10/03/2022 11:01

@jytdtysrht

The UK has taken some of the strongest measures and heavily encouraged other countries to do so as well, in pursuit of stopping Putin but without provoking WW3. So I don't think our efforts will be negatively viewed from that perspective. Our prime minister has spoken out far more strongly than others.

But
People struggle to get healthcare here, our NHS is literally bursting at the seams. It's undeniable that it's in total crisis. Every year people struggle with school places, classrooms are overcrowded. What about mental health services? People kill themselves before they can get help. Housing demand massively outstrips supply. I honestly do not think that we are the right place for refugees, despite the fact that I would want to have them come here and that they deserve to be able to come here.

Agree with this2nd paragraph, but the flip side is what's the answer for the refugees? Where do they go? Who takes them? There has to be a collective responsibility to help people fleeing from a war zone, and we must have an obligation to take them in, but I totally agree that this country is on its knees it terms of housing and resources. Maybe there should be a ban on foreign property investments, maybe people should only be allowed to own 1 home. That would free up a lot of housing for a start. But I think the current situation is dire whatever way you look at it.
TooBigForMyBoots · 10/03/2022 11:00

I see the usual fallacy is being peddled of all refugees wanting to come to the UK ahead of anywhere else. Nigel Farage and his ilk really did a great job of spreading their lies.

They were very well funded by Russia.

Putin is a cunt and he looks like this Envy.