Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
kungfupannda · 13/03/2022 08:35

Posted too soon. It wouldn’t just be an overhaul of transport systems that would be needed to significantly reduce car reliance. It would be a drastic overhaul of almost every aspect of society. Increased WFH is a recent change, but you’d also need to change they way we access heath services, education, disability support, benefits systems, maternity services, children’s services, leisure and enrichment, culture, shopping, social activities, all of it. And everything is intertwined - find a way to stop people needing to drive into the city centre for work or to access services, and you make a lot of businesses non-viable. De-centralise health services and you run out of funding for some of those services.

Some areas could certainly benefit from straightforward investment in buses for example. In other areas, your pretty much stuck with something that worked fifty years ago, but which can’t possibly work now.

Underhisi · 13/03/2022 08:31

"There are places where that school bus is free - which I think it shoulld be"

Secondary age children are entitled to free transport (in England) if the nearest school is more than 3 miles away. This would usually be a free bus pass.

Strictly1 · 13/03/2022 08:30

@Momicrone

Damebarsatemydogsphone, aren't you forgetting that sitting on public transport, you are letting someone else take the stress of driving, you can look out the window or read, and no traffic jams if you're on a train, I know which I prefer, I always feel sorry for car drivers stuck in traffic
You're assuming it's on time or turns up at all! The amount of cancelled/late trains recently is ridiculous. The upside is each time I can claim my money back as they've been that late but does mean I'm late every time.
kungfupannda · 13/03/2022 08:27

A lot of areas are never going to have a decent public transport system, because the cost of it would be astronomical. Our area has lots of small villages within a relatively short drive of town. To provide any sort of bus service, you would need multiple small buses doing convoluted routes for most of the day, and making very little in fares. The council couldn’t even keep a school bus service running due to the logistics - it uses taxis instead. A lot of the roads are unsuitable for cycling, not just due to safety issues - which would obviously reduce with less traffic, but not disappear entirely - but due to the abundance of large hills. There’s a village near me where you’d have absolutely no prospect of getting young children to school on bike or foot as the hill between the village and pretty much everything else is about a mile long and so steep that most of the local cycling club get off and push.

None of these villages have shops or schools or any other amenities. There is a park and ride in this area, but for a lot of the villages, it’s as long a drive to get to it as it is to just go into town by car in the first place. We’ve actually got some very good cycle routes, but most people would have to drive - with your bike - to access them.

The LA are constantly consulting on public transport/traffic reduction schemes, but the geography is a massive problem. Even in the centre, the layout of the streets and the shape of the land means that there is very little they can do. Most of the centre is historically important, with lots of tiny streets and dead-ends and corners that buses struggle to navigate. They’ve done a lot of work on pedestrian and cycle routes, but there’s little more they can do, short of turning back the clock to a time when the village shops were viable businesses and people didn’t have access to the level of services we have now.

SelkieQualia · 13/03/2022 08:21

@ivykaty44

I've been involved in lobbying over a stretch of road that gets driven far to fast. Council don't see the need for traffic calming. The locals can see that it's a matter of time before another person is killed.

Do you really believe it’s the councillors that are the problem ?

Can you not understand if you took the drivers away from the road that the road itself is not dangerous but the drivers make it dangerous by their behaviour? It’s drivers that choose to make a space dangerous - no one forces them to drive faster

Yes, but if you want to change human behaviour, you have to do it via leaders, who use tools like traffic calming.
OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 13/03/2022 08:08

@DinosApple

We live rurally, but cut down to one car about 2 years ago. It's annoying about 3% of the time, so not enough to justify the added expense.

Public transport has been cut down a lot, but there's a school (public) bus to our catchment secondary over 4 miles away, which we have to pay for. DH and I are low earners and £4 per day has a real impact on our wages, so we lift share instead.
If either of us want to earn more money (definitely before next winter so we can have the heating on!) we will need another car.

There are places where that school bus is free - which I think it should be.
OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 07:55

WhatIsThisPlease How will you feel if the cost of fuel increases to more than the cost of the inadequate public transport? Why do you tolerate bad public transport?

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 07:53

feels" safe because it's got a footpath

Drivers kill around 40 pedestrians on the footpath every year

It’s drivers behaviour that makes spaces dangerous and the sooner we talk about dangerous drivers instead of dangerous roads, the sooner we tackle the problem and prevent deaths

DinosApple · 13/03/2022 07:37

We live rurally, but cut down to one car about 2 years ago. It's annoying about 3% of the time, so not enough to justify the added expense.

Public transport has been cut down a lot, but there's a school (public) bus to our catchment secondary over 4 miles away, which we have to pay for. DH and I are low earners and £4 per day has a real impact on our wages, so we lift share instead.
If either of us want to earn more money (definitely before next winter so we can have the heating on!) we will need another car.

WhatIsThisPlease · 13/03/2022 07:25

I work 15 miles away from my house. To leave car at home and fully use public transport would cost me over £10 a day and would have me walking to a bus stop, waiting around, waiting some more at the train station then a 10 minute walk to the office. It would take just over an hour, each way.

I can drive it in 25 minutes, door to door. My car is small and economical and I own it outright. I don't pay tax and the insurance is less than £20 a month. So even with the astronomical rise in fuel prices it's still cheaper to drive and considerably quicker.

I don't tolerate my car, I need it, because public transport is long winded, expensive and inconvenient.

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 07:18

I should clarify the road I've lobbied about isn't either of the ones I refuse to walk. The one I've lobbied about "feels" safe because it's got a footpath and is a wide section of A road. But I know vehicles go far too fast. Last year alone 3 vehicles went off road on the same 100 yards stretch. But council still don't see the issue.

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 07:17

I've been involved in lobbying over a stretch of road that gets driven far to fast. Council don't see the need for traffic calming. The locals can see that it's a matter of time before another person is killed.

Do you really believe it’s the councillors that are the problem ?

Can you not understand if you took the drivers away from the road that the road itself is not dangerous but the drivers make it dangerous by their behaviour? It’s drivers that choose to make a space dangerous - no one forces them to drive faster

Underhisi · 13/03/2022 07:15

"It's not a planning issue, it's a parental choice issue"

Some children will not be able to attend a local school or have found that the local school isn't suitable for their child's needs. Ds has never been able to attend a local school, the nearest suitable being nearly 1 hour away.

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 07:09

driven far to fast

It’s the drivers choosing to make the space dangerous by driving faster than appropriate for the space

You may have lobbied for change but ultimately you had to change behaviour by force

The space itself wasn’t dangerous if drivers weren’t present

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 07:01

@ivykaty44 of course some roads can be really dangerous to walk or cycle. Inevitably it's people being hurt or killed on certain sections of roads that leads to the road network being improved.
Sad but true. OK some roads are improved because of congestion others it's dangerous junctions, bends, and the number of accidents that leads to we need to do something about it.
Nobody wants to be the statistic that leads to change.

I've been involved in lobbying over a stretch of road that gets driven far to fast. Council don't see the need for traffic calming. The locals can see that it's a matter of time before another person is killed.

I've also walked a couple of stretches of roads that I vowed never to walk again.
One a small back road full of blind bends so you can't see what's coming towards you.
The second an A road straight but incredibly busy both cars and trucks with a wall at the side of the road so not even a grass verge to step on to.

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 06:19

@Octomingo

Roads are not dangerous, people make an area dangerous by how they abuse a space

Octomingo · 12/03/2022 23:07

It's not the distance, it's how dangerous the road is. I don't like driving it, so I wouldn't like to cycle or walk it. It's national speed limit, bendy and hedgy, with passing places for cars.

KeepYaHeadUp · 12/03/2022 22:50

This is another planning issue I think. The fact that so many kids living in the same area go to different schools, sometime quite far away, makes for all the more transportation issues.

It's not a planning issue, it's a parental choice issue

DdraigGoch · 12/03/2022 21:37

@Octomingo

spikeysmooth similar here. A village 3 miles from a town (2 supermarkets and a high street, but still, bigger than the village). There is one bus an hour and they stop at 6. Theoretically, you could walk it, but most of the walk is a country road which can't allow 2 cars to pass. Now, what could happen is that the farmers be asked to give over some of their fields for pavements, but I can't see that ever happening.
Three miles is as close as my village is to the nearest town. Buses are frequent but I cycle anyway. It's only three miles and I can easily do that with shopping (up to 25kg, which is the limit on my pannier rack, conveniently the weight of a full sack of potatoes). I hardly break a sweat.
DdraigGoch · 12/03/2022 21:33

There was a poster on another thread today (possibly one of the cost of living ones, or maybe an environment one, I can't remember) who said that when she worked in Dublin, two of her senior colleagues always drove into work, even though getting through the traffic took twice as long as just getting on the DART or tram around the corner from their respective houses, and getting that straight to/from work. No rational reason for driving, but they did it anyway. Even when the public transport links are as modern and convenient as they could possibly be, some people still need their steering wheels prising out of their cold, dead hands.

SelkieQualia · 12/03/2022 20:50

@ivykaty44

ive been out this morning and on the way home came across roughly a mile and a half of drivers queuing in amongst them was my neighbour in his car, they queue in the weekday morning but its worse on a Saturday lunch time, I went across the park and out to another road and again that road is congested with drivers going at approx 3mph

I get home and about 20 minutes later my neighbour pulls up and literally moans about the amount of drivers on the road - so why doesn't he see his obsession with driving is no different from others and he is the traffic that is holding up other drivers?

if all the drivers that are able were using other forms of decent transport then you'd have one bus instead of 50 cars and it'd be quicker with 10 buses. whizzy round to where everyone wants to go

If you want to sit in queues of other cars, then fine but it will appear to the 30% that your completely crackers & obsessed with cars, unless of course your literally not able to

Totally. If just a portion of those people were on bikes or in buses, the traffic jam would not be nearly as bad.

There appears to be a significant segment of the population who don't seem to understand that some people would PREFER to cycle or bus (if the pt system were good). That, despite owning a car, I used to cycle to work every day. I've stacked on the weight since moving house and the cycling got more scary!

OP posts:
Octomingo · 12/03/2022 16:40

spikeysmooth similar here. A village 3 miles from a town (2 supermarkets and a high street, but still, bigger than the village). There is one bus an hour and they stop at 6. Theoretically, you could walk it, but most of the walk is a country road which can't allow 2 cars to pass. Now, what could happen is that the farmers be asked to give over some of their fields for pavements, but I can't see that ever happening.

SpikeySmooth · 12/03/2022 16:11

(I don't know how that gender emoji got there)

SpikeySmooth · 12/03/2022 16:10

DB lives rurally. His job is in a village 2 miles aeay. He used to cycle it, now he drives. Whereas I live in London and cycle to my nearest tube station, 2.5 miles away. (Folded bike, take it to work with me) DB ridicules my lack of a car, and I call him a lazy bastard for driving to work. But we are in different environments, and social cultures. 🙎‍♀️

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 12/03/2022 15:35

We're almost at the stage of our lives where we could manage without a car. It wouldn't be easy but we'd manage.

We don't have any bus routes near us but can walk 10 minutes one direction to a bus and 30 minutes another direction to a choice of buses. We're 7 minutes walk away from a train into city. Which is then only 7 minutes away! On days when I timed it right and the platform was right I could go door to door to work in 15 minutes. Don't work there now.

We walk and cycle as often as we can. I wish electric scooters (the stand on ones) would become legal. That would make such a difference.

Our town is trying to become a twenty minute town (everything in reach on foot/cycle within 20 minutes).

I wish we had better buses too.

Less reliance on cars isn't just about having public transport and cycle lanes. It's about having amenities and activities close by too.

We've been lucky to have activities for the DC that are close by (and car share with other parents) but sometimes matches are much further away!

We had two cars until 2007 and have managed with one since then.

I keep trying to convince my DH that we don't need a car but we've a fully paid 11 plate car that isn't costing us too much to maintain and it makes our lives much more convenient so it's not happening yet.

Yes the infrastructure should be better but as I said earlier it also about have the right amenities and activities nearby too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread