Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should tell someone that they have a terminal illness even if they have learning disabilities?

131 replies

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 22:47

This is probably not the best place to discuss this but I don’t feel like I can talk to anyone and I really need some advice. The lady in question has cancer and learning disabilities. She manages to be quite independent despite her disabilities, and has a basic understanding of life and death. She doesn’t know she has cancer and that it is terminal, and they’re not going to tell her. I just don’t know how I feel about this, it doesn’t feel right. Please be kind as I have looked after this women for many years and I am devastated. She’s not even very old.

OP posts:
shreddednips · 09/03/2022 00:48

It's clear from your post that you care so deeply for this lady, and I'm sorry to hear about her diagnosis. I hope she can spend her remaining days as comfortably and happily as possible and that you also have someone to support you. I used to be a carer for adults with SEN, and it's incredibly upsetting when someone you care for so much gets so sick.

All I would say is that there could be very good reasons that she isn't being told. I agree with you in principle that people should generally be told the truth about their prognosis so that they can make preparations and decisions, but that's not always going to be the right thing for every person. The news of a terminal prognosis would be distressing for anyone, but the question is whether she would be able to cope emotionally with the knowledge and whether there would be effective ways to support her through her distress.

What I mean is that the problem is, it might not be clear what the answers to these questions are until she's told. I think it would be very difficult for her and the people who care for her if she is told and it turns out that she becomes very distressed and that nothing gives her peace or comfort, and at that point there would be no way to untell her if it turned out to be the wrong decision. As a PP described, these are complex decisions, and I think that there's more potential harm to be done by telling than not telling.

I wonder if there is someone that you could speak to to help you process your feelings about this. I think in your situation, I would trust the conclusions of her medical team to be in her best interests. But I know it's really hard when you care for someone so much Thanks

DietrichandDiMaggio · 09/03/2022 00:45

To those people who say she has a right to know, would you say the same about a young child, because, depending on her capacity, that may well be the equivalent. Would you insist that a 5 year old child should be told that they were going to die in the near future?

tintodeverano2 · 09/03/2022 00:25

How would it benefit her to know?

OP, I think you're being a little selfish here. If they told her that she was terminally ill, would she have the capacity to understand? Does she have capacity to agree/deny medical treatment?

Yes, you are upset that someone you care for is dying, but your wish that they know that they are dying surely would not be good for them, you're only thinking of how you would feel. They may give up an die sooner than they would've done if they were none the wiser. Ignorance is bliss as they say... let her enjoy her life as it is rather than hanging a cloud over what time she has left.

Sapphireskies · 09/03/2022 00:15

To me as well OP that is so wrong that she doesn't know. She has the right to know. I feel they should at least attempt to gently tell her. Heartbreaking. I truly hope the rest of her life is as enjoyable, and comfortable as possible Thanks

cuno · 09/03/2022 00:11

OP I would think this decision was not taken lightly.

If it were me, of course I'd want to know. It would be devastating, sure. But it would be necessary for me to know so I can get my affairs in order. I'd probably marry my partner and try to create lots of happy memories before I die especially for my daughter. Even though it would be painful and shocking, I would be able to cope and make the most of the time I have left, that's the kind of person I am.

As someone who has supported various people with learning disabilities in care, I can think of some people who would be better off not knowing. One man in particular comes to mind, I just know if he were to be told he's terminally ill it would be absolutely earth-shattering in a way that's not conceivable for you and me. I just know the rest of his days would be spent in torment with great pain and suffering and not an ounce of happiness. This is a man who cannot cope with even the knowledge of a doctor's appointment, he cannot be told anything in advance because he puts his life on hold for whatever it is and is filled with the worst anxiety until that event passes. So what good would it be telling him he is terminally ill? I think his head would explode with that knowledge. I suspect the decision was made for the man you care for because of similar reasons.

Pissedoff22 · 09/03/2022 00:03

@Theunamedcat

Your self righteous and indignant behaviour is uncalled for this isnt your decision to make and it isn't about you and what you would want

There are many reasons to withold information like this some people would not cope they would withdraw do you really want to see them turn in on themselves? You don't want to see them suffer right?

My nan had dementia she would get lost in the past talk about my grandad and parties she went to "last week" there are many people who wanted to remind her that he died 20 years prior that her friends were dead that her dog was dead but that woukd be the same as her reliving his death over and over again and for what? To make them feel better? Make someone sad for no reason other than the vague feelings its the "right" thing to do? Nope no way I left her to enjoy her parties to wait for her husband she was happy to her he came home every night took her places she was happy

There’s no need for the personal attack. It may not be my decision but that doesn’t mean I can’t ask question. It may not be up to me but that doesn’t mean I have to agree with it. We try and provide a high standard of care, and sometimes it is necessary to ask questions in order to achieve this. It’s not like I’ve said I’m going to tell them. I’m just working through my own thoughts and feelings on this, I know it not about me but you cannot expect me to be totally unaffected. It’s still hard for us as carers but we continue to do this job that many of you wouldn’t consider because we care. I’d be a pretty shite carer if I didn’t care. I’m sorry about your grandmother but this person doesn’t have dementia so I don’t think it’s a fair comparison.
OP posts:
ChangeNameagain2 · 08/03/2022 23:56

I'm a palliative care specialist. In regards to individuals with learning disabilities, it is not straightforward at all. And it's also not an individual decision. There is far too much to go into, you could do some reading online which might give you a better grasp of why she hasn't been told and palliative care in LD in general. There is no way to say, even from your posts if she should have been told or not.

I'm sorry you have had this shock, it's easy to see you care greatly for her. I did have an autistic patient who was told her diagnosis a few years ago. She was living independently, minimal care input, workong, but it was horrendous. The anxiety linked with her asd, need for routine, for control was completely thrown. She couldn't control her health or diagnosis and went from living alone to having to have sheltered accommodation. She was an absolute mess of anxiety, meltdowns etc. It was very distressing for her, the family and our team. We had to put alot of services and mental health support in place. When we reviewed this case in supervision a while later, it was easy to see the wrong decision was made. She died, quite simply terrified. She couldn't make peace with her diagnosis at all. And in my experience making peace with it and letting go of the fear and terror is one of the keys to a peaceful death.
At the time though, and input from family etc she obviously was told. As I say, it's a very very gray area where every patient will have a different approach.

Maverickess · 08/03/2022 23:55

OP - you're not 'just' a carer. You're someone who clearly has the best interests of someone you care for at heart, which is care 101, it's the part of the job that can't be taught.

This sounds like a best interests decisions, made by the lady's legal guardians and I can understand why you're conflicted by it considering your description of those involved in the decision making process.

But, would it be of benefit or detriment for the lady to know about her diagnosis? I'd be leaning towards not telling her if it will cause greater alarm and distress to her because of the learning disabilities, than if those disabilities were not present.
You're right that anyone is going to be distressed by a terminal diagnosis, but the level of possible extra distress this lady may face due to her disability needs to be considered.

I'm sorry you're struggling to deal with this 💐

Theunamedcat · 08/03/2022 23:55

Your self righteous and indignant behaviour is uncalled for this isnt your decision to make and it isn't about you and what you would want

There are many reasons to withold information like this some people would not cope they would withdraw do you really want to see them turn in on themselves? You don't want to see them suffer right?

My nan had dementia she would get lost in the past talk about my grandad and parties she went to "last week" there are many people who wanted to remind her that he died 20 years prior that her friends were dead that her dog was dead but that woukd be the same as her reliving his death over and over again and for what? To make them feel better? Make someone sad for no reason other than the vague feelings its the "right" thing to do? Nope no way I left her to enjoy her parties to wait for her husband she was happy to her he came home every night took her places she was happy

MarmiteCoriander · 08/03/2022 23:53

OP- this obviously is very sad news, and must a shock for you. It concerns me that as her carer, you come across as believing its her right to know- even if it would be more upsetting for her, cause confusion, distress and anxiety.

Many of us have asked 'what benefit is it for her to know??? Yet you can't even come up with 1 answer, other than its her right to know! Confused

What is her mental age? IF the medical team decide to tell her, it would be done in a way that say a 5yr old, 10yr old etc might understand. I would sleep on it, and speak to your manager about your concerns. I would hope your manager has more experience of similar situations than you do, and might be able to explain it to you in a way YOU can understand.

Hankunamatata · 08/03/2022 23:49

Does she understand she is unwell? Do you know if they have tried to explain her illness at all? They may have tried but she didn't have the capacity to cope.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/03/2022 23:49

A member of my family wasn't told for the same reason. She knew she was ill that's all,anything else would've scared her. It was the right decision.

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 23:47

@WorkingItOutAsIGo

OP: I suspect your focus on this is displacement for your own grief. So May I extend my sympathy to you on hearing such sad news about someone you care for and have known so long. It must be hard to process. I hope she is comfortable and pain free, and I wish you all the best for supporting her on the journey to come. I hope that you will get some support from someone too xxx
I suspect you’re probably right
OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 08/03/2022 23:45

I think this is a very difficult situation and I understand your view.

On the other hand, you do sound a bit as if you’re on some sort of disability rights campaign as opposed to purely thinking about what would be kindest for your client.

It’s the sort of thing that gets tested in court, isn’t it? I wonder if there have been previous cases that have set a precedent. Maybe do a bit of research.

Nelliephant1 · 08/03/2022 23:44

Just because people have a right to know doesn't mean that telling them is the right thing to do. It may be that she wouldn't want to know.

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 08/03/2022 23:43

OP: I suspect your focus on this is displacement for your own grief. So May I extend my sympathy to you on hearing such sad news about someone you care for and have known so long. It must be hard to process. I hope she is comfortable and pain free, and I wish you all the best for supporting her on the journey to come. I hope that you will get some support from someone too xxx

FantasticFebruary · 08/03/2022 23:39

What would she do differently is she knew?

I have several people in my life with SEN None of them would benefit from knowing as they're living the only way they can already- they wouldn't understand the concept of bucket list. They'd still have pizza for dinner every night & they'd still play the exact same computer game/paint/whatever. None of them have the capacity to live a better life than they do right now!

So there's absolutely nothing to be gained by telling them. Some would shrug & some would be utterly distressed!

Why out them through that?

Just help your lady to make the most if everyday 😊

BoredZelda · 08/03/2022 23:38

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them.

A large part of that is so they can make a decision about their care. Will this person be doing that?

BoredZelda · 08/03/2022 23:36

She may have a learning disability and need care, but she should be treated as a whole human being with the same rights as anyone else.

Which is something I’m sure her medical and care team looking after her have balanced that in their decision.

You don’t need to agree with their decision but you do need to make peace with it, because you can’t do anything about it.

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 23:35

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them. I don’t understand how this is different when I know she will understand. I will do my utmost to support her regardless but I can’t help but feel like this is wrong. I just needed somewhere to speak anonymously as I feel sick and I can’t sleep.

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 08/03/2022 23:33

@Pissedoff22

what good would it actually do anyway

Well if it was me then it probably wouldn’t do any good but I’d still want to know.

What benefit is there to her of knowing? That’s what it comes down to.
Viviennemary · 08/03/2022 23:32

I would be leaning towards she should not be told.

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 23:28

@StoppinBy

OP,

What do you think the benefits are for her if she is told?

What do you think the negatives are for her if she is told?

I think that answering those questions will give you more clarity.

If the negative outweighs the benefit then would you personally want to know?

I would want to know because it would give me time to prepare my children and to make sure I did everything I could to give them a bright, happy future even though I wouldn't be there to support them through it. Honestly though if I didn't have kids and there were no treatment options available, I would rather just not know, it would just put a dark cloud over the final stage of my life for no benefit at all to me.

Thanks. I will have a think. Write it down. I guess I just feel like it’s her right to not have vital information withheld.
OP posts:
RonCarlos · 08/03/2022 23:27

I imagine she isn't being told for a reason which is based on evidence. I think it is difficult for you as you are her carer and emotionally involved so it is natural for you to question it. I am really sorry OP - I'd be really upset too.

PermanentTemporary · 08/03/2022 23:26

This person might have views on where they would like to die. At the very least. And most of us have views on medical treatment depending on what it does for us.