Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think history will judge the U.K. over ukraine

260 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 10/03/2022 07:01

I am so ashamed at how the U.K. is the only country in Europe effectively closing its doors to Ukrainian refugees. These are mostly women and children fleeing a country that has collapsed in the space of 2 weeks. A maternity hospital was bombed yesterday.

The rest of Europe is opening its arms and helping in every way it can but the U.K. had pretty much slammed the door, made it as difficult as possible to come. The U.K. signed the refugee convention in the 50’s that said that people fleeing war don’t need tons of paperwork and yet that’s exactly what they are asking people for.

I feel so embarrassed when everyone else is helping that we are doing nothing- we are an outlier in Europe.

I hate what this country has become under this disgusting government. I see so many posts on social media or brits wanting to do more.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fernandina · 10/03/2022 16:58

I think I'll be judging Russia to be honest.

debwong · 10/03/2022 16:49

@sashagabadon

I don’t think so at all. In fact I currently think the opposite. The U.K. has provided more practical help to Ukraine that many other European countries eg. Germany. They sent 5000 helmets apparently and then loads of stuff covered in mould in dusty old boxes. I think they are helping more now. Back in January when U.K. was making countless flights to Ukraine Germany would not allow them to fly over their airspace. They had to fly round. U.K. has been training troops in Ukraine for 6 years. I agree re. Refugees and on that we are slow but we are a further away country with fewer population ties and I bet we catch up rapidly in the next few days/ weeks. EU have the Schengen zone so people can move freely once inside that. We are not part of that and never have been.
This is correct. The UK has done more for Ukraine, going back years not just weeks. Much of the EU is only now waking up to the situation.
Kennykenkencat · 10/03/2022 16:16

@Letshaveablackcelebration

I work with refugees, many of whom fled war. I worked with an Afghan refugee yesterday who is studying a masters here - he fled Kabul with his family with a rucksack on w military plane in august - he’s worked in high level government for 20 years and brings unique experience and skills. He wants to contribute to society. The tone of some of the comments here is really unpleasant.
For him as he flew from Kabul to the U.K. then the U.K. would be the first country he got to out of Kabul.

The problem I am having is why would you travel a 1000+ miles when there is a safe country within 100.
I am presuming that if this is all over within a few days/weeks/months, even a few years then going back to Ukraine is going to be what the people fleeing ultimately want.

narcdad · 10/03/2022 16:16

@liliainterfrutices

'the worst thing I've ever read on Mumsnet'

'the worst thing I've ever read'

These two statements are not the same. It does twist the meaning to leave out two words and proceed on that basis.

🙄
liliainterfrutices · 10/03/2022 16:09

'the worst thing I've ever read on Mumsnet'

'the worst thing I've ever read'

These two statements are not the same. It does twist the meaning to leave out two words and proceed on that basis.

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 15:58

@Iggly

And it isn’t that many. Honestly.

All those pictures you obviously rage over, found in the daily mail or on Nigel Farage’s Twitter feed…. Of boats coming over?

Are because this Home Secretary has closed the other safe routes into the UK. She’s even tried to make it illegal to claim asylum.

It’s funny how people have just lapped up the rhetoric about greedy asylum seekers - probably because it chimes with their inherent racism.

There are millions of refugees worldwide. Millions living in refugee camps, waiting to go somewhere.

Ukraine is a drop in the bucket, but the question is, why do you think their situation is more urgent?

It's very natural to feel for them, to feel it's urgent. They live lives much like us, they have been attacked by a massively greater power. We can imagine ourselves in that position. We feel the need to do something.

When we look at a camp of over 100,000 people, on the other hand, who have lived there a generation, their kids were born there, it's almost too much - we freeze because we don't know what to do when we know that there are many camps like this, millions of people displaced, many people who will require a lot of resources if they come live in our country.

We could never just tell all these people, show up and we will take care of you. Even if they were all totally legitimate.

But you have to ask, why would we say, we will give first dibs to the easy people who we relate to, rather than the difficult ones who have been waiting 20 years? Is it just the news? Because they seem more like us?

I think it's pretty rotten to accuse people of racism because they don't see that as the way forward. They could easily throw that right back at you and that would be unfair too.

margegunderson · 10/03/2022 15:55

@x2boys

I mean there is a crazy man in Russia determined to carry on with this war and threatening everyother country ,but somehow it's the UK fault 🤔 Have you somehow managed to link it to Brexit yet Op Mumsnet is ridiculous sometimes
What are you on? We're talking about the response to what Putin is doing. Making refugees jump through hoops is shameful..
botharna · 10/03/2022 15:54

If you work with refugees you must know that when refugees enter a safe country, they are meant to stay there and have their claims and such processed.

This is not true. There is a EU wide agreement on processing in the first country but it is not longer applicable in the UK given how it is no longer in the EU.

For those claiming the UK is a leader in compassion for refugees, Patel's efforts are not seen as such by the UN

www.unhcr.org/uk/news/press/2021/9/614c163f4/unhcr-uk-asylum-bill-would-break-international-law-damaging-refugees-and.html

*The Bill is based on the premise that people should claim asylum in the “first safe country” they arrive in. But this principle is not found in the 1951 Refugee Convention and there is no such requirement under international law, where primary responsibility for protecting refugees is with the State in which an asylum-seeker arrives.

Requiring all refugees to claim in the first safe country reached would be unworkable and undermine global humanitarian and cooperative principles. *

worriedatthistime · 10/03/2022 15:48

@Rosehugger well thats not true when people say 5% they forget that the other 95% is not all suitable foe building due to various factors and we grown crops for humuns as well
Im sure you eat apples and strawberries and such which is also grown on the uk

HesterShaw1 · 10/03/2022 15:44

[quote ThoseTallTrees]@Nutellaonall The UK has built on around 5% of its land. We are hardly “full”.[/quote]
Do you have any idea what the UK would be like if 20/30/50% of it was built on?

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 15:42

@Letshaveablackcelebration

I work with refugees, many of whom fled war. I worked with an Afghan refugee yesterday who is studying a masters here - he fled Kabul with his family with a rucksack on w military plane in august - he’s worked in high level government for 20 years and brings unique experience and skills. He wants to contribute to society. The tone of some of the comments here is really unpleasant.
If you work with refugees you must know that when refugees enter a safe country, they are meant to stay there and have their claims and such processed.

In general you are not going to see people coming directly from Ukraine to the UK. It being an island and sharing no border.

So the process is going to be different than places that are closer and it can't be compared.

Are you happy for the UK to treat refugees who show up in an airport, that way or just those from Ukraine? Because there are quite a lot who would like to leave the camps and countries they are in right now.

samyeagar · 10/03/2022 15:41

While it feels overwhelming for some people here in the present, in the sense that it is being discussed on this thread, History will only judge for those in the future who find this important. For most people fifty years from now, this humanitarian crisis will at best be a blip in a secondary school history class at best.

This is one of those situations where it matters in the here and now, but taken from a historical perspective, will just be added to the ever ongoing list of humanitarian crises that have existed all over the globe for as long as time.

x2boys · 10/03/2022 15:41

@rebekuh

Doesn't surprise me

This is a country who voted for Brexit, Boris, Patel

Too many right wing racists here

Ah this old chestnut,anyone who doesn't vote the way you think they should is clearly racist You only show your own ignorance when you have to resort to name calling and insults
LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 15:39

Has it not crossed your mind at all that perhaps it is the government that has got worse over the last 3-4 years or so?

I'm speaking more of the tone of social media and the willingness to insult and make serious accusations against poster's characters, without knowing the first thing about them, just because they disagree with you. Are you saying the government are entirely responsible for this? Have we no personal agency at all? I do think there is more anger and frustration in society right now, some of it probably due to feeling helplessness at being stuck with government policies that you disagree with but I think a large part is unrealistic "social justice" ideas becoming mainstream and widely disseminated on SM in a way they could never otherwise have been without those platforms. After all the majority of the voting public voted Boris et al in and continue to do so, so most people aren't unhappy with them. There must therefore be more to the change in how people interact and communicate in all arenas.

Rosehugger · 10/03/2022 15:35

We grow food on almost all of the remainder

Food for animals in the most part.

rebekuh · 10/03/2022 15:35

Doesn't surprise me

This is a country who voted for Brexit, Boris, Patel

Too many right wing racists here

emuloc · 10/03/2022 15:30

@Nutellaonall

Everyone needs to do their bit. But I think it should be related to population density across Europe. The UK is one of the most densely populated countries in the EU. If you count just England it is the most densely packed country in the EU second only to Malta.

Historically The UK has always welcomed immigrants with open arms clearly. That is something to be proud of.

I would like some forests and green spaces for my childrens future also. I guess it is a balance.

Really? That is so not true.
worriedatthistime · 10/03/2022 15:28

@SirChenjins and this is what some remainers chirp out every time , brexit was never going to keep out foreigners we have always taken refugee and asylum seekers and always had people from all over the world come to the uk to work and study not just the eu
I didn't vote either way but maybe actually speak to some real life people on why they voted one way or the other instead if spilling out the same old crap and tarring all with the same brush
You could even argue that allowing people from the eu ( majority white) is maybe not fair as why did they get preferential treatment over someone from africa , india etc
Surely we allow immigration based on want and need rather than area
So currently Ukrainians have a greater need than most from the eu would
Plus anyone can still come from the eu they just have to meet the criteria same as the rest of the world , so is that maybe fairer ?

QuentininQuarantino · 10/03/2022 15:27

It's always been like this but definitely got worse over the last 3-4 years or so

Has it not crossed your mind at all that perhaps it is the government that has got worse over the last 3-4 years or so?

LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 15:24

Posters seem to be trying to turn MN into an anti-Government propaganda machine with insults levelled at anyone who dares to disagree

It's always been like this but definitely got worse over the last 3-4 years or so. I think Twitter has had a huge influence - that level and manner of communication has trickled onto most popular forums and SM and even RL. Don't be sad about it though, just keep pushing back and see it for the ill informed swallowing and half baked understanding of current social justice "ideas" that most of the abuse and insults come from. The fact that you're willing to engage with their viewpoints without resorting to offensive insults and accusations of serious character defects because they don't agree with you, has already given you the moral high ground.

DdraigGoch · 10/03/2022 15:22

[quote ThoseTallTrees]@Nutellaonall The UK has built on around 5% of its land. We are hardly “full”.[/quote]
We grow food on almost all of the remainder.

x2boys · 10/03/2022 15:22

@Xiaoxiong

I've written to my MP three times on this in the last week and a half. He has yet to respond to any of them so I will keep writing. It's absolutely shameful.
It's been a week and a half ,your mp might have more pressing matters to deal with .
forinborin · 10/03/2022 15:18

@Rosehugger

But would you be prepared for your child not to have a school place because 3000 refugee children had arrived in your city?

They wouldn't not have a place because of refugees, they wouldn't have a place because our government is fucking shit and an international embarrassment and because people have been repeatedly voting in Tories for the last 12 years

Be fair. No one is running the country under an assumption that there has to be 100K unoccupied school places at any moment. This is ~15% of the total number of children born annually in the UK (so roughly going into the same school year).
Rosehugger · 10/03/2022 15:15

But would you be prepared for your child not to have a school place because 3000 refugee children had arrived in your city?

They wouldn't not have a place because of refugees, they wouldn't have a place because our government is fucking shit and an international embarrassment and because people have been repeatedly voting in Tories for the last 12 years

narcdad · 10/03/2022 14:59

@liliainterfrutices

Big difference between what I've read and what I've read on Mumsnet, so you're still twisting things.

And you didn't say anything about it being great that she could offer a room; you attacked her for 'virtue-signalling' 'despising' her for it.
Of course not everyone can offer a room, but don't attack those who can and are happy to do so.

I'm not twisting anything I despise virtual signalling, I am not attacking anyone (not a great word to use given the subject matter, but just quoting the word you used) I have an opinion and I am entitled to it.

No, your right I didn't say great that they could offer a spare room in my original reply, however I used it now, my stance is still the same, you keep thinking I'm twisting things but I am quoting what you said.

Swipe left for the next trending thread