Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 06:47

You cannot widen a road through a fucking house and yes in some areas the house it literally next to the road no footpath HOUSE

Many roads are 3/4 lanes, with two lanes used for free storage of cars. How about sharing jyst one of those lanes for a cycle path - a third of quarter, not half

To despair at our obession with cars
Underhisi · 10/03/2022 06:43

You lost me with the special little snowflake comment.

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 06:42

If you are that uncoordinated, then you should not be driving. You would be significantly more dangerous behind the wheel of a car.

Anyway, it's not about MAKING people ride. It's about giving people the OPTION. If you don't want to, don't.

And you don't need bike paths on ALL roads. We just need ONE safe bike corridor between important waypoints.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 10/03/2022 06:32

I CANT RIDE IM UNCOORDINATED I WOULD BE DANGEROUS

Have I made it clear to you yet? Your just as bad as boris

You cannot widen a road through a fucking house and yes in some areas the house it literally next to the road no footpath HOUSE

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 05:56

@Theunamedcat

Unimaginative? Why not just admit cycling isn't for everyone? I'm dyspraxic as is one of my children literally cannot ride a bike

Also we have things like footpaths and housing trees next to the road should we really move them to build a cycle path? I live in an area full of hills valleys twists and turns cycling isn't safe maybe we could have a functioning reliable and economical bus service however we don't

The unimaginative parts
  • Not considering other bike types - there are heaps - you could probably ride a three wheeler.
  • Roads are being widened/changed all the time. We can build a motorway, why can't we build a few little bike paths?
  • "It's not safe" - yes, that's the problem! Let's make it safe!
-"Hills". You can ride a bike in the hills! Use low gear or an e bike.
OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 10/03/2022 05:43

Unimaginative? Why not just admit cycling isn't for everyone? I'm dyspraxic as is one of my children literally cannot ride a bike

Also we have things like footpaths and housing trees next to the road should we really move them to build a cycle path? I live in an area full of hills valleys twists and turns cycling isn't safe maybe we could have a functioning reliable and economical bus service however we don't

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 05:06

@StrawberrySquash

OP: public transport is terrible. We should make it better. Many posters: YABU. Public transport is terrible.

Seriously, people. There are obviously many places where public transport is never going to be the most practical option. But there are many places where it could be made so much better and reduce the number of car journeys.

Ha, too right.

Also: Me: "There are lots of places that I'd like to walk or cycle and can't because the infrastructure is awful and it's dangerous".

Everyone: YABU. The infrastructure is awful so cycling is dangerous. Also, I'm a paraplegic plumber who lives on the Isle of Skye and need my car to take my grandmother paragliding".

OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 01:51

@TweenTrauma

Where I live there is no option but to drive. There are some small convenience type shops in my small town but they are very expensive and are limited in what they sell. To get a bus to the nearest supermarket would mean a 20 min walk to and from the bus stop to the supermarket, not possible with a full weekly shop on the way back.

My place of work and where my horses are kept are not at all accessible by public transport. So I wouldn’t be able to get to them at all.

You’d have to have a death wish to cycle around here, it’s all twisty roads, only just wide enough for two cars, lots of hills and corners everywhere.

It’s either own a car or be stuck in a very small town with very limited facilities.

That's my point, though. Wouldn't it be nice if those roads were made so that there was a safe cycle lane, so people who wanted to use them could? People are so unimaginative about it.
OP posts:
TweenTrauma · 10/03/2022 01:28

Where I live there is no option but to drive. There are some small convenience type shops in my small town but they are very expensive and are limited in what they sell. To get a bus to the nearest supermarket would mean a 20 min walk to and from the bus stop to the supermarket, not possible with a full weekly shop on the way back.

My place of work and where my horses are kept are not at all accessible by public transport. So I wouldn’t be able to get to them at all.

You’d have to have a death wish to cycle around here, it’s all twisty roads, only just wide enough for two cars, lots of hills and corners everywhere.

It’s either own a car or be stuck in a very small town with very limited facilities.

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 01:17

Things that we'd have to look carefully at for that would be stuff like zoning and housing in multiple income brackets available, lots of mixed areas of shops and housing.

Also, contrary to popular belief, big cities like London are not more efficient at that stuff. At a certain point they become so big that efficiency starts to decrease. So a change to the economy would also be in order. For rural areas people need to have viable villages that can provide services for the surrounding countryside.

The UK is better at some of this than places like North America but it could still improve a lot.

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 00:56

@MangyInseam

I don't believe either public transport or bike infrastructure are really what is needed. They are fine as far as they go, but can't address the real issue which is around things like community planning, the decline of villages, towns and even smaller cities, and so on.

The most basic issue is that most people do not live within walking distance of where they work, walking distance of shopping, walking distance of entertainment, walking distance of at least some family and friends.

These things are due to the movable workforce and the way communities have developed around the car and public transport, to the point where many people cannot even afford to live within a short distance of work. This is only possible because workers can be brought into these areas. Zoning regulations and building up new developments without adequate infrastructure are also elements.

Bikes are relatively cheap to use but not everyone can. Public transport is a logistical and material expense. Walking is pretty free and cities, towns, and villages developed with walking as the organizing feature for thousands of years. And they still could be to a much much greater extent than they are now.

Thankyou! This is what I mean. They're are always jobs/activities that need to be done in person, and there are always going to be people who need to travel in a car for this. However, we could still do a lot better when designing our community spaces. We could make them much nicer places to walk or bike around in, for those people who want to, rather than blooding things so that you MUST use a car to get around.
OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 00:42

Ugh, I knew everyone would get on and bleat about how they are a special little snowflake that needs a car. For the last time, it's not about taking away all cars. It's about having a few other options IN ADDITION to cars.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 09/03/2022 23:17

@JudgeJ

Well said. MN is the place to be if you want to hear middle class privileged dilemmas and shrieks of ‘won’t someone think of the children?’. Everyone on here hates every comfort in life that they are afforded for simply being born in the Western Hemisphere. Wonder how some people get through the day.

Momicrone · 09/03/2022 22:23

Wanttomarryamillionaire- I use public transport and I'm not anti social, do you think you might be the anti social one?

Whisktea · 09/03/2022 21:46

@Octomingo

I didn't learn to drive until my 20s. Everything took so much longer on public transport. I had to get lifts to work, Wenden I got my first job, as there were no buses there.

I think many people who decry car use are lucky enough to wfh or live somewhere with good links. I also think a lot of mn has no idea about the places where pt assumes you all live and work fairly local, so doesn't link up across counties.

My journey to work is about 20 miles. Takes me about 40 minutes in the car. I do not live rurally. No one I know works near me, so car sharing is out. Not allowed to wfh.

By pt, I would have to get a bus to the train station (if any buses were running at 530), then a train. Then another train, to be in work by 8. Then in reverse. Not sure how I'd get dc to the cm by 7am in any of that though. Or how I'd do pick ups.

Where I live, I can get a bus to one town (10 miles away) every 30 minutes. No buses to another town(11 miles away). One bus an hour to a closer town(6 miles away). To visit parents (12 miles) it's a 20 minute walk to a bus stop, then 40 minute bus ride. I can drive it in 20 minutes.

Like someone upthread said, it's not just getting places but how much time you actually have. Even with 2 adults living here and driving, the kids can't do the activities they want, because of time. Without cars, they'd do nothing during the week. And dc 2 wouldn't be able to theirs at all.

Yeah, the only place I've found public transport better for day to day stuff is London. Other than that aside from if you live near a train station and can walk there, you end up taking buses as well as the train, perhaps a bus the other end as well- much more time and really pricey these days. I would have to get a bus and a train, the quickest assuming both were on time would be around an hour, cost £20 plus now or 25 mins by car.
ivykaty44 · 09/03/2022 21:46

You asked why the car came last In the video.

Yes, because it was said a car was more convenient- how can it be more convenient if it takes so long 🤷‍♀️

MangyInseam · 09/03/2022 21:45

I don't believe either public transport or bike infrastructure are really what is needed. They are fine as far as they go, but can't address the real issue which is around things like community planning, the decline of villages, towns and even smaller cities, and so on.

The most basic issue is that most people do not live within walking distance of where they work, walking distance of shopping, walking distance of entertainment, walking distance of at least some family and friends.

These things are due to the movable workforce and the way communities have developed around the car and public transport, to the point where many people cannot even afford to live within a short distance of work. This is only possible because workers can be brought into these areas. Zoning regulations and building up new developments without adequate infrastructure are also elements.

Bikes are relatively cheap to use but not everyone can. Public transport is a logistical and material expense. Walking is pretty free and cities, towns, and villages developed with walking as the organizing feature for thousands of years. And they still could be to a much much greater extent than they are now.

Agrudge · 09/03/2022 21:44

@ivykaty44

Because it's in london where traffic is always shit.

So there is no congestion in the rest of the U.K.? No traffic gridlock 🤔😂

You asked why the car came last In the video.
Octomingo · 09/03/2022 21:44

I didn't learn to drive until my 20s. Everything took so much longer on public transport. I had to get lifts to work, Wenden I got my first job, as there were no buses there.

I think many people who decry car use are lucky enough to wfh or live somewhere with good links. I also think a lot of mn has no idea about the places where pt assumes you all live and work fairly local, so doesn't link up across counties.

My journey to work is about 20 miles. Takes me about 40 minutes in the car. I do not live rurally. No one I know works near me, so car sharing is out. Not allowed to wfh.

By pt, I would have to get a bus to the train station (if any buses were running at 530), then a train. Then another train, to be in work by 8. Then in reverse. Not sure how I'd get dc to the cm by 7am in any of that though. Or how I'd do pick ups.

Where I live, I can get a bus to one town (10 miles away) every 30 minutes. No buses to another town(11 miles away). One bus an hour to a closer town(6 miles away). To visit parents (12 miles) it's a 20 minute walk to a bus stop, then 40 minute bus ride. I can drive it in 20 minutes.

Like someone upthread said, it's not just getting places but how much time you actually have. Even with 2 adults living here and driving, the kids can't do the activities they want, because of time. Without cars, they'd do nothing during the week. And dc 2 wouldn't be able to theirs at all.

ivykaty44 · 09/03/2022 21:41

Because it's in london where traffic is always shit.

So there is no congestion in the rest of the U.K.? No traffic gridlock 🤔😂

etulosba · 09/03/2022 21:40

You can tow with an EV - they have massive torque.

Torque isn’t the issue.

A lot of smaller EVs are not type approved for towing. More of the larger ones are, but they are just not affordable for many (most?) people. In addition, towing massively decreases the range, which might make it impractical for some people.

Agrudge · 09/03/2022 21:38

[quote ivykaty44]@Agrudge perhaps read the post as it’s states neither do I

But why did the car come last if it gives freedom and is more convenient?[/quote]
Because it's in london where traffic is always shit.

ivykaty44 · 09/03/2022 21:36

@Agrudge perhaps read the post as it’s states neither do I

But why did the car come last if it gives freedom and is more convenient?

Whisktea · 09/03/2022 21:35

Some areas it would be really challenging to have a comprehensive enough public transport network. I don't despair that many people find they make life easier, of course if someone drives absolutely everywhere including places they could easily walk then that's an issue, but meh. I don't think electric cars are the environmental saviours some seem to think either.

Fairislefandango · 09/03/2022 21:31

I don't like driving and I have no interest in cars. But I live fairly rurally and do a job that involves working in multiple locations. It would be literally impossible for me to get to my workplaces on time (or in some cases at all) by public transport.