Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what the motivation is for ‘acts of kindness’

145 replies

Hailsafe · 09/03/2022 11:54

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

OP posts:
ForcingSmiles · 09/03/2022 16:56

I guess my acts of Kindness would be regular donations to the food bank (every couple of weeks i'll pull their list off the website and go round asda once i've done my foodshop and buy about £15 worth of stuff)

For me we didn't grow up with much and i know how hard it is to rely on the foodbank..I'm thankfully in a much better position but I like to donate to them because I know how much people rely on them.

I never post on social media just tell my partner when I get home. As soon as you put it on social media it takes away the reasons why you did it in the first place imo and becomes more about other people validating you..

Fairislefandango · 09/03/2022 16:49

I firmly believe that human nature is such that no one ever does anything that they don't personally benefit from.

I think that calling the warm fuzzy feeling a non-altruistic benefit is pushing it tbh. I don't think that enjoying doing good means it's not altruistic. The enjoyment is often a by-product rather than a deliberate purpose imo.

Foody8410 · 09/03/2022 16:42

my dad is a very mean man, very tight with money, would never do anything for others unless there was something in it for himself. But he expects other people to do things for him. He is the most selfish and entitled person I've ever met. So I was also brought up with way.
I must admit I do stuggle to do acts of kindness, especially if it involves a financial cost. I think this is also because nobody has ever done anything for me ever. So I feel bitter and selfish I suppose.
I have huge respect for people who are so generous and wish very much I was like that

Liveandkicking · 09/03/2022 16:37

I work for a charity. We do have people who do things anonymously or very quietly for others pretty regularly.
But I agree that performative giving probably is seeking affirmation. Is that a problem though? If it was a nice thing for the people who received it (not always a given!) then I’m fine with it. It’s when someone does something that actually isn’t helping another person (like giving dirty clothes or something) that I would have an issue.

reqding · 09/03/2022 16:33

@Mylittlepixie

I think it doesnt really matter what the motivation is. Whether someone does something anonymously or very openly expecting praise, the kind thing still improves someones life. If the kind person feels better about themselves from the praise/likes etc then good for them.

More people should take this simple view. It's a good one.

Mylittlepixie · 09/03/2022 15:26

I think it doesnt really matter what the motivation is. Whether someone does something anonymously or very openly expecting praise, the kind thing still improves someones life. If the kind person feels better about themselves from the praise/likes etc then good for them.

Lovelteers · 09/03/2022 14:59

I volunteer with kids because I love kids, not because I want someone to tell me how good I am. I help out with a sports team because otherwise it wouldn’t run and my kids would miss out, I took in an extra job at work for someone off I’ll cos I know if unneeded it she would do the same.
Maybe it is all self serving in a way…

Lovelteers · 09/03/2022 14:57

Sounds like you weren’t brought up right to me.
I’m ‘kind’ because I feel good when I help other people. Because I hate to see others struggle when I can help. I often don’t tell anyone about it, and I don’t expect thanks. The act itself is satisfying enough.
It makes me feel like part of a community. And I was brought up
In a community where we didn’t have much ££ but people swapped skills. So my dad the plumber would help out neighbours, in return they would help my mum paint the hse, or fix the car.
My mum, good with numbers, would help with VAT stuff and in return the woman at the shop kept an eye on us after school.
I think if you’re brought up like this it’s ingrained in you.

sweetbellyhigh · 09/03/2022 14:49

On occasion I will post on a local Facebook page asking for specific items for women who have escaped violence and the response is always very touching. And there are always private messages from people offering money, vouchers and so on who do not seek any recognition at all. Lots of beautiful people out there who genuinely try to make a positive difference.

MoltenLasagne · 09/03/2022 14:46

I don't really consciously think about the kind things I do - I think its just part of how I was raised, that my family were the type to look after others and it just rubbed off. At most the thought is that I want to live in a world where people look after each other so I act like that.

sweetbellyhigh · 09/03/2022 14:44

Just because some people need to advertise their good deeds does not mean all acts of kindness are for show. It just means that some people need an audience. Zillions more do kind things without any need for recognition. There are so many people who volunteer, who help neighbours, family, friend and so on simply because they care. The value of life is in the strength of relationships and relationships are strengthened by goodwill. It's a normal human reaction to want to be connected to others and it is educated behaviour to be considerate of others, and to acknowledge our own privilege, to use this for the greater good. Less prevalent in Western society and directly linked to mental well-being.

Ariela · 09/03/2022 14:42

I do things to improve people's quality of life all the time, paying forward is not my forte as I rarely buy coffee but I have paid £10 for a gift card towards next person's shopping a fair few times. I might message a FB admin to say 'can I pay xx solicitor bill anonymously , as I know she'll struggle' or 'can I send you ££ for this item to forward to yy as I know she needs one', but I'd NEVER post about it or let xx know it was me.

youdoyoutoday · 09/03/2022 14:35

Doing nice things for people doesn't have to be broadcasted all over social media. I do nice things and I don't need recognition for it whether it be donating to charity, helping someone with their bags or buying some food for a homeless person.

Don't worry about what others are doing, just do what you can.

Treeroo · 09/03/2022 14:29

It is what used to be called “being neighbourly”? Then with the a great number commuting to work it became “random acts of kindness” with the ideas being shared then sadly being boasted about. However if someone benefits and the boaster benefits from being acknowledged by more than the receiver then maybe it’s no biggie. For myself I was brought up with the idea of trying to be/being a decent person, like a previous poster has already said.

Johnnypiratesfriend · 09/03/2022 14:21

Oh and I think people should post on social media to encourage people to help to or give them ideas of ways to Help!

Moonface123 · 09/03/2022 14:20

Some peopke are just naturally kind, others will attatch conditions to it, such as look at me, aren' t l a good.person to make themselves feel better.
Self.kindness is important , if your at.peace with yourself,.your at peace with others. This forum would have a totally different vibe if more women.on here practised self kindness.

Johnnypiratesfriend · 09/03/2022 14:18

I do it because I can remember times in my life when I have been really low and had no one to help me.
I would hate to think someone felt like that and I could have made them feel better or helped in anyway. If someone is going through a rough patch I'm always there for them no matter how well I know them.

gwenneh · 09/03/2022 14:15

I do things like this because I can. I was raised in a home where I was taught that if you can (within reason), you should. So I do.

TigerLilyTail · 09/03/2022 14:14

My parents used to take an elderly relative out for tea. It was awful and stressful for them to do so as she was always miserable and complaining and difficult. I never understood why they put themselves through it. She was a great aunt, so not a close relative. When she died, I was quite relieved for them.

SatinHeart · 09/03/2022 14:12

Not sure about posting on social media etc, but random acts of kindness can be good for your mental health. When you feel down and powerless about your own life, it can sometimes be easier to do something small to make a difference to someone else's life.

mnnewbie111 · 09/03/2022 14:09

I like to do things that make people smile as it genuinely makes me feel good. But like that iconic "friends" episode explains... that's also not a selfless good deed as I get the benefit of feeling good too.

It's cynical to think people do just for kudos, that's not true of everyone, just a handful of idiots

Tomikka · 09/03/2022 14:08

I do things because I can and it feels good to have done some good.

I’m an almost believer of karma. Doing good could come back to me somehow - but if it doesn’t then at least I’ve done some good
If something good happens to me then I feel more of an urge to pass on some goodness

Under lockdown I was easily able to continue working remotely, so I was in the good position of having my full income and saving both time and money by not commuting.
I do minor ‘caring’ anyway, and I was still doing shopping, getting prescriptions etc (in doing so so during lockdown I also benefitted with being able to go out with good reason) so it was no extra effort to shop & collect for other friends & family at the same time, and also go into a local private ‘community volunteer’ group to do the odd deed for others as well

Alcoholabuse · 09/03/2022 14:05

There’s a difference between empathy and sympathy (which empathy can be taught but most people sit at sympathy).

If you see a homeless man sitting wanting change. Most people will walk on by thinking ‘god there’s a homeless problem or everyone should have shelter’.

To have empathy is to feel/relate to how that person is feeling - to see them as an individual not just another number.

A couple of years ago I was going thru hell in my personal life, I lost family members who were close, I lost my job, had caring responsibilities, shitty relationship etc etc. people reached out with ‘support’ if I need anything to just ask especially on FB.

Somebody who was the biggest help was my friend with autism. I turned up to her house, exhausted, emotional and generally looking/feeling like crap.

She told me to go take a bath, she ran me a bubble bath, got me out a clean dressing gown, razor and gave me all the toiletries.

Got out of the bath, she put a face mask on me with a steamed flannel, I laid back and she painted my toes, waxed my face and gave me a facial. We spoke about my problems and then chatted about ‘normal things’.

I left that house feeling 100x better. I had felt exhausted for months and completely neglected myself. I got to the point where I didn’t even feel human but a robot.

A lot of other people would just say ‘me too’ when I said I felt like crap or ‘thinking of you’.

She offered me help that I needed, or at the time, I didn’t know that I needed. All the flowers/gifts/visits/phone calls and sympathy cards didn’t start to cut the surface.

Anyone who posts on SM of their ‘good deeds’ aren’t doing good deals. They’re doing it for the feel good factor of ‘being a good person’. You can donate anonymously, you can help others silently, you can volunteer without boasting about it.

I’m disgusted when I see people making videos on how they’ve helped the homeless. These people are real people, and having their picture posted for the world to see is dehumanising.

AnnaDelvorkina · 09/03/2022 13:58

Pre-COVID I would often take snacks into work according to people's likes or special occasions. I try to remember birthdays and to send people a message or card or little gift depending on how close we are. I try to make new neighbours in the building feel welcome, to help people at the bus stop etc. who are lost or have questions, and to ensure that new people are welcomed at work. Why? I don't know. I just think, if I can help, why wouldn't I?

I have never posted it on social media.

sst1234 · 09/03/2022 13:52

Being responsible is more important than being kind. Its because so many people are irresponsible, only caring about ‘rights’, that others have to pick up the slack with kindness.