Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not attend online seminars?

85 replies

coolstef · 08/03/2022 13:54

I'm in my 4th and final year at university and am due to finish in 2 months. It has been online for the past two years due to COVID. I have not set foot on campus since 2020.

I consistently sit at a 2.1 without much effort at all, I am fine with that and a 2.1 is what I am hoping to graduate with (on track for this). However, I haven't attended any online seminars this full academic year. It says the seminars are mandatory.

The reason I haven't attended is due to my experiences of online seminars last year I find them to be a complete waste of time. I gain nothing from them, learn nothing in them and would much rather focus my time elsewhere like on the actual assessments and my dissertation.

I have never been pulled up for my lack of attendance and always submit my work on time and as I said consistently get 2.1s.

However, my friend doing the same course has started to ask me am I not worried about getting kicked out due to my lack of attendance? I'd never really thought about it as no one has questioned me about it. I had a look at the uni policy and they said that they would give three chances before being kicked out and try and support you to engage more. Additionally, I am engaged with the course, this is shown in my work and working to the deadlines.

So am I being unreasonable to assume that since no one has been in touch they are not going to just kick me out of uni for not attending the seminars?

My personal tutor is very happy with me and says I'm the most hardworking student she's had this year.

OP posts:
coolstef · 08/03/2022 19:45

@RandomBasic

What some people do is log on, record then listen at double speed.

Are you aware of the Dunning Kruger effect?

At the very beginning of learning something, you recognize that you know nothing. Then you gain a little bit of knowledge. What then happens is that because you now know so much more than when you knew zero, you feel full of knowledge. But actually, people who are more experienced are aware of gaps in your knowledge that you are not aware of.

That's how you get someone who has done a weekend residential photography course mansplaining to a 20yr photojournalist why you need different lenses.

So curious what course this is where it is possible to know everything in 4 years. If you're doing a seminar on quadratic equations or something, you might be like 'oh I know that' but will you be familiar with the aside about Pythagoras the tutor mentions, and the story of the time he used it when the steel ordered had 10% less tensile strength than the spec requested? The handout just said 'quadratic equations' and you know that, so didn't attend that seminar...

I'm doing a politics course and no, the seminars are nothing like that. You get put into breakout rooms where everyone sits in awkward silence on their phone. You then get taken back into the main room where the lecturer asks what you've discussed. Since you've not discussed anything, nobody speaks and so the seminar ends. This was not a problem in face to face seminars which I attended, engaged and most of the time, enjoyed. But this is the reality of online seminars. I can say with 100 percent certainty that I am not at risk of missing out on a single thing based on my previous experiences.
OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2022 19:44

What some people do is log on, record then listen at double speed.

Most universities won't allow students record. The lecturer will record & share with the students.

For seminars like that, the learning isn't in listening anyway; it's the active participation & knowledge exchange.

OP, you being there & participating, along with your fellow students, is what should make the seminars 'worthwhile' I teach at a university; this attitude is so frustrating.

RandomBasic · 08/03/2022 19:37

What some people do is log on, record then listen at double speed.

Are you aware of the Dunning Kruger effect?

At the very beginning of learning something, you recognize that you know nothing. Then you gain a little bit of knowledge. What then happens is that because you now know so much more than when you knew zero, you feel full of knowledge. But actually, people who are more experienced are aware of gaps in your knowledge that you are not aware of.

That's how you get someone who has done a weekend residential photography course mansplaining to a 20yr photojournalist why you need different lenses.

So curious what course this is where it is possible to know everything in 4 years. If you're doing a seminar on quadratic equations or something, you might be like 'oh I know that' but will you be familiar with the aside about Pythagoras the tutor mentions, and the story of the time he used it when the steel ordered had 10% less tensile strength than the spec requested? The handout just said 'quadratic equations' and you know that, so didn't attend that seminar...

RandomBasic · 08/03/2022 19:27

[quote coolstef]@luckylavender what attitude? Why does it effect you so much? I'm a stranger on mumsnet. [/quote]
Affect / effect

lanthanum · 08/03/2022 19:26

Compulsory attendance requirements may not be just a university matter - I think they're sometimes required for the degree to be recognised by a professional body. Of course, that still doesn't tell you whether anyone is suddenly going to notice your attendance record and raise it as an issue.

It's more likely that they just need to ensure that you are engaging with the course. I think student finance are not impressed if they've been paying out all year for someone who hasn't engaged at all, so with more things online, there may be a need for some check on whether people are actually studying or not.

Rewritethestars1 · 08/03/2022 19:24

I did a degree that ended in a professional registration so its probably different but all seminars were mandatory, interesting and I gained alot from them. This was especially true when students engaged asking questions, extending the learning and taking part in debates. I do wonder what type of course your doing where this is not the case?
Anyway, as I said it was different on mine and attendance was definitely flagged at the earliest opportunity and if you failed to attend after warnings and intervention you failed. It would be impossible for you not to know this until the end because you'd have gone through a series of meetings and written warnings. so hopefully that's reassuring op. Who knows though.

coolstef · 08/03/2022 19:13

@Sunda

The other problem with your attitude is that seminars really run better the more students engage with them. To a lecturer it is incredibly frustrating when all students have their cameras off, don't respond/ engage, or don't show up at all. I can understand what you're saying re you're not getting anything from the seminars, but chances are you could have got something from them if you (and others) did engage properly. You could have influenced where the discussion was going, you could have shown an interest in other students' views. Or you could have given feedback to the seminar leader re why the seminars weren't useful to you. It's when students are passive like that that we end up dumbing things down and don't feel we can set more challenging discussion questions etc. It has been soul destroying tbh
That's fair enough.
OP posts:
Sunda · 08/03/2022 19:07

The other problem with your attitude is that seminars really run better the more students engage with them. To a lecturer it is incredibly frustrating when all students have their cameras off, don't respond/ engage, or don't show up at all. I can understand what you're saying re you're not getting anything from the seminars, but chances are you could have got something from them if you (and others) did engage properly. You could have influenced where the discussion was going, you could have shown an interest in other students' views. Or you could have given feedback to the seminar leader re why the seminars weren't useful to you. It's when students are passive like that that we end up dumbing things down and don't feel we can set more challenging discussion questions etc. It has been soul destroying tbh

coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:33

Thank you for your input @Cheeseandlobster

OP posts:
Cheeseandlobster · 08/03/2022 18:32

@coolstef

It was *@Cheeseandlobster* who was rude
Who is rude? Lucky Lavender who you aimed the rudeness post at or me? If it is me then I stand by what I say. It is arrogant to not bother to attend mandatory seminars for 2 years. Imagine if everyone on the course had this attitude. There would be no learning from peers via questions and answers etc. I bet you have missed some very important things, despite what you think
coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:30

@Cheeseandlobster I'll come back in may and let you know if I'll be graduating with everyone, don't worry too much, I have a good feeling.

OP posts:
Cheeseandlobster · 08/03/2022 18:29

[quote coolstef]@luckylavender I am allowed to respond on this open forum called mumsnet. I appreciate everyone's input and do hope people will respond but you're just downright rude. [/quote]
Nope. You are being quite scathing of anyone who is stating you are in wrong. You should have attended the seminars. The decision was yours but it was the wrong one and I think you know this. What a waste of 4 years to not graduate with your cohort when you could have logged on with your camera off and half listened while you got on with other things. It doesn't show much forward thinking.

coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:28

[quote EarringsandLipstick]@Cheeseandlobster asks a fair question though - how many seminars did you attend before deciding they were a 'waste of time'? 🤔[/quote]
Which I've answered.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2022 18:26

@Cheeseandlobster asks a fair question though - how many seminars did you attend before deciding they were a 'waste of time'? 🤔

coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:25

It was @Cheeseandlobster who was rude

OP posts:
coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:22

@luckylavender sorry, thought you were another poster. Ignore the 'downright rude' comment.

OP posts:
coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:21

@luckylavender I am allowed to respond on this open forum called mumsnet. I appreciate everyone's input and do hope people will respond but you're just downright rude.

OP posts:
luckylavender · 08/03/2022 18:20

[quote coolstef]@luckylavender what attitude? Why does it effect you so much? I'm a stranger on mumsnet. [/quote]
Why do you post if you don't want comments? It's a very entitled attitude to pick and chose what you do until you suddenly realise it may affect you.

coolstef · 08/03/2022 18:19

@Cheeseandlobster

Also how many seminars did you actually attend before you declared them a waste of time?
Three years worth as stated in the OP. Maybe I could have got a 1st by attending all the seminars - but as it stands I'm going to get a 2.1 and that's on me and nobody else's business. I don't think I'm so special - it's a conscious decision I made but am now worrying about the consequence of that decision which once again, is on me and me alone.
OP posts:
luckylavender · 08/03/2022 18:17

@RampantIvy

what attitude?

You don't get it?
When you get a job will you consider attendance at work to be voluntary as well?

This
Cheeseandlobster · 08/03/2022 18:15

Also how many seminars did you actually attend before you declared them a waste of time?

Cheeseandlobster · 08/03/2022 18:14

[quote coolstef]@luckylavender what attitude? Why does it effect you so much? I'm a stranger on mumsnet. [/quote]
I agree with Lucky Lavender. You sound a bit arrogant. What makes you so special that you don't have to do what everyone else does? I was a mature student. Some seminars were more of a waste of time than others but I always got something from them. I often found other students questions and the answers provided were very informative. Maybe you would be on track for a first had you attended the seminars. Just a thought.

tttigress · 08/03/2022 18:11

Do you have to say anything in these Seminars? Maybe just log in with the volume off?

SaskiaRembrandt · 08/03/2022 18:07

I'm a bit dubious about a university that doesn't check whether students are attending, if only for welfare reasons. That doesn't sound like a great place to study.

coolstef · 08/03/2022 17:56

@RampantIvy

what attitude?

You don't get it?
When you get a job will you consider attendance at work to be voluntary as well?

I'm a mature student, worked full time in one job for ten years before starting uni. I have a work ethic. Not attending seminars that I literally gain nothing from is very different. But thank you for your patronising 'lecture'.
OP posts: