Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should tell someone that they have a terminal illness even if they have learning disabilities?

131 replies

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 22:47

This is probably not the best place to discuss this but I don’t feel like I can talk to anyone and I really need some advice. The lady in question has cancer and learning disabilities. She manages to be quite independent despite her disabilities, and has a basic understanding of life and death. She doesn’t know she has cancer and that it is terminal, and they’re not going to tell her. I just don’t know how I feel about this, it doesn’t feel right. Please be kind as I have looked after this women for many years and I am devastated. She’s not even very old.

OP posts:
Elmo230885 · 09/03/2022 07:15

Hi,

In this situation there should be someone coordinating her care. As this is such a big life event/decision they would need to do a mental capacity assessment or possibly multiple mental capacity assessments.
These should be done as a multi-team approach and involve the person concerned, where appropriate, their family and relevant professionals.
There are 5 principles to look at-
1 - presume capacity unless the person is deemed not to have capacity
2 - the person should be supported to make decisions where possible e.g. presenting the information in an appropriate manner
3 - they should be allowed to make decisions you/me may consider 'unwise'
4 - decisions made must be in the persons 'best interests'
5 - the least restrictive option must be taken

In short, one person can't just decide not to tell her.

Hope this helps a little, your line manager may be the best starting point for you to make sure all things have been considered.

Chicaontour · 09/03/2022 07:14

I lost a beautiful very young adult who I loved dearly. She had treatment for 4 years. The doctors advised against telling her that she terminal as it would likely she would have a panic attack and traumatic passing. I would like to know to allow me to make plans however if the person has limited understanding I believe that it would cause them great distress and ruin the time she has. I am sorry for the pain you are going through. Daffodil

balalake · 09/03/2022 07:11

I think the person should know, unless there is a very good reason, dependent on the nature of their disability.

RandomBasic · 09/03/2022 07:08

People with dementia often ask for their husband or wife. Rather than say 'they died' and have the person cry until they ask again the next day, they are often told they've 'gone to the shop' the person asking forgets and doesn't ask again.

Treating people equally and with respect does not mean treating them the same. For me, a weekend at chess camp was a dream. For my brother a weekend at football camp was great. If you had forced us both to go to the other it would have been torture.

Just because you would want to know doesn't mean she should be told.

She will be upset and distressed. Perhaps they will tell her when she is bedbound.

You can still say "Jenny, write me a list of your favourite people in the world so that we can facetime them more."

"Jenny what are your ten favourite things to eat?"

"Jenny, if you could visit anywhere in the world where would you like to go? The seaside? I think we can arrange that."

So the can have the bucket list experience without the distress.

picklemewalnuts · 09/03/2022 07:00

Bear in mind that the decision not to tell her isn't a 'once and forever' decision. If her situation changes, the decision may change. It may become clearer in future that she does want and need to know.

I looked after children with emotional difficulties who needed support to process difficult things. There were times when we didn't tell them about coming events until the last minute, in order to allow them to enjoy each day. If they knew about a holiday booked, for example, they'd become very erratic- unable to sleep, over excited, anxious- and day to day life would be trying for them and us.

We'd trail what was going to happen without actually announcing it. Lots of work was done on preparation, then at an appropriate time beforehand we'd give the detail. So we'd buy clothes 'for the summer', talk about singing songs in the car 'if we were on a long journey' etc. When they found out about the trip, they already knew they had appropriate clothes, games for the car, etc.

If they knew too soon, it would stop them coping with day to day life and they'd have no benefit of the knowledge. Perhaps it's the same for your lady. Perhaps the people who have made the decision have seen similar situations before that inform their action.

I'm sorry for your sadness. I'm sure as she becomes less well, there will be opportunities to support her helpfully. It's very sad and she's lucky to have someone who cares about her as you do.

TheHoptimist · 09/03/2022 06:59

An assessment has to be made in line with care act and mental capacity act

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/03/2022 06:57

@XenoBitch

I recall having a patient that had dementia.... and he was admitted for investigations into a potential cancer. He had no idea what was going on at all. It was awful. He had no family to say what should happen either way.
There wouldn’t be much point in giving any bad or distressing news to most people with dementia, when they’re only going to forget so quickly anyway. We soon learned to stop explaining (however gently) to my FiL that MiL had died 10 years previously, when it was only going to distress him to the point of tears - only for him to forget and ask again half an hour later where she was. So she’d ‘gone to the shops’ or ‘to visit Auntie So-and-So.’ In dementia-carer circles these are called ‘love lies’.
seashellsunderthesand · 09/03/2022 06:22

@Pissedoff22

She may have a learning disability and need care, but she should be treated as a whole human being with the same rights as anyone else.
I don't think that not being privy to your own medical care means that you are in any way less human. Knowledge is not quintessentially positive, we encourage it to be in control of our own lives and make decisions based on various factors, however we also accept the negative aspects which come with it, and often, in situations where we have little or no control, they out way the positives. We don't tell small children, what would they gain, it doesn't make them in any way less human , less respected or less loved.
GlamorousHeifer · 09/03/2022 06:03

If she was told and her anxiety took over meaning she spent the last few months of her life screaming and having meltdown after meltdown how would you feel about it then?

Woolandwonder · 09/03/2022 05:31

It's a complex one and you obviously really care about the person,I hope a lot of thought has gone into the decision based on the person's best interests.
My sister has learning disabilities, generally she's v involved in her medical care, although doesn't fully understand things is supported to have all the information she can manage. I'm not sure whether it would be in her best interests to know that she was terminally ill, I'd definitely want her to know she had cancer to try and help her understand any treatments and appointments she was going to, but she may find being told she is going to die very distressing and frightening (as a lot of people do!) but might really struggle to cope emotionally.

LovelaceBiggWither · 09/03/2022 04:34

My child has a lifelimiting illness. They know nothing about it and I am hoping to keep it that. He had major surgery last year and came close to dying and he doesn't know that either, he just knows he was very ill.

With his LDs and his autism, it would be a cruelty to tell him. He would spin into acute anxiety and the condition would rule his every minute of every day. He's much better off without knowing.

SofiaAmes · 09/03/2022 03:02

There is a fantastic movie from 2019 called The Farewell that deals with the cultural aspects of telling or not telling someone that they are dying of cancer. I certainly made me think twice about my preconceived ideas about the subject. Perhaps it might give you some solace, OP.

movingsoon13 · 09/03/2022 03:01

Also, just to add apparently thanatophobia is quite common in ASD. This is the question of quality of life and as long as you can ensure that pain is managed, then the quality of life is much greater by not knowing.
Also please read my post directly above before commenting negatively.

movingsoon13 · 09/03/2022 02:58

I have a type of Autism formerly known as Asperger's and can still work and moderately function. I would prefer not to know if there is nothing more that can be done, as long as I wasn't in severe pain. As part of my OCD and anxiety, as a result of my autism I have thanatophobia, so actually not telling me would let me live a more positive life but everyone is different.

alexdgr8 · 09/03/2022 02:38

i think your reasoning, moral reasoning has become muddled, probably due to your own sadness at her diagnosis.
you seem to be asserting that she has a right to be distressed, as much as a non-disabled person would be by such knowledge.
actually i think things have swung too far towards telling everyone everything.
once spoken, it cannot be unheard.
even the way doctors have spoken to me about others' condition has caused me great distress.
i'm sure you want your client to have the best life possible, for as long as possible, and you will continue to enhance the enrichment of her life.

Suzi888 · 09/03/2022 01:56

No.
What for?
What good will it do?

I think some people give up when they find out, not everyone gets told- learning disability or not.

itsjustnotok · 09/03/2022 01:51

@Pissedoff22 this is a really difficult situation. For the most part yes everyone has a right to know they are dying but there are some situations where it’s best to decide on the basic of well-being for the individual. There are some people who might grasp elements of death but depending on the LD it might actually make their last days worse for a variety of reasons. It’s all based on individual ability to cope and whether it’s in their best interests and how extreme the LD is. You can say you would want to know but that’s your personal decision.

wombat1a · 09/03/2022 01:48

I think it comes down to 'how will it improve her life to know' and I can't really see the answer to that. She does not sound like someone with a bucket list of things to see and do and plans to make so how would knowing help her?

Christabellaxx · 09/03/2022 01:48

There may well be an argument for saying that everybody has a "right" to know the truth about their diagnosis. However that doesn't mean that all cases it's the right thing to do . It's impossible to know what would be best for the person you care for based solely on your interpretation of the circumstances, and how you would like to be informed personally.
I honestly think there is no right or wrong decision ... there will be equal arguments for and against telling her .... each one will have some validity.
You obviously care for her a great deal , and your practical support of her is what matters now - for her and for you . I'm so sorry you e been left in a conflicted situation .

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2022 01:48

To echo a PP, my DGM had severe mental health problems all her life - although not dementia - and she would tell us a whole load of what were, objectively, lies. Reports of what real people had 'told her' (via the voices in her head) and other random things that made no sense and were of course not true.

Now, we realised that she wasn't deliberately telling us lies - she was quite honestly telling us HER 'truth'. We could have firmly gainsaid her, described to her (in vain) logically why it wasn't true and told her to be away with her 'nonsense'. From our pov, we might have been happy 'setting the record straight' - but doing so would only have made us - the 'stronger' more privileged ones - feel better.

As we clearly saw no desire or value in making her more distressed - in her case, not just genuinely believing these voices but the added upset that we were calling her a liar, we naturally said nothing and just nodded along. There was a lot we didn't tell her - but only because it would have upset her to hear/know it and not helped her at all (possibly made her worse) if we had.

ShippingNews · 09/03/2022 01:44

Well if it was me then it probably wouldn’t do any good but I’d still want to know

You can't compare yourself to her . You are her carer and it's best if you just keep on caring for her and leave this to her family. It is never wise to go outside of your scope of practice .

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2022 01:40

To me as well OP that is so wrong that she doesn't know. She has the right to know. I feel they should at least attempt to gently tell her.

I don't want this to come out in the wrong way, but sometimes, we deliberately take away the rights of vulnerable people when we - with the privilege of much greater capacity - know that giving them that right would ultimately upset or hurt them more than not doing so.

Our toddlers do not belong to us - they're free individuals with their own rights, including the right to run into a road if they so want to. But those of us who know their interests 'better' than they do, and have a greater appreciation of the consequences, will grab at their hand, restrain them and deliberately deprive them of these 'rights' - out of pure love and care for them. Even with that safety net in place, we still would never tell them all the gory details of a horrific, painful death that could befall them if they get hit by a car - we just say "It isn't safe" and take the rest of the responsibility ourselves on their behalf.

I suppose there might be a dilemma in future, if this lady in question senses something is different and actively asks if she's going to be OK, or even if she's going to die; but if the people charged with her best interests genuinely believe that she would be more distressed by knowing than she is by being blissfully unaware - bearing in mind that plenty of people without any kind of learning challenges don't want to be told the whole story - telling her when she otherwise wouldn't know would be the active decision, and could actually mean that they have deliberately taken away her right to peace of mind.

Xpologog · 09/03/2022 01:28

@Pissedoff22

She may have a learning disability and need care, but she should be treated as a whole human being with the same rights as anyone else.
But knowing the full extent of her prognosis may not help her. If told the full extent of her illness but she be expected to make decisions and be able to cope with that? Slightly different situation, my friend’s father had Alzheimer’s when he was diagnosed with terminal cancer. If he had been told he would not have retained the information and a doctor explained it would hit him anew each time he was told. It could well be a shock and a grief over and over. He wasn’t told and all the family’s energies went into making his last months comfortable and as happy for him as possible.
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2022 01:18

She may have a learning disability and need care, but she should be treated as a whole human being with the same rights as anyone else.

But she needs to be treated as the whole human being that she is - there is no default 'whole human being' that applies to everybody.

As has been said, for most of us in her position, it would be a case of getting our affairs in order and making sure everything was known/passed on to our loved ones to take over. We'd know we couldn't stop the dying, but we'd focus on what we could take care of - indeed probably with a lot of worry. Her affairs are already looked after by others, so she has nothing to worry about there.

Rights come with responsibilities and, sadly, her inability to take on some of the latter already means that she also doesn't have equal of the former. To compare her case to children again, they don't have the right to decide on which house to buy/rent - how big, location, facilities, price etc. as this right is ultimately down to adults; but equally, when it comes to the concern of having to find the money to pay the mortgage/rent each month, and to meet all of the bills and put food on the table, the children also don't have any responsibility for that.

In fact, continuing with the likening of her circumstances to those of a child.... we shield children from films/documentaries telling stories of the harrowing deaths of other real people, because we know it would frighten and trouble them; so why would we dwell on telling them of their own deaths?

I'm with you: I would hate not to know if it were me, and I can see why you're wanting to defend her; but you and I are fortunate enough not to have learning disabilities and would be able to deal with the whole picture in a 'standard' adult way.

ItsDinah · 09/03/2022 01:04

I've never known anyone whose doctors told them outright they were dying. It is something that the patient pieces together from information about what is wrong with them and treatment plans. Occasionally people do ask doctors "how long have I got?". This is often asked with a view to making plans/arranging their affairs. The information you have is very private and I do not think you should discuss it with her. If she asks about her illness or prognosis, refer back to her doctors.