Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stopping scouts/GGs due to behaviour after

89 replies

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 19:48

DC is 7.

Once per week they do scouts/GGing (I won’t say which and I won’t say which section). They absolutely love it, have earnt loads of badges, done work outside of meetings to get more badges and talk about it all the time.

In theory they should be able to cope with 1 later bedtime per week, but they just don’t. It should only be 1 hour later, but they kick off, shout, scream, bite even when they get home so it can take 3 hours+ to get them into bed. I put them in their room and ignore but they just carry on until my neighbours text me to tell me they can hear them or they’re disturbing their DCs sleep (I live in a block of flats). It’s just getting too much.

Every time I’ve thought about stopping it for that reason I’ve convinced myself not to. They get so much out of it, and their teacher has insisted that they love it and get a lot out of it that I keep thinking no.

They’re not the most academic child, have struggled massively and was unable to access home learning during the lockdowns due to SN but didn’t qualify for a place at school (currently taking the local council to tribunal over their refusal to assess, school have had DC assessed at their own cost but can only go so far but the assessments told us there is SN there). At school although they behave they struggle with the basics; reading, writing and maths, and are still working 2 years below their actual age.

They often tell me “Scouts/GGs is the only thing I’m good at”. They have swimming lessons but are still in Stage 1 with children aged 4 and 5 where most of their friends are stage 4 or 5 or have stopped as finished, so I do want something that is just for them.

For context they do have meltdowns after school sometimes, especially if they’ve found something very hard, so it may not necessarily be related to scouts/GG specifically.

I don’t know what to do, WWYD?

OP posts:
SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 21:33

@Instawhat

I have one DC with SN and one without (9). We also had the same massive tantrums, shouting and screaming when she got home from her activities. Now she's that bit older, they have tailed off and she is used to it. I don't think you necessarily need to put it down to SN.

On the basis of experience with my DC with SN, I would drop the swimming lessons. It will do no good for her confidence or self worth to see she's in group 1 when her friends are in 4 or whatever. Find a different swim school where no one she knows goes, or look into private lessons.

Keep the activity. It sounds like she really needs it.
I'm wondering if the lack of routine isn't helping things. You said she doesn't bath etc on activity nights, maybe this is unsettling her. How does she cope if you keep the same nightly routine but just start it when you get home instead of at the normal time (I.e. everything is 1 hour later)? From your side, you need to accept it's going to be a tough evening and don't expect any better, she'll also pick up on your reaction. Easier said than done.

Can you talk to the guide leader and see if they will play along with there being something like a bedtime badge? That way going home and getting into bed becomes an extension of the guides/scout group for the evening? Perhaps you could set up a chart or similar and get your child to work towards a consistent number of good bedtimes after class? Then they get a slightly unofficial badge for it? It sounds like it's really doing them good so perhaps an alternative approach would work....
I'm sorry, but I think this is a really bad idea. You will be using something she loves as a hold over her and merging it into something she finds stressful. She will find out you're lying, when she mentions it to the other kids and you will have destroyed her trust both in you and in her safe activity.

@Instawhat No private pools nearby, the pool she goes to is the only pool for 10 miles (I live in the a**e end of nowhere, literally the only people who don't live work and go to school here are the teachers!) there's a hotel with a pool but it doesn't run lessons.

She has to do swimming as her school take them in summer term of Year 1 so she's missed out due to covid.

She doesn't bath every other night, the only thing that stays the same is the bedtime routine I mentioned earlier. She's not autistic and copes well with changes, so I can say "Lets go to the shop" straight after school and she manages that, although she does get tired which school think is related to the SN.

OP posts:
Elieza · 09/03/2022 21:29

If they are still high as a kite for a good while would they stay in bed if you read them a story? That way they could unwind and gradually relax as they wouldn’t be jumping about and what have you?

I know it’s a pain in the arse for you to have to go back to what you did for them at a younger age but if it helps calm the situation and was something they enjoyed with a calm theme it could help them switch off and calm down.

You could ‘read a story you wrote to see if they like it’ but it’s more like a meditation.

Like once there was a girl/boy who went on holiday. Blah blah. She walked along the lane to the seaside blah blah then something about walking quietly and listening to the quiet sounds the animals in the hedgerow made and perhaps sitting watching baby bunnies bouncing in and out of the bushes. That kind of gentle thing. And the walk continued and she saw a birds nest and saw the parents feeding the little chicks, blah blah, trees swaying in the breeze, waterfall in a glen, deer in the distance. Etc etc. if you can go on long enough it could help? I’d write it out first to make sure it’s long enough. If you do a few versions they can ask for their favourites one once they get to know them all.

I used to do that. They never made it to the end. I don’t think to this day they knew what happened to the king who had three sons one I did Grin

Instawhat · 09/03/2022 21:25

I have one DC with SN and one without (9). We also had the same massive tantrums, shouting and screaming when she got home from her activities. Now she's that bit older, they have tailed off and she is used to it. I don't think you necessarily need to put it down to SN.

On the basis of experience with my DC with SN, I would drop the swimming lessons. It will do no good for her confidence or self worth to see she's in group 1 when her friends are in 4 or whatever. Find a different swim school where no one she knows goes, or look into private lessons.

Keep the activity. It sounds like she really needs it.
I'm wondering if the lack of routine isn't helping things. You said she doesn't bath etc on activity nights, maybe this is unsettling her. How does she cope if you keep the same nightly routine but just start it when you get home instead of at the normal time (I.e. everything is 1 hour later)? From your side, you need to accept it's going to be a tough evening and don't expect any better, she'll also pick up on your reaction. Easier said than done.

Can you talk to the guide leader and see if they will play along with there being something like a bedtime badge? That way going home and getting into bed becomes an extension of the guides/scout group for the evening? Perhaps you could set up a chart or similar and get your child to work towards a consistent number of good bedtimes after class? Then they get a slightly unofficial badge for it? It sounds like it's really doing them good so perhaps an alternative approach would work....
I'm sorry, but I think this is a really bad idea. You will be using something she loves as a hold over her and merging it into something she finds stressful. She will find out you're lying, when she mentions it to the other kids and you will have destroyed her trust both in you and in her safe activity.

godmum56 · 09/03/2022 21:20

re the bed tme badge thing....I wonder if other parents would find it useful too?

BogRollBOGOF · 09/03/2022 21:09

DS has ASD and is particularly sensory. If he's struggling to settle at night, he loves walks. We've got woods nearby and loves being in there with a torch as it's so quiet and feels quite cocooned. He enjoys walking at night more than the day!

There clearly are a lot of benefits to DC maintaining the activity.

mumwon · 09/03/2022 21:07

maybe give them a bath anyway & see if it makes any difference

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:59

Thank you everyone, I think you're all right that taking DC out of the activity could do more harm than good and I just need to find a way to help them regulate after it.

Will definitely use some of the suggestions here.

Thank you

OP posts:
sillysmiles · 09/03/2022 20:56

DC is very happy where they are and loves the meetings, when I've peaked in at the end when picking up they look the happiest I've ever seen them.

I don't know what the answer is, but I honestly don't think you can pull them out of the thing that makes him happy and the only thing they feel they are good at.

Maybe instead of straight to bed they get to stay up a little and decompress.
The only thing I could equate it to would be when I waitress. You got home late and were wrecked but still needed a cup of tea and to lie with my legs up against the wall before going to bed.

Is there any form of short meditation or breathing techniques you could use to help them decompress.

They must love it and be so wound up from an activity where for 1 hr a week they feel like they are good at something.

Whybirdwhy · 09/03/2022 20:51

And yes, the 10 min walk home in the fresh air does help a bit too.

Whybirdwhy · 09/03/2022 20:50

I have an autistic child. I get how hard this must be as my child is similar. I agree with PP it sounds like over stimulation and change of routine rather than tiredness and addressing the sensory needs might help.

My child find that it really helps to lay in a dark room with a sensory light and sounds on, sometimes chewing a toy or sometimes just reading and listening to a CD.

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:43

@Elieza

I don’t know if it’s practical (or safe in your area) as I don’t have sen dc, but would walking home instead of the car/bus help settle dc as it would give them time to unwind while tiring them out?

Or would going for a hot chocolate or something in a cafe on the way home settle them down or would that be worse as it’s sugary?

@Elieza In the summer term we usually walk home, but it's just a little bit too dark at the moment as the school it's in is down a lane with no pavement. Few more weeks and I can test that theory out though.
OP posts:
50DaysAF · 09/03/2022 20:42

I wouldn’t take away the one thing they feel they are good at. No way.
I agree.
My child is the same age and also attends a club of this nature that finishes at 7.30. They are usually in bed by this time on every other night of the week. If it helps, a condition of attending the club in our house is pj’s, teeth and bed when they get home. Straight to bed. They know this is the deal and they’ve agreed to that.

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:41

@OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea

So either Beavers or to end Rainbows about to move up or a young Brownie.

Tough one. Meeting times are rarely in the control of the organisation as it depends on when they can have the hall etc. Eg our Beavers start early which means we can struggle for leaders to get there on time and some kids miss out as parents not back from work but we run straight into Cubs and then Scouts and because of that Scouts finishes at 9 which can be late for the younger ones. My own Cub will be in Scouts after Easter and they usually go to bed around 8.30.

I feel your pain, but I was so struck by your child feeling that it was the only thing they were good at and that alone for their self esteem is worth so much and if you can ride it out a bit longer or find a way to help them cope into they are a bit older and therefore go to sleep later then I think it will be worth it.

@OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea but I was so struck by your child feeling that it was the only thing they were good at and that alone for their self esteem is worth so much

This is why I've been so hesistant to stop it, DC loves going and talks about it all the time. The class teacher says DC gets so much out of it, which for a child who doesn't like school is massive.

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 09/03/2022 20:40

You've had some sensible advice about the post-scout bedtime routine, and I wonder if there is anything you can do before hand, as well. If tiredness is an issue, can they have at least some quiet time, if not a nap, before they go?

Elieza · 09/03/2022 20:40

I don’t know if it’s practical (or safe in your area) as I don’t have sen dc, but would walking home instead of the car/bus help settle dc as it would give them time to unwind while tiring them out?

Or would going for a hot chocolate or something in a cafe on the way home settle them down or would that be worse as it’s sugary?

Emmelina · 09/03/2022 20:39

Can you send a small snack with her to keep her on an even keel? I’m sure the unit won’t object to her taking a short banana break half an hour before hometime!

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:39

@litlealligator

Can you talk to the guide leader and see if they will play along with there being something like a bedtime badge? That way going home and getting into bed becomes an extension of the guides/scout group for the evening? Perhaps you could set up a chart or similar and get your child to work towards a consistent number of good bedtimes after class? Then they get a slightly unofficial badge for it? It sounds like it's really doing them good so perhaps an alternative approach would work....
@litlealligator Interesting idea but that could work, thank you will have a chat to the leaders!
OP posts:
OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 09/03/2022 20:38

If scouting by the way then of they have not done their personal challenge award that night be something to try? They need to come up with a challenge of their own and have one set by a leader. I'm sure the leader would be happy to suggest going to bed nicely as a challenge!

Justkeeppedaling · 09/03/2022 20:36

DC is very happy where they are and loves the meetings, when I've peaked in at the end when picking up they look the happiest I've ever seen them.

As an ex Guider, that warms my heart.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 09/03/2022 20:34

So either Beavers or to end Rainbows about to move up or a young Brownie.

Tough one. Meeting times are rarely in the control of the organisation as it depends on when they can have the hall etc. Eg our Beavers start early which means we can struggle for leaders to get there on time and some kids miss out as parents not back from work but we run straight into Cubs and then Scouts and because of that Scouts finishes at 9 which can be late for the younger ones. My own Cub will be in Scouts after Easter and they usually go to bed around 8.30.

I feel your pain, but I was so struck by your child feeling that it was the only thing they were good at and that alone for their self esteem is worth so much and if you can ride it out a bit longer or find a way to help them cope into they are a bit older and therefore go to sleep later then I think it will be worth it.

litlealligator · 09/03/2022 20:33

Can you talk to the guide leader and see if they will play along with there being something like a bedtime badge? That way going home and getting into bed becomes an extension of the guides/scout group for the evening? Perhaps you could set up a chart or similar and get your child to work towards a consistent number of good bedtimes after class? Then they get a slightly unofficial badge for it? It sounds like it's really doing them good so perhaps an alternative approach would work....

thisisscary · 09/03/2022 20:31

I would look at a sensory wind down after scouts. Your DC sounds tired and overstimulated. Scouts can be noisy, bright, busy, lots going on... a lot to deal with for any child let alone one with SN. Think about what calms your child and set up a little routine just for after scouts. Remember it may not be an obvious choice like milk and a cookie, it could be being pushed on a swing, it could be a bath with some soft music, it could be chewy food under a weighted blanket, or 20 minutes of mind numbing screen time.

I'd definitely go with addressing sensory needs rather than looking at it as behaviour.

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:28

@Justkeeppedaling

See if there are any other sections on the area with an earlier start/finish time

If your DC is 7 they'll be at either cubs or Brownies I expect.

GG was experimenting with weekend meetings and holiday meetings , so eg an intensive week (or more) covering several badges in place of the weekly evening meetings.

As an ex Guider, I can tell you that lots of 7 year olds struggle with the timings of Brownie meetings, but they aren't 7 for long and it gets easier as they get older.

There may be some units in your area with earlier start times, though if your child is happy where they are, I'd be reluctant to move them in your shoes.

@Justkeeppedaling DC is very happy where they are and loves the meetings, when I've peaked in at the end when picking up they look the happiest I've ever seen them.
OP posts:
Justkeeppedaling · 09/03/2022 20:26

See if there are any other sections on the area with an earlier start/finish time

If your DC is 7 they'll be at either cubs or Brownies I expect.

GG was experimenting with weekend meetings and holiday meetings , so eg an intensive week (or more) covering several badges in place of the weekly evening meetings.

As an ex Guider, I can tell you that lots of 7 year olds struggle with the timings of Brownie meetings, but they aren't 7 for long and it gets easier as they get older.

There may be some units in your area with earlier start times, though if your child is happy where they are, I'd be reluctant to move them in your shoes.

SpoilTheirFunMaybe · 09/03/2022 20:24

@LYSHB

Where is the scout/gg unit held? I know my DD has real issues with halls and the noise of the kids in it and it was too much sensory wise, she kicked off like I’ve never seen before.
@LYSHB It's in a school, not DCs school but another nearby school.
OP posts: