Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at secondhand gifts?

418 replies

GirlMum93 · 10/03/2022 00:03

Feel awful but just want a couple of opinions on this if I may….

It was my birthday last week and MIL sent some gifts home to me (didn’t hand deliver got my DH to drop them off to me).

Don’t have a massively great relationship with MIL, perhaps that’s the reason she doesn’t feel she wants to spend at least a pound on me.

It’s pretty obvious they are regifted. For example I got:

⁃	a mini next perfume that has obviously been taken out the box (tape looked to have been removed so the box looked ripped under where the tape should have been) and the plastic packaging you usually get with it has been removed. It smells lovely though. 

⁃	a handbag without a tag that is pretty obviously been given away as one she no longer wanted. But is that not something quite personal to buy someone? It’s a handbag I would likely never use....? 

Last Xmas I got from her:

⁃	A portable hand mirror without a box or tag- the ones you usually get in the perfume boxes free. 

⁃	a small pocket diffuser with a ripped box (looked to be smelt and then boxed back up) I have seen them in primark for £0.99 

⁃	hand cream without the seal on it (looks to be used) 

So after reflection no money was spent on me at all for my birthday when I have looked back?

AIBU to want at least one item expected to be bought for me for my birthday and not re-gifted if I likely spend money on her?

Why is it so difficult to expect just so little? Me and DH spend at least £60+ on MIL for birthday. My DH gets £100 in cash as well as other presents bought for him- tagged… also the SIL gets the cash and iPads… (?!)

I do feel really ungrateful and feel awful but it’s really upset me and I don’t know why. Sometimes I’d rather not get anything. No effort had gone into it at all Sad

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 10/03/2022 08:48

Definitely make a gift of the perfume for Mother's Day except it has to come from your DH not you....You are not going to be doing gifts for his side of the family any more. For any of the family.

Stick to it.
Don't do cards, don't do gifts. If there is an event coming up (birthday/mother's or father's day/ christening/wedding) and it's on his side of the family, HE looks after the gift and card. Not your job any more.

Step back and stop doing it. Let your DH know that it's up to him now. But step back.

nuffinimlazyatthemoment · 10/03/2022 08:46

My boss at work once gave me a candle that had been obviously lit before as a moving home present and my SIL gave me a perfume set one Christmas that I'd given to her the Christmas before.

I laughed them both off because I don't set my worth on what other people give me as presents (and I mean that in the nicest way possible, OP). As a previous poster said, leave the present buying for that side of the family to your DH from now on and try and stop caring so much. I doubt being upset (or any reaction or even your DH having a word) will change anything so try and change your response to it.

Ourlady · 10/03/2022 08:45

Your husband isn’t stupid, he knows exactly what’s going on with the presents. He pretends it’s all hunky dory as he doesn’t want to rock the boat and have to stick up for you to his mother. He’s not nice!
Have you actually had a proper conversation with him about all of this where you lay it all out on the table.
I would be telling him you will not be involved with his family’s present buying ever again
You will also be telling your family to stop buying him thoughtful gifts when his family not only cannot give you the same courtesy by continuing to give you secondhand shite gifts.

Zillamop · 10/03/2022 08:42

Give her a charity goat on every occasion from now on.

Jockolgy · 10/03/2022 08:41

@1forAll74

I think that you should be grateful for anything. mentioning torn packaging and what you consider the price of things, is not nice at all, and to mention what you have spent on her at times, is quite irrelevant.
You have deliberately missed the point!! It’s the inequality and thoughtlessness that has offended OP !
ukborn · 10/03/2022 08:40

And I have a great relationship with them, it's just something they don't do.

ukborn · 10/03/2022 08:39

I can't recall getting gifts from my in laws in years. They've even stopped giving Xmas presents to my kids (teens).
She may be a frugal woman and so what? Just let it go.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 10/03/2022 08:34

Don’t have a massively great relationship with MIL, perhaps that’s the reason she doesn’t feel she wants to spend at least a pound on me.

just dont worry about it op

perhaps work on your relationship?

CharSiu · 10/03/2022 08:33

Your husbands sister is the favoured child and this is cascading down to her children as well.

Nothing you do will change it.

My Mother had a very obviously favoured child and then her grandchildren became the favoured grandchildren. I am one of six children. Two of us just accepted it. The other three spent a lifetime handwringing over it and being upset, why did she prefer the youngest sister etc. my Mother lived to the great age of 93 and she left her entire worldly goods which was quite a decent amount to the favoured child only. Myself and the other accepting sister just thought well whatever but the others were incredibly upset. It was Mothers last chance to treat us equally.

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2022 08:33

As for saving things from landfill, there's enough charities around who'll do that for you.

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2022 08:32

"Is it to do with her upbringing"

No because it's only the OP that she does this to. We stopped doing gifts with my Sister for the same reason. If it's the thought that counts then you think about what the recipient would like and get it. If it's the norm to give presents and people are spending on you, then they shouldn't be grateful for any old shit thrown at them.

Ionlydomassiveones · 10/03/2022 08:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

CounsellorTroi · 10/03/2022 08:30

@SkyeT

Honestly, I don't see the problem with regifting or 2nd hand gifts. I've done it before and never out of spite or because I don't care about the receiver. I do it because it more environmentally and economically friendly. It's the thought that counts, surely?
As long as the gift is in good condition and not obviously used, worn or inappropriate to the recipient. Some thought needs to be put in to regifting too.

I’ve had plenty of regifts in my time but I’ve never done it.

ilovesushi · 10/03/2022 08:28

Is it to do with her upbringing? My MIL who was a lovely person was very tight around presents. She was brought up in real poverty and even though later in life she was comfortably off I think she just couldn't get into the whole presents thing. She would seem quite distressed about receiving nice gifts - didn't like us wasting our money! She got some awful things for the kids - plastic bag of grubby plastic toys one year. She did get some nice things too, but she definitely had an issue around gift giving.

thepeopleversuswork · 10/03/2022 08:27

In theory I have no problem with regifting. I can totally understand the logic behind it.

In practice, and shoot me if this makes me a grabby capitalist bastrd, every time it's been done to me it's left the clear impression that someone can't be arsed and is using sustainability as a figleaf for that fact. In recent years I've been regifted a blanket which I know someone was keeping in their spare room, a set of really naff coffee cups and, wait for it, a gift wrapped rock. All of those presents screamed "Oh help, I can't find anything, let's just give her this."

If regifting presents genuinely are appropriate and well thought out they can theoretically be lovely but they always feel like a cheap afterthought.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 10/03/2022 08:26

the clue is in the beginning
the op does not have a great relationship with her MIL

KittenKong · 10/03/2022 08:25

I was once given a really scary China faced doll. They freak the hell out of me and who gives a 30 year old woman a dolly (I don’t collect dolls, teddies or weird things - or horror film props). It was seriously creepy.

So I have it to a local (to me) charity shop and hoped I’d never be asked about it.

Bugger me if they didn’t send it over to the branch of the charity store near the person who gave it to me - and put it in the bloody window. It was the same (brought abroad, still in the box).

I swear to god it was scowling at me every time I passed by (and it was there for ages - because it was so freaky). I assumed it had killed everyone in the first shop and had been moved on.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/03/2022 08:24

If your husband is fine with it then I'd suggest to him that you gift your mother in law the top and the smellies and the purse from the back of your cupboard that you've never really liked or used. See what he says. If he is ok with it then fair enough but if he isn't then he has double standards (or higher standards for his mum)

lemongreentea · 10/03/2022 08:18

@Polyanthus2

Next time straight in the bin - wouldn't even open them. To get the point across to DH.
do this!
Gardeningcreature · 10/03/2022 08:18

Start regifting her this carp back. If she says anything just shrug and say yes you can have it back as I don't want it.

lemongreentea · 10/03/2022 08:16

What does your mum give to your husband as presents? Ask her to regift some old/opened gifts to him for his birthday and xmas and if he complains remind him its the same as what HIS mum does to you and he shouldnt be ungrateful/upset.

Your MIL sounds mean and spiteful OP.

Honeyroar · 10/03/2022 08:14

@User73ui843

"Oh look mil..a jumper just like the one you showed me a couple of months ago.. we can be jumper twins".

"Oh look.. this handcream has been opened, I'll take it back to the shop!"

Anyway it's not environmentally friendly to give people stuff they'll throw out, it's certainly not nice to hand over worn jumpers, opened creams and any old crap.
She could have said 'I dint like this jumper/cream/perfume do you want it? That's fine.
It's also fine to regift items that are brand new and you'd have bought anyway for someone eg a voucher to a shop they love, a perfume that's their favourite that hasn't been opened etc.

I think pulling her up on it like this is the way forward. The jumper was the perfect opportunity- “wow, it’s just like the one you got for Xmas. Shall we have a photo in our matching jumpers?”
Zillamop · 10/03/2022 08:11

you are being mercenary
why should you care how much she spends

It isn't about the monetary value, it's about the gifts being deliberately unpleasant and a passive aggressive insult to the OP.

Lovemusic33 · 10/03/2022 08:08

I don’t see a huge issue, I have family members that gift 2nd hand gifts, they are not skint but just like to regift or save things from landfill. A gift isn’t really about cost or where it came from. I’m not a huge fan of getting gifts, people often get it wrong but at the end of the day it’s the thought that counts.

MzHz · 10/03/2022 08:02

If your mum saw this, then she’ll be on your side when it comes to mutual no gifts for our dc spouse, have you spoken to her?

Also, where were you when you opened the gifts? Your house or at MIL? If at MIL, rude as it is, but fuck it I’d leave her gifts behind. Let her clear up her own rubbish.

You’ve got some great solutions suggested here, whatever works for you, do it.