Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what the motivation is for ‘acts of kindness’

145 replies

Hailsafe · 09/03/2022 11:54

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

OP posts:
DilemmaDelilah · 09/03/2022 20:38

I do nice things for people when I can. I occasionally send little gifts to my siblings or my adult children just because.... I bake for our delivery people/postmen/local street sweeper and put individually wrapped snacks and drinks in a box for them to help themselves. I found out a former colleague (and somebody I like) had covid and did some shopping for her. Apart from on here (and you don't know who I am) I don't advertise what I do - however I call it 'storing up pennies in heaven'. I am a bad Christian.... in that I think I believe but I have doubts about bits of it and I don't go to church much, but I suppose I am hedging my bets a bit and hope that my random acts of kindness will be a plus on my personal balance sheet when I eventually shuffle off this mortal coil.

Snugglepumpkin · 09/03/2022 20:28

Offline I help people as much as I can because I can.
Years ago I did it more publicly but found I was permanently drained with requests.
The world never runs out of people who are in need.
If people know you will give, you can never give enough & they will never stop asking.

It breaks my heart though to think that tonight someone who lives near me will go to bed genuinely hungry when I have food in my cupboard I could spare.

The people I help now never know my name or where I live & that's the way I like it.
This is the only site I ever even mention it on because nobody here knows me offline.

I've been watching Dave Ramsey lately & I really understand what he says when he talks about 'outrageous acts of generosity'.
If you have enough money for everything you need (by his definition I do not) then what else is there left to spend it on but helping others?

I actually feel my life is richer & better for the help I have given others even if they'll never know who I am.
These are things that make me feel good at the end of the day.
I can look myself in the mirror & not be ashamed of who I am even if I come across as horrible & most people hate me.
Every day I know I did a tiny something that made someones life a tiny bit better.

I am happy to know that children go to bed in decent bedding, or got birthday presents, or have a hot meal today, or that a stressed out single mum with no contact from her abusive ex & just preschool kids to try & raise on pennies gets a surprise box of chocolates on Mothers Day.

As a Christian, I also feel my life has been blessed with good luck because I try to be kind even though that is not why I started it.

I hope, one day when they are in a better position, some of the people I've helped might choose to help others who are in need too.

There was a film many years ago called Pay it Forward.
It probably wasn't as good as I remember it being, but the concept of paying acts of kindness forward stuck with me & shaped a large part of my life.

It doesn't matter if nobody else ever does 'pay it forward' though.
Being the person who does try to help when help is needed is enough for me.

sweetbellyhigh · 09/03/2022 20:02

@Mylittlepixie

I think it doesnt really matter what the motivation is. Whether someone does something anonymously or very openly expecting praise, the kind thing still improves someones life. If the kind person feels better about themselves from the praise/likes etc then good for them.
Yes and it's so much better than posting miserable crap and tearing apart others for doing something nice.

No brainer

1Micem0use · 09/03/2022 20:01

I buy meal deals for homeless women sometimes. They are so much more vulnerable than homeless men, both in hostels and on the streets. It makes me feel happy about myself. But I dont advertise it except here anonymously right now

Piggy666 · 09/03/2022 19:44

I do an RAOK every month, but I never talk about them

It makes me feel good, and hopefully people will feel encouraged to do something for someone else as the world is a rather shitty place at the moment

ChiefInspectorParker · 09/03/2022 19:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

RealBecca · 09/03/2022 19:39

If someone makes someones day better is it really so bad if they need some praise?

Surely everyone saying they dont boast on social media feels secure? So people boasting probably dont. Yes, people might pity the neediness of boasting but actually the doer doesnt even see that because they are so insecure.

So I think the good deed still puts good out there. The worst thing about it is the embarrassment and pity we fee for people who boast. And that's still better than the good deed not happening.

Pinkpassionfruit · 09/03/2022 19:33

I just generally live by the principle “if everyone were like me, would the world be a nice place”
I try to act in a way that means that people’s lives are better for knowing me. Is it selfish? In a way- I guess I want to know that I serve a purpose in the world and make a difference. I like to feel consequential according to my own values.

Hawkins001 · 09/03/2022 19:27

@Hailsafe

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

I try to help people at various times that are close to me, sometimes when you see them struggling or you just feel pity for them and want to help, with x situation.

For me my reasons are, some people have helped me, and I have achieved what I have with the assistance of others helping me, so I try to return the favour. And sometimes if I know someone is struggling I try to help, sometimes their ego prevents them from accepting but then others appreciate it.

Plus my other line of reasoning is , e.g. With bosses, I try to help and do extra when possible, because then in theory if I needed a favour hopefully they would be more flexible granting the request, I know this doesn't always automatically mean they can assist but at least I've made the effort on my part.

Ionlydomassiveones · 09/03/2022 19:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Caminante · 09/03/2022 18:53

Doing kind things for other people is good for your mental health.

Anything that's means you spend less time thinking about yourself is good.

Sharing it on social media is only good if it is to highlight the cause and encourage others to do the same.

Whybirdwhy · 09/03/2022 18:28

Mylittlepixie

"I think it doesnt really matter what the motivation is. Whether someone does something anonymously or very openly expecting praise, the kind thing still improves someones life. If the kind person feels better about themselves from the praise/likes etc then good for them."

"More people should take this simple view. It's a good one."

Totally agree. If it makes the giver feel good then it's just double the benefit as far as I'm concerned. That's also human nature, we are designed to care for each other to ensure survival.

Whybirdwhy · 09/03/2022 18:26

@12:44Helenahandkart

I try to do things for other people because I think deep down I’m a horrible selfish person. By taking someone a bunch of flowers or giving them a lift or babysitting etc I feel less awful about myself. I’m also autistic and struggle a bit with what is appropriate, but I try to think about what I would want done for me in any given situation.
I’m often depressed and struggling with life, so if I think someone else might need help I try to give it because I know how it feels.

You don't sound like a horrible selfish person at all.

DiscoBadgers · 09/03/2022 18:19

I just like the idea of being able to make someone happy if I can, and I know how much random acts of kindness have meant to me in the past on bad days.

I don’t use social media particularly so I don’t post about that sort of thing - I prefer people don’t know as I’d be embarrassed. The only exception would be something like a marathon for charity, because it’s not the actual marathon that helps the charity, it’s how much you are sponsored so that needs publicising.

I find I feel better about the world if other people feel better so I try and be a part of that where I can.

Kendodd · 09/03/2022 18:13

God is this yet another thread slagging off people who try to do a bit of good.

I very rarely post anything on social media, never post holidays etc. I volunteered as a marshal at a covid vaccine site for the last year though. Day one, when it opened, I posted that I was volunteering there. I had never in my life been so happy to stand in a car park in my life, I wanted to tell the whole world. If that makes me a virtue signalling narcissistic, in your eyes, so what.

Scbchl · 09/03/2022 18:06

I do lots of things to help others and make their life easier. Many I don't even tell my own husband never mind anyone else. I definitely don't put anything on social media. At the end of the day if some people do do it for the glory then I personally ignore that and just think its a good thing that someone somewhere less fortunate is benefiting.

On the other hand, people sharing it on social media also raises awareness. Two things for Ukraine iv seen in the last week and done to help, I wouldnt even of considered doing. So in that sense its great.

gumball37 · 09/03/2022 18:03

@Hailsafe

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

I do it even if people don't know. 1. It makes me feel good. 2. I know how fucking awful life can be, and if some small stupid thing I do can make someone's day better... Why not?
Fandangles · 09/03/2022 17:57

This has been an interesting thread to read through. I volunteer with a charity that helps mothers with young children who are finding parenthood hard for whatever reason. I struggled with 2 young kids so always wanted to help out others in a similar position when mine were old enough. I don’t brag about it but it does make me feel good to help someone. I’ve started to think - what is life all about if you can’t give others even a little bit of kindness?

mamakoukla · 09/03/2022 17:46

Kindness can change a person’s life, a stage in their life or just a few moments of their day. I like adding spots of brightness and joy to people’s lives. I dunno, just nice to see them happy even if it’s a brief respite. Other people’s kindness has been a comfort in my life. It’s not even paying it forward. Just seems to be the right thing to do

BigYellowTaxiT · 09/03/2022 17:41
  1. Nobody is “slightly autistic”. You’re autistic or you’re not.
  2. Being inconsiderate and selfish is not an autistic trait.
cherrylicious2 · 09/03/2022 17:14

I absolutely love doing acts of kindness and I don't post it on social media or expect anyone to sing my praises.

duckme · 09/03/2022 17:01

@Confusedteacher

This is reminding me of that episode of friends when Joey says there is no selfless good deed and Phoebe tries to prove him wrong… Grin
I came here to post this.
Shuffleuplove · 09/03/2022 17:00

I have a very unusual skill set and experience which enables me to help people in a very specific set of circumstances, which they would usually like to keep private. I don’t tell anyone about it, people come to me by word of mouth and I never charge. I do it because I can, and I like to help, it makes me feel like I’m giving something back to the world.

My mother, an atomic narcissist, got wind of this via a friend who was singing my praises, and cannot conceive of why I won’t tell anyone, and won’t allow her to either. For her, if there’s no external praise, it’s worthless.

AthelstaneTheUnready · 09/03/2022 16:58

Does it matter?

You've just made the world a slightly better place. Why does it matter if you also get to benefit from the 'better'.

Ncwinc · 09/03/2022 16:56

MyLittlePixie is right. A kind thing is a kind thing. The more people doing kind things, whatever their motivation, the more pleasant life is.

I pick up other dog’s shit (as well my dog’s shit) on dog walks. I give myself permission to have an inner rant about selfish dog owners while I do it, so that’s my pay off Grin