Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 20:04

@Momicrone

Badbunny, it's the sheer volume of cars causing congestion
Yes, but making things harder for motorists, i.e. traffic calming, one way systems, etc., just causes more congestion if there aren't realistic alternatives. Put the alternatives in place first so that the drivers who are able & willing to use alternatives can do so.
Momicrone · 13/03/2022 17:31

Badbunny, it's the sheer volume of cars causing congestion

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 17:28

@RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho

One way streets cause more congestion. Most cars will have to travel further to get where they want to go, ergo, more cars on the road at any one time, which leads to congestion.

In my town, you have to drive all the way around the town centre to get from the Sainsburys to the hospital, which are literally next to each other, but the hospital comes first on the one way system. Multiply that with all the other journeys (there are lots of similar journeys with other businesses, homes, etc etc) and it's no surprise the one way system is usually heavily congested, mostly with cars that actually don't want (and shouldn't need) to be on the one way streets.

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 17:22

Make that road one way and park cars diagonally from one side only - that only takes 2 "lanes" so you now have 2 lanes of space to play with.

if a car width is 4foot and 8ft long, how is pointing the cars at a 45 degree angle going to reduce the lanes from 2 parked lanes to one parked lane?

you'll still have two lanes taken and one for the cars on a one way street, making a street one way will also have an effect on all traffic flow, how will that effect other nearby streets?

Momicrone · 13/03/2022 17:15

Badbsdbunny - that comment was to a poster who lives in london with a car, which is why I was talking about london, where there is indeed less need for a car

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/03/2022 17:15

@Momicrone

Butitsnotfunny - London has so many restrictions for car drivers now, be it congestion charge, ULEZ, low traffic neighbour hoods, not sure I'd feel 'free' driving a car under those circumstances. Places like London are trying to discourage driving and private car ownership.
True. But then trying to discourage it doesn't mean it'll happen. I wouldn't be giving up my car. I go many places outside of London that I also use my car for, I'm not waiting for a train every half hour or hour in those places, not a chance.
Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 17:05

@Momicrone

Butitsnotfunny - London has so many restrictions for car drivers now, be it congestion charge, ULEZ, low traffic neighbour hoods, not sure I'd feel 'free' driving a car under those circumstances. Places like London are trying to discourage driving and private car ownership.
Yes, indeed, but "places like london" have a far superior public transport infrastructure in place so there's less (if any) need for a car.

It's chicken and egg situation. You really can't start forcing people out of their cars when there isn't an alternative public transport system in place.

Momicrone · 13/03/2022 13:37

Butitsnotfunny - London has so many restrictions for car drivers now, be it congestion charge, ULEZ, low traffic neighbour hoods, not sure I'd feel 'free' driving a car under those circumstances. Places like London are trying to discourage driving and private car ownership.

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 13/03/2022 13:23

[quote ivykaty44]@RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho

how is any of your suggestions going to aid sharing the road with other road users? Where in your suggestions do you fit a cycle path? Pavement that a motorised walking aid can get along and cross the road?[/quote]
Well in the picture you shared there are 4 "lanes" one for driving each direction and one on each side of the road full of cars.

Make that road one way and park cars diagonally from one side only - that only takes 2 "lanes" so you now have 2 lanes of space to play with.

Make the pavement wider and put the cycle lanes next to the pavement with some sort of kerb that meets the needs of sight impaired people

So it'd be:

Wider pavement
Cycle lanes separate from road and from pedestrians
Diagonal car parking (with built in charge hubs)
Road for driving - one way only.

Obviously there'd be another road nearby which did the same but goes one way in the other direction to allow cars to travel a route.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/03/2022 13:22

I love my car and the freedom it brings. I also live in London. Public transport in areas should be improved, if there isn't much. However it doesn't mean people would give up their cars, a lot of people enjoy having a car and/or it's convenient for them. I wouldn't bike ride as I simply don't like it and other forms of transport would add extra time onto my journeys that I'm not willing to add.

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 13/03/2022 13:09

@Spikeyball

I'm not obsessed with cars. I didn't have my own car until I was 40 and I don't like driving but I have a severely autistic teenager who can't walk far, can't use a bike and can't cope with public transport (as well as others not being tolerant of shrieking, spitting, punching etc) so we need a car.
If those who could use alternative means of transport did then there would be fewer cars on the road meaning those, like you, with no option had a quicker drive with more likelihood of parking more easily at your destination.
RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 13/03/2022 11:56

@ivykaty44

Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

that was the ops question

and so many replies are - public transport and cycling infastructor are really bad - so ill drive

but thats not answering the question

why do you accept it?

I think part of the answer is what I referred to in one of my earlier posts.

The twenty minute town concept. That could be applied anywhere and would make a massive difference to all our lifestyles.

I don't tolerate it BTW. I'm actively involved in trying to make changes, albeit small changes and encourage others to do the same.

Including doing all sorts of training to become a Bikeability instructor. I've taken 100 school children through levels 1 and 2 and supported parents (mostly Mums) to be more confident when cycling.

My small town is planning more cycling routes to aid with the 20 minute town aim.

I live maybe a 30 minute walk from our "high street". In busy times I can't get from my home to the post office (for example) quicker than a car.

Mind you I can do so much of what I need to online now (even the post office!) that a trip to the high street is rare.

I've even paid 60p for some mail to be picked up. So much cheaper than me going to the post office in terms of my time never mind the other costs.

There are solutions WE just have to ask for them, campaign for them and support them. Not simply ignore them and write them off.

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 11:19

who use tools like traffic calming.

that need to be used as its the drivers that are dangerous - not the road. Take away the pedestrians and cyclists and the road is still dangerous - take away the drivers and the road becomes safe

thats why so many cyclists want segregation for safety

plan towns and habitat around pedestrians, trains, buses and cycling and not private cars and the towns would become safer and traffic calming petitions wouldn't be needed.

its amazing anyone ever goes to centre parks where they have to leave their cars at the gates as the whole living area has been dedicated to people and when they want to go out they have to travel to their car to leave the area

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 11:13

A lot of areas are never going to have a decent public transport system, because the cost of it would be astronomical.

yet nearly £8 billion can be used for fuel freeze for private car use in 5 years

ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 11:11

@RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho

how is any of your suggestions going to aid sharing the road with other road users? Where in your suggestions do you fit a cycle path? Pavement that a motorised walking aid can get along and cross the road?

DdraigGoch · 13/03/2022 10:55

@Octomingo

It's not the distance, it's how dangerous the road is. I don't like driving it, so I wouldn't like to cycle or walk it. It's national speed limit, bendy and hedgy, with passing places for cars.
It might be NSL but that just means that you drive appropriately to the conditions. I've never seen anyone doing 60mph on a single-track lane with passing places. Cycling along such a road seriously would not bother me.
RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 13/03/2022 10:42

@ivykaty44

You cannot widen a road through a fucking house and yes in some areas the house it literally next to the road no footpath HOUSE

Many roads are 3/4 lanes, with two lanes used for free storage of cars. How about sharing jyst one of those lanes for a cycle path - a third of quarter, not half

There are options here though. Make the street one way. Cars park diagonally from kerb and only on one side of the road. Et voila - more space for pedestrians, cyclists and drivers.

Combine this with a scheme in the area to incentivise less car ownership/more car sharing/more E-bikes/cargo bikes and your laughing.

I'm terraced areas I think going one way and adjusting the parking will be the only way there will be space for cars to go electric with charging points built under the pavement so no trip hazards.

This is the sort of imaginative solution we need.

Would require a wider planning exercise but should be possible with a bit of will from the people and the local authorities.

rwalker · 13/03/2022 10:19

I live in a city in the north there isn't the volume of journey's to make most routes viable for public transport .
it's not densely populated not everyone wants to can cycle .

Momicrone · 13/03/2022 10:10

Pinksparkly, or more cyclists

Momicrone · 13/03/2022 10:09

Strictly1, no mode of transport for longer journeys is perfect, both motor transport and trains have their issues in terms of delays, but trains aren't 'always' late, as cars can't always get you to your destination on time

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 09:49

@Badbadbunny that's where some sort of dial a bus would work he can't be the only person going from the Uni to the football stadium.

And it would run on demand rather than a paper timetable.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/03/2022 09:34

Can you not understand if you took the drivers away from the road that the road itself is not dangerous but the drivers make it dangerous by their behaviour? It’s drivers that choose to make a space dangerous - no one forces them to drive faster

Drivers can also make it safer. My route to either walk or cycle is along the river, no lighting and trees on the other side of the road. If I was to cycle I would welcome a few cars so I'm not on my own.

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 09:15

Even where there is a "bus service" of sorts, buses don't even connect well between routes.

My son does a 7 mile journey between his University campus and his team's football stadium. Obviously a Uni is a main "hub" for buses, and the image looks good as there's literally always a bus at the main square, often 2 or 3, with departures literally every 5 minutes or so. But there are no direct buses to the football stadium and few direct buses to the city centre (first change point) so even the first stage takes ages as the buses go all round the houses to get to the city centre bus station. OK, a change isn't the end of the World. But it's not just one change, it's 3 changes at various places, so a total of 4 buses to go just 7 miles between two pretty large/important places, both having lots of people wanting a bus from each point (Although granted, not too many wanting that exact journey but lots wanting to go elsewhere from each end). But even from the city centre main bus station near the Uni, it's still not a direct bus route and still needs at least 2 changes en route.

I've just checked on Google and total journey time by bus is whopping 94 minutes (remember this is only 7 miles) and that isn't even door to door as there's still about half a mile of walking. Direct door to door bus would be over 2 hours.

It's only 2 hours 15 minutes to walk the whole route!

In fact, yesterday's game, he did walk most of the route as the buses were chaotic due to some road works, services randomly cancelled, etc. He got off half way between Uni and city centre to walk to try and get the bus from city centre towards the Stadium, but he missed it by a couple of minutes and it was only an hourly service, so he took a different bus in a slightly different route, and got off half way on that and then walked a mile or so to get to another route to get a bus for a mile or so, then got off and walked the rest of the way.

When he rang last night, he says he's taking his car to Uni after Easter - he didn't take it as he thought the buses would be OK with it being a Uni and the image of buses everywhere, but yesterday was the last straw.

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 09:00

@Dinoteeth

A lot of areas are never going to have a decent public transport system, because the cost of it would be astronomical.

That's where some sort of modern shared taxi/bus system needs to come into play. Dial-a-bus. Buses coming to order almost so you need to book it.

Trouble is that with a "dial a bus" mini bus network (or taxis), the roads would be full of minibuses and taxis instead of cars. It doesn't actually save many journeys because most people aren't doing the same journey at the same time.

If I've got a hospital appointment at 9 am and my neighbour has a hospital appointment at 11 am, she's not going to want to come in my "shared taxi" at 8.30 is she? So she'll want her own "shared taxi", but that means the taxi firm trying to find someone else with a 11 am hospital appointment somewhere along a roughly similar route. Just not going to happen is it? That means they'd have separate taxi journeys, so just what's the different between that and just using our cars in the first place (besides it costing more!)?

Mini buses and shared taxis are fine in theory where you have small groups of people starting/ended their journeys in similar places (or en route), but it's a logistical nightmare to organise that and will be inconvenient because everyone's timings can't possibly fall into place and people will end up waiting around.

A hybrid system is needed where cheap buses/trains are available for the high volume/high density journeys to give car drivers a genuine alternative for the bog standard journeys, such as school runs, workers commuting to retail parks/industrial estates/office blocks etc, just to get as much traffic off the roads as possible. That reduces congestion for everyone else who has to use a car (i.e. rural areas, hospital appointments, heavy shopping, etc.).

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 08:38

A lot of areas are never going to have a decent public transport system, because the cost of it would be astronomical.

That's where some sort of modern shared taxi/bus system needs to come into play. Dial-a-bus. Buses coming to order almost so you need to book it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread