Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think society has lost the ability to allow opposing views anymore

181 replies

allmixedup12 · 07/03/2022 23:57

there is no space left in the UK/US for opposing views anymore and any kind of debate feels totally polarizing. It seems the public has been dumbed down to understand black and white are the only two colours - i feel uncomfortable raising doubts anymore in public for the fear of being attacked

Brexit vs EU love
Trump vs Democrats
Covid vs Deniers/doubters
BLM vs I'm not racist, and no one else is either
Russia/China bad - UK/US good
NATO is innocent - Putin is Satan (neither is true)
woke vs not woke?
BBC vs RT
Indyref vs Union
Islamophobes vs Liberals

Insane how difficult it has become to voice opposing opinions without being attacked personally as a fascist/racist/insensitive/crazy

OP posts:
VisaQuestions · 08/03/2022 08:40

Also answering the above to @Theluggage15 regarding nato

VisaQuestions · 08/03/2022 08:40

@PleaseDontDriveMeBlind people are frustrated that so many accept that NATO expansion caused his war.

It’s a pretext given, but Putin has explicitly stated that he views Ukraine as part of Russia. He’s also given many false flag reasons to invade, from imaginary nukes to nazism.

It suits the left wing liberals to give the NATO answer, but if you are entering the debate from the position of accepting the NATO excuse you’ve actually already disregarded a fair few facts and accepted some bias.

MintyFreshBreath · 08/03/2022 08:36

Totally agree @allmixedup12 With my brother and his wife, there are certain subjects we are just not allowed to discuss. They’re correct and that’s that. It’s like living in a real life version of 1984 where my view means nothing and I’m made to feel like an ignorant twat for daring to suggest anything else. I gave up in the end and our conversations are very surface level now eg boring.

PleaseDontDriveMeBlind · 08/03/2022 08:34

Telling civilians there is a safe corridor then bombing it - you're definitely on the right side OP

But... This is her point. You are proving it. She hasn't said she is on Putin's side at all, and discussing causes of the war isn't making excuses.

I tried talking to DP about NATO expansion last night and he was all "so what's your point?" I'm not really making a point, I'm just trying to discuss what has lead up to this point, "well we are the good guys compared to them" he was very accusatory in tone. I never said we weren't the "good guys"!? He just seemed ready to put down.

People will assign you motives and thoughts and beliefs over the smallest thing. All I did was mention that there are influences that played a part in the invasion, not that that makes it OK or that NATO are the bad guys. I wasn't making a value judgement. I told him to stop putting words in my mouth when I've said nothing of the sort, nor do I think it.

lightand · 08/03/2022 08:34

Great Res et

PLus the media love to dramatise everything, so fuel flames.

ClemFandangoo · 08/03/2022 08:32

Definitely but this is a worldwide problem. The issue is people are in their own echo chambers on social media, they surround themselves with people who think like them and do when accosted with an opposite view they can’t cope. It’s like their whole world view has been changed.

This cartoon by the Oatmeal sums it up better than I ever could.

theoatmeal.com/comics/believe

haaaaaaalp · 08/03/2022 08:29

There's a great psychotherapist on Instagram who gives out a few truths about this

https://instagram.com/seerutkchawla?utmmedium=copyy_link

Theluggage15 · 08/03/2022 08:28

And Ukraine joining NATO is one of the reasons for the war. There’s nothing wrong with stating that but Pilger is definitely an unreliable source.

vivainsomnia · 08/03/2022 08:27

my reading up on the topic from credible sources has made me very very skeptical of mainstream media coverage of the war and i am starting to understand that the reality may be something completely different from what is fed on TV
It always is. The only interest of the media is sensationalism and money. It makes me laugh when people argue politics and all the energy spent on hating individuals when our countries are governed by one central party, the media.

I wonder when populations will finally wake up to this.

Theluggage15 · 08/03/2022 08:25

Russia is not in NATO!!

MaryAndHerNet · 08/03/2022 08:24

In my experience, limited as it is, people these days just don't like being challenged or critiqued.

Very recently, a woman wrote a book, it got slammed and critiqued. She then claimed the experience have her complex post traumatic stress... Very doubtful.

It's like the world has become toddlers where saying 'no' or 'thats not very good' is met with tantrums and claims of mental damage etc.
There was a time that if you were rubbish at something or made something crap you wouldn't get asspatted and told it was great, you'd get eye rolls and told to try harder.

knittingaddict · 08/03/2022 08:20

[quote allmixedup12]@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation No i am not for war nor do i know putin/russia well enough to have a real opinion, yet. I do think when incredibly ethical and high quality independent journalists write something, it is worth reading and thinking about than following like sheep[/quote]
You really just used "sheep" in your post? I think I know what we are dealing with now.

Let's be clear that not all sides/views/opinions are created equal. Some are patently obviously wrong and go against known facts and science. I have no patience with those and will not respect things that aren't based in reality.

Of course some things are more nuanced, but you used "sheep", so I'm out.

Trixiefirecracker · 08/03/2022 08:16

Also relying on one journalistic view of day, John Pilger, means you are relying on only one view that also might not be the whole truth. Read widely round the subject, he might not have all the truth either.

Trixiefirecracker · 08/03/2022 08:14

Whatever is happening behind the scenes in Ukraine doesn’t warrant a war so I think that is why people are very against it and calling Putin a madman. In that respect it is very black and white. I think on platforms like this it appears there are very opposing views but the reality is different. I have several friends that haven’t been vaccinated, they are just waiting a while. I don’t consider them anti-vaxxers and they are not spouting loads of extremists nonsense, they are quietly going about their business. Some issues certainly polarise people but there are lots of folk voicing the grey areas too. I think mainstream media and SM has a lot to do with how it appears everyone seems ‘divided’ but that’s just not the case.

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/03/2022 08:06

I was interested until you got all conspiracy theorist.

Lambkin689 · 08/03/2022 08:05

And when I say pummelled, I don't mean legitimate debate. I mean threatening language and insults.

Lambkin689 · 08/03/2022 08:00

Best example of this is any pro-life comment on mumsnet... They get absolutely pummelled to the extent that I think pro-life people on here have just given up voicing their views altogether. I certainly have. Although usually these comments get deleted as even the admins can't cope with a view that offends their sensibilities to that extent.

VisaQuestions · 08/03/2022 07:55

This is just yet another way of trying to pad out Putin apologies isn’t it? There’s enough of it, we’ve all seen it.

I’m usually very strong with my words about nuanced understanding of the world, I believe in debate, free thinking and I hate tribal thinking.

That’s however got nothing to do with invading a sovereign nation, shelling civilians or attempting to oppress your own population into submission.

I mean Hitler had some good points, did wonders for the economy and employment, really good at bringing people together. Your argument is like saying ‘because the Spanish flu wasn’t always handled well we should also consider if his was a good leader.’

Some things are really wrong, have the balls to own an opinion on them- and if you aren’t sure get a bit more educated.

Hoardasurass · 08/03/2022 07:53

@allmixedup12 a couple of things that you may not be aware of 1st Russia is part of Nato so how would the Ukraine joining Russia in Nato be a reason for war?
2nd when you use terms such as sheep/sheepole you are the problem and are actively both othering and ridiculing anyone who disagrees with you

Sugarplumfairy65 · 08/03/2022 07:52

[quote allmixedup12]@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation No i am not for war nor do i know putin/russia well enough to have a real opinion, yet. I do think when incredibly ethical and high quality independent journalists write something, it is worth reading and thinking about than following like sheep[/quote]
John Pilger is neither an ethical nor high quality journalist.

Gowithme · 08/03/2022 07:48

Try living under Putin you're not allowed a different view at all there, the opposition is poisoned, people protesting against the war are imprisoned. Strange argument to me OP.

Motherofcats007 · 08/03/2022 07:41

I’ve not gone through all the responses but I totally agree with OP. Especially the extreme hatred for the other side, the name calling, telling them they should die just for having different views. I used to have a labour colleague who kept saying all tories are scums and must die (during universal credit roll out), she was otherwise just a normal person but openly saying someone must die because of their political views? Esp in England where most people are pretty centrist anyway, that is scary.

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/03/2022 07:36

Yes it’s a very polarising time.

It started pre SM I think but it is to do the mass media.

ThisIsGroundControl · 08/03/2022 07:26

I agree, I've posted alternative views on here and people get angry that I'm not 'listening' my thoughts 'won't be changed' I'm 'thick' etc, failing to see that I just have a difference of opinion and that is OK.

However as a counter there are so many voices on the Internet that are posted as having authority/the truth compared to MSM. With the idea MSM is only for sheep and those on the Internet are 'prophets '

bakebeans · 08/03/2022 07:18

YANBU. It’s gone mad!