Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
jytdtysrht · 15/03/2022 19:30

Probably because it's a pipe dream to access everything you need locally. I take my autistic dc 10 miles to school. He wouldn't cope with either public transport or school transport and both would take five times as long as a car trip (no exaggeration).

I make lots of unnecessary journeys due to other people's incompetence. Meds that are hospital only ones where the delivery system doesn't work - I have to go get them.

ivykaty44 · 15/03/2022 18:51

Badbadbunny a box fitted in each and every car to charge for road use, it wouldn't be difficult to fit. Cars will be fitted soon enough with speed limiters

ivykaty44 · 15/03/2022 18:49

I don't think it's heavily subsidised is it?

@Peasock Ive had the decency to back up my statement with links to show the figures and working - at least lets have you prove me wrong withe the same - happy to be shown Im incorrect with some facts and figures rather than your thoughts

and go and research who owns hospital carparks, as it not the government

Badbadbunny · 15/03/2022 18:45

@ivykaty44

That’s going to be a big hole to fill once we all go electric.

The government will just charge drivers to use roads, it will eventually happen as there is such a short fall

They'll start rising the vehicle excise duty (road tax) which is currently zero for electric cars. That's a quick and easy win for them.

Road pricing is more difficult, but a cynic could say that all the congestion charge cameras and Smart motorways would be a good start for road use pricing in the busier/congested places. Currently, congestion charges are lower/zero for low emission cars, but, like road tax, that's very easy to change.

More difficult to do road use pricing in less congested/rural areas as there are fewer cameras, but I'm sure that would follow over a few years, as the camera infrastructure is expanded, say, to the entire motorway network first, then onto dual carriageways, etc over time.

ivykaty44 · 15/03/2022 18:40

That’s going to be a big hole to fill once we all go electric.

The government will just charge drivers to use roads, it will eventually happen as there is such a short fall

Shade17 · 15/03/2022 15:31

If the fuel duty freeze over the next 5 years costs over £7 billion in tax for the country, there would have been the money to give free bus transport for every single person in the country

The rising fuel costs will be going some way to counter that as a result of VAT.

At current prices the government is taking £34bn/year in fuel taxes alone. That’s going to be a big hole to fill once we all go electric.

Momicrone · 15/03/2022 14:47

Like 20min neighbourhoods, although that's mainly an urban solution
www.rtpi.org.uk/research/2021/march/20-minute-neighbourhoods/#:~:text=20%20minute%20neighbourhoods%20are%20a,within%20a%2020%20minute%20walk.

user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 14:41

In reality, rather than arguing about mode of transport, i.e. the old "car versus bus", what we should be looking at is reducing transport of whatever form. That way we wouldn't be just transferring the costs/pollution of transport from car to bus/train or whatever.

Encouraging/facilitating people to need to travel less is the real answer to the problems. I.e. localism. Get people back to shopping/working more locally and incentive that instead of subsidising public transport.

Go back a few decades and people really didn't travel as much. They worked/shopped much closer to where they lived, and there was usually recreation/entertainment more locally too. Over the past 30 years or so, nearly everything has been centralised, local shops have been closed down firstly by town centre shopping centres, then huge out of town retail parks etc. National firms (banks, accountants, insurance firms etc) have closed down town centre/regional offices and centralised into London and a handful of other big cities. There's been a "drain away" from villages, small towns, etc leaving people with no choice but to have to travel for work, shopping, leisure, etc.

A policy of localism would help reverse that. There were a few green shoots of optimism due to covid, where people started getting things delivered instead of going shopping (but more vans on the road), people working from home, a suggestion that small/village shops/cafes could become profitable again if people worked from home instead of commuting for an hour or two to their city jobs. All that seems to have stalled now and people are reverting back to how it was before, which is a great shame.

Momicrone · 15/03/2022 14:31

User149, although less people driving cars would hopefully be less of a burden on the nhs. We can't keep an archaic system going because of tax revenue, we'd all still be smoking if that was the case.

Momicrone · 15/03/2022 14:28

User149, that was precisely the time I came to compare it, when we needed to replace our old car...or not

user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 14:26

Roads and infrastructure would still be needed even if there were no private cars. As there'd still be lorries, vans, buses, taxis, etc, in fact, there'd be more as people would have more home deliveries if they couldn't drive for shopping, there'd need to be a huge increase in the number of buses and taxis to ferry people around, etc.

So, Govt would lose billions in revenue (fuel tax, road tax, insurance premium tax, vat on fuel, vat on repairs, vat on cars sold, fuel duty tax, company car benefit in kind tax/nic, etc).

Not only would the govt lose billions in tax revenue from private cars, they'd have billions to spend in subsidising public transport. Govt are already getting worried about the loss of tax revenue due to the growth in electric cars and thinking about "per mile" tax to recoup the lost revenue!

Momicrone · 15/03/2022 14:25

I would

Peasock · 15/03/2022 14:16

@ivykaty44

Peasock. all that you've said goes back to my early posts that with private car ownership subsidised (links to this in early posts) and public transport not getting that same level of subsidy - its going to be cheaper to drive yourself. If the fuel duty freeze over the next 5 years costs over £7 billion in tax for the country, there would have been the money to give free bus transport for every single person in the country
I don't think it's heavily subsidised is it? There are all sorts of taxes and roads and infrastructure are maintained to the absolutely minimum they can be. You have to pay to park in most government owned places like hospitals etc. The bus network isn't sufficient as is for most areas, unless there was a huge investment in improving and extending it (bearing in mind the impact of that), I wouldn't be a fan of free bus passes as many people would still not use them.
user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 13:54

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

My brothers car is 15 years old and only done about 50,000miles! We should be encouraging people to use things for as long as possible instead of upgrading all the time.
Exactly, my 13 year old with 30k on the clock got written off by a neighbour a few months ago. I couldn't bring myself to scrap it as it was more or less immaculate, so I took the insurance money and paid for it to be repaired myself to keep it on the road. It gives me a warm glow inside to see it outside on our drive, once again, looking pristine (not a mark nor scratch on it), and despairing that the insurance company wanted to scrap it when it had so much life left in it.

Leave the incentives/laws for the cars that have been hammered and/or are the highest polluters!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 15/03/2022 13:45

My brothers car is 15 years old and only done about 50,000miles! We should be encouraging people to use things for as long as possible instead of upgrading all the time.

Sirzy · 15/03/2022 13:42

What a waste of resources scrapping cars after 10 years would be. My car now is 7 years old and has a lot more than 3 years life left in it - and I have no intention of changing it any time soon!

Zazdar · 15/03/2022 13:39

Maybe if there was a rule where a car could be on the road for no more than ten years, after which the owner has to scrap it.

Have you considered the negative effect of emissions created and valuable raw materials used when it’s shiny new replacement is manufactured?

user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 13:30

@ivykaty44

Peasock. all that you've said goes back to my early posts that with private car ownership subsidised (links to this in early posts) and public transport not getting that same level of subsidy - its going to be cheaper to drive yourself. If the fuel duty freeze over the next 5 years costs over £7 billion in tax for the country, there would have been the money to give free bus transport for every single person in the country
7 billion divided by 60 million people gives only £117 per person. That's nowhere near the cost of a bus pass. And what about all the people who don't live/work/shop on a bus route with frequent buses? A bus pass is useless if you can't get a bus from/to where you want to go at a time you want to travel.
ivykaty44 · 15/03/2022 13:26

Peasock. all that you've said goes back to my early posts that with private car ownership subsidised (links to this in early posts) and public transport not getting that same level of subsidy - its going to be cheaper to drive yourself. If the fuel duty freeze over the next 5 years costs over £7 billion in tax for the country, there would have been the money to give free bus transport for every single person in the country

ivykaty44 · 15/03/2022 13:20

@LoveFall. have you ever cycled in the dutch winds? id take a hill anyway over the winds, reason being you know after 15 minutes its going to be behind you

tbh the winds this last week in the uk have been excellent for training but they are nothing in comparison to the winds in the Nederlands

user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 12:33

@Nicholethejewellery

Maybe if there was a rule where a car could be on the road for no more than ten years, after which the owner has to scrap it.

I agree with everything you say except that. You can't have a blanket rule like that. It needs to be something more specific, such as cars over x years old with CO2 emissions of y or above, or cars with mileage over 150k, or similar. There are lots of relatively low emission cars that are only half way through their life at the 10 year stage. We have a 13 year old small (second) car, which has only done 30,000 miles and I confidently expect to keep it another 7 years or so. It's CO2 emissions are similar/less compared to a basic new car today. It'd be a massive waste of resources to scrap perfectly good cars just because they're a particular age. Not to mention I'd be particularly peeved to have to buy another car at great expense, to replace a perfectly good, reliable car already in my drive.

Nicholethejewellery · 15/03/2022 12:15

I despair at the anti-car attitude many people have. Many seem to be against cars in themselves rather than against pollution and accidents.

Cars can be made cleaner, the process has been going on for decades now. A modern vehicle creates a tiny fraction of the pollution of one from the late 1980's. There's still a long way to go but new technologies will make cars cleaner to the point where the only emission is water.

Cars can be made safe, again a process that's been ongoing for decades. Since the Euro NCAP tests were created tens of thousands of lives have been saved. (One of the main benefits of these tests is that cars are bought from dealers rather than the manufacturer being able to supply a vehicle of their own choosing - which wasn't a great thing.)

In terms of safety we will fairly soon reach the point where self-driving AI cars become demonstrably safer than human-driven cars. This will prevent most incidents even occurring.

Rather than expect (other) people to give up their cars, we should pressure the government to speed up safety and environmental measures, and force scientists to work harder to solve the remaining problems.

Clearly there will also need to be a large scrappage scheme to remove non-compliant vehicles from the road. Maybe if there was a rule where a car could be on the road for no more than ten years, after which the owner has to scrap it. Collectors would still be allowed to keep older cars at home and take them to events on a trailer.

user1497207191 · 15/03/2022 11:30

@Momicrone

It's not just fuel though
It is when it's making a decision about whether to use PT or the car for a specific journey as all other costs are fixed and have already happened.

The time to compare is when it comes to replace the car, i.e. whether or not to replace - that's the time when you can validly compare ALL costs of owning/running a car against making ALL journeys by PT.

dannydyerismydad · 15/03/2022 10:25

Whilst it's absolutely true that many people have no choice but to use the car because of lack of alternatives, it's in everyone's interest for those who have no choice to make a fuss.

People with some disabilities don't have the option to use a car and can be housebound as a result. This could happen to anyone without warning. We all need an alternative.

A family I know was rehoused last week. They don't have a car. Their child is at nursery 3 miles from their new home. Although the house and nursery are on bus routes it would take 2-3 bus rides in each direction to do the journey because of the nature of the routes. The child will no longer be able to come to nursery and as she is due to start school in September no other nurseries or preschools have space for her in her new area. The child is missing out on preparation for school transition because of poor infrastructure. We should all care more.

Peasock · 15/03/2022 10:17

It's the most expensive track per mile in Europe apparently which is annoying when you're only going one stop hah. Used to be around £7 return but now £11 which is a wild increase.

Swipe left for the next trending thread