Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think history will judge the U.K. over ukraine

260 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 10/03/2022 07:01

I am so ashamed at how the U.K. is the only country in Europe effectively closing its doors to Ukrainian refugees. These are mostly women and children fleeing a country that has collapsed in the space of 2 weeks. A maternity hospital was bombed yesterday.

The rest of Europe is opening its arms and helping in every way it can but the U.K. had pretty much slammed the door, made it as difficult as possible to come. The U.K. signed the refugee convention in the 50’s that said that people fleeing war don’t need tons of paperwork and yet that’s exactly what they are asking people for.

I feel so embarrassed when everyone else is helping that we are doing nothing- we are an outlier in Europe.

I hate what this country has become under this disgusting government. I see so many posts on social media or brits wanting to do more.

OP posts:
Livpool · 10/03/2022 14:55

@SirChenjins

We’ll, it’s what the Brexiteers voted for, innit? So we can control our borders and keep out the foreigners (although not the foreigners with dirty money, we’ll happily take them).

This Tory Government disgusts me - and anyone who votes for them is as morally bankrupt as they are.

Agree with this.

This is what Brexit-voters wanted.
Not that I agree with it at all

liliainterfrutices · 10/03/2022 14:52

Big difference between what I've read and what I've read on Mumsnet, so you're still twisting things.

And you didn't say anything about it being great that she could offer a room; you attacked her for 'virtue-signalling' 'despising' her for it.
Of course not everyone can offer a room, but don't attack those who can and are happy to do so.

BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 14:51

I'm pretty sure those getting bombed out of their country would much prefer to have being able to stay where they were rather than having to flee for their lives. It must be terrifying having to run not knowing if at anytime you'll get shot at, not knowing if at any point you and your family will get separated or if you'll even see them again. I'm pretty sure if I was fleeing for my life my first thought wouldn't be oh I'd best not go to England cos they have too many homeless people over there and I don't want to overcrowd it anymore. My first and only thought would be getting myself and my family to somewhere safe.

Exactly… and Ukraine doesn’t border the UK so the UK wouldn’t be your first thought.

BeHappy91818 · 10/03/2022 14:49

@Xiaoxiong

I've written to my MP three times on this in the last week and a half. He has yet to respond to any of them so I will keep writing. It's absolutely shameful.
Give him a chance to reply. Jesus Christ.
ApricotCrush · 10/03/2022 14:48

It makes me sad that so many posters on here are ashamed of their country. Yes, we are in a mess on the refugee front but that will be put right. However, the UK is doing an enormous amount to help Ukraine in many other areas.

inews.co.uk/news/politics/uk-how-helping-ukraine-weapons-support-britain-russia-invasion-explained-1490170

www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/how-is-the-uk-helping-ukraine_uk_6218c526e4b03d0c803751

Posters seem to be trying to turn MN into an anti-Government propaganda machine with insults levelled at anyone who dares to disagree. Sad

Xiaoxiong · 10/03/2022 14:44

I've written to my MP three times on this in the last week and a half. He has yet to respond to any of them so I will keep writing. It's absolutely shameful.

Rinatinabina · 10/03/2022 14:41

@MrsEdnaWelthorpe

Well, the situation with refugees is a total shitshow, not really surprising with Priti Patel in charge, but imo the country that history will judge is Germany.

They made themselves hugely reliant on Russian gas- totally unnecessarily choosing to get rid of their nuclear power abilities. They refused to let other countries send equipment and weapons to Ukraine across their territory and airspace despite Putin building up huge numbers of troops on the Ukrainian border, becoming increasingly threatening and western intelligence clearly showing he had belligerent intentions. When they did finally send some equipment to Ukraine it was a few thousand helmets.

They opposed sanctions and opposed Russia being cut out of the Swift banking system, indeed they are still opposing sanctions on Sberbank.

So, yes, I think Germany have played a pretty appalling role in this crisis.

Precisely, the UK’s response on refugees will be a footnote compared to the myopic western understanding (or lack thereof) of Russia. God the week before the invasion I think it was politico that was reporting that French diplomats were acting like the brits and the USA were overreacting to the troop build ups on Ukraines borders. I am actually really angry about this, the volume of weapons has massively increased but it’s mainly blocked off from kyiv because everyone was too late to respond.

I really really hope we fix our response to the refugees and that people will be able to join their families but I don’t think the UK is going to come off the worst on this.

narcdad · 10/03/2022 14:35

@liliainterfrutices which is what I said "one of the worst things you've read"

Repugnant for having a view? Devoid of human feelings?
Nope just a realist, there is so much virtual signalling, great of that poster can offer a spare room, great that she has space and finances to support a refugee(s), I'm saying not everyone has spare rooms, many, many people already living in this country are in overcrowded and dismal accommodation, like I said before we can't save the world.

liliainterfrutices · 10/03/2022 14:23

No narcdad - what I actually said was 'one of the worst things I've read on Mumsnet'. Please don't twist my words like that. Nobody would need to be sheltered to find what you said repugnant - just to have a vestige of human feeling.

narcdad · 10/03/2022 14:14

@liliainterfrutices one of the worst things you've read 🙄 dear lord you've led a sheltered life, yes I hate and despise virtual signalling.

LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 14:05

There, fixed it for you Londonwolf.

Literally forcing people to think what you think. Interesting 🤔

QuentininQuarantino · 10/03/2022 14:05

Yes, if they can open stately homes as schools and employ more teachers and health care professionals then fine, that might be a solution. How many Ukrainian women would need to be teachers in order to teach 100,000 say if a class was 30-40?

Well, I'm imaginining if it happened here and my DCs class had to flee to another country. There are 30 of them, and of the Mums, 4 of us are teachers. That would also free the other 26 Mums up to work, maybe there would be some dentists among them. Just brainstorming, but it isn't ridiculous, and we've had to do drastic temporary things in wartime before. And they're having to in Poland and Moldova.

TebayOrNotTebay · 10/03/2022 13:55

"Honestly i feel like clapping when I see a chance to deflect and criticise another country rather than face up to our own government's conspicuous shortcomings"

There, fixed it for you Londonwolf.

LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 13:42

@MrsEdnaWelthorpe

Well, the situation with refugees is a total shitshow, not really surprising with Priti Patel in charge, but imo the country that history will judge is Germany.

They made themselves hugely reliant on Russian gas- totally unnecessarily choosing to get rid of their nuclear power abilities. They refused to let other countries send equipment and weapons to Ukraine across their territory and airspace despite Putin building up huge numbers of troops on the Ukrainian border, becoming increasingly threatening and western intelligence clearly showing he had belligerent intentions. When they did finally send some equipment to Ukraine it was a few thousand helmets.

They opposed sanctions and opposed Russia being cut out of the Swift banking system, indeed they are still opposing sanctions on Sberbank.

So, yes, I think Germany have played a pretty appalling role in this crisis.

Honestly i feel like clapping when I see actual facts when discussing political issues on this site and not emoting and breast beating.
LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 13:40

I despise the virtual signalling of "welcome to stay at my spare room" types. 🙄

I don't despise them but I don't believe most of them and those who would put their money where their mouth is - good for them - will be in a very privileged position that allows this to be an option for them.

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/03/2022 13:16

[quote loutoofoo]@AllOfUsAreDead are you purposely being dense? The last election 22 percent voted for Tory's in Scotland - Scotland hasn't voted for a Tory government since 1959. Yet here we are because of what ENGLAND wanted. There may be Tory MPs but the majority of Scotland don't want them! God get me out of the UK! [/quote]
Are you? Never said Scotland likes them, I said some in Scotland still vote for them, and 22% is actually pretty high for a country/party that hates them. But it is just the snp voters who say that of course and they would. They prefer snp. I don't like either, both are as useless as each other. No point anyone saying though that only England voted them in as its not true. We all did.

Really when you think about it, voting snp is a wasted vote. They will never get in. You're better off picking Labour or lib dem if you don't want tory.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 10/03/2022 13:09

Well, the situation with refugees is a total shitshow, not really surprising with Priti Patel in charge, but imo the country that history will judge is Germany.

They made themselves hugely reliant on Russian gas- totally unnecessarily choosing to get rid of their nuclear power abilities. They refused to let other countries send equipment and weapons to Ukraine across their territory and airspace despite Putin building up huge numbers of troops on the Ukrainian border, becoming increasingly threatening and western intelligence clearly showing he had belligerent intentions. When they did finally send some equipment to Ukraine it was a few thousand helmets.

They opposed sanctions and opposed Russia being cut out of the Swift banking system, indeed they are still opposing sanctions on Sberbank.

So, yes, I think Germany have played a pretty appalling role in this crisis.

Gilead · 10/03/2022 13:03

Well, @narcdad, you’re a delight, aren’t you.

liliainterfrutices · 10/03/2022 12:52

trsitrambrandy - no - it wasn't you I was responding to. It was narcdad.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 12:49

@liliainterfrutices

I haven't said anything about spare rooms!

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 12:48

It refers to a likely final number-not to how many have already applied.

liliainterfrutices · 10/03/2022 12:47

Fucking hell - you despise people who say that they are going to offer their spare room to a refugee?! The poster didn't condemn people for not having a spare room - she just said she would offer hers. How mean-spirited to condemn it as virtue-signalling.

That's one of the worst things I've ever read on Mumsnet.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 12:46

The 100,000 figure comes from last night's Question Time.

TristramBrandy · 10/03/2022 12:45

@QuentininQuarantino

Someone asked me why should my child have precedence for a dental appointment over a refugee and I know where that sentiment is coming from. But honestly, when push comes to shove I suppose I do want my child to have access to dentists and to schools and you cannot fit a gallon into a quart pot.

That was me, and you misread or misunderstood. I asked if you think your child should have precedence over a polish child, not a refugee. Because Poland is not at war either, but there are more than a million refugees there already. Do you think they should be staying there, "clogging up" Polish schools? If so, why?

in WW2, schools were opened in stately homes. At the moment, Russian Conservative donors have empty stately homes here. Some of the Ukrainian women will be teachers. Why can't it be done?

I din't say "clogging up".

I asked what was to be done logistically and honestly admitted that I didn't want my child to suffer. If it came to it, then yes I would rather a Polish child went without an education than mine did.

I think a lot of others may feel the same but don't want to say it. I understand that because I am ashamed to acknowledge it to myself but my child is first and foremost to me.

Yes, if they can open stately homes as schools and employ more teachers and health care professionals then fine, that might be a solution. How many Ukrainian women would need to be teachers in order to teach 100,000 say if a class was 30-40?

narcdad · 10/03/2022 12:40

@Brainwave89

Reading some of the comments on this thread with considerable disappointment. Most of these refugees will be women and children. There is support for hosting them. their position is dire. My spare room is available. I cannot in conscience act differently.
Not everyone is lucky enough to have spare room, so many families in overcrowded accommodation.

I despise the virtual signalling of "welcome to stay at my spare room" types. 🙄