Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think society has lost the ability to allow opposing views anymore

181 replies

allmixedup12 · 07/03/2022 23:57

there is no space left in the UK/US for opposing views anymore and any kind of debate feels totally polarizing. It seems the public has been dumbed down to understand black and white are the only two colours - i feel uncomfortable raising doubts anymore in public for the fear of being attacked

Brexit vs EU love
Trump vs Democrats
Covid vs Deniers/doubters
BLM vs I'm not racist, and no one else is either
Russia/China bad - UK/US good
NATO is innocent - Putin is Satan (neither is true)
woke vs not woke?
BBC vs RT
Indyref vs Union
Islamophobes vs Liberals

Insane how difficult it has become to voice opposing opinions without being attacked personally as a fascist/racist/insensitive/crazy

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 08/03/2022 10:28

@Polyanthus2

Young people can't debate properly or accept there is an alternative point of view. I'm pretty sure I had some very strong but ill-thought out views as a teen - cringe when I look back I don't think things have changed there.
What has changed is that your views would once not have progressed much further than the dinner table at home. Now with "social media", today's teens get a much bigger platform upon which to air their dodgy ideas.
GrolliffetheDragon · 08/03/2022 10:27

[quote stupidandconcearned]@GrolliffetheDragon I always wonder why we need to know any of this , surely the best person for the job should be the case
I don't care what sex, colour, religion they are
I think cv should be sent in stating applicant no. And no details other than work history , qualifications [/quote]
It's the equalities monitoring form, so the panel don't see it, it gets removed from the applications and is anonymous. It is literally just for monitoring purposes - if we didn't get applications from people from a BAME background we would look at why that was and consider if there were other places we could advertise - not actually a problem for us as we have close links with a number of BAME networks. We get a quite a few applications from LGB people as well - don't know about trans people as gender identity wasn't on our previous form. Don't have a problem with it being included at all, just annoyed that sex isn't included.

LaingsAcidTab · 08/03/2022 10:23

Pilger may be well-intentioned, but it doesn't mean he's right. I agree there are shades of grey. There are only ever shades of grey, which is a difficult stance to tolerate for most of us, and impossible for a few.

But wrt to what's going on in Ukraine and the wider politics, it always comes down to this for me: would I prefer to live in Russia, or in the UK? That tends to settle things quite quickly.

DottyHarmer · 08/03/2022 10:20

@stupidandconcearned of course it is not a good idea to discuss “controversial” subjects at work etc BUT it seems the prevailing wind is “if you’re not with us you’re against us” in some quarters. So if you say no thank you to displaying your preferred pronouns you’re a bigot.

I’ve just become aware of “bi-phobia” which apparently is not being open to bisexuality yourself Confused On an innocuous thread about the delights of Stanley Tucci, on came someone to berate the participants for their mono fancying Confused .

stupidandconcearned · 08/03/2022 10:19

@GrolliffetheDragon I always wonder why we need to know any of this , surely the best person for the job should be the case
I don't care what sex, colour, religion they are
I think cv should be sent in stating applicant no. And no details other than work history , qualifications

GrolliffetheDragon · 08/03/2022 10:16

Usually when people say "I feel like I can't even say what I think any more without fear of ", that's not a good sign. On MN they're usually opposed to trans rights, in the wider internet/world it'll generally be something racist/sexist/homophobic. Political correctness gorn mad innit. I'm ok with not hearing those views.

Ok - so in work we have a new Equalities Monitoring form, just introduced this year. It doesn't monitor the sex of applicants. I would like to raise this as an issue, but I don't think I can without marking myself as potentially transphobic. Is that reasonable? Is it transphobic to think that the sex of applicants should be included alongside gender identity, ethnicity, sexuality, religion and whether the person identified as disabled or not?

Bluebellsunderthetrees · 08/03/2022 10:06

OP you are completely correct and of course you will be called a Putin apologist.
Sadly facts/truths/grey areas on causes get pushed to one side if they don't fit and often do get picked up by those who are a bit or a lot left field ( not left in the political sense before my words get twisted!) and then discredited.
It's extremely alarming to watch people arguing for an escalation of this war and the basis they are coming to that conclusion on.

stupidandconcearned · 08/03/2022 10:06

Doesn't the old saying go never talk about politics and religion or something like that
I think certain things at work is just not appropriate , always know your audience as such and in work that may not be the case
But OP you seem to be following one journalist only and reading from that , and I guess tbh most people do not see justification in innocent people being called or having to flee their homes, there always has to be another way

DottyHarmer · 08/03/2022 10:02

It is interesting - or alarming - that in the US the Democrat Party was always very centrist, certainly not socialist. But now it has been hijacked by some with extreme views, which leaves middle-of-the-road voters with… what? Republicans?

Ds was reading a film book and mentioned that until relatively recently the stars would all mix, and a fair few would be Republicans as well as the liberals. Now it would be death to your career to be anything other than super woke.

I simply don’t understand how this has all happened, where moderate views can’t be discussed, and people genuinely fear for their jobs if they don’t buy into the Emperor’s New Clothes narrative.

mummykel16 · 08/03/2022 10:00

@allmixedup12

there is no space left in the UK/US for opposing views anymore and any kind of debate feels totally polarizing. It seems the public has been dumbed down to understand black and white are the only two colours - i feel uncomfortable raising doubts anymore in public for the fear of being attacked

Brexit vs EU love
Trump vs Democrats
Covid vs Deniers/doubters
BLM vs I'm not racist, and no one else is either
Russia/China bad - UK/US good
NATO is innocent - Putin is Satan (neither is true)
woke vs not woke?
BBC vs RT
Indyref vs Union
Islamophobes vs Liberals

Insane how difficult it has become to voice opposing opinions without being attacked personally as a fascist/racist/insensitive/crazy

This about sums it all up.
frownaminute · 08/03/2022 09:51

I think there's always been a human tendency to want to enforce rules, belong to a club and denounce heretics. The way people discuss trans rights on Twitter is not much different from old fashioned preachers threatening hellfire and damnation to anyone who didn't follow their rules to the letter, and believers competing to be the most virtuous.

The problem now is that we have social media, so it's not people ostracising their neighbours or denouncing unconventional women as witches, it's now very easy to anonymously organise bullying of ordinary people on a large scale, even to the point of petitioning their employers or inciting violence.

I still have respectful and nuanced discussions with friends about things like Brexit and trans rights. I don't know if the intolerance is just from a very noisy minority, but I am definitely much more fearful of talking about controversial topics with strangers or in public, and sometimes I keep my views quiet.

tempester28 · 08/03/2022 09:51

You are correct in my opinion and I have to wonder if this environment has been brought about intentionally to ruin our society.

JudgeJ · 08/03/2022 09:48

I always took the line that if you aren't saying anything racist, sexist etc then you have nothing to worry about, but then they came for me.

That's the problem, one group of highly opinionated people decide to rigidly define terms like 'racist' 'sexist' etc and then go around as judge, jury and executioner towards anyone who is not 101% on their self-defined message! I know of a few people on this site who have been called 'racist' for daring to ask questions about BLM etc., the funny thing is that they're 'of colour' themselves!
The truth is that free speech is dead now.

stuckdownahole · 08/03/2022 09:36

John Pilger is very much on the hard left and like many members of that tribe seems to have weird blind spots: usually it's Russia and Jews. He is capable of being more truthful than mainstream media in some situations, and less truthful in others.

allmixedup12 · 08/03/2022 09:30

First, on John Pilger, i find his content thought provoking. I read both sides - so I will read John Pilger but also David Nott. Just because I am raising a question is not a sign of blindedness/sheep behavior.

Most of his documentary work is freely available on this website. I havent seen anything yet which would make me doubt his motivations. Can you please share with me the facts/reasons why you doubt him ?

topdocumentaryfilms.com/

The really shocking one for me were the ones on palestinian crises.

Second, in any case, I am not married to his views, but i do very much find it interesting to see two sides of the same coin. This conversation for me is about whether being open minded on controversial topics is possible or not.

No one is debating war is bad, of course it is horrible. I cannot even imagine in from the comfort of my first world existence.

OP posts:
ItWorriesMeThisKindofThing · 08/03/2022 09:21

OP you are not open to accepting that Pilger could be wrong on this. That’s absolutely your right, but maybe you are following him like a “sheep” and therefore as guilty as the rest of us?

52andblue · 08/03/2022 09:08

.

forinborin · 08/03/2022 09:06

[quote allmixedup12]@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation No i am not for war nor do i know putin/russia well enough to have a real opinion, yet. I do think when incredibly ethical and high quality independent journalists write something, it is worth reading and thinking about than following like sheep[/quote]
John Pilger is high quality and incredibly ethical?

Ormally · 08/03/2022 09:01

@MangyInseam great posts. I was also deeply troubled to see some of the things universities were embracing but with blind spots as to actual practice or effects, or even consistent data/information when it comes to certain characteristics. I have known 3 very good EDI people act up to the same vacant senior role and then not be appointed, with challenges and suggestions ignored.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/03/2022 08:59

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation

I take it you're a putin apologist?
This is the exact issue OP was raising - if you introduce any nuance into an argument you must be an apologist for the bad people. It's so blinkered.
allmixedup12 · 08/03/2022 08:54

[quote ClemFandangoo]Definitely but this is a worldwide problem. The issue is people are in their own echo chambers on social media, they surround themselves with people who think like them and do when accosted with an opposite view they can’t cope. It’s like their whole world view has been changed.

This cartoon by the Oatmeal sums it up better than I ever could.

theoatmeal.com/comics/believe[/quote]
that oatmeal link is completely awesome. thanks for sharing.

OP posts:
Kylereese · 08/03/2022 08:54

I agree. The minute you try and discuss anything to do with the whole changing gender or sex thing you are immediately told you are transphobic. There doesn’t seem to be any middle ground of debate or exploration of views it’s one extreme to another

VisaQuestions · 08/03/2022 08:52

Then be calm, be informed and state your facts. Twisting words or pulling at a lack of knowledge is a common technique.

My family are in Ukraine, bar kids who’ve got to Poland. I went to the Trafalgar Square protest to be confronted first by a British National views with the f word and then a group of twats with hammer and sickle flags.

I wanted to slap someone or scream, at the Putin apologies too. I wanted to cry and rage.

But I just walked down to Parliament square with everyone else who was displaced and protested calmly. I wasn’t going to either back down because they were big men, nor give the news photo of me covered in blue and yellow attacking anyone.

If you believe in something you need the strength to stick with it.

PleaseDontDriveMeBlind · 08/03/2022 08:45

that so many accept that NATO expansion caused his war.

But I didn't even say it is the cause of the war. Wars don't just have one cause. I just said it was one factor more than anything, not that that legitimises anything or that the war is therefore fine, or that there aren't other more important reasons. I never got a chance to discuss it further than that because I was seen as saying it's ok then, which obviously it is not.
I'm well aware he views Ukraine as part of Russia, and maybe we would have gotten on to that as well had I not felt there's no point because my words were getting twisted to have intent that wasn't there.

MorrisZapp · 08/03/2022 08:44

I always took the line that if you aren't saying anything racist, sexist etc then you have nothing to worry about, but then they came for me.

The Scottish indyref was my first taste of being on the 'bad' side. It was a massive reset moment for me because it made me think, hang on, I know beyond doubt that I'm not a fascist. So maybe... some of the people I'd dismissed as mean, evil, full of hate or whatever in the past might actually be normal?

Then came the whole trans thing and I'm literally self censoring on social media so that I don't lose friends.

Looking at peaceful protesters being flung in police vans in Russia, clearly we live in a relatively free society. But we've become weirdly self policing, with the punishments being social rather than legal.

If you think 'yeah but I'm OK because I'm not a fascist' then good luck. My head is spinning from how suddenly I found my cuddly, liberal self on the baddie list.