Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
halfpastthree · 11/03/2022 23:26

We gave up our car when we moved back to London. I don't miss it at all. Our 7yo could walk to school by himself if he didn't have to cross a road. Cars ruin everything, don't they?

SelkieQualia · 11/03/2022 22:50

@FreakinFrankNFurter

Shortage of time is a big factor for me and many people. I do every school drop off and pick up for DS, whether it's from school or after school club.

School is a 45 minute round trip if walking. On days when I'm in the office, it's another 20 minute walk to the train station. I get the train into Manchester City Centre.

I don't have 90 to 130 minutes available every day to do those walks, when I can save 60 to 90 minutes of that if i drive.

I enjoy the walks to school, it makes me feel better and it is good for DS too. I will be walking to pick DS up today as I'm not working. But I don't have time most days.

Bike isn't an option as we live in terrace so can only keep bikes in the cellar which is difficult to get bikes in and out of. We do have them for weekend bike rides.
DS school has also shut and still not replaced the bike/scooter shed. Partly as it was knackered but the HT told me it was also because not having bikes/scooters means playground at school pick up is calmer

And wouldn't it be better if there was a dedicated school bus that picked the kids up? When you have one of those, it's amazing - give you back so much time.

And this at attitude by the school to the bike shed - forget the health and environmental benefits (when we are having a health crisis due to under exercise), and the way in which having some kids on bikes would relieve the school pick up traffic problem (find me a school that does not have this issue), "the playground is calmer"?!

OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 11/03/2022 22:43

@Sleepyblueocean

"Currently, however, the system does penalise those whi can't drive. And I suspect that the number of people who can't drive is much larger than those who can't use cpublic transport."

A large number of people who cannot use public transport cannot drive but they do need to be driven around by others in private vehicles.

Yes, and cars will always be there for those people. NO ONE IS SUGGESTING TAKING AWAY CARS COMPLETELY.

There is just currently no real alternative for those who can't drive, but could have some independence if there were other alternatives.

OP posts:
Momicrone · 11/03/2022 19:11

User149, but said taxi wouldn't keep going back to office/rank c. I'd rather live on a street with one car serving 20 households than 20 cars

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 16:13

If the transport networks were much better more people wouldn't use cars.
everyone agrees with that, the question is why do we tolerate it?

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 16:07

You could if it had wheels, otherwise it would be obstructing the highway

not even with wheels - it was done in Kenilworth with with wheel and a motor, but had to be moved. It was a seat for everyone to use and the council had it moved. It now sits in a private car park for people to sit on - the carpark is next to a shopping corridor so pleasant enough

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 16:05

user1497207191

I will reframe

people will avoid living in a place if it doesn't offer them what they want in the way of transport, then perhaps those places would need to look at what they could offer in the way of transport

If petrol rises in price people will seek alternatives, as people become old and some unable to continue to drive, they will also seek alternatives

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 15:57

@user1497207191 I put links in further back he thread that explain this question you asked

Theunamedcat · 11/03/2022 15:56

@Spikeyball

I'm not obsessed with cars. I didn't have my own car until I was 40 and I don't like driving but I have a severely autistic teenager who can't walk far, can't use a bike and can't cope with public transport (as well as others not being tolerant of shrieking, spitting, punching etc) so we need a car.
Same here awful isn't it
Zazdar · 11/03/2022 15:32

Interesting you can't put a secure bike box on the road outside your house and keep bikes in it for ease

You could if it had wheels, otherwise it would be obstructing the highway.

user1497207191 · 11/03/2022 14:37

There's definitely a gap in the market for something between the flexibility of a taxi (costly) against the cheapness of a bus (but inconvenient due to fixed stops/routes and often poor timetable).

Maybe something like shared minibuses to be run by taxi firms, where you pay less than the usual taxi fare, but have the "inconvenience" of sharing the minibus and maybe a slightly longer route due to dropping off/picking up a few other passengers.

Or alternatively something like the "Dolmus" system in Turkey where there are minibuses working set routes, but not to a timetable (they come literally every few minutes) but instead of bus stops, you can jet on and off anywhere you like along the route, just by telling the driver.

Burgoo · 11/03/2022 14:20

I don't think we are obsessed with cars. We simply need a quick, easy way of getting to and from places. If the transport networks were much better more people wouldn't use cars. I want to get from A - B without hassle, constant changes and constant stops. I don't want to be crammed into a small space with smelly, rude, obnoxious people.

To get me on board they would need a few things:

  1. Direct links with very few stops to the places I want to get to.
  2. Extremely frequent services - I am talking
Calennig · 11/03/2022 14:06

@DomesticatedZombie

There's a great new bus service round here that is a bit like a 'louage' or shared taxi - you call it and it picks up several people at their requested stops. We need a lot more of that - responsive, sensible use of tech, affordable, etc.
I saw a you tube showing a similar service in London seemed lik ea good idea.

There's a local tourists site which has a request bus service - had to get there for a girl guide thing and taxi too expenisve and it's not a walkable route. Unfortunately you have to pre-book a working week ahead time for both get there and leave times. It was okay for the event - though did end up hanging round waiting as hard to gauge when it woud be finished but we'd like to take some visiting famiy there - but pre-booking an predomiately outdoor site that early never seems like a good idea. It's a pity it can't be a big more flexiable but I suspect driver work patterns have to be planned ahead of time.

user1497207191 · 11/03/2022 14:01

@DomesticatedZombie

There's a great new bus service round here that is a bit like a 'louage' or shared taxi - you call it and it picks up several people at their requested stops. We need a lot more of that - responsive, sensible use of tech, affordable, etc.
Yes, nail on the head. We really do need to start using modern technology to "hail" transport, and for the transport provider to use modern technology to plan routes according to need at that time.

Completely pointless to have big double decker buses running around housing estates with just a handful of people on them, no one wanting to get on/off on a 10 minute detour through a housing estate.

We need responsive public transport. App based AND bus stop based, i.e. press a button at a bus stop to request the bus, the bus logistic system then diverts the nearest bus to come and pick you up, whether it's the one on the route, a diverted one from a slightly different route, or if nothing is close, then some kind of mini bus or even a taxi coming specially for you. And no, I'm not meaning a fully variable system where passengers could end up being delayed because of a route diversion, I'm talking about a system where routes would be flexible within limits, i.e. if not required to go through housing estate A due to no demand at the time, then miss it out and go through housing estate B instead because there are a few passengers wanting a bus and their usual bus is delayed or not due for another half hour or whatever. I.e. flexible within tolerable limits.

It's madness and nonsensical that the way buses run is basically the same as it was 50 years ago, i.e. fixed bus routes, fixed timetables, etc. Technology has changed so many things (in fact most things), yet we're still stood out in the cold/wet at the bus stop waiting for the number 15 to come at a random, pre-set time.

Calennig · 11/03/2022 13:59

If we couldn't have a taxi occasionally - we have to drive so from us they'd be at least another 12 car journeys a week extra to get to and from work plus the rest at weekends.

Ideally with better public transport both more compehesive and at more times fewer occaional taxi's would be less needed - but of they didn't exist then there would be more people who couldn't manage with a car and more cars.

user1497207191 · 11/03/2022 13:51

[quote ivykaty44]@bathroomparty

my dd1 is in Manchester and presently unable to drive, but gets around with pram on bus and tram, taxi to hospital 10 minutes away. Dd1 has saved a fortune in her own words on not driving

So perhaps if people avoid places without good public transport then local councils will have to look at what they have to offer[/quote]
Difficult to avoid your local hospital if you're ill, though, isn't it??? Not all hospitals are in town/city centres with a bus stop outside!

Likewise our local council sports centre/swimming pool etc - on an out of town site with a very poor bus service. The council closed and demolished the one in the town centre within sight of the bus station rather than spend money on it to modernise it to current standards!

Spikeyball · 11/03/2022 13:49

I'm not obsessed with cars. I didn't have my own car until I was 40 and I don't like driving but I have a severely autistic teenager who can't walk far, can't use a bike and can't cope with public transport (as well as others not being tolerant of shrieking, spitting, punching etc) so we need a car.

user1497207191 · 11/03/2022 13:48

@ivykaty44

How much do people want to pay to subsidise public transport?

If we stopped subsidising private car use and swapped the same money for public transport - that'd suit me

£7.89 billion is what the fuel tax freeze will mean over the next 5 years - spend that on buses

How do you mean "subsidising private car use"? Do you mean the billions we spend on building/maintaining roads and road infrastructure (street lights, traffic lights, signage, etc?)

If so, then don't you realise that we'd still need the roads for lorries, buses, taxis, etc., so the "savings", would be minimal, if anything at all.

bruce43mydog · 11/03/2022 13:38

cars are amazing. and i would be lost without mine. but in reality if we just stop for a moment and realise we have legs. that can walk for miles then we will all do what we can to save the planet from the polution of cars, 1 person alone wont save the world, but together we can do our best. its our children and childrens children we must think of.

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 13:34

@bathroomparty

my dd1 is in Manchester and presently unable to drive, but gets around with pram on bus and tram, taxi to hospital 10 minutes away. Dd1 has saved a fortune in her own words on not driving

So perhaps if people avoid places without good public transport then local councils will have to look at what they have to offer

DomesticatedZombie · 11/03/2022 13:30

There's a great new bus service round here that is a bit like a 'louage' or shared taxi - you call it and it picks up several people at their requested stops. We need a lot more of that - responsive, sensible use of tech, affordable, etc.

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 13:30

How much do people want to pay to subsidise public transport?

If we stopped subsidising private car use and swapped the same money for public transport - that'd suit me

£7.89 billion is what the fuel tax freeze will mean over the next 5 years - spend that on buses

DomesticatedZombie · 11/03/2022 13:28

YANBU, OP. The car is one of the worst things to happen to civilisation.

So bloody useful, so convenient, & they've ruined so much of our lives.

With petrol/fuel prices going the way they are, we may be forced to find alternatives, though.

ivykaty44 · 11/03/2022 13:24

Bike isn't an option as we live in terrace so can only keep bikes in the cellar which is difficult to get bikes in and out of. We do have them for weekend bike rides.

Interesting you can't put a secure bike box on the road outside your house and keep bikes in it for ease - people wouldn't like you claiming that space, but are happy to place one car for free on the road

would you be happy to pay a £25 fee the same as some councils charge for car permits? obviously it would have to be secure

user1497207191 · 11/03/2022 12:13

@Momicrone

So a 'dead' journey is someone driving on their way to pick something up, that means most of the cars on the road are doing dead journeys. If one taxi replaced 20 private cars, that's more space on the road for driving and parking.
OK, you live at point A, work/shop at point B.

At the moment, you travel A>B and then back again later.

If you use a taxi, it's currently at office/rank C, so it has to make a journey C>A to pick you up then A>B to drop you off, then B>C to go back to the base/rank. The two journeys starting and ending at C are extra to what you'd have done if you drove yourself, hence "dead" journey.

Of course, the taxi may be lucky and be parked at the end of your street, in which case the dead journeys are trivial.

The reason there could be more traffic/congestion is all the taxi journeys to come and pick you up and all the journeys to their next fare or base/rank after they've dropped you off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread