Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 14/03/2022 12:49

@CuteOrangeElephant

Yeah that was me. It is a choice to allow those out of town retail parks.

If councils genuinely want to fix this what they must do is focus all their planning on making their area more livable for people without a car. So that means not allowing any new out of town retail parks. No housing estates with poor facilities and 0 cycle routes. At the minimum.

This will come in very handy when petrol becomes prohibitively expensive.

Given the perilous retail situation, I don't think there'll be many more out of town retail parks being built any time soon. The horse has bolted on that one.

Re housing estates, the councils are between a rock and a hard place. There's a desperate shortage of houses, so the council will be strongly criticised if they don't give PP for new estates, as that's what the people want. You can't make a developer build and staff a school or GP surgery. As in a case local to us, the developer put aside land on the estate for a primary school, GP surgery and a couple of shops, but no one was interested in running them, so that earmarked land remains unused and not built upon.

CuteOrangeElephant · 14/03/2022 12:32

Yeah that was me. It is a choice to allow those out of town retail parks.

If councils genuinely want to fix this what they must do is focus all their planning on making their area more livable for people without a car. So that means not allowing any new out of town retail parks. No housing estates with poor facilities and 0 cycle routes. At the minimum.

This will come in very handy when petrol becomes prohibitively expensive.

Dinoteeth · 14/03/2022 11:50

@Satsumaeater

Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular

How are our demographics not the same as eg Denmark or the Netherlands? They are very similar. All we need is some decent investment.

Well actually the demographics are different from Netherlands you've got people up thread saying they don't allow out of town developments which means everything is in the town centers. That makes organising public transport so easy.

My own town has 3 separate retail parks with supermarkets in each of them. You can hardly buy an egg in the town center but there you go.

Momicrone · 14/03/2022 11:38

Annesbrokenstate, I meant to write 'without' balancing bags on them, baskets, crates, cargo bikes, all excellent for shopping

Momicrone · 14/03/2022 11:36

Howlisthisright, get a family rail card, I travel by train with my kids all the time, has never cost that much!

Momicrone · 14/03/2022 11:35

User149, I lock my bike to lamp posts most of the time, has yet to be stolen, I wouldn't let lack of secure bike storage put me off cycling

Momicrone · 14/03/2022 11:33

Annesbrokenstate, bikes are an excellent way to transport goods, with 'balancing bags' on them

Momicrone · 14/03/2022 11:31

Love fall, you don't need to be 'young', to cycle

CuteOrangeElephant · 14/03/2022 11:31

Demographically the UK and the Netherlands are quite similar.

Geographically they are different. But nowadays with electric bikes a lot of obstacles like hills can be overcome. It's just political will

Pyewhacket · 14/03/2022 11:23

@Satsumaeater

Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular

How are our demographics not the same as eg Denmark or the Netherlands? They are very similar. All we need is some decent investment.

Demographically. The population of Holland is 17m and Denmark is a tad over 5m. Also the UK is 6 times bigger than either Holland or Denmark.
user1497207191 · 14/03/2022 11:17

@Satsumaeater

Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular

How are our demographics not the same as eg Denmark or the Netherlands? They are very similar. All we need is some decent investment.

Our geography is very different.
Pyewhacket · 14/03/2022 11:13

Here's another view on car ownership.

Nearly a million ppl are directly employed in the motor trade in the UK and the treasury receives over £40billion in tax revenues, annually.

user1497207191 · 14/03/2022 11:11

@HowIsThisRight

Nope. Can't think why I prefer cars.

Similar here with what used to be my daily commute. Only 20 miles away but in a different town across the county border. By car it's 25 minutes door to door. By bus it's 1.5 hours and by train it's 2 hours, both due to multiple connections as there's no direct buses nor trains and different bus/train providers. It's complete lunacy not to take the car when the public transport takes so long and is so inconvenient, not to mention, a lot more expensive.

Satsumaeater · 14/03/2022 11:10

Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular

How are our demographics not the same as eg Denmark or the Netherlands? They are very similar. All we need is some decent investment.

HowIsThisRight · 14/03/2022 11:01

Heading to a specific destination with the kids by train: £260

Driving our car (old and anything but fuel efficient): £30. Saving a whopping £230!)

Going by train: have to walk to station with bags, can only go on the train's schedule, need to faff buying tickets and having everything ready and we can't be late. May also be seated next to a total stranger who stinks, is listening to loud music, or is having a loud phone conversation etc. Have to use further transport methods or walk with bags from station to destination.

Going by car: only have to walk outside of front door, can leave whenever it suits us, no extra prep other than checking the car's oil, water and fuel and can be late leaving. No smelly or loud strangers sat next to us. Can drive straight to destination door/parking.

Nope. Can't think why I prefer cars. Hmm

user1497207191 · 14/03/2022 10:27

Secure cycle storage at destinations is also a big issue. There aren't many secure places, i.e. lockers. Yes, lots of half hearted barrier type structures around where you can lock your bike to, but they're not secure and bikes can very easily be stolen or damaged.

SelkieQualia · 14/03/2022 09:54

@AnnesBrokenSlate

This is why there are no serious conversations about it because people suggesting it don't engage with the issues. Lots of rural roads aren't suitable for bikes. There isn't the space for cycle lanes. Not everyone can cycle because of health conditions or time commitments. And only someone with a very small family and no experience of taking teens to school and clubs could seriously recommend everyone cycling trying to balance all their bags on their bikes. Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular. Any answers for here need to be focused on public transport. And include an acceptance that for a high proportion of the population private cars are the only solution to their transport needs.
Cycling may not be the answer WHERE YOU are. And yes, it's likely that for people in rural regions cars are always going to be way more important.

I lived places before where cycling was the answer. It was lovely. And the demographics not different to where I am now.

As for the teenagers.. imagine if they could get themselves to some of those clubs on a bike!

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 14/03/2022 07:35

If they were serious about trying to avoid car use they'd start with town planning and avoid out of town shopping centers and office parks.

That also means not going wild with city centre business rates. Which encourages companies to move out to the cheap low rates and rent business parks.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 14/03/2022 01:31

This is why there are no serious conversations about it because people suggesting it don't engage with the issues. Lots of rural roads aren't suitable for bikes. There isn't the space for cycle lanes. Not everyone can cycle because of health conditions or time commitments. And only someone with a very small family and no experience of taking teens to school and clubs could seriously recommend everyone cycling trying to balance all their bags on their bikes.
Cycling obviously isn't the answer. Our demographics are not the same as the countries where cycling is more popular. Any answers for here need to be focused on public transport. And include an acceptance that for a high proportion of the population private cars are the only solution to their transport needs.

SelkieQualia · 14/03/2022 01:18

Hmm, I agree that you need really good alternatives if you are going to discourage cars.

However, I think people are really overly negative about bikes. I accept that there are going to be people and situations for whom they are just practical or possible. However, mumsnet seems to think that if you are not a MAML, a bike is not for you. That's not true. Hills and bikes are fine, especially if you have an e bike! Yes, you can carry kids and shopping on an e bike! Yes, they are expensive, but they have gotten much cheaper over the past few years, and if owning one means that you don't have to buy and run a second (or third) car, they can save you a ridiculous amount of money.

OP posts:
LoveFall · 13/03/2022 23:37

@Momicrone

Making things more difficult for drivers encourages people out of their cars
That has been a strategy where I live for years. But public transit is inadequate to say the least, and biking is only fine for healthy, fit young people. Our city is very up and down hilly. We are constantly told about Amsterdam, but it is flat.

The result of all the "traffic calming"?

Increasing congestion and endless lines of idling cars. Just the perfect way to reduce emissions.

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 20:30

@ivykaty44

Do you really think people enjoy being sat stuck in traffic jams?

my old neighbour used to drive the just over 1 mile journey to work every day, its a 20 minute walk and id get there before her - so I guess yes she wanted to sit in traffic? it was the same going home, congestion and traffic crawling along at 3mph

Anecdote isn't evidence.
ivykaty44 · 13/03/2022 20:18

Do you really think people enjoy being sat stuck in traffic jams?

my old neighbour used to drive the just over 1 mile journey to work every day, its a 20 minute walk and id get there before her - so I guess yes she wanted to sit in traffic? it was the same going home, congestion and traffic crawling along at 3mph

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 20:09

@Momicrone

Making things more difficult for drivers encourages people out of their cars
Only if there are viable alternatives. Do you really think people enjoy being sat stuck in traffic jams?
Momicrone · 13/03/2022 20:07

Making things more difficult for drivers encourages people out of their cars

Swipe left for the next trending thread