Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that children don't need a phone until they're at secondary?

103 replies

irritablehead1 · 09/03/2022 18:16

DD is in Year 6. Everyone, it seems, is getting a phone. I hate the idea of her having a phone all the time but I also feel like we are getting increasingly isolated in our thinking about waiting till summer/secondary.

AIBU to think it's just so young?

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 09/03/2022 19:21

DD got hers at the Summer before Y6.

DD was walking to and from school on her own, learnt to use the bus to go into town to meet friends, was all day at the stable yard, kept in contact with friends at a different school, chatted with the grandparents.

It taught her independent without being afraid to be lost somewhere and no way to contact us.

I think Y6 started with 1/2 of them having a phone, by the end all had one.

BookwormButNoTime · 09/03/2022 19:20

I agree totally BUT we did get my DD a phone in Y6 but with strict rules. For example, checking her phone every day, what she could and couldn’t have access to.

It was actually the best idea as it meant that phone etiquette and how to behave online could be dealt with in a safe environment. There were invariably things said in WhatsApp groups that shouldn’t have been but because we had all known each other for 7 years it was easy to make apologies and work with other parents. My DD was on the receiving end of some negativity. We taught her to navigate through that (taking screen shots there and then in case they got deleted, not responding, blocking etc).

These are skills they need to have. Some parents waited until Y7 and the same situations arose but then heads of years got involved, plus in one instance the police (the child was expelled eventually).

I’m really glad we had Y6 to properly educate.

MajorCarolDanvers · 09/03/2022 19:18

@ChattanoogaShoeShoe

I would have agreed with up until about 2 years ago. But during lockdown a cheap sim in an old phone was a brilliant lifeline to my primary school aged DC for staying in contact with friends.
Agree and we did the same
Bitofachinwag · 09/03/2022 19:18

@RedskyThisNight

That might work for some. We never bought ours smartphones and now in their middle/ late 20 s they just aren't interested in SM so have never joined any

Technology moves on. All secondary school students now make plans and communicate via social media. Not to mention that school itself may set up channels to discuss work related items. A child without a phone is likely to find themselves quite socially isolated IMO.

Yes of course, life is different now to 10-15 years ago. My point was really that some things are very desirable when you are a certain age, but if you never start using them you might be less likely to want them later.
steff13 · 09/03/2022 19:17

YANBU to make rules for your child. If you think it's too young, it's too young.

Stompythedinosaur · 09/03/2022 19:14

No one needs a phone.

But if not having a phone is making then socially isolated then I think that's a pretty good reason to consider getting one.

RedskyThisNight · 09/03/2022 19:12

That might work for some. We never bought ours smartphones and now in their middle/ late 20 s they just aren't interested in SM so have never joined any

Technology moves on. All secondary school students now make plans and communicate via social media. Not to mention that school itself may set up channels to discuss work related items. A child without a phone is likely to find themselves quite socially isolated IMO.

bellac11 · 09/03/2022 19:06

@tigerbird

If you ever use the kind of social media apps that teenage kids also use, you’d know that it is shockingly easy for them to be exposed to the kind of extreme hardcore porn that was unthinkable even a few years ago, and other completely inappropriate things.

Parents are very naive about this and your DC don’t even have to seek it out.

I agree and also some naivety that parental controls limit things, a lot of children have the skills to navigate round that or a 'friend' who will say 'let me show you this' and do it for them and then the child is left with access to things they shouldnt
Bitofachinwag · 09/03/2022 19:05

Also, phones can obviously be useful when you are out and about, but it's unhealthy to rely on them.

Children (and adults) should be able to cope being out of the house without them.

AHungryCaterpillar · 09/03/2022 19:05

Too young for a phone at 13? Confused

bellac11 · 09/03/2022 19:02

@Divebar2021

If you have given a child a smart phone and don’t have full parental controls on you are absolutely playing with fire - speaking as someone who worked in child protection and saw the messages that children received on SM. My sisters school has also been embroiled in bullying situation where a year six child was being horrendously bullied / threatened on a year 6 WhatsApp group. As if teachers haven’t got enough to deal with.
I was going to say this, Im amazed at the number of younger children who have smart phones

In fact they're still too young at 13ish in my view

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/03/2022 19:02

Normally I would agree with you and my older kids all had their phones on their 11th birthday. But DC6 had hers for her 10th birthday as it was during lockdown and it meant she could keep in touch with her friends.

Bitofachinwag · 09/03/2022 19:02

@grosgirl

I'm a teacher and after being head of year 7 and spending every Monday dealing with ridiculous friendship issues caused by unrestricted access to phones over the weekend, I was SURE my son (currently 4) wasn't going to have his own phone/ social media until he was in secondary school at least.

However, we recently had a school visit from a company specialising in internet safety and something they said really resonated with me: 'parents who are a firm "no" to phones have metaphorically scooped up their child and are carrying them towards a cliff edge. This cliff edge is the age of 13 when children can legally use most social media accounts. At 13, these parents usually capitulate but then leave their children to navigate the intricacies of social media alone, 'dropping them off the cliff'. Better to walk towards the cliff holding your child's hand and navigate an acceptable use of a phone and social media together so that when they reach the cliff edge, they've been provided with the parachute they need to enjoy a less restricted access.'

Made lots of sense to me!

That might work for some. We never bought ours smartphones and now in their middle/ late 20 s they just aren't interested in SM so have never joined any .
atomicnotsoblonde · 09/03/2022 18:57

Mine had one in year 6. A few of children made big mistakes using their phones. It was a MUCH better lesson learned in primary where it was contained rather than secondary where things spread online like wildfire.

EricScrantona · 09/03/2022 18:55

Phones aren't the devil.

DD is in year 5 and walks home from school. When she does, I want her to be able to contact someone in an emergency. Sometimes she goes to the shop for me and calls to check she hasn't forgotten anything.

She had a phone before this. Appropriate supervision means that she has not been inappropriately contacted and is not destined for hell.

grosgirl · 09/03/2022 18:54

I'm a teacher and after being head of year 7 and spending every Monday dealing with ridiculous friendship issues caused by unrestricted access to phones over the weekend, I was SURE my son (currently 4) wasn't going to have his own phone/ social media until he was in secondary school at least.

However, we recently had a school visit from a company specialising in internet safety and something they said really resonated with me: 'parents who are a firm "no" to phones have metaphorically scooped up their child and are carrying them towards a cliff edge. This cliff edge is the age of 13 when children can legally use most social media accounts. At 13, these parents usually capitulate but then leave their children to navigate the intricacies of social media alone, 'dropping them off the cliff'. Better to walk towards the cliff holding your child's hand and navigate an acceptable use of a phone and social media together so that when they reach the cliff edge, they've been provided with the parachute they need to enjoy a less restricted access.'

Made lots of sense to me!

Honeypickle · 09/03/2022 18:53

Birthday in Year 6. For all the reasons said above - starting to have independence, going out with friends for ice cream, sleepovers - she can text me and I can text her. Also for us, she is not going to the local state secondary unlike the rest of her class; this way they can exchange numbers and hopefully stay in touch!

flashpaper · 09/03/2022 18:51

DD is now in y6 and I got her a phone during the lockdown so she could communicate with her friends and contact me if I nipped to the shop. It's since allowed her to become more independent, she now goes to the park and walks home from school on certain days by herself or with DS. We can track her on it too which helps my own anxieties about balancing allowing her to grow and trying to keep her safe. She's going to a secondary school which is a bus ride away, she needs to be more independent now before she has to make that journey each and every day and having the phone has allowed that.

lanthanum · 09/03/2022 18:49

A non-smart phone as a first step is a good way to test out how well they look after it.

MrsPussinBoots · 09/03/2022 18:47

DD (8, yr 3) is sitting next to me speaking to her dad on FaceTime on her phone so I can look at mumsnet on my phone. It doesn't leave the house as she never goes out without me but was perfect for talking with friends and family while isolating with covid.

DaisyWaldron · 09/03/2022 18:46

YANBU to think your child doesn't need one. I got one for DD in her final year at primary school because she would cycle by herself straight from school to orchestra and sports clubs.

AHungryCaterpillar · 09/03/2022 18:46

So tell your kids they can’t have SM mine isn’t allowed any snap chat tik tok etc

Chely · 09/03/2022 18:45

We didn't give our eldest one until high school. GP gave our 2nd one for Christmas, he's year 6 and not allowed to take it to school because I drop off and collect. He uses it to watch YouTube mostly.

Eightiesfan · 09/03/2022 18:44

Both my DS got a phone when they went into Year 7. Would not have considered it any earlier.

tigerbird · 09/03/2022 18:42

If you ever use the kind of social media apps that teenage kids also use, you’d know that it is shockingly easy for them to be exposed to the kind of extreme hardcore porn that was unthinkable even a few years ago, and other completely inappropriate things.

Parents are very naive about this and your DC don’t even have to seek it out.