Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
Calennig · 10/03/2022 17:06

Do you expect me to cycle to the hospital when I go into labour?

I got a taxi and then had couple of home births - though did get lift back after pfb from friend which I was greatful for as DH had thought we'd be fine on the bus - despite me having given birth night before and had no sleep due to dire pnd ward. TBF the bus route did stop next door to our then house and it was just outside the hopsital entrance but even so it felt very daunting.

I did find DH being in hopsital in next city to were we lived an issue - transport out of town site wasn't great - it was bus, train bus and the times didn't tit well and they were very restictive visiting hours - it didn't look like anyone had thought about it and no shelters. New hospital here had issues as apparently they thought of buses and even taxi very late expecting everyone to come in an ambulance or be driving.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/03/2022 17:00

Why are we so obsessed with keeping ourselves away from other people? Building big fences round our houses and locking ourselves away in polluting metal boxes and seeing that as a sign of comfort and luxury? When did we forget that we are social creatures and that the more we move around, mix and interact with other people (like us a different from us) the healthier and happier we are?
For me on public transport it started around the era of the Walkman, but has continued with ipods, smartphones and Bluetooth speakers.

Calennig · 10/03/2022 16:57

Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

The expectation is everyone drives.

We don't, IL don't and never have in their 70s now, sibling who works as a carer doesn't - you tell people this and they'll still give you car directions as it's their default, they'll do times like you're driving and get irked when you can't meet them. There will occaionally be an issue that you can't get to a location at all either solved by taxi or by not doing event but you'll probably be met with skepticism that it's not possible to get there or there at time wanted and frequently told the solution is to be driving.

But everyone thinks in terms of driving - it's the default the expectation and has been for decades- you see it all the time on MN.

Problem is I don't see this changing without viable reliable afforable alternatives - and they're frequently not there which reinforces expectation everyone drives - thus there's no real poltical incentive to priotise improved public transport services - (given that I think the UK
cities that brought trams back have been very forward thinking.)

It's ingrained the expecation - maybe higher driving costs will change this - but I've seen over crowded train routes for decades with no improvements such as bigger or more frequent trains so I doubt it.

So it's tolerated because large swaths of the population can opt out by driving so don't use servces so live in blissful ignorance how bad the system is or regination the alternatives aren't but they do drive so they cope. When drivers do venture onto public transport or try biking the experinces can be so dire they go back to driving thankful they can drive and avoid the dire alternatives.

iamsoreadyforbednow · 10/03/2022 16:56

Because my hospital is 45-50 minutes away, with a bus route with only two buses that run on a Wednesday (I believe, I drive so unsure if this is still correct but I know it’s sparse still) and I’m 9 months pregnant.

Do you expect me to cycle to the hospital when I go into labour? Grin

Driving is great for us but I would certainly cut back if we lived in a city or larger town where I’m able to walk to cycle to get to basically amenities.

dameofdilemma · 10/03/2022 16:52

Even if the entire of the UK had the best public transport in the world, many, many people would still insist on using their cars.

Many see cars as a status symbol - from the first boy racer (you can't neck your girlfriend or smoke weed in the back of a bus) to the mid life crisis sports car.

We have family in other parts of the UK who sneer at our use of buses - apparently they 'wouldn't be seen dead on them' and they're 'only for old people and children'.

Momicrone · 10/03/2022 16:45

Onlyfoolsnmothers, this was the source
www.nimblefins.co.uk/cheap-car-insurance/average-cost-run-car-uk#:~:text=What's%20the%20Average%20Cost%20of,(%C2%A3273%20a%20year).

Momicrone · 10/03/2022 16:43

Herbaceous, people also hire cars to go to remote places

Blossom64265 · 10/03/2022 16:42

Not everyone is happier around other people. Many of us experience great distress in groups or crowds. We thrive on solitude. Not everyone is NT. Being on public transit or in a crowd I can’t exit is dangerous for someone like me with an airborne fragrance allergy because there are people who still think using scented products doesn’t violate the social contract.

KeepYaHeadUp · 10/03/2022 15:47

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Because nothing can come in any way close to matching the convenience of a car - especially outside London.

And trains and busses are full of sniffing sneezing tossers, people shouting into their phones and gits playing tinny "music" loudly, who give you a mouthful of abuse if asked politely to desist.

These are not easy issues to address.

Why are we so obsessed with keeping ourselves away from other people? Building big fences round our houses and locking ourselves away in polluting metal boxes and seeing that as a sign of comfort and luxury? When did we forget that we are social creatures and that the more we move around, mix and interact with other people (like us a different from us) the healthier and happier we are?
Dinoteeth · 10/03/2022 15:38

Car sharing isn't the answer either, the days of people working 9-5 and starting and finishing at the same time are long gone.

I know two other people who live in the area who work in the same industrial estate. We all work different hours, and have little people who need collected. So even if two of us could car share what do we do with the four kids that get collected on the way home?

Sleepyblueocean · 10/03/2022 15:35

"If then public transport is subsidised, efficient and runs properly for all?"

Bear in mind that all cannot use public transport because it will never be accessible for all. Yes it needs to be better but those who cannot use it should not be penalised because of that.

herbaceous · 10/03/2022 15:17

One of the problems is the sunk costs of a car. If you need a car for reasons like carting about children occasionally, going to remote places, etc, as it cost you £10 grand, or whatever, people feel they might as well use that, and just pay the petrol, rather than fork out again for public transport.

Not sure what the solution might be - car sharing seems to work in densely populated areas...

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/03/2022 15:14

@ivykaty44

The Dutch are masters of planning

they were in the 1970s

people protested and campaigned for this to happen

Yes they did.

I lived in the UK for 12 years and this was one of the most frustrating things about it, the public just tolerating bad policies and lack of vision by the (local) government.

If I compare where I used to live in the UK to where I live now, it's night and day. In essence they are very similar towns, same size and with good connections to bigger cities. But the English town was incredibly run down, extremely poor city planning with a big retail park sucking the life out of the city centre. Of course no cycle route to the retail park. Virtually no people live in the city centre, making it like a ghost town at night apart from drunks and homeless people.

The Dutch town is vibrant with lots of shops. But that does not come easy or for free. 10 years ago the council ran a scheme where empty spaces above the city centres shops were converted to apartments, so loads of people live there now supporting the local economy. It's a very easy 3 mile cycle for me to go there. On safe, well maintained cycle paths.

The English town could have done that but didn't.

Not everything is perfect here but I am not ever going back.

Dinoteeth · 10/03/2022 15:10

@ivykaty44

Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

that was the ops question

and so many replies are - public transport and cycling infastructor are really bad - so ill drive

but thats not answering the question

why do you accept it?

People don't really accept it they find an alternative, ie the car.

It's a bit like people choosing to go private with medical treatment, can't be assed to wait months for a bus or Operation they splash the cash and go private.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/03/2022 15:00

[quote AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii]@CuteOrangeElephant I’m assuming there will be people who need their cars for work? I’m thinking community nurses, carers etc?[/quote]
Yes of course, some people will always need a car. That being said I know community carers who use bikes only.

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 14:43

@ivykaty44

Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

that was the ops question

and so many replies are - public transport and cycling infastructor are really bad - so ill drive

but thats not answering the question

why do you accept it?

I think the underlying answer is - what can I really do about it?

It's rather passive but I think many people do feel powerless.

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 14:42

@etulosba

Villages used to be much more independent, because most people did not have cars.

I read somewhere that most villages in England are located within seven miles of a market town (or what was a market town) because 14 miles is as far as people were prepared to walk in one day.

Yes, and if you look at old maps what you see is a very sensible distributed network that minimizes the need for long trips.

But I will say there is in my experience some hypocrisy found among a certain number of the people who really push some of this getting rid of car business. Because they are often people who want access to all the things, they want activity choices for their kids, they want to live in a multicultural area. etc.

So they end up living in these giant cities that have all those choices close by with good public transport to boot. But those cities tend to suck the life out of surrounding villages and towns, and grow to epic proportions. They become these economic black holes, and they also set a standard for choice and way of life that is not sustainable in a more distributed network.

The fact is in a small town or village, with minimal car use, people are not going to have the choices we now expect. There might be one or two kids activities, one exercise class at the hall, your neighbours are the people who happen to live nearby, your groceries are going to be less exotic, maybe there is only one dentist's office, etc.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 14:37

Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

that was the ops question

and so many replies are - public transport and cycling infastructor are really bad - so ill drive

but thats not answering the question

why do you accept it?

etulosba · 10/03/2022 14:34

Villages used to be much more independent, because most people did not have cars.

I read somewhere that most villages in England are located within seven miles of a market town (or what was a market town) because 14 miles is as far as people were prepared to walk in one day.

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 14:30

I'm going to stick my neck out and say that someone who is disabled probably needs to conserve their limited energy for navigating their usual activities, not for cycling from a to b..

and others are using bikes as a mobility aid, campaigning for better cycling infastructor as its easier than using other transportation. bikes can be a real asset as it takes away the worry of running out of energy

www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/jan/02/cambridge-disabled-people-cycling-rolling-walking-stick

cardiffbybike.wales/2017/06/23/bicycles-as-mobility-aids/

DoraSpenlow · 10/03/2022 14:24

When I was working it used to take me about 20 minutes to drive there. I did think that I could probably cycle and had a trial run which took me 40 minutes there and 30 minutes back (hills!). Trouble was it was country lanes with no verges so it was scary being passed by tractors and trailers and lorries when there is nowhere to go. Thinking it would also help me lose some weight I did it for a week. Got soaked getting there twice and on the Friday I got knocked off. So that was it, not doing that again.

I also once broke my arm so had to get to work on the bus. It took me 1hr 20mins with one bus change on the way. It also cost me £8.50 a day.

So. Yes, I will stick with my car.

Blossom64265 · 10/03/2022 14:21

We do need a solution. I don’t suspect it will come in my lifetime.

Whatever that solution is won’t be packing people in with increasing density. There just won’t be support for it. Many of us resist living in tightly packed cities for a reason. The solutions need to let people still have green space and detached homes.

I personally think the movie Minority Report may have been in to something. Individual vehicles that link into a system, but then can separate off to do the last part of the journey if it doesn’t happen to be on the network.

MangyInseam · 10/03/2022 14:07

@TweenTrauma

Where I live there is no option but to drive. There are some small convenience type shops in my small town but they are very expensive and are limited in what they sell. To get a bus to the nearest supermarket would mean a 20 min walk to and from the bus stop to the supermarket, not possible with a full weekly shop on the way back.

My place of work and where my horses are kept are not at all accessible by public transport. So I wouldn’t be able to get to them at all.

You’d have to have a death wish to cycle around here, it’s all twisty roads, only just wide enough for two cars, lots of hills and corners everywhere.

It’s either own a car or be stuck in a very small town with very limited facilities.

This kind of thing is a bit of a catch-22. Villages used to be much more independent, because most people did not have cars. They didn't have the choices of the city perhaps but you could certainly get what you needed. My grandmother used to speak quite fondly of going to do errands for her mum around 1930. For some things she would go to shops on the high street, for milk and some other things she went to the nearby farms, all on foot. In that same village today you have to go into the town by car for most of it.

But it's because of the car. When people suddenly had the option of buzzing off 20 km to get their shopping or to see a film, small villages could no longer complete. Towns near cities often suffer the same fate.

It would be interesting to see, if cars became too expensive to drive so much, if shops and services became better in small places.

Buzzinwithbez · 10/03/2022 13:58

The bike will be an extra. Do you know how much adapted bikes cost?

Suitable clothing would also be an extra for most people.
I'm going to stick my neck out and say that someone who is disabled probably needs to conserve their limited energy for navigating their usual activities, not for cycling from a to b..

ivykaty44 · 10/03/2022 13:52

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii how would it penalise rural people to have a charge to park their car on public property? If then public transport is subsidised, efficient and runs properly for all?