Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't think all men 18-60 should be forced to fight and not allowed to leave Ukraine. It should be the choice of individual men and women.

157 replies

Jjjayfee · 07/03/2022 22:17

I just saw a young father in tears as he said goodbye to his wife and baby. He is not allowed to leave Ukraine, but has to stay and fight. I think it should be a choice of individual men and women.

OP posts:
FloraPostePosts · 08/03/2022 01:01

If men and women all stayed behind then child refugees would be on their own. It happened with evacuees in ww2 but it is a bit of pot luck; some were lucky with the families they stayed with and some weren’t. I imagine it would be scary from the children to be separated from both parents unless they absolutely had to.

This is true, but even more pertinent is the fact that the evacuation of children was only possible because we hadn’t yet been invaded, so had control of our own transport system. This isn’t the case in Ukraine, where the Russians are already in the country, disrupting transport and posing danger to civilians. There’s no way it would be remotely safe to send unaccompanied children anywhere there at the moment.

beanbaggalore · 08/03/2022 00:47

I haven't read the full thread.
I think it would be expected. Who else can fight otherwise?!
Unfortunately rape is used as a weapon of war against women so men staying does make more sense from this point of view. Whether we like it or not women are much more likely to be vulnerable.
Rapes of Ukrainian women have been occurring by Russian soldiers. according to some sources, they then kill the women,

CityHigh · 08/03/2022 00:47

All together now, sisters : ‘What do we want?’

‘Equality!’

‘When do we want it?’

‘Er, only when it suits us, thanks. Definitely not when it might involve getting shot at, which sounds horrid. So we’ll leave that to the men.’

Equality is not possible when rape is commonly used as a wartime weapon. Obviously I’m not saying that men can’t get raped but when you look at the precedent that is set by using this as a weapon, it’s the women that they are raping. And men can’t get pregnant. We are already starting on uneven footing.

Nanny0gg · 08/03/2022 00:40

@montysma1

I wouldnt fight politicians wars for them. Its the fact that the population is willing to be told to do this that let's there be wars at all. The politicians who cause them certainly aren't out there getting shot at. Why should anybody else.
Oh.

So they should have just rolled over and let Russia invade and take over their country then, yes?

Nanny0gg · 08/03/2022 00:37

@blackcurrantjam

I think it's possible to want to stay and fight and also cry on leaving family members. If I was in a position to do so, I'd stay and fight or contribute in some way, even get the children to help if at all possible like some are doing.
You wouldn't want the children sent to safety?
Nanny0gg · 08/03/2022 00:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

PigletJohn · 08/03/2022 00:32

@Clarabe1

It’s worth remembering that it was only 80 years ago that we conscripted men into the army and we would do it again if need be. It’s the realities of war.
1963 was not 80 years ago.
PlanetNormal · 08/03/2022 00:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BoredtoTiers · 08/03/2022 00:18

YABU inasmuch as we cannot pretend that sex differences are not real; that age differences are not real when it comes to on the ground combat.

We can smooth over them in civilised society because when we are civilised they don't matter so much. When we are not, the reality that young women are bearing / raising the children, that young men are generally best placed for physical fighting isn't sexism or ageism - it's just reality. Some nature, some socialisation.

It looks like a good many women are also fighting but this is a crisis, not a job fair. (There is also of course a question about the use of conscription in general.)

XelaM · 08/03/2022 00:13

The Ukrainian men I know had every chance to leave (all very wealthy) but chose to stay in Kiev yo protect their country. It's like WWII - their homeland is under attack.

Whereas my uncle and cousins (boys in their 20-s) in Moscow want to flee in case Putin declares a state of emergency and forces my cousins into the army. No one wants to fight this war for Putin.

Tilltheend99 · 08/03/2022 00:03

@Jjjayfee

If it happened here would it not be fairer if men and women had to stay behind then?
If men and women all stayed behind then child refugees would be on their own. It happened with evacuees in ww2 but it is a bit of pot luck; some were lucky with the families they stayed with and some weren’t. I imagine it would be scary from the children to be separated from both parents unless they absolutely had to.

Interestingly, on the news tonight it said many women were dropping the children off in neighbouring countries and going back to work at the power station etc to keep things running for those trapped

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/03/2022 00:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/03/2022 23:59

@ChangeNameagain2

I have to be honest, I'm in awe of the bravery of these people. But if this happened here, there isn't a hope in hell my husband or oldest son would be staying behind. I don't care how I would get them out. We were talking about it the other night and honestly I'd push them down the stairs, break a leg on each on them, anything, I just couldn't imagine fleeing with 3 kids, our foster daughter and leaving them behind. I had been wondering if some people are exempt eg my husband is a surgeon, so would he be allowed/needed to keep on working? Aware of how much of selfish coward this makes me!
I know what you mean but it’s your home and your long term future they’d be defending by staying. And it’s your children you’d be protecting by leaving (unless you had someone else to take them and could stay too.)

If your husband’s a surgeon he’d working as a doctor not fighting. I’m guessing he’d want to stay?

PlanetNormal · 07/03/2022 23:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

merrymelodies · 07/03/2022 23:53

There are more ways of fighting than going into actual battle, armed to the teeth and hurling grenades or whatever.

ChangeNameagain2 · 07/03/2022 23:52

I have to be honest, I'm in awe of the bravery of these people. But if this happened here, there isn't a hope in hell my husband or oldest son would be staying behind. I don't care how I would get them out. We were talking about it the other night and honestly I'd push them down the stairs, break a leg on each on them, anything, I just couldn't imagine fleeing with 3 kids, our foster daughter and leaving them behind. I had been wondering if some people are exempt eg my husband is a surgeon, so would he be allowed/needed to keep on working? Aware of how much of selfish coward this makes me!

CheshireChat · 07/03/2022 23:52

@montysma1 a significant proportion of Ukrainian politians are fighting. Their parliament also had an emergency meeting, they were definitely targets.

I did hear a Russian mother make the exact point you're making though!

CheshireChat · 07/03/2022 23:49

There's already human traffickers trying to lure Ukrainian women as well.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 07/03/2022 23:49

@montysma1

I wouldnt fight politicians wars for them. Its the fact that the population is willing to be told to do this that let's there be wars at all. The politicians who cause them certainly aren't out there getting shot at. Why should anybody else.
Well the Ukrainian president doesn't seem to be hiding away, and apparently there's been at least three attempts on his life already.
CheshireChat · 07/03/2022 23:48

If both men and women remain behind, who'll take care of children and the elderly.

We don't even have a decent system to tackle and punish rape and sexual crimes during peace, let alone during a war.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/03/2022 23:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

montysma1 · 07/03/2022 23:42

I wouldnt fight politicians wars for them.
Its the fact that the population is willing to be told to do this that let's there be wars at all.
The politicians who cause them certainly aren't out there getting shot at. Why should anybody else.

jcyclops · 07/03/2022 23:37

Ideally it should be totally voluntary, but in the current situation I think that children should be evacuated with one parent of either sex, and fit people without children should be conscripted irrespective of their sex.

In WW2, British children in target areas were evacuated without their parents, and women were conscripted in some countries including UK and USSR. The USA was about to conscript women for the invasion of Japan, but the atomic bomb brought peace before it was enacted.

Nowadays, several countries have existing legislation for national service or to conscript women as well as men, but in some it is not currently in use or is restricted to volunteers, and in other cases to certain professions (such as medics). As more countries remove historic restrictions on women in combat roles, the conscription of women is growing.

M0RVEN · 07/03/2022 23:33

[quote karcar]@PlanetNormal
Seriously??[/quote]
No he’s not serious, he’s just taking the piss.

What jolly japes ! Mocking the people of Ukraine. So clever and amusing Hmm Angry

PlanetNormal · 07/03/2022 23:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.