Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not attend online seminars?

85 replies

coolstef · 08/03/2022 13:54

I'm in my 4th and final year at university and am due to finish in 2 months. It has been online for the past two years due to COVID. I have not set foot on campus since 2020.

I consistently sit at a 2.1 without much effort at all, I am fine with that and a 2.1 is what I am hoping to graduate with (on track for this). However, I haven't attended any online seminars this full academic year. It says the seminars are mandatory.

The reason I haven't attended is due to my experiences of online seminars last year I find them to be a complete waste of time. I gain nothing from them, learn nothing in them and would much rather focus my time elsewhere like on the actual assessments and my dissertation.

I have never been pulled up for my lack of attendance and always submit my work on time and as I said consistently get 2.1s.

However, my friend doing the same course has started to ask me am I not worried about getting kicked out due to my lack of attendance? I'd never really thought about it as no one has questioned me about it. I had a look at the uni policy and they said that they would give three chances before being kicked out and try and support you to engage more. Additionally, I am engaged with the course, this is shown in my work and working to the deadlines.

So am I being unreasonable to assume that since no one has been in touch they are not going to just kick me out of uni for not attending the seminars?

My personal tutor is very happy with me and says I'm the most hardworking student she's had this year.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2022 19:26

"It would put you in a better position to try to get a 1st though 😄. Or even to make a 2.1 more secure."

Not really. If OP knows she can't get a 1st it changes nothing. If she knows she already has enough credit for a 2.1 then it's already secure.

HumptySumptious · 09/03/2022 19:20

@Gwenhwyfar

"So, if you can easily get a 2-1 without attending online seminars, wouldn't it hold that you could probably get a 1st by attending seminars?"

No. That's really not how it works in some subjects.

It would put you in a better position to try to get a 1st though 😄. Or even to make a 2.1 more secure.
Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2022 19:17

@Mullercornershop

You’re the most hard working student but only on course for a 2:1?
It's not just a case of how much work you do leading to a certain grade now is it? You must understand that. I wouldn't have got a first at my uni (I did manage one with the OU) even if I had worked day and night.
Gwenhwyfar · 09/03/2022 19:15

"So, if you can easily get a 2-1 without attending online seminars, wouldn't it hold that you could probably get a 1st by attending seminars?"

No. That's really not how it works in some subjects.

RampantIvy · 09/03/2022 13:27

I don't think what anyone else did is relevant to the OP. It depends on the university and the subject.

aluvss · 09/03/2022 13:12

I don't think you need to attend.

I went to uni and achieved a 2:1 without ever going to a seminar, they were a waste of time IMO.

HumptySumptious · 08/03/2022 21:43

So, if you can easily get a 2-1 without attending online seminars, wouldn't it hold that you could probably get a 1st by attending seminars?

I don't understand - seminars were a relatively large part of my degree, I can't imagine wanting to 'go it alone', even if I could pass by doing that.

ShyMaryEllen · 08/03/2022 21:35

IME attendance is usually monitored for the Borders Agency, so that international students can't register on a course and then disappear, rather than to check up on anyone. It is assumed that people who have registered on a course have an interest in it and want to participate. Other students tend to get irritated by those who don't bother, too; but I suppose if you are at the end of your course that's not a consideration.

There are always those who get along just fine without attending much, but for every one of those there is another who thinks they are doing well because they don't know enough to know what they don't know.

Brefugee · 08/03/2022 21:20

Not attending seminars that I literally gain nothing from is very different. But thank you for your patronising 'lecture'.

you sound as though you think you don't need to waste your time attending. How do you think the lecturers feel? What if nobody attends? I wonder why they waste their time trying to teach you anything. You sound quite supercillious about it all, tbh

UnsuitableHat · 08/03/2022 21:12

If you were pulled up on it (which sounds unlikely now), could you say you listened to the recordings? I'm doing an online Masters, and that's all we'd have to say, not that we'd be asked. Your degree sounds pretty much online if you haven't been on campus since 2020.

Mullercornershop · 08/03/2022 21:11

You’re the most hard working student but only on course for a 2:1?

iamsmaller1 · 08/03/2022 21:04

I'm a University lecturer. It will depend on what course you are doing. If students don't attend lectures/seminars for what I teach, then yes they can't pass the course. This is due to a skills based element to what I teach though, they have to log a certain amount of teaching hours. I do though know all the students who sign in and don't get involved. It makes me sad and makes the seminar/lecture less of an experience for the group. If the students are doing small group work there's at least 2 in each group that aren't there so that causes issues too, the people who want to join in, in the seminar are left with people who can't be bothered in thier group. Generally I won't give students who haven't been involved in seminars and kectures a reference as there's not much I can say about them.. students are adult learners though.. if they want to spend 9k then they need to know what they need to do to pass the course.. it will tell you somewhere in your documents what your attendence requirements are or should do, I'm sure you probably know with only 2m to go whether you need to attend possibly. I let students know if they are not attending or making hours needed halfway through Yr 1

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/03/2022 20:38

I’d argue that learning these skills is at least as important a part of the university experience as the knowledge one receives.

I agree 100%. I've interviewed so many candidates with 2:1s and 1sts rejected because they had little else to offer

ButtockUp · 08/03/2022 20:36

Based on my children's experience of uni these last three years, I'd advise you to tread very carefully.
Assume nothing.
At the very least, check with your tutor .
I've heard some sorry tales from my children.

FloraPostePosts · 08/03/2022 20:22

@RockingMyFiftiesNot

You get put into breakout rooms where everyone sits in awkward silence on their phone. You then get taken back into the main room where the lecturer asks what you've discussed. Since you've not discussed anything, nobody speaks and so the seminar ends.

You've missed a trick there OP. Leading the discussions and including those not confident enough to contribute or who just couldn't be arsed would have been great evidence at interviews for whatever career you wish to follow.

I agree with this. University isn’t a passive experience - by simply receiving information, you’re only getting half of what you might out of it. Learning to debate, to persuade, to lead and to develop your own voice are more valuable than the knowledge you gain by passively receiving. I’d argue that learning these skills is at least as important a part of the university experience as the knowledge one receives.
EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2022 20:21

But this is the reality of online seminars.

It's not the reality of the online seminars I run.

I use breakout rooms too. Students have clear tasks, I get feedback through discussion in the main room, plus online engagement tools like Vevox & via Chat. It works well

If it hasn't worked well for you, you could have tried discussing the topics in the breakout rooms, and / or letting the lecturer know.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 08/03/2022 20:19

I work in HE and this sounds a bit surprising.

Firstly, we returned to F2F as soon aa we were allowed (Sept 21). The SoS made a show of ringing HEIs to check they were back properly. Recording lectures, sure, but 100% online seminars? Either you don't realise there are additional sessions to attend or your institution is skating on thin ice.

Also v odd that you have M-level students taking your seminars. Are you sure? I have worked at universities in hums/ soc sci for 17 years and have never seen anyone below L8 take a seminar unsupported.

Also odd the staffing changes every week, they don't do welfare checks, they don't log e-attendance.....

If this is true it sounds very badly run and as a senior manager I'd be having a disciplinary conversation with the programme lead if this happened on my patch.

If it's true.....

Rewritethestars1 · 08/03/2022 20:08

@nycliving fair enough. Like I said it depends what degree you are doing and why. That was just my experience but I did a professional qualification at undergrad and I have worked in the role in some form or another since. Good luck with your studies.

TheMerrickBoy · 08/03/2022 20:05

@Sunda

The other problem with your attitude is that seminars really run better the more students engage with them. To a lecturer it is incredibly frustrating when all students have their cameras off, don't respond/ engage, or don't show up at all. I can understand what you're saying re you're not getting anything from the seminars, but chances are you could have got something from them if you (and others) did engage properly. You could have influenced where the discussion was going, you could have shown an interest in other students' views. Or you could have given feedback to the seminar leader re why the seminars weren't useful to you. It's when students are passive like that that we end up dumbing things down and don't feel we can set more challenging discussion questions etc. It has been soul destroying tbh
This this and more this.

This thread has been so depressing. We've been back on campus fully for a while now, but I know see in black and white why it was so hard and horrible to make an online seminar into a good experience, despite all my best efforts. As for people's mums condoning them logging in and tuning out.... very grim reading.

nycliving · 08/03/2022 20:05

Posted too soon. The OP might be the same? So can't assume she wants/needs the additional knowledge.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/03/2022 20:05

You get put into breakout rooms where everyone sits in awkward silence on their phone. You then get taken back into the main room where the lecturer asks what you've discussed. Since you've not discussed anything, nobody speaks and so the seminar ends.

You've missed a trick there OP. Leading the discussions and including those not confident enough to contribute or who just couldn't be arsed would have been great evidence at interviews for whatever career you wish to follow.

nycliving · 08/03/2022 20:04

[quote Rewritethestars1]@RandomBasic makes an excellent point.

University to me is not simply about passing the course and doing the bare minimum to do so. There is s much knowledge to be gained by interacting with experts on the subject, which course tutors and lecturers will hopefully be. I still think about conversations I had with mine years later. Questions would be asked in lectures and tutors would be happy to have conversations after or over email to expand on them. The reading materials can only give you so much but i suppose it depends on what degree your doing.[/quote]
To be absolutely honest I have no interest in my degree, it's merely a mean to an end to get me to my postgrad which is a professional course which will take me into my chosen line of work.

Rewritethestars1 · 08/03/2022 19:58

Cross posted with your update. Id have complained in your shoes op. Your paying for this. People on my degree did complain and took action if they were unsatisfied with teaching. That sounds so frustrating for you.

JemimaMuddledUp · 08/03/2022 19:55

My DS is studying politics and finds the seminars the most useful part of the course. I think the main issue here is that you need to flag it up with the lecturer that they way they are running the online seminars isn't working.

When I was at university I could check online under my Student Record what my attendance was for each module. If overall attendance fell below 85% you were called in by your personal tutor for a chat. One of the things that it can impact is if you are borderline between degree classifications (eg you are on 69.4% overall) you are more likely to be awarded the higher degree if your attendance is good.

Rewritethestars1 · 08/03/2022 19:54

@RandomBasic makes an excellent point.

University to me is not simply about passing the course and doing the bare minimum to do so. There is s much knowledge to be gained by interacting with experts on the subject, which course tutors and lecturers will hopefully be. I still think about conversations I had with mine years later. Questions would be asked in lectures and tutors would be happy to have conversations after or over email to expand on them. The reading materials can only give you so much but i suppose it depends on what degree your doing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread