Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think society has lost the ability to allow opposing views anymore

181 replies

allmixedup12 · 07/03/2022 23:57

there is no space left in the UK/US for opposing views anymore and any kind of debate feels totally polarizing. It seems the public has been dumbed down to understand black and white are the only two colours - i feel uncomfortable raising doubts anymore in public for the fear of being attacked

Brexit vs EU love
Trump vs Democrats
Covid vs Deniers/doubters
BLM vs I'm not racist, and no one else is either
Russia/China bad - UK/US good
NATO is innocent - Putin is Satan (neither is true)
woke vs not woke?
BBC vs RT
Indyref vs Union
Islamophobes vs Liberals

Insane how difficult it has become to voice opposing opinions without being attacked personally as a fascist/racist/insensitive/crazy

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 19:28

@GrolliffetheDragon

Usually when people say "I feel like I can't even say what I think any more without fear of ", that's not a good sign. On MN they're usually opposed to trans rights, in the wider internet/world it'll generally be something racist/sexist/homophobic. Political correctness gorn mad innit. I'm ok with not hearing those views.

Ok - so in work we have a new Equalities Monitoring form, just introduced this year. It doesn't monitor the sex of applicants. I would like to raise this as an issue, but I don't think I can without marking myself as potentially transphobic. Is that reasonable? Is it transphobic to think that the sex of applicants should be included alongside gender identity, ethnicity, sexuality, religion and whether the person identified as disabled or not?

So in my workplace, new hires are meant to do a very objective interview process that is points based. The person with the most points gets the job barring very serious issues.

But they also make a big deal of saying they are open to all kinds of identity groups and encouraging such people to self-identify.

Now, in a few cases this makes sense, if they need special accommodation for example. But in pretty much every instance except certain disabilities, there should be no reason this makes any difference to the interview process.

I've had more than one applicant wonder whether they are in fact preferencing some people who belong to certain groups but claiming not because it would be dodgy, or what the heck is going on. For others, they might wonder if in fact self-identifying might in reality make them less likely to be chosen.

But alas, it is not a discussion that can really be had.

FloBot7 · 08/03/2022 19:23

Yep. I found out yesterday that my work subscribes to Stonewall. I'm all for progressing the rights of trans men and women but not at the expense of biological women. It shouldn't be an either/or situation. We should be fighting for both. Stonewall's response to feminists fighting for women's rights is to scream BIGOTS!

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 19:22

I think there's always been a human tendency to want to enforce rules, belong to a club and denounce heretics. The way people discuss trans rights on Twitter is not much different from old fashioned preachers threatening hellfire and damnation to anyone who didn't follow their rules to the letter, and believers competing to be the most virtuous.

Yeah, I always think that if we went back 130 years these same people would be head of the Temperance Union.

Obbydoo · 08/03/2022 18:55

[quote allmixedup12]@cuno I've followed an investigative journalist named John Pilger for several years now and watched many of his documentaries, which opened my eyes on the realities of Iraq & Afghanistan wars, US-China diplomacy, NHS privatization etc. johnpilger.com/ Most times the reality was completely different from what was the popular opinion - which was also unfortunately my opinion before seeing reality

His tweets on the recent Ukraine crises and since then my reading up on the topic from credible sources has made me very very skeptical of mainstream media coverage of the war and i am starting to understand that the reality may be something completely different from what is fed on TV. As much as it breaks my heart for the individual families stuck in the middle of this crises, the causes of this seem far more complex than "Putin is a madman"

this is making me uncomfortable and I am afraid to speak up for fear of losing friends/job/being cancelled in some other form etc. etc. even my own family is looking at me with wtf eyes[/quote]
🤣🤣🤣 Ah the old 'I've done my research' line. You always know when someone says they've done their own research, they mean they have followed a load of conspiracy theorists links, especially when they throw in the phrase 'mainstream media'. If people are afraid of sharing their views it's probably because their 'views' are either incorrect or embarrassing. I am delighted peoole feel uncomfortable, hopefully that will stop them spreading their bigoted, scaremongering bile and crackpot conspiracy theories.

Hawkins001 · 08/03/2022 18:41

@allmixedup123
So along the lines of Goldman ect ?

Hawkins001 · 08/03/2022 18:39

"Mainstream media (MSM) is a term and abbreviation used to refer collectively to the various large mass news media that influence many people, and both reflect and shape prevailing currents of thought. The term is used to contrast with alternative media which can often present opinions, views or dissent from various stances."

allmixedup123 · 08/03/2022 18:27

[quote FavouriteFortnight]@Lilifer

Conspiracy theorists are not the only people to use the phrase mainstream media - what a ridiculous suggestion - what term then do you suggest we use to describe the dominant news outlets ??

I think it’s pretty clear what I meant. OP is talking about the output of John Piliger as “the truth” and then using it to question what is being “fed to us by mainstream media” that people are following “like sheep”.

Sorry, that’s the line of thinking that gets you into conspiracy theory territory. Yes, by all means listen to a range of voices, yes interrogate why they are saying what they are saying but assuming that one person with a fringe viewpoint is telling the truth and therefore everything else you hear must be a lie is not a healthy way to inform yourself.[/quote]
is Mearsheimer also “fringe” - or is anyone whose view is not mainstream automatically considered as non credible in your books?

Can you also explain why you think Pilger/Mearsheimer are not to be believed.

FavouriteFortnight · 08/03/2022 18:06

@Lilifer

Conspiracy theorists are not the only people to use the phrase mainstream media - what a ridiculous suggestion - what term then do you suggest we use to describe the dominant news outlets ??

I think it’s pretty clear what I meant. OP is talking about the output of John Piliger as “the truth” and then using it to question what is being “fed to us by mainstream media” that people are following “like sheep”.

Sorry, that’s the line of thinking that gets you into conspiracy theory territory. Yes, by all means listen to a range of voices, yes interrogate why they are saying what they are saying but assuming that one person with a fringe viewpoint is telling the truth and therefore everything else you hear must be a lie is not a healthy way to inform yourself.

LondonWolf · 08/03/2022 16:39

I posted a thread with almost this exact title about two years ago and was mainly told that some things shouldn't be allowed to be said or thought and anyone who defended the right to say them and was then "cancelled", deserved it. How things change.

Jaxhog · 08/03/2022 16:19

dare not

Jaxhog · 08/03/2022 16:18

You are right, sadly. You missed the trans v. feminism 'debate' (or lack of)

It's as if we've lost the ability or desire to listen to someone else's point of view other than to agree or disagree absolutely. To the extent where many of us dared expose our beliefs. It is truly sad.

Noodlewave · 08/03/2022 16:13

@MsMD

Donald Trump is a rapist who openly mocked women who had been assaulted.

No, I have absolutely no patience at all for people who think he is God.

Respecting opinions is for 'I like coffee. Well, I don't', NOT 'I like to sexually assault women'.

Ludicrous we need to explain this.

Justin Trudeau is a racist who repeatedly wore black face to social functions.

No, I have absolutely no patience at all for people who think he is God.

Respecting opinions is for 'I like coffee. Well, I don't', NOT 'I like to perpetuate racial stereotyping'.

Ludicrous we need to explain this.

Ncwinc · 08/03/2022 15:54

The media?

Lilifer · 08/03/2022 15:25

@FavouriteFortnight

Why does 'mainstream media' and 'sheep' suggest a slippery slope?

Because it’s the kind of language used by conspiracy theorists and other people with fringe views to justify their positions - that everyone else is blindly following the mainstream narrative but they are uniquely enlightened to know the truth.

It’s exactly that kind of thinking that leads to the polarisation of debate that the OP is complaining about.

Conspiracy theorists use the word "and"

I use the word "and" too

Does that make me a conspiracy theorist?

Conspiracy theorists are not the only people to use the phrase mainstream media - what a ridiculous suggestion - what term then do you suggest we use to describe the dominant news outlets ??

Lilifer · 08/03/2022 15:20

@MsMD

*74.2 million Americans voted for Trump in 2020. I doubt many of them think he is god.

I dont like Trump one bit. But you're kind of making my point where views from across the bench are "ludicrous*

The view that you can sexually assault women because you're rich and can get away with it? The view where some women could not have been raped because they're too ugly?

No, I will not respect those views so that you can shout about acceptance. It's sick.

I also think that in relation to Trump many of those people were voting republican, not necessarily because they like Trump so much as they just have always and will always vote republican because they are conservative in their political leaning. Someone who normally votes conservative is hardly going to vote for a democratic candidate because then they will have a democratic administration and so they stick with their republican vote regardless of the presidential candidate or their feelings about him.
Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 08/03/2022 15:15

Yea people are no longer using or learning critical thinking, even at universities.
For those who think it doesn't happen in real life, I've basically been cancelled by 3 family members and I've known one woman who has lost her job. I even had someone (my employee!) come into my office and take me to task over something I liked on LinkedIn.
It's ridiculous.
I've been called a racist by someone before they knew that my kids and partner are NOT white.
It all beggars belief.

Theluggage15 · 08/03/2022 15:14

I didn’t say NATO was the cause of the war, I said it was one of the reasons @VisaQuestions

MsMD · 08/03/2022 14:47

*74.2 million Americans voted for Trump in 2020. I doubt many of them think he is god.

I dont like Trump one bit. But you're kind of making my point where views from across the bench are "ludicrous*

The view that you can sexually assault women because you're rich and can get away with it? The view where some women could not have been raped because they're too ugly?

No, I will not respect those views so that you can shout about acceptance. It's sick.

Polyanthus2 · 08/03/2022 14:41

It's ok to complain about people being intolerant of others' views but the problem arises when the others' views are materialised as restrictions on the other side eg Brexit - nearly half the voters did not want to leave.
Inderef, nearly half the voters did want to leave, trans rights more than half the population have their rights restricted to allow trans rights to be increased.
Brexit and Indyref should have had sensible debate in parliament and a decision as to how big a majority is needed for such a major change in the country.
To say just accept the change and shut up won't work.

allmixedup123 · 08/03/2022 14:29

@Vitani

Had anyone seen the lecture on US-Russia-Ukraine from 6 years ago, given by John Mearsheimer at Chicago uni?

What's the general opinion on him?

For me this Mearsheimer video is what started it on this Ukraine topic and i start googling and found the alternative perspective. UChicago is quite respected but I do not know a lot more about Mearsheimer himself. Video was 2014, so maybe the world has changed. He is still teaching there though and not kicked out/cancelled
allmixedup123 · 08/03/2022 14:18

@MsMD

Donald Trump is a rapist who openly mocked women who had been assaulted.

No, I have absolutely no patience at all for people who think he is God.

Respecting opinions is for 'I like coffee. Well, I don't', NOT 'I like to sexually assault women'.

Ludicrous we need to explain this.

74.2 million Americans voted for Trump in 2020. I doubt many of them think he is god.

I dont like Trump one bit. But you're kind of making my point where views from across the bench are "ludicrous"

MsMD · 08/03/2022 13:58

Donald Trump is a rapist who openly mocked women who had been assaulted.

No, I have absolutely no patience at all for people who think he is God.

Respecting opinions is for 'I like coffee. Well, I don't', NOT 'I like to sexually assault women'.

Ludicrous we need to explain this.

balalake · 08/03/2022 13:47

I think OP what you describe started with Brexit and the unexpected 52% in favour.

FavouriteFortnight · 08/03/2022 13:42

Why does 'mainstream media' and 'sheep' suggest a slippery slope?

Because it’s the kind of language used by conspiracy theorists and other people with fringe views to justify their positions - that everyone else is blindly following the mainstream narrative but they are uniquely enlightened to know the truth.

It’s exactly that kind of thinking that leads to the polarisation of debate that the OP is complaining about.

Vitani · 08/03/2022 13:36

Had anyone seen the lecture on US-Russia-Ukraine from 6 years ago, given by John Mearsheimer at Chicago uni?

What's the general opinion on him?