Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think this should have been allowed (young lad going to Ukraine)?

138 replies

Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 16:54

A 19 year old lad near me has gone to fight in Ukraine. He has no prior military experience, has never left the country before and the mother is understandably beside herself.

www.itv.com/news/granada/2022-03-08/call-of-duty-obsessed-teenager-fighting-russia-with-no-experience

She feels this shouldn’t have been allowed. Obviously as a worried mother she would say that but it’s got me wondering. I am surprised he was allowed to go, tbf.

I suppose my AIBU is whether you feel somebody should step in when there’s people with no military experience trying to go, or whether they are adults who should be left to it? After all it’s their prerogative isn’t it?

OP posts:
DaisyStPatience · 09/03/2022 18:11

Call me cynical but I wonder with some of the Brits who run off to join foreign conflicts whether it's less about a genuine desire to do the right thing and more about wanting their "main character moment". How much use can you be in a country where you have no knowledge of the people, language, culture, geography or military skills? Probably be more of a hindrance really.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 18:05

@Woollystockings are you aware of how many variations of the Indian language there are?

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 18:05

[quote Gemmathecat]@Woollystockings have you ever heard of NATO?[/quote]
Of course I’ve heard of NATO.

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 18:04

[quote [AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o]Not true!! Many citizens of the British empire were conscripted not requiring them to speak English hence why it was called a WORLD WAR[/quote]
Obviously Indian units all spoke the same language - together.

Thereisnolight · 09/03/2022 18:03

@ItsRainingTacos

I think he falls into the same camp as the young men who left the UK to fight with Islamic State. Just waiting for a loose justification to get involved in armed violence and live out their video game fantasies. You just have to give them a cause.
This is exactly what I think. Many men just love wars and violence.
[AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o · 09/03/2022 18:02

Not true!! Many citizens of the British empire were conscripted not requiring them to speak English hence why it was called a WORLD WAR

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 18:02

[quote [AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o]Well then he will get turned away and return to the United Kingdom able to say he tried to help those in need which is more than any of us can say[/quote]
What rubbish. People will be more helpful to those in need proving funds, cyber help etc in the U.K. and welcoming refugees.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 18:01

@Woollystockings have you ever heard of NATO?

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 17:59

[quote [AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o]We celebrate those who fought in the first and Second World War despite their inexperience, many of whom came from different backgrounds and didn’t all speak the same language I don’t see why this mentally has gone out the window now. His mother’s right to worry but he is a brave young man doing himself proud[/quote]
We don’t celebrate them. We mourn them. And they went together as a unit, speaking the same language, and trained.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 17:58

Watching tv and Playing COD is a damn sight more experience and exposure than they had back in ww1 and ww2. The world truly is survival of the fittest and this thread shows who’s going first.

Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 17:56

He’s already in Ukraine. He crossed the border days ago.

OP posts:
Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 17:55

It’s all well and good saying he wants to help so let him, but his military experience is COD and a year in the army cadets.

If he gets injured he’ll be taking resources away from Ukrainian’s who have been FORCED to stay and fight. It’s also another mouth to be fed in a country that is going to experience shortages.

He won’t be any help at all.

OP posts:
[AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o · 09/03/2022 17:55

Well then he will get turned away and return to the United Kingdom able to say he tried to help those in need which is more than any of us can say

ItsRainingTacos · 09/03/2022 17:54

I think he falls into the same camp as the young men who left the UK to fight with Islamic State. Just waiting for a loose justification to get involved in armed violence and live out their video game fantasies. You just have to give them a cause.

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 17:54

“The FCDO advises against all travel to Ukraine, including Crimea, Donetsk oblast and Luhansk oblast. If you travel to Ukraine to fight, or to assist others engaged in the conflict, your activities may amount to offences against UK legislation and you could be prosecuted on your return to the UK.”

[AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o · 09/03/2022 17:54

We celebrate those who fought in the first and Second World War despite their inexperience, many of whom came from different backgrounds and didn’t all speak the same language I don’t see why this mentally has gone out the window now. His mother’s right to worry but he is a brave young man doing himself proud

toastfiend · 09/03/2022 17:53

[quote [AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o]He’s being brave and helping those in need, the Ukrainian government said they will welcome anyone who wants to come and help support their fight so I don’t see why this applies to everyone but him[/quote]
And yet they're turning people away with no combat experience precisely because they don't have time to babysit or train some fool who thinks playing COD is a good substitute for actual warfare.

Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 17:53

@Getoff

He’s already in Ukraine. He was tracked as far as Lviv (just in Ukraine near the Polish border) then his tracker stopped working.

OP posts:
Getoff · 09/03/2022 17:53

I think I saw on the news the other night that a middle-aged British man with no military experience was turned away at the border by the Ukraniains. Hopefully they will do the same in this case.

Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 17:52

@ZealAndArdour.

I’m sure he means well but he won’t have a clue. He’ll be taking up food and (hopefully not) medical supplies.

There won’t be time to train him either.

OP posts:
Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 17:50

[quote [AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o]This is all bloody ridiculous he’s a grown boy and if he wants to go fight them let him!! Teach this generation a thing or two about compassion all too soft and self centred no thought for others and what they are going through. I hope my young boy would do the same[/quote]
Grown boy? Makes no sense. It’s self-centred and thoughtless and stupid to go to Ukraine. He will take up precious resources there and will have to be looked after. Any parent should be embarrassed. He could find something actually useful and supportive to do in the U.K. - fundraising, cyber skills, whatever.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 17:50

@LizDoingTheCanCan i know a few young lads in the village and all will be going ASAP be careful with your words

[AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o · 09/03/2022 17:49

He’s being brave and helping those in need, the Ukrainian government said they will welcome anyone who wants to come and help support their fight so I don’t see why this applies to everyone but him

[AUTO]9szl6l0jthb5o · 09/03/2022 17:47

@LizDoingTheCanCan

he’s a grown boy

Contradiction in terms there.

Let’s not squabble over the semantics here there’s a bigger issue at hand. You can be a young man, a young boy, a grown man or a grown boy the terminology makes no difference in this persons ability to fight and do the right thing
TravellingFrom · 09/03/2022 17:46

[quote Chocolattay]@PeterPomegranate
Yes I thought that as well, he’s probably going to be a hinderance rather than any real help.

The mother feels Liz Truss’s comments were irresponsible.[/quote]
Liz Truss comments were also wrong because it is actually illegal for him to go there and fight…..

He might well arrive there and be told to go away. I’d hope that’s what would happen.