Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
bozzabollix · 10/03/2022 08:50

I love my car, absolutely love driving but I do agree with you, there needs to be more options. I live semi rurally and there’s a big pressure here to pass your test and get a car ASAP. Without that you’re very limited. I did invest in a beautiful bike which I’ve barely used because I lack confidence on the road. It’d be good to have a network of cycle routes that didn’t share space with cars or pedestrians, and also not at the edge of roads where all of the ruts and holes are. I’d certainly use my bike far more if there was access to those.

Otherwise long journeys are just so expensive by train, for a family of four it’s prohibitive. We’d probably quadruple our costs. Our car is prettt good MPG wise though.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 08:25

During the pandemic this was apparent when the local cut through road was closed to vehicle traffic for cyclists , walkers , horse riders etc etc and there was uproar, I've never seen such fierce reactions to one tiny road being closed

yet motorways are closed to traffic which is cycling, horse riding, walkers, mopeds etc. There aren't protests about this, these other forms accept that motorways are for motorised vehicles only. Motorists are great activists and very militant when they think another form of traffic is getting something they're not

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 08:21

But most people who need an adapted bike will also need access to a car

but most people who can cycle will need access to a car

a car is more expensive than a bike so why use the expense as a reason not to buy a mode of transport?

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 08:17

People want to use cars , simple .
It's quicker
,

but its not always quicker and could well be much slower for many shorter journeys. So why do people take a car when its clearly slower and then grumble about how long it took them to drive in the congestion? Many town centres are gridlocked - so why not take a folding bike and cycle the last three miles to the centre? Or get the park and ride bus?

hattie43 · 10/03/2022 08:14

People want to use cars , simple .
It's quicker , cheaper , timing is when you want not the timing of train / bus etc etc . Much more comfortable particularly in winter , who wants to stand / walk in the wind / rain .
During the pandemic this was apparent when the local cut through road was closed to vehicle traffic for cyclists , walkers , horse riders etc etc and there was uproar, I've never seen such fierce reactions to one tiny road being closed .
As good as the OP's intentions are I think she is in the minority.

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 08:03

That last message @Sirzy

OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 08:02

But that's my whole point! What if other transport options were better, so that not owning a car was a choice that we were free to make?

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 10/03/2022 08:00

What gets me is 'out of town' shopping centres and office parks. They become a nightmare to get to unless you drive.

Which then encourages car use. And then the planners also wonder why the high Street is empty.

Sirzy · 10/03/2022 07:57

@ivykaty44

Underhisi Adapted bikes are expensive? How much more expensive are they than a car?
But most people who need an adapted bike will also need access to a car (sometimes also adapted) unless they live life in a very small area. Especially given how inaccessible much public transport is to those with mobility issues. only this week Tanni Grey Thompson got an email to say her assistance for the train station had been cancelled - when she was on the train to that station.
ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 07:50

Underhisi Adapted bikes are expensive? How much more expensive are they than a car?

Underhisi · 10/03/2022 07:45

Cars don't have to have pedals. You can get adapted bikes but they are very expensive, won't work for everyone who cannot pedal and you still need a car as well.

Sirzy · 10/03/2022 07:43

I think more park and ride options would be a good start.

When I go to York I know I can easily access a park and ride location which will have regular buses into the city centre at a reasonable cost (less than you would pay for city centre parking)

If more towns and cities offered a decent park and ride then more people would use that - if local enough they would walk/cycle and know they could get directly in from there, from further away they would drive.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 07:41

If we get rid of cars public transport needs to be so much better so that people can still find jobs even in areas where not a lot of well paid work is available.

This was exactly my point in my earlier post Problem is with so many militant motorists, if you suggest using a different type of transport - they decide that it means they must never use the car, ever

This isn’t about getting rid of cars, it’s about reducing and using alternatives some of the time

Just like you if I travel 112 miles to see family it’s £64 on the train return and takes 2.5 hrs. By car a good trip is 2 hrs 10 and can be 3 hrs but cost is £26 return. This doesn’t mean I have to use my car to bust the shops 2 miles away, I can use other methods. Which I do as parking is expensive and I prefer to use a bike which is quicker. Do I want to cycle the 112 miles to visit family - not really id prefer to go by train but I’ll drive as it’s cheaper

bumblingbovine49 · 10/03/2022 07:40

@Konstantine8364

I live in Manchester and public transport from the suburbs to the city centre is excellent and when travelling to the city centre I use the tram (most people I know would use tram/bus for this). However public transport from the suburbs into Cheshire and around the suburbs is dire. For example; my office is a 40min drive away, would take 2hrs plus each way on public transport. My friend A lives 10 mins drive away, 50mins on public transport. My friend B lives 20mins drive away, 1hr 20 on public transport. I cycle a bit in the summer but don't feel safe cycling on the roads when it's dark/wet/icy (which is 99% of autumn/winter). People have busy lives and can't spend half their life or really restrict themselves relying on public transport. And this is in a major city, it's much much worse rurally! Until public transport is much improved people won't give up their cars!
Many UK cities have this problem. I live on the outskirts of a small city and never drive to the town centre. The bus is easier though not always cheaper but visiting friends in non central parts of the city is very very inconvenient without a car . There are almost no bus routes around the suburbs, only into the town centre and out again. The busses are run by different companies and tickets are only valid for the company you buy them from. This means that even though return tickets are cheaper than singles , if more than one bus serves a route you can't get the one most convenient one home at the time, you have to wait for the bus from the right company or pay again which is very frustrating or more expensive
Momicrone · 10/03/2022 07:39

It costs on average 3k per year to keep a car on the road, that's a lot of train or bus journeys

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 07:36

@bumblingbovine49

I visited my family for a one night stay yesterday. It takes just over an hour by car and even with sky high petrol prices would have cost me about £20 in fuel I had a problem with one of the tyres at the last minute so went by train instead. It cost me £60 on the train and another £10 on buses and tubes getting to and from stations . It also took about 3 hours . So a 2.5 hour journey both ways became over 6 hours and cost £70 instead of £20. I know cars cost more than just petrol and this was for a non essential visit so I could hav chosen not to go but people often need cars to work. If we get rid of cars public transport needs to be so much better so that people can still find jobs even in areas where not a lot of well paid work is available.
Another one.

IT IS NOT ABOUT GETTING RID OF CARS.

IT IS ABOUT PROVIDING OTHER OPTIONS SO THAT CARS ARE NOT SO COMPULSORY.

OP posts:
bumblingbovine49 · 10/03/2022 07:25

I visited my family for a one night stay yesterday. It takes just over an hour by car and even with sky high petrol prices would have cost me about £20 in fuel I had a problem with one of the tyres at the last minute so went by train instead. It cost me £60 on the train and another £10 on buses and tubes getting to and from stations . It also took about 3 hours . So a 2.5 hour journey both ways became over 6 hours and cost £70 instead of £20. I know cars cost more than just petrol and this was for a non essential visit so I could hav chosen not to go but people often need cars to work. If we get rid of cars public transport needs to be so much better so that people can still find jobs even in areas where not a lot of well paid work is available.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 07:21

Underhisi Driving requires coordination and I’d really question the safety of someone driving without this attribute- one wrong pedal move could be fatal for a pedestrian

Underhisi · 10/03/2022 07:15

Driving and riding a bike require different skills. I think people who have a physical condition will know more about how that condition effects their ability to do either than someone who knows very little about the condition.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 07:12

Totally! And if people had other transport options, then they wouldn't be forced to drive, which might take some pressure off the parking situation!

Problem is with so many militant motorists, if you suggest using a different type of transport - they decide that it means they must never use the car, ever

Rather than perhaps doing a bit of mix and match and reducing some of their car journeys, which could even be drive 18 miles of a 20 mile journey and bus/walk or cycle the last 2 miles

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 07:11

I mean, if you removed kerbside parking on a lot of
b roads, you would have a lot of space for alternative forms of transport.

OP posts:
SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 07:09

@ivykaty44

You cannot widen a road through a fucking house and yes in some areas the house it literally next to the road no footpath HOUSE

Many roads are 3/4 lanes, with two lanes used for free storage of cars. How about sharing jyst one of those lanes for a cycle path - a third of quarter, not half

I think we also need to consider why we think it's acceptable to give so much PUBLIC space over to the storage of PRIVATE property at the expense of using that public space for actual transport.
OP posts:
malificent7 · 10/03/2022 07:06

Cars sucj. Dd does not understand why i don't lust after a brand new land rover or tesla and am content with my honda jazz. It's because they suck but are a status symbol for many. At least tesla are electric.

SelkieQualia · 10/03/2022 07:01

@ivykaty44

You cannot widen a road through a fucking house and yes in some areas the house it literally next to the road no footpath HOUSE

Many roads are 3/4 lanes, with two lanes used for free storage of cars. How about sharing jyst one of those lanes for a cycle path - a third of quarter, not half

Totally! And if people had other transport options, then they wouldn't be forced to drive, which might take some pressure off the parking situation!
OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 10/03/2022 07:00

@irregularegular

Our next car - soon - will be electric!
Well that will keep the exhaust gases out of my lungs, if not the particulate pollution from tyres and brakes. How is it going to improve congestion or reduce the emissions caused by manufacturing the thing though?