Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should tell someone that they have a terminal illness even if they have learning disabilities?

131 replies

Pissedoff22 · 08/03/2022 22:47

This is probably not the best place to discuss this but I don’t feel like I can talk to anyone and I really need some advice. The lady in question has cancer and learning disabilities. She manages to be quite independent despite her disabilities, and has a basic understanding of life and death. She doesn’t know she has cancer and that it is terminal, and they’re not going to tell her. I just don’t know how I feel about this, it doesn’t feel right. Please be kind as I have looked after this women for many years and I am devastated. She’s not even very old.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dishh · 10/03/2022 00:30

*Many had poor concept of time for example. They would have been asking every day when they were going to die, is it today, is it tomorrow?

Well, if I have been told I was going to die, but not been given or fully understood the prognosis, I might have some of the same questions..*

When my mother was dying of cancer, she also had premature dementia (she died relatively young). We had her in a care home as no other places were suitable for her, and we couldn't care for her at home. I would go and see her every day. She couldn't understand why she was in so much pain, but this was because her spine and hips had crumbled away. I'd have to explain to her, every day, that she had cancer. And she'd look at me in such confusion. I never said she was dying, but she knew it, and she never asked. She just wanted to the pain to go away, and soon it did.

If I could change anything, I wouldn't have kept telling her, day after day, that she had cancer. I'm not sure if she fully understood, and the impact has never left me.

Rinatinabina · 09/03/2022 18:52

Would it help in anyway knowing? Maybe the view is her quality of life will be affected by knowing what was going to happen? What if the remainder of her life is lived in distress and fear? Or she could believe she’s just a bit poorly but otherwise get on with her life? I’m sorry OP you are obviously really close to her and I’m sorry this is happening.

Maverickess · 09/03/2022 18:43

@starfishmummy

It may not be my decision but that doesn’t mean I can’t ask question. It may not be up to me but that doesn’t mean I have to agree with it.

Actually you do have to agree with it. It's your job to agree with it. I understand that you don't like it, but you are not tje decision maker here.

No, the job of a care or support worker is not to follow orders blindly and just do what they're told, it is to provide person centred care, which includes all aspects of someone's life. We are expected and encouraged to question things that we don't agree with, or aren't sure of, because we are not just there to wipe bottoms, make cups of tea and for a trip to the shops, we're there to listen, observe and advocate for the person(s) we care for and act in their best interests in everything we do. We're encouraged to ask questions and should do so. In this case the person is unlikely (imo) to come to harm if the carer doesn't question that decision, but there are plenty of instances where they could come to harm when a decision is made, and that harm can be prevented by carers questioning decisions and actions that they don't feel reflect the best interests of the person they are caring for - in a professional manner and through the proper channels, the manager being the first step.

Managers and HCPs should be open and transparent in these circumstances, it's not about heirachy or who's above who and who's decision it should be in the proved absence of capacity, it's supposed to be a team effort to give someone the best quality care that can be given.

This kind of attitude is why abuse can happen, because the carer is ignored when they have vital input that could lead to a better decision for the person they're caring for being made.

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 17:40

This is why I suggested she request to see the documentation around the decision. If it is lacking then she can then challenge it

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 17:39

@Cbtb I actually agree with you here. If she is the person doing the Fay to day to day care and has the closest relationship with the lady, has known her a long time, she should absolutely have been involved in the best interest decision.

I might also argue that she could also have been involved in the capacity assessment. Everything possible is supposed to be done to try and find that the person DOES have capacity. In many cases, that means the person asking them questions and having exploratory conversations should be someone they already know well, are comfortable with, who knows how to communicate with them and how to understand their communication in return. It should take place at the time best for the person, in a place they know and are comfortable, in order to get the most accurate picture of that persons understanding.

My son is autistic. If a stranger tried to explain something complex to him like this he would not engage, would go mute. The assumption could well be made that he did not understand and therefore lacked capacity. But with someone who knows him, who he trusts, he would engage and respond and be much more able to accurately communicate his level of understanding.

Cbtb · 09/03/2022 17:14

“ Actually you do have to agree with it. It's your job to agree with it. I understand that you don't like it, but you are not tje decision maker here.”

Her job is to care for and advocate for her client. Her compassion is shining through here and I wish that all carers cared so much. If she feels that this decision is not best for her client she should raise it. If she is the main long term day to day carer then she may well know the client best and a proper best interests meeting would have included her. The fact the main carer was not included in the meeting raises suspicion it was not done correctly.

BlackandJello · 09/03/2022 15:50

My brother was born with a life limiting genetic condition similar to downs.

He was unwell throughout his life and had many operations. We thought we were going to lose him at several points but he pulled through.

When his body eventually couldn't cope we made him aware of what was going on and that he wouldn't survive. But only a week or so before he passed did we ever mention death to him as it was something that massively distressed him. When he was moved to a hospice we thought it was appropriate to tell him, he definitely wouldn't have coped with the news before that.

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 15:49

@Thornrose both my sons are autistic too x

Uafasach · 09/03/2022 15:36

The doctor said to my husband that if a direct question was asked by the patient,regarding their prognosis, then that question would be answered honestly. If the patient did not ask ,and many NT people do not want to know, then it would not be discussed. It is not automatic in health care to tell anyone that they are dying

That was what we were told when a family member was terminal. She never asked so the doctor never told her.

Thornrose · 09/03/2022 15:29

@Rinoachicken I just want to say that your posts are so helpful and written so thoughtfully.

Your description of understanding time and the distress is exactly how I imagine my dd with autism would be if she was given a terminal diagnosis.

ChangeNameagain2 · 09/03/2022 15:13

However unless certain powers of attorney(?) (or whatever the medical equivalent is) is given to their parent/carer, then they still have a human right to be told, regardless of whether it's believed to be the kindest option or not. Only the person with full autonomy over that body has the right to decide. That just simply isn't true. It is far more complex than a right to know or not.

Upamountain43 · 09/03/2022 14:14

This is part of my job - being involved in these decisions.

There will be a mental capacity assessment done to establish if she has the capacity to understand and if so the she will be told. If not then a legally established process will follow.

There will be a Best Interests decision made on telling her done with all relevant parties and should include and independent advocate who would represent the individuals views and would have had the time to spend with the individual and approach this matter in all sorts of round about ways to try and establish her typical reactions.

If anyone disagrees they can make a challenge to the Court of Protection.

There is a complete legal framework that should be being followed. These types of situations happen all the time.

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 13:45

Forgot to add, you said However unless certain powers of attorney(?) (or whatever the medical equivalent is) is given…

The OP did state that PoA is in place, held by the local authority. Whether that’s for finance only or Health and Welfare we don’t know, but presumably OP does.

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 13:37

@MotherofAutism the OP says that this lady also has a LD, which makes the matter much more complex as her ability to understand, profess and make decisions is more likely to be compromised. Not necessarily, (and legally capacity is assumed unless shown to be otherwise) and certainly not for everything, but that’s what we have the MCA for. And hopefully that process has been followed appropriately.

That’s why I suggested the OP requested to see the documentation that should be there to support this best interest decision - as it will set out the reasons and thinking behind the decision, and the assessment of this woman’s capacity around this specific issue.

If that hasn’t been done or not done to high standard then she can and should request it be re-done

saraclara · 09/03/2022 13:35

Having all the information doesn't make for a better quality of life.

You're right, of course, and I'm sorry that you've had cause to discover that @RobinBlackbird

I used to think honesty mattered above all in these things. Until the day that my MIL, as her dementia got significantly worse, asked at a family get-together, where "that man" was, clearly meaning my late husband, her son. It had been years since he died and since she'd ever mentioned him. Stupidly, I felt I should be honest and said "I'm sorry, but he died".
She broke her heart, and because of the severity of her dementia, it was very difficult to console her. I should just have said "oh he couldn't come today". Absolutely nothing was served by being honest, and all it did was ruin her happy day away from her care home, and really distress her.

Rachie1973 · 09/03/2022 12:51

@RobinBlackbird

Honestly. It's difficult. I've been told I've got cancer and what's more I have a genetic mutation that will make me prone to recurrence/ different cancers. I think it's the second half of that has totally taken joy and hope from my life. Having all the information doesn't make for a better quality of life.
Of all the posts on this thread this one stood out to me.

I’m sorry for the loss of joy. If I could give you a portion of mine I would send it willingly. I hope you have some bright days xxxx

x2boys · 09/03/2022 12:44

@MotherofAutism

A lot of you on here seem to be totally disregarding this person's basic human rights. Yes, there's a lot of things which us as humans, throughout life, would probably rather not know. However we do know/find out/are told because of our human rights. Having Autism is no reason to disregard her human rights. Also, Autism as we know, is a spectrum. I have a family member with Autism and they are only very mildly affected. However I have a friend with a child who is non-verbal and severely cognitively impaired. Yes, there's an argument for my friend's child being better off not knowing should they (god forbid) ever end up in such a position. However unless certain powers of attorney(?) (or whatever the medical equivalent is) is given to their parent/carer, then they still have a human right to be told, regardless of whether it's believed to be the kindest option or not. Only the person with full autonomy over that body has the right to decide.

If we're going to say that we must ignore these human rights and what is 'kindest', then why isn't voluntary Euthanasia legal in this country? Even if just for severely impaired individuals with a life-limiting/terminal diagnosis?

I don't really understand your comparison Would your friends child have any understanding if they were told they had a terminal illness? My own child has severe non verbal autism He has no concept we have even been in a pandemic for two years ,if God forbid he was terminally ill due to his severe mental impairments ,he would have no concept of what was happening,the kindest thing would to make sure he felt safe and comfortable and out of pain .
DoingAway · 09/03/2022 12:36

What is concerning about this is that OP appears to be saying that this decision has been made by people who don’t really know this woman but OP who does know her well has not been consulted. If this is the case OP I think you are quite right to question it and hopefully you can speak to the legal guardian and satisfy yourself on what basis this decision has been made. I am sorry you find yourself in this situation.

saraclara · 09/03/2022 12:14

If we're going to say that we must ignore these human rights and what is 'kindest', then why isn't voluntary Euthanasia legal in this country? Even if just for severely impaired individuals with a life-limiting/terminal diagnosis?

Your question is based on a totally false equivalence.

MotherofAutism · 09/03/2022 11:41

A lot of you on here seem to be totally disregarding this person's basic human rights. Yes, there's a lot of things which us as humans, throughout life, would probably rather not know. However we do know/find out/are told because of our human rights.
Having Autism is no reason to disregard her human rights. Also, Autism as we know, is a spectrum. I have a family member with Autism and they are only very mildly affected. However I have a friend with a child who is non-verbal and severely cognitively impaired. Yes, there's an argument for my friend's child being better off not knowing should they (god forbid) ever end up in such a position. However unless certain powers of attorney(?) (or whatever the medical equivalent is) is given to their parent/carer, then they still have a human right to be told, regardless of whether it's believed to be the kindest option or not. Only the person with full autonomy over that body has the right to decide.

If we're going to say that we must ignore these human rights and what is 'kindest', then why isn't voluntary Euthanasia legal in this country? Even if just for severely impaired individuals with a life-limiting/terminal diagnosis?

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 10:04

As someone who has also worked in LD for a very long time, you have to know that it's hit or miss whether this has been done, and to a good standard

Which is why I suggested she check the documentation herself Smile

hugr · 09/03/2022 09:50

So at some point, when the issue of telling her or not has come up, she has been assessed and it’s been decided she lacks capacity in this area of her life.

As someone who has also worked in LD for a very long time, you have to know that it's hit or miss whether this has been done, and to a good standard.

Many had poor concept of time for example. They would have been asking every day when they were going to die, is it today, is it tomorrow?

Well, if I have been told I was going to die, but not been given or fully understood the prognosis, I might have some of the same questions..

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 09:25

Neurotypical not neurosurgical! (Obv)

Rinoachicken · 09/03/2022 09:22

I’ve worked in LD for quite a while.

Mental Capacity is not fixed. It can fluctuate with age, environment even time of day. It is always situation specific.

Legally, the assumption is that someone HAS capacity unless you have good reason to doubt that. In which case you just assess their mental capacity and this must be recorded. This can be a lengthy process as every effort has to me made (and you have to be able to prove) that amity tried everything reasonable to enable the person to understand the situation and communicate their decision (even if their decision is not what you would choose yourself).

This lady may well be perfectly able to make decisions about what she wants for dinner, where she wants to go every day, etc but not have capacity when it comes to complex medical care.

So at some point, when the issue of telling her or not has come up, she has been assessed and it’s been decided she lacks capacity in this area of her life.

It then becomes a best interest decision, which is also a formal legal process. The mental capacity assessment done prior has to accompany this best interest documentation as you can ONLY make best interest decisions where someone has been proved to lack capacity.

Again, the best interest decision with be decision specific. In this case, it will have been ‘should X be told about her terminal diagnosis’.

People involved in her care and her life would have been involved. This includes next of kin, her doctors, sounds like your care manager (who arguably should have asked for your views also if you work closely with her and know her best), anyone with legal guardianship (so her SW). They will have looked at the benefits and downsides of telling her or not, and weighed the decision based on what they felt was in her best interest.

She does have a right to know yes. But that does not necessarily mean she NEEDS to if the consequences of that for her would significantly put weight any benefits.

For many of the people I used to work with, knowing this information would not have been beneficial for them. This is not a neurosurgical person with no LD, hearing devastating news, being able to process it, come to terms with omit and then getting on with making the best of what time they have left. Many had poor concept of time for example. They would have been asking every day when they were going to die, is it today, is it tomorrow? They would have told everyone they met they were going to die. It would have occupied their every waking thought and caused fear and anxiety that just would be unnecessary and cruel because they were not able to process the information in any helpful way. It would have tormented them until their last moments and they would have lived their last months in fear and confusion.

In your situation, I would suggest speaking to your manager and asking to read the best interest decision and capacity assessment so you can get a better understanding of why this decision was made.

If you feel that the capacity assessment was un-sound (for example the lady uses PECS to communicate but PECS weren’t used in the conversation) then you can challenge it and it would have to be re-done. But if it’s all been done properly, with due care, then you will have to accept the decision. But hopefully being able to see how they weighed it up and reached their final decision will help with that.

Do reach out for support for yourself as you continue to support this lady towards the end of her life. It’s wonderful to see your care for this lady, it comes through clearly in your posts. But don’t let your grief and emotions about her prognosis cloud this. It’s about what’s BEST for her, emotionally and physically, what benefits her most.

HiJenny35 · 09/03/2022 09:22

The big question is what good would it do for her to know, people are told so they can get their finances in place, put care in place for children, do a will etc if there's no need for any of that would it really be beneficial? Just to have a few months of fear and sadness? I know 2 people who have died of short aggressive terminal cancer, both said they would have preferred not to know. They both spent the last few weeks in absolute fear. I appreciate that doctors would legally have to tell me but would I really want to know if there was absolutely no hope, no I don't think I would. Especially with someone who can't fully understand the limitations of the situation. I wouldn't want a child to be told for example, I'm not sure this is that much different.