Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at our obession with cars

633 replies

SelkieQualia · 09/03/2022 11:11

They are awful. Noisy. Polluting. 4 million people die every year from the effects of air pollution. Housing developments are built around them, which means that the most vulnerable people in our society - young people, the elderly - are made even more dependant on those who drive.
Why do we tolerate such terrible public transport and cycling infrastructure?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChrissyPlummer · 19/03/2022 18:23

I was going to ask my boss to reduce my hours. A p/t vacancy came up at work after someone left. The original hours were 8-2 Thursday-Sat, day off on Sunday, then 8-2 Mon-Wed with 7 off. I could get the train, which would save me a fortune in petrol and parking.

However, they have changed the hours to include a Sunday shift and some late shifts. I’m so glad I didn’t apply, as I’d still be spending the same amount of money (would only be able to get train on 2 days) but on half the wage. I’d love p/t but with those shifts it just isn’t viable.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2022 09:42

@Momicrone

It's one vehicle, often electric, doing multi drops rather than lots of vehicles on the road
Ocado's website shows 'green' deliveries, when they are already delivering to your area. I don't use them as they never seem to be when it's convenient for me but it's a good idea if you don't mind being flexible.

We really need more part time / shorter hours jobs.

But how many people can afford to reduce their salaries to take a shorter hours job?

Alondra · 18/03/2022 08:31

I never had a car in Madrid, the public transport was so good we didn't need it. Same with going on holidays to other parts of Spain, the AVE fast train network is so vast, we didn't need to take a plane.

It changed when I came to Australia - without a car you can't function, you need it for work, shopping or going to a restaurant. And I live in Sydney.

I walk and cycle as much as I can but I'm restricted in how much I use my car because Australia has an awful public transport policy, trains are slow and expensive, buses and metro are very restrictive to the CBD with most of the greater Sydney population unable to access.

One of the things I seriously miss from Spain is their public transport. The ability to go from Cordoba to Seville in 30 minutes in a fast train. Or from Madrid to Segovia in 20 mins with affordable prices.

I really miss the public transport system in Spain.

Momicrone · 18/03/2022 08:16

Cuntymcbollox, trains can be a great way to visit family in other counties in the uk

Momicrone · 18/03/2022 08:13

It's one vehicle, often electric, doing multi drops rather than lots of vehicles on the road

maddening · 18/03/2022 08:09

@Momicrone

"Maddening, you don't have to do all your shopping by bike, just some of it, weekly shop can be delivered"

I don't want it delivered, tried it, don't like the service. and I am sure a vehicle is doing the delivering, it is still a vehicle on the road so no thanks.

CuntyMcBollocks · 18/03/2022 07:00

I'm not 'obsessed' but I need one to get to work and back as there is no public transport and it's a long way from where I live. I also live in a different county to most of my friends and family and use my car to go and visit them. That's the reality for most people I expect - they use a car because they NEED to. They're expensive to run and I'd rather not have to have one, but I wouldn't be able to work otherwise.

SelkieQualia · 18/03/2022 00:43

@lampygirl

A cargo bike or trailer would take it for sure, really much more common in Europe.

I do think being time poor makes us more reliant on the car. The 'weekly shop' probably mostly does warrant a decent boot to bring it all home again, but if we were popping out every other day for that evening's meal and the bits for tomorrows lunch and that was it then this would be much much easier even with a rucksack or ideally a couple of panniers, nothing really heavy duty. When your working day is already 8.30 - 6 with a 30 min commute if you go by bike on top of that, plus changing time, the last thing you want to do is still be in the supermarket at 7 every night. If the working day was 8.30-4 it might be more viable.

I personally think 8.30 - 6 daily is a pretty crap lifestyle anyway (yes, I do it myself). There's a thread going about working part time without kids. We really need more part time / shorter hours jobs.
OP posts:
theemperorhasnoclothes · 17/03/2022 23:27

Really good public transport requires serious government investment; this can been seen in other countries where public transport is well funded and used . The UK hasn't with it's insistence on a so-called 'private' model, which is really just a wealth transfer exercise to shareholders because it's not like anyone has much choice in which train they get since there's usually only one company going from A to B.

Where I live - and I only live here because I couldn't afford a house in the city centre - we used to have a bus service twice a day and it was stopped about 3 years ago so now there are no buses and no form of public transport whatsoever. Cycling is taking your life in your hands and obviously only accessible to the totally fit and not families with young children. There have been several accidents and cyclists dying on the main road as there's no room for them. The only safe option is car.

It's only possible to make choices when there ARE choices.

There seems to be no real political will to improve public transport from any side. We need another party I think probably.

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2022 23:19

@lampygirl

A cargo bike or trailer would take it for sure, really much more common in Europe.

I do think being time poor makes us more reliant on the car. The 'weekly shop' probably mostly does warrant a decent boot to bring it all home again, but if we were popping out every other day for that evening's meal and the bits for tomorrows lunch and that was it then this would be much much easier even with a rucksack or ideally a couple of panniers, nothing really heavy duty. When your working day is already 8.30 - 6 with a 30 min commute if you go by bike on top of that, plus changing time, the last thing you want to do is still be in the supermarket at 7 every night. If the working day was 8.30-4 it might be more viable.

I work shifts and fit my shopping in around it. Sometimes I'll go shopping after an early shift, or before a late. Normally though I'll pop out when on my lunch break. The only time I really went out of my way was the 5 miles each way to/from the zero-waste shop for refills of baking stuff and cleaning liquids, but like with the spuds it wasn't very often - they've now closed to concentrate on their other business so I'll have to use the one in the city where I sometimes work.

Little-and-often detours via shops on the way home from work doesn't take long anyway. I'd guess that I only usually carry shopping on my bike twice a week, plus walking to the corner shop for bread and milk (the only place I've know using returnable glass bottles).

If I had a large family I would probably get it delivered. Better to have one van on the road, delivering to dozens of customers than having dozens of cars vying for parking spaces.

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2022 22:45

@etulosba

Disregarding the weight, which must be upwards of 50kg if sacks of spuds are included, where do you put it all without compromising the stability of the bike?
Sack of spuds weighs 25kg, gets draped over the pannier rack and is bungeed on. Not really any different to carrying a child in a seat mounted on the pannier rack. I don't do it often, a 25kg sack will last me months.
WeirdlyKind · 17/03/2022 21:58

I'd love to use a bike to get my shopping but the nearest proper supermarket is at least six mines away, down a very busy duel carriageway. Not to mention the lanes in and around my village aren't very safe (unlit, very bendy, lots of farm traffic).

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 17/03/2022 17:06

Why not? I take my shopping home by bicycle all the time, even fill 25kg sacks of potatoes.

Good for you, I won't be. I'll carry on getting my main shopping delivered as I'm not going out on a bike in the pouring rain. I can't fit a sack of spuds in the boot of my car and I'll use the car for the rest.

Momicrone · 17/03/2022 13:37

Supermarkets deliver

lampygirl · 17/03/2022 13:34

A cargo bike or trailer would take it for sure, really much more common in Europe.

I do think being time poor makes us more reliant on the car. The 'weekly shop' probably mostly does warrant a decent boot to bring it all home again, but if we were popping out every other day for that evening's meal and the bits for tomorrows lunch and that was it then this would be much much easier even with a rucksack or ideally a couple of panniers, nothing really heavy duty. When your working day is already 8.30 - 6 with a 30 min commute if you go by bike on top of that, plus changing time, the last thing you want to do is still be in the supermarket at 7 every night. If the working day was 8.30-4 it might be more viable.

etulosba · 17/03/2022 11:46

Disregarding the weight, which must be upwards of 50kg if sacks of spuds are included, where do you put it all without compromising the stability of the bike?

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2022 10:27

@etulosba

Why not? I take my shopping home by bicycle all the time, even fill 25kg sacks of potatoes

What other superpowers do you have? It’s a ten mile ride back from my local supermarket. Uphill all the way.

Gears
ShavingTheBadger · 17/03/2022 10:08

@Momicrone

You don't need superpowers to carry heavy things by bike
You don't, but you do need to be fit. I'm speaking as someone who cycle commutes, goes on cycling holidays, and bike-packed the coast to coast last year. It's hard work. If you don't have a rack for panniers (mine's a cyclocross bike so great for commuting and off-roading), then you're limited to what you can get into a backpack. Cycling back from the supermarket with a "small shop" - a chicken, some veg, toothpaste, and a bottle of squash, for example, isn't easy. We can all do better, but the best way to do that is to offer different options for different people, because with Active Travel, it's not a case of "one size fits all".
Momicrone · 17/03/2022 10:02

You don't need superpowers to carry heavy things by bike

etulosba · 17/03/2022 09:31

Why not? I take my shopping home by bicycle all the time, even fill 25kg sacks of potatoes

What other superpowers do you have? It’s a ten mile ride back from my local supermarket. Uphill all the way.

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2022 09:25

cycling is no good for shopping

Why not? I take my shopping home by bicycle all the time, even fill 25kg sacks of potatoes.

Underhisi · 17/03/2022 09:18

And my son goes to a school on individual transport an hour away as does virtually every child at that school because of the large area they take from and most of the kids cannot share transport or wait around for transport. A school that specialist couldn't be built in every town for 5 pupils so there is no way around that.

Underhisi · 17/03/2022 09:13

My village has free school buses to the secondary school about 2.5 miles away. However many children go in cars because they would have to leave the house earlier if going by bus and it can be unpleasant on the buses. My neighbours child goes to special school on school transport but the 15 min direct drive takes 45 mins by the time they picked everyone up so other parents choose to drive.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 17/03/2022 08:12

No transport no business=no money.
For me anyway.
However how many people are just popping out?

MajorCarolDanvers · 17/03/2022 08:03

We've just bought a second car.

We went down to one in 2020 but as life returns to normal we just can't both do work and all the children's activities with one car.

The kids walk one bus to school - it's everything else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread