Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is reasonable and fair?

142 replies

Woollensheep · 09/03/2022 09:37

I had an affair - yes I know. I am a terrible awful person who deserves to be miserable forever.
I told DH about it because we went to marriage counselling as things had not been great for about a decade.
He took it better than I expected initially - he wasn’t over the top angry and he didn’t throw me out or threaten me or anything. He said that he could see why it had happened.
This was about six months ago.
However he’s now saying he wants to be able to track my phone / car at all times, have all my passwords and be able to read all messages I send / receive.
My affair is over so there’s no ‘issue’ exactly, although I don’t love him reading messages I send to my friends for no particular reason really.
I told a couple of my friends about what DH had said and they were pretty horrified but I think I’m lucky that I’m still allowed to be in the house and to see my children.
Aibu for accommodating this and just accepting it’s the outcome of my actions?

OP posts:
Easterbunnyiswindowshopping · 09/03/2022 11:13

Calm before the storm ime.
Took me tears to rebuild the relationships with my dc after exh spent years poisoning them against me.
*if he hadn't raped and mentally abused me I most likely wouldn't have had an affair.
*if he hadn't been a closet gay man he may have actually been a dh to me and I wouldn't have cheated.
Be weary op. He may be biding his time.

Bananarama21 · 09/03/2022 11:03

Your lucky he's not ended the relationship you were deceitful in order to move forward he needs full disclosure its still new and he's still processing it.

Arabellla · 09/03/2022 11:00

@ValerieCupcake

I married someone after knowing him 6 months. I never should have married him there were red flags everywhere. But I did and I was unhappy with him being mean, shouting and bullying. After a year or so of marriage I went out with someone else. Just a few dates, not an affair. I kissed him but no sex. The guy was only 20 and I was 3 years older at the time. My husband found out and hit me and I fell into the bed frame and bruised my face. His mother said I deserved it for cheating. He controlled everything I did. He said I was not allowed to see my friends, as they were on the hunt for men. (They weren’t). He drove me to and from work and to the running club I was in. He controlled things financially (all my income went into the mortgage on our flat and running it). He never shut up about what I “had done”. He went into my workplace and told my boss about what I “had done” and kicked off there. The “other man” was transferred to another branch as a result which he didn’t want. The next year or so was filled with constant reminders with bullying and abusive behaviour. He beat me up and raped me. I apparently deserved it because of “what you did”. I was only allowed to see friends if he could go into town too and follow me from one venue to another to check I was not “up to something”. This went on for another 9 years. I was terrified to leave. He said nobody would want anything to do with me. He would make sure they all knew what I had done. I wish I had left.
This sounds horrific. Flowers I’m so glad you’re out of that.

OP, this is the trajectory you will be in. Don’t beat yourself for years because of this, or allow him to.

Do you think if he had cheated he would allow you to monitor his phone and going’s and comings? 100% no chance

He now thinks he has you on a leash for life.

77kidsandcounting · 09/03/2022 10:59

@ValerieCupcake please tell me you have left now?

ComeOnSpringtime · 09/03/2022 10:59

@Shesmyperson

I think post affair yiu do need to be open and honest and as transparent as possible. But not forever.

However, the whole you now can't go anywhere, do anything, can't see your kids if you leave etc sounds concerning.

Either he is an abusive bastard. Or you are rewriting what's going on in the hops of getting sympathy off people.

Either way, all the counselling in the world isn't going to help. I don't know what to suggest because it sounds like you wouldn't leave even if you can and this sounds like it's heading to a complete disaster.

My actual advice would be that you need to leave, that this doesn't mean you can't see your kids, but the marriage needs to end.

This is really what I was saying - you said it better.
77kidsandcounting · 09/03/2022 10:56

Oh OP, please get out of this relationship. Affair or no affair he has not right to control your life, saying you cant go out on your own? That's no life to live.

Please seek help to get you and your kids out of this unhealthy relationship. My heart is actually breaking for you, I can see why you did what you did

Quartz2208 · 09/03/2022 10:50

Having an affair is a terrible thing to do - it does not make you a terrible person who deserves to be punished forever.

Not allowed out apart from to work isnt a life and it isnt fair on him to ask. If he needs that amount of control and oversee of your life to the extent where you are feeling so beholden to him it isnt a marriage.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/03/2022 10:49

When there are affairs I think you either need to cut your ties and leave, or decide you have to trust that the person won't do it again. I do not think tracking and reading all your messages is acceptable, if he feels the need to do that then there is no marriage to save and he should leave you.

MunchyMonsters · 09/03/2022 10:46

I don't condone what you did but you can't live like this.

Why would you lose your children ?

Wnikat · 09/03/2022 10:45

So you're not allowed out of the house and you're not allowed any privacy? Why do you want to stay in this marriage? Did you have an affair because he's a controlling arsehole, by any chance?

Lifeissuch · 09/03/2022 10:45

It’s such a hard one op, I feel for both of you. As being on the other side of being cheated on (by previous partner) i asked if it was possible to see their phone whenever I felt anxious but didn’t actually look, but knowing I could made me feel more at ease (it’s psychological I guess).

You might have to be willing to give it a time frame of the ‘monitoring’ but make it clear it won’t be healthy for you both to live like this forever, he will need to let you get on living an unmonitored life at some point.

It’s a rubbish thing what you did but you owned up to it (most cheaters don’t and make you feel like you’re going crazy) and you’re trying to make it right so please don’t beat yourself up for it forever.

ValerieCupcake · 09/03/2022 10:42

I married someone after knowing him 6 months. I never should have married him there were red flags everywhere. But I did and I was unhappy with him being mean, shouting and bullying. After a year or so of marriage I went out with someone else. Just a few dates, not an affair. I kissed him but no sex. The guy was only 20 and I was 3 years older at the time. My husband found out and hit me and I fell into the bed frame and bruised my face. His mother said I deserved it for cheating. He controlled everything I did. He said I was not allowed to see my friends, as they were on the hunt for men. (They weren’t). He drove me to and from work and to the running club I was in. He controlled things financially (all my income went into the mortgage on our flat and running it). He never shut up about what I “had done”. He went into my workplace and told my boss about what I “had done” and kicked off there. The “other man” was transferred to another branch as a result which he didn’t want. The next year or so was filled with constant reminders with bullying and abusive behaviour. He beat me up and raped me. I apparently deserved it because of “what you did”. I was only allowed to see friends if he could go into town too and follow me from one venue to another to check I was not “up to something”. This went on for another 9 years. I was terrified to leave. He said nobody would want anything to do with me. He would make sure they all knew what I had done. I wish I had left.

Star81 · 09/03/2022 10:42

So you are staying in a marriage where

  • you said things hadn't been great even before your affair
  • your not allowed not to go out alone
  • you may be tracked wherever you go
  • your acted you may have been killed if he had found out about the affair

So why do you want to stay married ? If it’s for the children your assuming you’d lose them. Courts don’t award custody based on who had an affair .

What happens long term when the children leave home ?

ComeOnSpringtime · 09/03/2022 10:25

You don’t think being worried that she’d be kicked out of the house, threatened, never allowed to see her kids or even killed are signs that maybe there’s been some coercive control going on?

Where did I say this in any of my post? You seem to enjoy putting words in my mouth or assuming. I, too, have no issues to project but you seem all too heated up for no reason - or perhaps, there's a reason for it.

Of course, what you wrote is controlling and dangerous but did I mention that in my post? Was that what I said wasn't abuse? Or did you just add it there to make your accusation sound better?

If OP genuinely has those concerns, then she shouldn't even stay with someone like that whether he's checking her phone or not. Her life is in danger. Why mention the affair as if it's the problem when there is a much bigger one.

Anyway, I'll leave you to it before you accuse me of worse.

GoogleWhacked · 09/03/2022 10:22

While I understand that he needs to build trust again, I think he is using this as a stick to beat you with.
Where does it stop? When does it stop? He can't keep this up forever. Are you never allowed to have a private conversation ever again?
Think long and hard about your future - what do you want? If you both want to stay together you need to start rebuilding the trust, but he doesn't need access all areas to your life.

aSofaNearYou · 09/03/2022 10:22

No it isn't reasonable, though it's understandable that he doesn't trust you, but putting everything together he sounds quite controlling and scary. I don't think continuing the marriage sounds healthy all around.

And seperating should never mean you can't see your kids.

ANameChangeAgain · 09/03/2022 10:20

Your marriage is over. You need to go to a solicitor and arrange split of assets and formalise an agreement regarding your children. If you are frightened you need to call the police.

BertieQueen · 09/03/2022 10:19

You was wrong for having the affair and you know it but what’s done is done it’s time to move on.

Obviously trust is shattered when you cheat on a partner and it does take time to rebuild, but no one should be a prisoner where they can be tracked 24/7 and unable to leave the house alone. That is no life and is in fact abuse.

The marriage is over you need to both move on. As for being lucky to see your children that was a stupid comment, you are their mum and just because you were foolish to have an affair doesn’t mean you suddenly stop being that.

BobbinHood · 09/03/2022 10:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating deleted message. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

PinaColada123456 · 09/03/2022 10:16

OP this is NOT reasonable and fair. This man sounds dangerous, very very dangerous if he wants to track your car. Do you still go to counselling with him? If so I would bring that up at the next session, guaranteed the counsellor will shut down that level of control from him quick smart. You need to get away from him. Having your EVERY MOVE TRACKED for the rest of your marriage is no way to live, and way out of proportion to the crime you committed. Make plans to leave. And you'd naturally be taking the children with you, right? So why would he stop you from seeing them when you're the primary carer and they would live with you? He'd get visitation. That's all he'd get. Please get away from him now, he is making you suffer and pay for the rest of your life. Controlling your every move and where you can go and when is NOT NORMAL or HEALTHY.

BobbinHood · 09/03/2022 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating deleted message. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Aquamarine1029 · 09/03/2022 10:15

Your husband can not take your children away from you because you had an affair. It simply won't happen.

ComeOnSpringtime · 09/03/2022 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Pluvia · 09/03/2022 10:13

OP, when you say you can't leave the house on your own, what do you mean? Can you leave the house to go to work? Can you leave the house to go shopping or to visit a friend? Can you go for a walk in the park or wherever?

ComeOnSpringtime · 09/03/2022 10:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.