Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should she have paid for Carrie’s shoes?

77 replies

AllyBama · 09/03/2022 14:02

Lighthearted obviously and I know I’m being unreasonable for doing an AIBU for a Sex And The City episode but it was the on in the house in the background today and it was like they took the storyline right out of a mumsnet classic! You don’t need to have watched the series to weigh in.

It was the episode where Carrie goes to a baby shower or kids party or something in $475 Manolo Blahnik shoes and is asked (with everyone) to remove them at the door. At the end of the night, the shoes are gone, ostensibly nicked. After some deliberation,

Carrie comes to the conclusion that the homeowner who asked her to remove her shoes should replace them. Carrie is ‘shoe shamed’ - the party thrower initially rebuffs the idea of reimbursement and says she shouldn’t have worn such extravagant shoes to a party and they shouldn’t have to fund her lifestyle.

So
YABU: The party thrower was right, Carrie chose to wear such an over the top shoe to a baby shower, she shouldn’t have to replace them
YANBU: Carrie is right, while the shoe was an extravagant choice, it was never Carrie’s choice to remove them and the homeowner should replace them.

OP posts:
AnnaDelvorkina · 09/03/2022 14:04

Carrie is always U.

smallandimperfectlyformed · 09/03/2022 14:04

As soon as I saw the title I remembered the episode! Yes, she should have paid for the shoes and she was bloody judgemental about Carrie's life choices. I was team Carrie all the way