Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think this should have been allowed (young lad going to Ukraine)?

138 replies

Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 16:54

A 19 year old lad near me has gone to fight in Ukraine. He has no prior military experience, has never left the country before and the mother is understandably beside herself.

www.itv.com/news/granada/2022-03-08/call-of-duty-obsessed-teenager-fighting-russia-with-no-experience

She feels this shouldn’t have been allowed. Obviously as a worried mother she would say that but it’s got me wondering. I am surprised he was allowed to go, tbf.

I suppose my AIBU is whether you feel somebody should step in when there’s people with no military experience trying to go, or whether they are adults who should be left to it? After all it’s their prerogative isn’t it?

OP posts:
Chocolattay · 09/03/2022 20:33

@cabansunset

I agree it’s scary for the lads as individuals if caught but I don’t think Putin will escalate towards U.K. over lone wolves going over to fight. He’ll be bothered if we send troops over, but I don’t think he’s particularly threatened by Jamie from Warrington.

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 09/03/2022 20:32

Of course it's not the right thing. He's not trained. He has no expertise. He would just become someone that would take up medical supplies, need rescuing or a costly process of repatriating a body because no insurer would pay out.

If he wanted to help he could have done something constructive. This is just making a mess for someone to have to sort out.

Darbs76 · 09/03/2022 20:27

Who is supposed to have stopped him? The airline flying him to Poland? Since when do they quiz passengers on onwards plans.

Ukraine aren’t going to turn him away. They don’t care if people don’t have any experience - they will train them up. Of course it’s worrying but he’s an adult and he will most likely be back before long

DetailMouse · 09/03/2022 20:23

@SommerTen

I've just met so many people drinking their lives away because of ptsd from military service
I've no doubt at all that been involved in any capacity will leave very many people scarred for life but what happens if no one steps up?
EddyF · 09/03/2022 20:16

@GreenWhiteViolet

He's nineteen years old, not a child - the article really seems to be infantilising him. Spelling mistakes don't make you a child. Nor does making a bad or ill-informed decision.

I don't agree with what he's done and of course his mother is worried but there are plenty of men and women younger than him in Ukraine who will be fighting.

Just because the government label young people as adults at 18, the reality is that most 18 to at least 24s are not really adults in the sense of what it really means being an adult. Maybe it’s the western culture because when my 18 year old brother at the time was messing up with college, my mother was still able to send him abroad to boarding school without his say so. He is a little older now and better behaved.

I wouldn’t like it, OP. And if I had a child at that age, I would find a way to stop it.

cabansunset · 09/03/2022 20:11

Terrifying...when these UK lads are caught or when the Russians get wind of British fighting in Ukraine....we all know what will happen.

Thanks very much 'Jamie, video game obsessed 19 year old with no military experience'

Shipoftheseus · 09/03/2022 20:09

he's trying to do the right thing and I'd have to admire him for it.

I genuinely don’t understand this. He is not trying to do the right thing. It is clearly the wrong thing to do - immoral and unethical. The damage he could do to the Ukrainian effort. Just so he can go and play games?

iheartmybeachhut · 09/03/2022 20:06

Total stupidity and a danger to others around him if he has no military experience Being influenced because he playsby Call of duty smacks of immaturity. His poor mum.

Moonface123 · 09/03/2022 20:02

l don't think he is doing himself proud.
l am totally anti war, there are never any winners when it comes down to war, history has taught us nothing.
Worst senario is he will get killed, if if gets injured and becomes disabled nobody will want to know, its an absolute disgrace the lack of care that is shown towards our ex soldiers, his mums life will then become a full time carer for him, never mind the MH issues suffered years after the war has ended. How can anyone be so stupid to applaud a
young man walking into that kind of situation ?

Frazzled50yrold · 09/03/2022 19:54

Young British soldiers are being posted to the Polish border to assist with the refugees so a young inexperienced man like him may be posted to something similar. Obviously the mother must be really concerned but he's trying to do the right thing and I'd have to admire him for it.

Theregoesmyhomebirth · 09/03/2022 19:53

I listened to a podcast some years ago about research in young brains making risk based decisions. The conclusion was that young men don't necessarily underestimate the risks involved, but do massively overestimate the potential benefits. My DH calls it "chasing the story", doing the risky thing because the aim is a good tale down the pub for years after.

Jenasaurus · 09/03/2022 19:53

@Gemmathecat

Really interesting to see how many mumsnetters fought in the First World War
My grandfather fought in the first world war, he is British and was stationed in India, he lived until he was nearly 100 (died in 1982 when I was 20) He told me lots of tales about the war but he would never answer the question of whether he killed anyone (he was a machine gunner) and lost both brothers in the same war. He had no language barriers, despite not speaking anything but English.
SommerTen · 09/03/2022 19:46

Actually quite a few paramedics get ptsd too.
And I have some nightmare memories from my previous career that keep me awake.
Maybe it just depends how sensitive you can be to trauma affecting you.

redbigbananafeet · 09/03/2022 19:45

@PeterPomegranate

I don’t think the Ukrainians will want someone with no military experience. Hopefully he’ll be back home soon enough. Probably feeling silly and a bit wiser.
Which is exactly what happened to Leon Dawson. Glory hunting gym owner who went to Ukraine after boasting on social media he was going over to raise arms and help. He was sent home again. Why someone with no military or firearms experience thought he'd do anything but get in the way just baffles me.
SommerTen · 09/03/2022 19:43

I've just met so many people drinking their lives away because of ptsd from military service

redbigbananafeet · 09/03/2022 19:43

@mumsiedarlingrevolta

I read some UK soldiers went AWOL to fight and the fear is that, if captured, it could indicate that the UK has joined the fighting.

So no-not a good idea and can't believe anyone will actually get there/join up etc

My partner who is in the military was told they were all warned that if they went over they'd be tried with terrorism when/if they came back.
SommerTen · 09/03/2022 19:42

I suppose so...

DetailMouse · 09/03/2022 19:38

No one thinks it's a fun outing for him Sommer, I expect he will come back with all sorts of issues, if he comes back, but where would the world be now if people like your Grandad didn't do it?

SommerTen · 09/03/2022 19:34

My Grandad joined the British Army before Ww2 firstly because he was homeless but also because he enjoyed a drink & a fight.
It was all good until he returned home from the war in Burma with Malaria, Dysentery, back problems & nightmares for years about his dead mates (would now be called cptsd I guess?).
Even the memories at the end of his life with dementia were specific war memories of killing Japanese soldiers that tormented him daily.

All those who think it's great this young man has gone to fight... it's understandable to feel that way but speak to the veterans of war even the hardened professional soldiers who've fought in recent wars like some of the men & women I know & you won't think it's so clever.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 19:03

@BordelDeMerde not being threatening at all.

Thewindwhispers · 09/03/2022 19:01

He’s an adult, he made a decision. Ukrainian soldiers don’t have time to do background checks on people, they’re a bit busy right now.

I feel for his poor mother, but I suspect the lad is probably having a brilliant time - until it all goes wrong of course. Given the choice between a boring job in a shop that doesn’t really matter, or overnight becoming a soldier fighting on the ‘good guys’ side against an evil empire, a lotta boys and men would jump at the chance. Look at ISIS. Look at how they queued round the block to go on Shackleton’s adventure. Young men crave brotherhood, excitement and adventure and there isn’t much of that around.

BordelDeMerde · 09/03/2022 18:59

[quote Gemmathecat]@BordelDeMerde my village and you have no idea[/quote]
Grin What are you being so bizarrely threatening about? You're right, though, that I have no idea whether the young lads in your village are reading Mumsnet or not. Seems unlikely, but, as you've pointed out, what do I know? 😂😂😂

Zilla1 · 09/03/2022 18:56

Am mildly sceptical that many 19 year olds pay so much attention to Liz Truss that she made much difference. If there are many late teens wearing headscarves and sat in tank turrets and obsessively using Flikr with ambitions to succeed Boris then happy to be wrong.

Gemmathecat · 09/03/2022 18:55

@BordelDeMerde my village and you have no idea

TiddyTidTwo · 09/03/2022 18:50

I respect his bravery but he should concentrate on the humanitarian effort. He's not trained, he will be a hindrance. Army training is not a walk in the park. Your personality is deconstructed then reconstructed into a different mindset. Even then, the effects of war are devastating on those are are trained. Worst, he will die.