Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what the motivation is for ‘acts of kindness’

145 replies

Hailsafe · 09/03/2022 11:54

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

OP posts:
LadyCordeliaFitzgerald · 10/03/2022 10:05

I’ve had problems with depression and low self esteem and I know how very vulnerable you can be to a small unkindness, how little it takes to push you over the edge.

I’ve also had the experience of people doing a small kindness for me that stayed with me - one that springs to mind is being utterly exhausted with my toddler and baby in tow and buying myself lunch out because I hadn’t the energy to cook, and the manager stepping out to carry my tray because I had my hands full. It was a tiny thing but I was so low that day and it was a ray of sunshine.

I find some of the random acts people describe a bit - I don’t know - they don’t quite sit right. But if I can smile at someone, take a few minutes to char, be a slightly bright spot in someone’s day, or show a bit of kindness I will. I think that we can inadvertently cause unhappiness without knowing it so I try to offset that. I guess it’s like a carbon footprint.

But I would feel uncomfortable with overt gestures or free cakes/flowers/coffee. Maybe this is daft but I think it disrupts the balance and leaves people in a sort of psychic debt.

Janetizzy30 · 10/03/2022 10:01

It just comes naturally to me. I find if I treat others how I would like to be treated I get treated how I want to be treated back 99 percent of the time. Obviously in life you will get cos and users who try to take advantage but it's a minority xx

LoganberryJam · 10/03/2022 09:55

I think it's a bit of a circular argument to say that people only perform acts of kindness to make themselves feel good so it's not really altruistic. Surely only a genuinely kind person feels good after doing something nice for someone else?

sairiegamp · 10/03/2022 09:12

I have far more money than I need, through luck rather than any particular virtue of mine. I give a fair bit of my money away. I'd rather pay more taxes but as I can't, I pay for people I know and admire, to have private operations when the NHS route is a matter of years. I support some charities quite significantly. I part fund a local sports facilitiy that I use that gives huge joy to poor people.

I do this because I've been lucky all my life and because money is there to provide choice and my choices are to "buy" for good rather than solely for myself. I don't post about it ever. Other than here now.

Kendodd · 10/03/2022 08:46

@Lalliella

Actually, I'd rather not. I'd rather go through life thinking most people in the world are lovely and kind (and I am constantly proven CORRECT on this) than think they're all self centered virtues signalling. You choose your own view though.

Lalliella · 10/03/2022 08:31

If you’re concerned that you’re not yet cynical enough about virtue signallers, watch the Friends episode The One Where Phoebe Hates PBS. You will doubt the selflessness of good deeds forever!

BeyondMyWits · 10/03/2022 08:24

I like to be nice, makes me feel good. Because I'm "a nice person" I don't always know what I'm doing is "an act of kindness" because it used to be known as just looking out for others.

Someone is a quid short at the checkout, "here's a quid". Elderly folk lonely during covid, have a chat through the window while walking the dog. Pick up a prescription, I'm going near the pharmacy anyhow. Fallen in the street " I'll take you home, do you need me to call someone". Go to the school fete even though the kids are long past that stage and volunteer to litter pick.

I feel a lot better if my go to is "what can I do to help?" in random situations ... instead of "what now?" So it is selfish I guess.

Calandor · 10/03/2022 08:04

It makes the giver feel good. Whether that's because of praise or feeling superior or just enjoying helping others.

Putting it on social media winds me up, but at least they're doing it.

littledrummergirl · 10/03/2022 07:51

I try to be kind to make my part of the world a little nicer. I will offer help where possible. If everyone did this the world would be a better place.
I don't post it social media though, I prefer to keep it quiet.

itsgettingweird · 10/03/2022 07:43

I don't ever post when I do stuff like this and many of my friends don't.

I just like knowing I've cheered someone up as I know when others have done it for me it's made me feel better.

Perhaps not having a mum who taught you that feeling is the reason?

But also a) what is slightly autistic? You either are or aren't and b) my diagnosed autistic ds would also do stuff for others to make them feel good - he's extremely empathetic.

sweetbellyhigh · 10/03/2022 07:40

@BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ

What kind of mean sod says that people being kind leaves a nasty taste in their mouth?!?
Yea it's a new level of meanness
reqding · 10/03/2022 07:22

I like to donate £5-£10 to charity per month and did have a standing order with a charity that no one knew about. In addition to that I had friends doing fund raising events so couldn't afford both in the end. Standing order has now stopped but I quite like supporting friends that are raising money for charity and I don't think a month has gone by where there hasn't been one or two people to support.

They obviously know I've donated but it doesn't get shared further than that. It helps them and genuinely makes me feel good too.

If I there's wanted to share and shout from the rooftops they've done the same thing I would not blink twice, each to their own and good job, may encourage others to do the same.

THisbackwithavengeance · 10/03/2022 07:00

This is a nice thread. I would like to be a kinder person. I'm nice to people and not mean but I think I can be thoughtless and uncharitable at times.

My son and his friend were stranded in a neighbouring town after the event they were supposed to attend got cancelled last minute and all the public transport home was cancelled (bad weather) and their phones died! A nice lady bought them a drink and sandwiches and got a local shopkeeper to let them charge their phones so they could call home. I need to pay that forward.

Mabelface · 10/03/2022 06:52

I like to pay it forward. There's been people who've helped me when I've needed it. I do little things like paying for someone's meds at the chemist when their card is declined, toy cars in a charity shop for a little boy, that sort of thing. It does make me feel good.

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 10/03/2022 06:39

What kind of mean sod says that people being kind leaves a nasty taste in their mouth?!?

JennyForeigner · 10/03/2022 06:26

I just think I'd be happy if someone did that for me. And friends/colleagues do do randomly nice things for me, so it feels like a connection with them. Lastly, the more we do nice stuff like say - a colleague bringing in a box of apples from a tree in their garden and telling other people to help themselves, the more the people who hadn't previously felt that was ok do it too. The culture of niceness grows.

But also there is a massive upside of buying people small gifts they would really like as or when you find them. Takes the pressure off birthdays and Christmas.

cookiemonster2468 · 10/03/2022 05:34

I can sort of see where you're coming from OP but it's a strange way to think, really.

Yes, we do get some kind of personal reward for doing good things - it makes us feel good. Even giving money to charity that no one knows about makes us feel like we're doing some good.

Does that mean we shouldn't do it though?

Of course not!

If you want to do more "acts of kindness" then just start small. Think of one single thing you could do and see how you go. Everyone can do something. Don't get so fixated on whether you get any benefit from it or not, that's really neither here nor there, you're still doing something good.

SD1978 · 10/03/2022 04:21

Anyone who has to advertise what they do are doing it for Arte toon and selfish reasons- look at my benevolence. Although some people argue they advertise it to encourage others. But it really seems more for the Pat on the back to me.

sashh · 10/03/2022 03:51

With me it is often that I see someone struggling and it is a simple thing for me to help.

In the days when I could do my own shopping I have given the odd person a lift home from the supermarket, just because could see they were struggling.

I have a car with just me in it, I could see the lady at the next checkout distributing things to her 3 small children to help her carry them so asked how far she was going.

I've never been the woman with three small children walking home from the supermarket but I can imagine it and that a lift would make her life a little easier and it didn't cost me anything,

GeidiPrimes · 10/03/2022 01:53

I saw a post on sm earlier where a man was describing an act of kindness he did today. Apparently the recipients were so grateful for their coffee and cake that they chased him through town to thank him. The story was told in lip-smacking embellishment.

TheSmallestGiraffe · 10/03/2022 01:47

[quote Hailsafe]@BigYellowTaxiT

Thank you for your kind words.

By ‘slightly’ I meant that I am on that spectrum but highly functioning. Sorry if that offended you.

And I never said I am inconsiderate or selfish. I said that it often doesn’t occur to me that I could help, or that I don’t really know what to do to help.

I have given to charity for Ukraine, I sponsor a child in Liberia, I have also given to the crisis in Yemen. I supported a friend with cancer by giving her boxes of goodies. No one knows about any of this.

I started this thread because recently a friend told me in conversation how she gave cakes to the teachers at our school. I didn’t know what to say - why was she telling me this?

The same day I saw a post on Facebook by someone who’d organised a cake sale for Ukraine. They posted the thank you email from the charity. Again, why? It’s just made me question people’s motives.[/quote]
This seems an odd comment given that you're either diagnosed as autistic, or not. The autistic spectrum is about the proportionate presentation of the specific features of autism within one person's profile. You can be in different places on the autistic spectrum - which is actually spikey, not a linear thing - but only if you are autistic in the first place.

You may well be. But based on your comments I highly doubt it because you have made some massively ignorant and factually wrong comments/ insinuations about autistic people (e.g. that they lack empathy) and then described yourself as "high functioning" which is never given as a diagnosis because that's just so, so offensive and totally misrepresents how a person experiences autism as being all about how other people experience the effects of it on their behaviour.

Please either seek diagnosis properly and learn about it or stop spreading harmful stereotypes.

I do hope you find a way through that, and your other problems.

TheSmallestGiraffe · 10/03/2022 01:39

Oh and I meant to say, none of the kind people I know ever post about what they're doing on social media. 🤨🙄🤔

That would sort of negate the purpose, which is that the kind act is about the other person, not about the person doing it.

I think maybe you are misinterpreting virtue signalling idiots who want some kind of validation as being kind people? That's not real kindness.

TheSmallestGiraffe · 10/03/2022 01:36

@Hailsafe

I struggle to be a considerate person and have always felt other people ‘get it right’ more than I do when it comes to doing kind things for people. I had quite a selfish mother and I was never taught to do nice things for others (not an excuse, just an explanation). I try my best but I am slightly autistic and often it just doesn’t cross my mind or I feel hugely awkward about it. I often berate myself for this.

On the other hand, I know a few people who do a lot of ‘acts of kindness’ - bringing in cakes for the teachers, taking someone flowers if they’re down, raising money for charity etc. But I have to say it often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Often they tell me about what they’ve done, or put it on social media, and I start to wonder, what drives them? Would they do it if they knew no one would ever know?

So: Do you think IABU to think some of it isn’t well intentioned or am I just an old misery guts?

OP. I am autistic. There is no such thing as "slightly autistic" and the myth that autistic people aren't empathetic has been thoroughly debunked. So for a start please stop insulting some of the kindest, most caring people I know by implying that their actual, diagnosed disability is the reason that you are unkind, when you are prepared to describe yourself as "slightly autistic". 

I have a horrible mother. If anything that has made me more kind.

Maybe you should look at the things that make you feel fulfilled in life, many people get joy from helping others. From friendships (including - newsflash - lots of autistic people!!!).

Are you having a very hard time coping with your own issues so have no mental or emotional space to care about others? That sounds much more like trauma than autism, if so. Is there another reason why you don't understand this joy of helping other people?

There is a great programme on Radio 4 called "Thank you" which is about kind things people have done for no personal benefit. So moving. The impact kindness has for the other person is enough reason that people do it.

sweetbellyhigh · 09/03/2022 22:54

[quote Hailsafe]@BigYellowTaxiT

Thank you for your kind words.

By ‘slightly’ I meant that I am on that spectrum but highly functioning. Sorry if that offended you.

And I never said I am inconsiderate or selfish. I said that it often doesn’t occur to me that I could help, or that I don’t really know what to do to help.

I have given to charity for Ukraine, I sponsor a child in Liberia, I have also given to the crisis in Yemen. I supported a friend with cancer by giving her boxes of goodies. No one knows about any of this.

I started this thread because recently a friend told me in conversation how she gave cakes to the teachers at our school. I didn’t know what to say - why was she telling me this?

The same day I saw a post on Facebook by someone who’d organised a cake sale for Ukraine. They posted the thank you email from the charity. Again, why? It’s just made me question people’s motives.[/quote]
What you are really asking is what motivates people to advertise their good deeds. It's called PR.

Hailsafe · 09/03/2022 20:59

@BigYellowTaxiT

Thank you for your kind words.

By ‘slightly’ I meant that I am on that spectrum but highly functioning. Sorry if that offended you.

And I never said I am inconsiderate or selfish. I said that it often doesn’t occur to me that I could help, or that I don’t really know what to do to help.

I have given to charity for Ukraine, I sponsor a child in Liberia, I have also given to the crisis in Yemen. I supported a friend with cancer by giving her boxes of goodies. No one knows about any of this.

I started this thread because recently a friend told me in conversation how she gave cakes to the teachers at our school. I didn’t know what to say - why was she telling me this?

The same day I saw a post on Facebook by someone who’d organised a cake sale for Ukraine. They posted the thank you email from the charity. Again, why? It’s just made me question people’s motives.

OP posts: