Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is reasonable and fair?

142 replies

Woollensheep · 09/03/2022 09:37

I had an affair - yes I know. I am a terrible awful person who deserves to be miserable forever.
I told DH about it because we went to marriage counselling as things had not been great for about a decade.
He took it better than I expected initially - he wasn’t over the top angry and he didn’t throw me out or threaten me or anything. He said that he could see why it had happened.
This was about six months ago.
However he’s now saying he wants to be able to track my phone / car at all times, have all my passwords and be able to read all messages I send / receive.
My affair is over so there’s no ‘issue’ exactly, although I don’t love him reading messages I send to my friends for no particular reason really.
I told a couple of my friends about what DH had said and they were pretty horrified but I think I’m lucky that I’m still allowed to be in the house and to see my children.
Aibu for accommodating this and just accepting it’s the outcome of my actions?

OP posts:
BeHappy91818 · 09/03/2022 12:22

He can’t take your kids away from you affair or no affair.

I wouldn’t agree to never going out on my own either. That’s stupid.

TheCatWearsPrada · 09/03/2022 12:19

Of course it's unreasonable to track your every move and honestly like it or not your relationship is over. He can't trust you because you've already proved that you can't be trusted.
Your actions have destroyed your relationship. The best thing you could do is walk away from him

ValerieCupcake · 09/03/2022 12:04

[quote 77kidsandcounting]@ValerieCupcake please tell me you have left now?[/quote]
Yes when I said I wish I had left, I meant at 23 not 33.

whynotwhatknot · 09/03/2022 12:03

In a way i dont blame him for not trusting you for now but tracking your car and forbiding you to go out alone is too far

Has he told you he would stop you seeing your children if you left-because he cant

Leftbutcameback · 09/03/2022 12:02

I don’t think he was actually feeling reasonable, he’s hidden his anger and distrust which is coming out now in his actions. What did the counsellor say about it?

CornishGem1975 · 09/03/2022 11:56

Nope. Regardless of having an affair - I would never ever agree to that. He has made the decision to continue the relationship with you so he needs to learn to trust you. If he can't do that without tracking and checking, then he needs to end the relationship and move on.

Thewindwhispers · 09/03/2022 11:53

That isn’t a marriage, OP.

Your DH needs to decide if he can forgive you and trust you - or not. Reading your phone and tracking you etc is a slippery slope and creepy stalkerish revenge-type behaviour that is more likely to drive you away than heal the marriage.

It sounds like he is punishing you and you, out of guilt, are encouraging him to. That ain’t a healthy marriage.

Go back to counselling and pay the counsellor £70 to tell you that the marriage will fail unless you can genuinely learn to forgive and trust each other again. Or take it from me and save yourself £70 🤷‍♀️

Notallcatsarenicecats · 09/03/2022 11:45

*you

Notallcatsarenicecats · 09/03/2022 11:44

He has lost trust with you.

He'll never be able to trust you again.
He won't forget, which means he can't forgive him. Isnt it best that you leave the family home because you're the one who broke the family up.
He doesn't have the right to keep the kids from you though.

jeaux90 · 09/03/2022 11:44

OP you need to know that coercive control is against the law.

You having an affair is irrelevant to your rights of access to your kids or divorce outcomes.

Please consider divorce, he sounds like a controlling bully.

wheresthespatula · 09/03/2022 11:42

I think coming home and having a play-by-play of your day sounds reasonable. "X-Y-Z happened and for lunch I had a tuna sandwich" sort of thing. But tracking you? Nope I wouldnt stand for that, I'd be off like a shot

SpanishPapers · 09/03/2022 11:39

A lot of people posting without apparently RTFT.

PurpleDaisies · 09/03/2022 11:39

@saleorbouy

This is his way of dealing with your dishonesty and secretive behaviour which enabled you to conduct an affair. In time as he learns to perhaps trust you again then he'll likely have less need to check up on you. I think he's been more than reasonable in the circumstances.
You think it’s reasonable for someone to need to know where their partner is at all times? To read all their emails and texts? Really?

Regardless of what the op has done, nobody should have to submit to that.

noirchatsdeux · 09/03/2022 11:37

I voted YABU for one reason - this is no way for anyone to live.

My father started cheating on my mother before I had even started primary school. My mother stayed with him, but never 'forgave' him and ruined mine and my two brother's childhood by following him around the world so she could keep an eye on him. It's a long story I've posted about numerous times on here.

Everyone in my family would have been far better off if their marriage had ended when we were all young. As it was my father ended up leaving my mother for another woman as soon as my younger brother turned 18.

End this farce now.

saleorbouy · 09/03/2022 11:34

This is his way of dealing with your dishonesty and secretive behaviour which enabled you to conduct an affair. In time as he learns to perhaps trust you again then he'll likely have less need to check up on you.
I think he's been more than reasonable in the circumstances.

Nameisjustaname · 09/03/2022 11:31

If I thought he might kill me I would be worried that in the not too distant future I may have an 'accident..

Time to get out now.

Sittingonabench · 09/03/2022 11:30

Look you made a bad decision and it will have hurt him. His trust will be broken and will take time and effort to rebuild. However you are crossing into abusive behaviour - you can’t go out on your own - only to work and for childcare. This will become a pressure cooker and one of you will break. Go to marriage counselling, agree boundaries and what you are prepared to do now but that it will be reviewed. E.g. for now reading messages is ok but when you no longer feel it is it stops. You should never feel like you can’t leave your house on your own - that is totally abusive. Yes tell him where you’re going and with who but do go out. If he can’t rebuild trust over time (which is understandable) then you will both need to call it a day

ValerieCupcake · 09/03/2022 11:29

[quote 77kidsandcounting]@ValerieCupcake please tell me you have left now?[/quote]
God yes years ago!

TakeYourFinalPosition · 09/03/2022 11:27

You've posted about this before, I think. I remember your phrasing.

The problem isn't the affair. It's that both of you know that this a loveless marriage, and that you're both there for convenience. And now he suddenly can't trust that this is convenient enough for you to stay; and he's worried you'll move on and he'll be blindsided.

That doesn't mean he can control everything you do, or read all your messages. It'll stop being enough at some point, anyway. It's a horrendous scale. Right now he's happy to read your messages and track your car to make sure you're at work. Then sooner or later your tracker will be an inch out because of the rain and it'll look like you're elsewhere, or he'll start to wonder if you're having an affair with a colleague, or his brain will tell him that he doesn't know enough anymore, and you won't be allowed out of his sight...

This is over, you both know it.

Arabellla · 09/03/2022 11:26

@ComeOnSpringtime

I agree and that's what I was trying to say too but apparently, OP has given more info. It's now known to be so much more than that and he's being abusive. So the marriage shouldn't even be encouraged any more.

It ws obvious from the first post that he was abusive.

Gowithme · 09/03/2022 11:24

When the trust is broken I understand the wish for more transparency - but this sounds like it has tipped over into him trying to have power over you in an abusive way. For example, knowing you are ok with him asking to check your phone is one thing - doing it religiously with every message you get is not. Asking you not to go out getting slaughtered late night at clubs is one thing, saying you can't even go for a coffee with a girlfriend is another. Tracking your car sounds like it's getting really obsessive.

On the other hand your attitude to your affair is very strange, 'the affair's over so there's no issue' has zero empathy or understanding for the impact of an affair on the other person. There is nothing approaching genuine remorse - or even that you regret it and want to work with him to move past it. There's a detached feeling and no talking about love.

It seems to me this has been miserable for a long time, it's now even more miserable but you feel lucky? The dynamic is way off here, there's something really wrong in all this - your emotions are really off and he is tipping over into abusive. I think you need to get out OP this all sounds really messed up.

BadBear · 09/03/2022 11:24

How exactly do you think this will work as a partnership moving forward if you have zero trust from the man you're with. Yes you did a bad thing but surely the idea of working through therapy is to re-develop the trust not an unhealthy controlling behaviour from his side.

Greyarea12 · 09/03/2022 11:24

I have to start with - why do you think you are lucky to still be able to see your children? Yes you done wrong but it does not qualify for being unable to see your children. It is your right to be able to see your children and if your husband did decide to end your marriage, unless there was a genuine safeguarding issue, then he would have no right what so ever to stop you seeing your children, nor would he legally get away with keeping your children from you if you went down the legal route for access to your children.

I don't think the way forward is for him to be controlling. If he can't trust you, then I'm sorry but it likely won't work in the long run. He has to learn to build up trust again and I don't think invading your privacy is the way to do that.

ComeOnSpringtime · 09/03/2022 11:19

@Bananarama21

Your lucky he's not ended the relationship you were deceitful in order to move forward he needs full disclosure its still new and he's still processing it.
I agree and that's what I was trying to say too but apparently, OP has given more info. It's now known to be so much more than that and he's being abusive. So the marriage shouldn't even be encouraged any more.
irishfarmer · 09/03/2022 11:15

What does the counsellor say about him tracking your movements?