Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think society has lost the ability to allow opposing views anymore

181 replies

allmixedup12 · 07/03/2022 23:57

there is no space left in the UK/US for opposing views anymore and any kind of debate feels totally polarizing. It seems the public has been dumbed down to understand black and white are the only two colours - i feel uncomfortable raising doubts anymore in public for the fear of being attacked

Brexit vs EU love
Trump vs Democrats
Covid vs Deniers/doubters
BLM vs I'm not racist, and no one else is either
Russia/China bad - UK/US good
NATO is innocent - Putin is Satan (neither is true)
woke vs not woke?
BBC vs RT
Indyref vs Union
Islamophobes vs Liberals

Insane how difficult it has become to voice opposing opinions without being attacked personally as a fascist/racist/insensitive/crazy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MasterBeth · 11/03/2022 08:16

No it hasn’t

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 11/03/2022 07:43

We should cancel cancel culture and replace it with impartial education across the board, from school to plaques on buildings. We need the intellectual tools to counter idiots and bots with an agenda with educated analysis. Make the dark underbelly of history known and explained. We need to be able to put things into context.
By the way, if we cancel Tschaikovski, how about Wagner?
It's ludicrous.
Knowledge is power. What we need more of is awareness of the full complexity (and sadly the awfulness) of human history. We are being infantilised currently.

debwong · 10/03/2022 16:35

@Allsorts1

Although OP I thought that NATO expansion was a pretty well accepted “motive” behind what Putin has done? No one is saying it is an acceptable motive but I thought it was standard news that NATO had expanded further than agreed and this is something that contributed to Putin’s actions? It’s sad that you feel unable to bring that up, but it is a sign of the times eg people calling you a “putin apologist” for even mentioning a well known fact!
NATO didn't "expand" of its own accord. Sovereign countries in eastern Europe applied to join NATO because they had been under the Russian boot from 1945 until 1990, and they didn't want to fall back under it.

Also, nothing was "agreed" in terms of expanding or not, because Russia has no veto over the foreign policy of those aforementioned sovereign countries.

LondonWolf · 10/03/2022 16:18

@worriedatthistime

Ive always been told two sides to every story and normally the truth lies somewhere in the middle , thats how i approach most articles etc these days
This is what I teach my children. However it's enough to get you called "racist" or "bigot" or "full of hate!" these days.
worriedatthistime · 10/03/2022 15:35

Ive always been told two sides to every story and normally the truth lies somewhere in the middle , thats how i approach most articles etc these days

FavouriteFortnight · 10/03/2022 13:23

i think social media has had a huge part to play in the lack of nuance. People try and reduce complex issues into 140 characters and you lose the depth as a result.

I think it definitely does that but it doesn’t HAVE to. I find Twitter now a really good place to educate myself. It exposes me to lots of experts and opinion that I wouldn’t otherwise have heard, and forces you evaluate your sources. If I see an interesting point argued I want to know more about who has made it, can I trust it, what else have they said.

I followed loads of epidemiologists and data scientists through covid and have started following military strategists and diplomats now.

DottyHarmer · 10/03/2022 09:59

I listed to that programme - very interesting.

I have a bottom imprinted with rusty barbed wire from fence sitting. Like probably many others I have mixed opinions on almost everything. I like some Conservative policies, I like some Labour policies and conversely hate many policies of both. But no, I’m Tory Scum whatever. If I am live and let live but want to retain women’s spaces I’m a bigot and probably on my way to the ducking stool for that and no doubt masses of other transgressions.

CatDogMonkeyPOW · 10/03/2022 09:23

There was a really good Radio 4 show about this called the death of nuance or something similar. Worth a listen.

I'd be wary of taking any one journalist at face value though OP. No matter how credible or worthy you think they are. Almost everyone has an agenda of some sort.

I think social media has had a huge part to play in the lack of nuance. People try and reduce complex issues into 140 characters and you lose the depth as a result. The more it happens the more black and white things become. Tribes are formed and suddenly anyone who disagrees is the enemy.

Covid really made this apparent. Lockdowns were a necessary evil at the start in my opinion but I was acutely aware that they would have significant negative impacts on individuals and society. However trying to express this got me lumped in with the deniers and labelled as a "granny killer."

DottyHarmer · 10/03/2022 08:45

Quite - cancelling Tchaikovsky Shock . As someone else pointed out, what about Shostakovich? Is he approved? Would people know he is approved ? The Classic FM Countdown this Easter is going to be a bit threadbare…..

Polyanthus2 · 10/03/2022 05:37

People are going crazy to de Russian-ify everything.

So much I would guess is being driven by what Twitter or other social media platform might say if they don't - and if the SM patform takes against you - look how that can spiral to huge consequences.

My point is that SM just amplifies everything to ridiculous levels so a 'normal' discussion is impossible - an example -The orchestra not performing Tchaikovsky at their upcoming concerts - well they would have run the risk of some SM deciding everyone should not attend their concerts as the orchestra was supporting Russia - and people are so busy being 'kind' and virtue signalling there is probably a risk of that happening.
So they are forced into this extreme position.
This is what happens with most arguments/discussions today.

allmixedup123 · 09/03/2022 21:20

[quote FavouriteFortnight]@MangyInseam

I don't think the OP was saying everyone has to agree with her POV. The point was that she was basically being told that her POV wasn't acceptable.

at which point a number of people came along and essentially said, don't be silly, views are all allowed except if they are stupid like yours.

We’ll much as I don’t think shouting someone down as being a “Putin apologist” is particularly constructive, at least it’s at engaging at some level with the substance of the argument.

What I was cautioning OP against was the temptation to slide into seeing things as truth and lies. As I said, it’s the basis of conspiracy theories, the worst of anti-vax and covid denier logic etc. It’s ducking meaningful engagement with debate, I substituting it with a belief that most people (sheep) are victims of cover up and conspiracy and only the enlightened few see the “truth”.

I’m not saying that’s the point OP is at, but the way she’s talking sounds as though she’s at risk of falling into that trap.[/quote]
Do you think it is possible you are at risk of consuming the consensus view without questioning it?

thanks for warning me what i'm at risk of

Polyanthus2 · 09/03/2022 07:50

He's 82

Valeriekat · 09/03/2022 05:33

@Theluggage15

Russia is not in NATO!!
They probably mean the NATO-Russia Council. Ie not NATO?
JimmyDurham · 09/03/2022 01:47

[quote allmixedup12]@cuno I've followed an investigative journalist named John Pilger for several years now and watched many of his documentaries, which opened my eyes on the realities of Iraq & Afghanistan wars, US-China diplomacy, NHS privatization etc. johnpilger.com/ Most times the reality was completely different from what was the popular opinion - which was also unfortunately my opinion before seeing reality

His tweets on the recent Ukraine crises and since then my reading up on the topic from credible sources has made me very very skeptical of mainstream media coverage of the war and i am starting to understand that the reality may be something completely different from what is fed on TV. As much as it breaks my heart for the individual families stuck in the middle of this crises, the causes of this seem far more complex than "Putin is a madman"

this is making me uncomfortable and I am afraid to speak up for fear of losing friends/job/being cancelled in some other form etc. etc. even my own family is looking at me with wtf eyes[/quote]
Pilger! Blimey, he must be nearly 90 by now.

deragod · 09/03/2022 01:23

I've just read Pilger nonsensical comment about invasion of Ukraine.
I can only answer with this link: freedomnews.org.uk/2022/03/04/fuck-leftist-westplaining/

FavouriteFortnight · 09/03/2022 00:16

@MangyInseam

I don't think the OP was saying everyone has to agree with her POV. The point was that she was basically being told that her POV wasn't acceptable.

at which point a number of people came along and essentially said, don't be silly, views are all allowed except if they are stupid like yours.

We’ll much as I don’t think shouting someone down as being a “Putin apologist” is particularly constructive, at least it’s at engaging at some level with the substance of the argument.

What I was cautioning OP against was the temptation to slide into seeing things as truth and lies. As I said, it’s the basis of conspiracy theories, the worst of anti-vax and covid denier logic etc. It’s ducking meaningful engagement with debate, I substituting it with a belief that most people (sheep) are victims of cover up and conspiracy and only the enlightened few see the “truth”.

I’m not saying that’s the point OP is at, but the way she’s talking sounds as though she’s at risk of falling into that trap.

LondonWolf · 08/03/2022 21:12

@VladmirsPoutine

I wonder if most of it is just annoyance that now there are real consequences to airing bigoted, racist / whatever views. The people who scream the loudest about cancel culture basically want a free pass to say whatever they like with no consequence.
It's really worrying that people are still saying this and in doing so defending the suppression of free speech. Sometimes I think though, that those who say it have gained somehow from the current social status being a victim of some kind endows them and so enjoy cancel culture, excuse it and are loathe to give it up.
mummykel16 · 08/03/2022 21:01

@VladmirsPoutine

I wonder if most of it is just annoyance that now there are real consequences to airing bigoted, racist / whatever views. The people who scream the loudest about cancel culture basically want a free pass to say whatever they like with no consequence.
Though I'm sure JKR would appreciate your words.
mummykel16 · 08/03/2022 20:59

What tosh

VladmirsPoutine · 08/03/2022 20:55

I wonder if most of it is just annoyance that now there are real consequences to airing bigoted, racist / whatever views. The people who scream the loudest about cancel culture basically want a free pass to say whatever they like with no consequence.

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 20:50

[quote FavouriteFortnight]@allmixedup123

is Mearsheimer also “fringe” - or is anyone whose view is not mainstream automatically considered as non credible in your books?

Can you also explain why you think Pilger/Mearsheimer are not to be believed.

Where did I say they were non credible or not to be believed?

It’s not about dismissing people because they don’t have a mainstream view. But it’s equally not about accepting that they hold the “truth”. They have opinions and use evidence to back them up. By all means engage and critically evaluate what they say (same as you would with any opinion), agree or disagree.

If OP had said “I agree with what John Pilger has to say” then fair enough. It’s the assertion that it’s the “truth” and that everything in the “mainstream media” should be treated sceptically is where it gets problematic.[/quote]
I don't think the OP was saying everyone has to agree with her POV. The point was that she was basically being told that her POV wasn't acceptable.

at which point a number of people came along and essentially said, don't be silly, views are all allowed except if they are stupid like yours.

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 20:47

@Ncwinc

The media?
There is a real differentiation between big, established media, and many of the smaller, more independent media sources.

And then there are also things like personal websites or blogs.

There are also some which fall in between these categories. These are well established different types of publications and if you were to go to a university journalism program they would talk about them as different.

PleaseDontDriveMeBlind · 08/03/2022 20:01

I’ve just become aware of “bi-phobia” which apparently is not being open to bisexuality yourself confused

Well that's ridiculous. I'm bi and biphobia is just the same as homophobia but directed at bisexuals. The sort of "oh bisexuals are greedy/shag around/can't decide/confused/doesn't make sense/more likely to cheat/always up for a threesome" type of stuff.

FavouriteFortnight · 08/03/2022 19:57

@allmixedup123

is Mearsheimer also “fringe” - or is anyone whose view is not mainstream automatically considered as non credible in your books?

Can you also explain why you think Pilger/Mearsheimer are not to be believed.

Where did I say they were non credible or not to be believed?

It’s not about dismissing people because they don’t have a mainstream view. But it’s equally not about accepting that they hold the “truth”. They have opinions and use evidence to back them up. By all means engage and critically evaluate what they say (same as you would with any opinion), agree or disagree.

If OP had said “I agree with what John Pilger has to say” then fair enough. It’s the assertion that it’s the “truth” and that everything in the “mainstream media” should be treated sceptically is where it gets problematic.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 08/03/2022 19:39

[quote DottyHarmer]@stupidandconcearned of course it is not a good idea to discuss “controversial” subjects at work etc BUT it seems the prevailing wind is “if you’re not with us you’re against us” in some quarters. So if you say no thank you to displaying your preferred pronouns you’re a bigot.

I’ve just become aware of “bi-phobia” which apparently is not being open to bisexuality yourself Confused On an innocuous thread about the delights of Stanley Tucci, on came someone to berate the participants for their mono fancying Confused .[/quote]
You're KIDDING! Ffs