Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should tell someone that they have a terminal illness even if they have learning disabilities?

131 replies

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 22:47

This is probably not the best place to discuss this but I don’t feel like I can talk to anyone and I really need some advice. The lady in question has cancer and learning disabilities. She manages to be quite independent despite her disabilities, and has a basic understanding of life and death. She doesn’t know she has cancer and that it is terminal, and they’re not going to tell her. I just don’t know how I feel about this, it doesn’t feel right. Please be kind as I have looked after this women for many years and I am devastated. She’s not even very old.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 09/03/2022 09:12

It may not be my decision but that doesn’t mean I can’t ask question. It may not be up to me but that doesn’t mean I have to agree with it.

Actually you do have to agree with it. It's your job to agree with it. I understand that you don't like it, but you are not tje decision maker here.

Luredbyapomegranate · 09/03/2022 09:08

Very sorry you are going through this OP, and for your client.

It used to be quite common, a few decades ago, not to tell people. We don’t normally do that with adults now, but it’s still normal to let parents decide how much to tell terminally ill children.

You could certainly put your views forward to her care team. However, given she has limited understanding and no dependants it’s perfectly reasonable for them to have decided not to tell her. While you may feel you’d want to know, the view that there is no purpose to telling her because it could cause her needless distress in the time she has left is valid.

I think that you may be displacing your own grief here. Carers can get very close to clients. You may be finding it difficult that you can’t express your grief and sense of loss to her - but it would not be fair on her for you to do this.

Go and see your GP and ask for a referral for grief counselling - or talk to your agency/union if you have one (it may be quicker). Or Google local charities direct.

Get some support so you can continue to care for her as well as you can. Sounds like you are doing a great job.

RobinBlackbird · 09/03/2022 09:06

Honestly. It's difficult.
I've been told I've got cancer and what's more I have a genetic mutation that will make me prone to recurrence/ different cancers.
I think it's the second half of that has totally taken joy and hope from my life.
Having all the information doesn't make for a better quality of life.

saraclara · 09/03/2022 08:58

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them.

That's not actually true. I was there when my husband's oncologist spoke to him about his cancer diagnosis. Having talked about the extent of its spread, the doctor asked my DH how much he wanted to know. My DH said very clearly that he didn't want to know his prognosis in the sense of time or probable outcome. He wanted every bit of treatment available to him, but nothing else.

He only knew that he would die, when every bit of treatment had to be withdrawn, and his consultant mentioned contacting the hospice. That was 18 months later. Not knowing worked for my DH. It meant that he could live life 'normally' without the though if death in his mind constantly.

Mummytobe93 · 09/03/2022 08:54

www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/making-decisions-for-someone-else/mental-capacity-act/

“ Examples of people who may lack capacity include those with:

dementia
a severe learning disability
a brain injury
a mental health illness
a stroke
unconsciousness caused by an anaesthetic or sudden accident
But just because a person has one of these health conditions does not necessarily mean they lack the capacity to make a specific decision.

Someone can lack capacity to make some decisions (for example, to decide on complex financial issues) but still have the capacity to make other decisions (for example, to decide what items to buy at the local shop).

The MCA says:

assume a person has the capacity to make a decision themselves, unless it's proved otherwise
wherever possible, help people to make their own decisions
do not treat a person as lacking the capacity to make a decision just because they make an unwise decision
if you make a decision for someone who does not have capacity, it must be in their best interests
treatment and care provided to someone who lacks capacity should be the least restrictive of their basic rights and freedoms
The MCA also allows people to express their preferences for care and treatment, and to appoint a trusted person to make a decision on their behalf should they lack capacity in the future.

People should also be provided with an independent advocate, who will support them to make decisions in certain situations, such as serious treatment or where the individual might have significant restrictions placed on their freedom and rights in their best interests.”

Basically you can’t just assume someone lacks capacity in all aspects of life. Each decision should be assessed separately.

AngelinaFibres · 09/03/2022 08:41

@Pissedoff22

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them. I don’t understand how this is different when I know she will understand. I will do my utmost to support her regardless but I can’t help but feel like this is wrong. I just needed somewhere to speak anonymously as I feel sick and I can’t sleep.
My husband lost his late wife when she was 38. She had cancer. The doctor said to my husband that if a direct question was asked by the patient,regarding their prognosis, then that question would be answered honestly. If the patient did not ask ,and many NT people do not want to know, then it would not be discussed. It is not automatic in health care to tell anyone that they are dying. When my father was dying we had months of care at home from the hospice at home team of carers. We knew dad was dying and he ,as the patient, wanted to talk about it. He was totally comfortable about his death being talked about. He got everything in order and everything that needed to be said was said. He planned his own funeral.The hospice team didn't use the words death or dying or terminal at any point until we had used those words. I asked them about it and they said that it wasn't at all unusual for a person who is dying or the family of the person to absolutely not want to discuss it or to have it acknowledged. I have said to my husband that I would absolutely want to know because I have children and a grandchild (arriving anyday now) and there are things I would want to say and do. His late wife knew that she was becoming more and more ill and that all the treatment options had been exhausted. She didn't want to discuss it. She didn't want it put into words. He respected that completely. What difference would it make to the person you care for to know. Do they need to tell anyone? Do they need to make a will? Do they have life insurance? Do they own a house ? As their carer it isn't your role to push their diagnosis into their face. The kindest thing you can do is to make whatever time they have left as good as possible because you know it is limited. The truth is not always helpful.
Cbtb · 09/03/2022 08:32

First off thank you for caring.

Are you her main day to day carer? The person who knows her best? If so you really should have been involved in the discussions as best interests discussions should involve the people who know the patient best. If that is you and you weren’t involved it would make me worried that the process was not correctly followed.

Do you know is there was an IMCA - independent mental capacity advocate involved? They should be and have spoken to your client to find out her views and advocated for her. It’s possible she has spoken to an IMCA and said something along the lines of not wanting to know about bad news or upsetting things.

I think it’s very honourable that you want to protect her rights. Usually concerns should be raised through your manager but if there not responding I would contact her social worker with your concerns.

EssexLioness · 09/03/2022 08:21

Autism isn’t a learning disability. Many people with autism also have a learning disability on top but you do not make it clear from your posts if this is the case.
Everyone is different. I am autistic, dully able to comprehend what a terminal diagnosis of cancer entails and would want to be informed. However, I also know someone whose daughter is autistic, with some learning disabilities who would be unlikely to understand and process this sort of news. You cannot treat both those cases the same as it wouldn’t be appropriate

EricCartmansMagicalUnderpants · 09/03/2022 08:19

I would presume that a best interest decision had been made on her behalf, and on balance it was deemed it was better for her not to know. Unless you were party to that, then you wouldn't know why. But it certainly would not be a good thing for you to make the choice to tell her.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 09/03/2022 08:14

@Pissedoff22

She may have a learning disability and need care, but she should be treated as a whole human being with the same rights as anyone else.
Of course she should. However, withholding a prognosis for the sake of a patient's mental health is common practice and is not exclusive to those with learning disabilities.

Doctors will withhold a terminal diagnosis from those who do not have a disability too if they determine that it is the right action for the patient. The diagnosing doctor will have made this decision after discussion with this person's family and they will be the expert in the field.

What you're feeling is sympathy. Thinking about how the situation would affect you, how you would feel, that you would prefer to know. Your customer would be better served if you were empathetic to HER needs instead. She is not you. Her circumstances are very different and you are not the expert here, the GP and your customer's guardians are.

She should not find out she is close to death from you. That would be wholly inappropriate and very damaging to her. I hope you understand that.

EthelTheAardvark · 09/03/2022 08:09

@Pissedoff22

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them. I don’t understand how this is different when I know she will understand. I will do my utmost to support her regardless but I can’t help but feel like this is wrong. I just needed somewhere to speak anonymously as I feel sick and I can’t sleep.
But doctors don't tell people normally just for the sake of telling them. They do it for a variety of reasons. The chances are that the person in question will suspect anyway, plus they may need to know so that they can do things they always wanted to do but have put off, put their affairs in order, say goodbye to people they love, etc. For a very learning disabled person, none of that really applies. Furthermore, an NT person will be able to understand better; for a learning disabled person, the information may simply cause them major distress and anxiety. Whether that is the case for this person depends on a lot of personal factors and you simply can't formulate a blanket rule that they must be told just because you as an individual would want to know.
hugr · 09/03/2022 08:08

That how a proper mental capacity assessment is made, not thought mumsnet.

It's not though, a proper capacity assessment is made by assessing the persons capacity first, which would necessitate discussing cancer, death and dying. How would you do that? You cannot make a decision in someone's best interests unless they lack capacity.

Woollystockings · 09/03/2022 08:08

@Mummytobe93

So YABU for asking about it in here.

If she’s got a capacity and someone is withholding her medial status from her, there’re breaking the law.

Eh?
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 09/03/2022 08:06

For the most part yes everyone has a right to know they are dying but there are some situations where it’s best to decide on the basic of well-being for the individual.

And also we need to think about what the person thinks dying is. I've known people whom others think know what 'death is' but then they ask (about a dead person) " when are they coming back". So they don't know what death is and instead they have learnt the words which others say about person x ("they are dead"). Not everyone actually has the cognitive ability to know what death really is (I know we can all struggle but we know it's final, our bodies will rot, we won't talk again etc.). If someone is very confused about death, then telling them they are dying can be meaningless but terrifying. It's easy to think we're doing the right thing by treating people as we'd want to be treated but if we start with such an un-individualised mindset then we sometimes will not be. That said, I wish drs were clearer with everyone about prognosis though I think some of their shying away from the brutal truth is to help them avoid painful feelings.

Mummytobe93 · 09/03/2022 08:06

Medical status* sorry

Mummytobe93 · 09/03/2022 08:04

So YABU for asking about it in here.

If she’s got a capacity and someone is withholding her medial status from her, there’re breaking the law.

hugr · 09/03/2022 08:04

I disagree with PP that it's likely this has been carefully thought out. I work as a hcp specialising in ld and autism and we know that people with ld are often not involved or informed in their care, regardless of mental capacity.

That doesn't mean that the decision not to tell this person about their cancer is wrong, OP, but just that there is a huge amount of social context that needs to be considered when answering questions like this.

As to pp talking about mental ages - it's not appropriate, nor are the comparisons to children. Adults with ld are adults legally, physically and mentally.

Mummytobe93 · 09/03/2022 08:02

It’s not really up to what one person thinks.

Under the mental capacity Act, there’s many parties involved in such decision making such as doctors , a social worker, legal guardian, maybe a psychologist/psychiatrist and any family members to come up with what’s in her best interest. That how a proper mental capacity assessment is made, not thought mumsnet.

Has she got a carer/support worker? Is this cancer just been discovered now? If so how did it get to the terminal stage without being pick up by people supporting her?

DiscoBadgers · 09/03/2022 07:58

@Sapphireskies I’m sorry but that’s bollocks. My son has severe learning difficulties. As an adult he would have the right to walk out into the road if he wanted to. As someone with SEN, he doesn’t have the capacity to understand about traffic so I do what I need to to protect him.

Those who care for people with special needs to their best every day to make the very best decisions we can for them. It is our job to advocate for them, protect them, and prevent them from pain and distress.

The right to the best quality of life possible is what matters and that includes not terrifying and distressing him with information he doesn’t have the capacity to deal with that has no benefit for him.

coloradoqueen · 09/03/2022 07:58

@Pissedoff22

Having a terminal illness is supposed to be distress but doctors still tell people regardless of what difference it will make for them. I don’t understand how this is different when I know she will understand. I will do my utmost to support her regardless but I can’t help but feel like this is wrong. I just needed somewhere to speak anonymously as I feel sick and I can’t sleep.
No they don't always. I've known several situations where the patient has been vulnerable and the doctors have dealt with the family.

Personally, I can't see the benefits of this lady knowing, all it will cause her is distress. And quite honestly that's all that counts in this situation.

x2boys · 09/03/2022 07:56

As the parent of a child with severe autism and learning disabilities ,this is a very individual my child wouldn't have the capacity to understand ,and it would not bebin his interests to tell him
If telling her is going to confuse and frighten her ,why woulda anyone do that

MotherCupboard · 09/03/2022 07:52

I think some people have been awful to you on this thread. You've just found out someone you care deeply for is terminally ill, a little empathy wouldn't have gone amiss. I think this lady is incredibly lucky to have you looking out for her.

LittleSnakes · 09/03/2022 07:30

This is so hard. It must be so horrible to have a big secret like that from someone you care about. I don’t know the answer either. I guess it would depend on whether it makes her life unbearable going forwards. If she had lots of meltdowns or something. I totally get what you mean about treating her the same as you would if it were you who had the diagnosis. There is a huge power imbalance in care and this can be tricky to navigate if you’re a good person.

londonrach · 09/03/2022 07:21

I'm not sure. My friend aged 17 when I was 17 had cancer. Her family at her funeral admitted they didn't tell her it was terminal so she got to enjoy her last summer with hope. Having spent time with her during that last summer I agree...she talked of the future and things she do and was positive. It's hard. On the fence here. My friend didn't have any learning difficulties.

spring2022 · 09/03/2022 07:19

I am sorry Flowers. Mum and my sister are both cared for by carers, and I’d be glad to know there was an individual in their corner who cared as deeply as you do . I hope you can take comfort and solace from this thread, @RandomBasic has particularly good ideas going forward .