Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is BU here, me or DP?

68 replies

j89vsd · 09/03/2022 10:28

I'm in an LDR, my DP and I started talking about moving in together last year. We agreed DP's place was too small for 2 to live comfortably in, plus he's not entirely happy there for other reasons, so started looking for a new place local to him.

We could (just about) afford to buy, but DP feels the housing market is about to tank, and this isn't a good time. So we have been looking for a rental place since the summer.

Unfortunately we've not been successful in obtaining anywhere. The market is crazy in his area, on FB there are people constantly posting looking for properties to rent. We've looked in all the usual places - Rightmove, Open rent, on social media etc and applied for everything suitable. However there's a lot of competition for every place - usually at last 5 other applicants and sometimes as many as 10 or 20. We never get a reason why we've not been selected but reading between the lines I think it's been either because we're not already living together, we're not a family (a lot of places we've viewed have had other applicants with children), or we're not renting through the same agent. One place last week we got down to the final 2 we were asked how quickly we could move in. As DP can only give his notice on the 1st of the month we said 3-4 weeks as then DP would still be paying a month overlap - ie giving notice on 1 April and moving out on 1 May, but new tenancy starting late March/ early April - and we got rejected for that one, I guess because the other applicant said 'immediately'. We've had another couple of applications where the agents came back with questions like why I lived in another part of the country, whether I/we worked from home, and I think that's probably been reasons to reject us - likewise a couple of times we've asked if basic repairs (think cupboards hanging off, holes in carpets), repainting flaking or chipped paint and so on would be done, and again heard no more.

There's not really any more we can do as far as I can see. Our finances are ok, we have good credit and secure jobs, we pass the affordibility criteria. There's no obvious reason to reject us other than there's just so much demand.

The upshot of it all is DP is fed up, thinks it's completely pointless, and we need to stop looking. He said it's a waste of time, he's sick of going to viewings (this falls to him as I'm too far away) and we're never going to get anywhere if we haven't in the last 9 months so what's the point?

I see where he's coming from but equally if we stop looking we definitely won't find anything will we? He thinks we just have to make do as we are, and possibly next year the situation will change. I find that quite frustrating, and want to keep on with it, because surely at some point we will get somewhere, other people do so why not us?

So who's BU, or do we both have a point?

OP posts:
AnnesBrokenSlate · 09/03/2022 13:59

I think YABU tbh. He's right about the market. Both about how busy it is just now and that it's likely to dip. It's difficult to get a rental and your inability to make viewings and his inability to say he'll move immediately mean you're unlikely to make it to the top of the list. You need to change your tactics if you want a different outcome and it seems you are both unable or unwilling to do so. I don't blame him for being tired of it. There's a degree of emotional investment and instability in looking at properties all the time too.

Cocomarine · 09/03/2022 13:58

@Momijin

I would rent a house where he lives. Then either live separately but a lot closer until you decide to buy or maybe both of you use one property as your office and live together in the other property. Job done.
“Job done” 🤣 Well thank goodness you showed up! Did you actually read the OP?
steff13 · 09/03/2022 13:50

I don't really understand the comments of "he doesn't sound like he's that into you" and "doesn't sound like he wants to take the next step"? It sounds to me like he's sick of going to viewings (alone) only to be rejected constantly and needs a break from it.

I agree. The mental gymnastics required to make that leap are worthy of Simone BIles.

girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 13:48

@DragonSnapCrimson it's because he's also refusing to buy (it's not the right time) and won't look anywhere outside of his area

DragonSnapCrimson · 09/03/2022 13:47

I don't really understand the comments of "he doesn't sound like he's that into you" and "doesn't sound like he wants to take the next step"? It sounds to me like he's sick of going to viewings (alone) only to be rejected constantly and needs a break from it.

Do bear in mind that he also might be feeling a bit of pressure, as imagine he goes to a viewing, says "this is the one", you get it and then things go wrong - he may feel like it's his fault for "choosing the wrong place" (all of that is just a thought, something that I would probably feel in his position).

I'd stop looking for properties for 2 or 3 months, take a breather and then dive back in.

girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 13:39

@Momijin

I would rent a house where he lives. Then either live separately but a lot closer until you decide to buy or maybe both of you use one property as your office and live together in the other property. Job done.
The whole point of the thread is they can't find a house to rent
Momijin · 09/03/2022 13:24

I would rent a house where he lives. Then either live separately but a lot closer until you decide to buy or maybe both of you use one property as your office and live together in the other property. Job done.

nearlyspringyay · 09/03/2022 13:20

House prices wont tank imo, you'll be waiting forever. If anything they'll go up as the pool gets smaller. People (including us) have decided not to move for the moment as I know we can manage the price rises in this house, if we go to a bigger house now I'd be shitting myself.

HollowTalk · 09/03/2022 13:19

@PeacefulPrune

Why don't you just move in with him until you find a place? ...I suspect that he doesn't want that though, as he's not showing many signs of prioritising you two living together.
Because she can't work from his home!
PeacefulPrune · 09/03/2022 13:15

Why don't you just move in with him until you find a place? ...I suspect that he doesn't want that though, as he's not showing many signs of prioritising you two living together.

needingpeace · 09/03/2022 13:09

Just rent a workspace or work from one of those places that got set up during Covid - the work from home office collectives. Cheaper than all the travelling. Put bulk of stuff into storage until ready to buy

Ragruggers · 09/03/2022 13:05

If you are first time buyers ,look at shared ownership in his area surely better to buy even a basic 2 bed than rent at least you are on the ladder for the future.Do you have a decent deposit?Can’t see why you would rent if there is a choice.

girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 13:04

How long are you willing to wait before you move in with him?

Because if there's no massive change in 2/3 years what happens then?

j89vsd · 09/03/2022 13:01

He's quite up on financial matters, watches/ listens to a lot of stuff suggesting that a recession/ house price crash, or at least a drop in real terms, is coming. There's a thread on here now saying the same, so I do think it's a view shared by a lot of people.

OP posts:
Whatsonmymindgrapes · 09/03/2022 12:55

Why does he think it’s about to tank? Is he an expert?

j89vsd · 09/03/2022 12:32

I think DP expects prices not to fall per se, but in real terms - so for example a friend of mine is buying a house which costs 7x her salary; 20 years ago the same house would have been 2x her equivalent salary. That multiplier can't keep increasing indefinitely I don't think?

DP does also work from home most of the time so working while he's out isn't really an option.

Obviously as he's the one doing the viewings if he doesn't want to do any more for the foreseeable I'll have to accept that. But I'm just not sure how anything will be any different in a few months, the reasons for rejecting us as tenants, or preferring others, will be the same then.

OP posts:
2DogsOnMySofa · 09/03/2022 11:44

It can be soul destroying viewing so many houses and not being successful. Maybe give it a few months and then start again.

WouldIwasShookspeared · 09/03/2022 11:35

Oh, I saw the workplace calls thing.
Does he not work outside the home? There's no way you could do your hours while he's out?

WouldIwasShookspeared · 09/03/2022 11:33

If you really want to live together where he is then why not move into his place and carry on looking from there?

That way you'll be living together, in the area, you'll be settled work wise etc etc and if they are indeed reasons you aren't finding anywhere to rent, that issue will be solved.yes you'll have to make do for a bit but it's an option.

girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 11:23

OP house prices have been rising for the last 30 years.
Houses that cost £250,000 now won't cost £180,000 in 2 years time.

McScreamysGhostPants · 09/03/2022 11:20

@j89vsd

We take the travelling in turns, so that is pretty equal, and if anything he comes to me slightly more.

I do think he probably is right that now isn't a good time to buy (prices have gone up by about 25% in the area in the last 2 years which can't be sustainable) but I do wonder how long it will take to drop, probably more like 2-3 years at least, which feels a long time to wait.

Why can't it be sustainable? There is a shortage of housing..... that's what creates the market. We have a housing shortage crisis. That's not going to magically disappear.

j89vsd · 09/03/2022 11:20

@KylieCharlene

If I was renting out a house the fact that you currently live so far away would make me worry you might return there short-notice and try and get out of the tenancy and leave your DP to try and afford it alone (which may not be possible)- or take DP with you, potentially causing me to chase you or fight legally for rent. I'd worry your relationship wasn't stable and again, I'd be left with potential financial fallout. I'd also be thinking there's a good chance you only want to let short-term and ideally I'd be looking for a family, who for eg, have dc at a local school, who would be looking to rent long-term. Just my musings.
Yes, on the short term point we think we'll be there for 2-3 years (waiting for house prices to drop so we can buy) and normally say if asked 2-3 years, or long term. But of course if another applicant says 10 years I'm sure that's who a landlord would go with.

I could also understand a landlord being concerned about us not living together, but I can't really see a way round that as things stand.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 11:19

OP do you rent or own?

If you rent could you not give notice then say you're available to move immediately and just manage in his small property short-term, or work in a library or similar?

girlmom21 · 09/03/2022 11:17

[quote user1471457751]@girlmom21 the OP is hardly doing on the leg work when her partner has done over 75% of the viewings alone. He's done about 16 viewings without her. At least with doing applications you can sit at home in your pjs and do them at your convenience. With viewings he will be having to fit in with the estate agent timings, maybe rearranging work etc. The OP is in the easier position here[/quote]
Applications, communicating with estate agents and all of the admin are massively more time consuming than viewing properties

user1471457751 · 09/03/2022 11:16

@girlmom21 the OP is hardly doing on the leg work when her partner has done over 75% of the viewings alone. He's done about 16 viewings without her. At least with doing applications you can sit at home in your pjs and do them at your convenience. With viewings he will be having to fit in with the estate agent timings, maybe rearranging work etc. The OP is in the easier position here