Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't think all men 18-60 should be forced to fight and not allowed to leave Ukraine. It should be the choice of individual men and women.

157 replies

Jjjayfee · 07/03/2022 22:17

I just saw a young father in tears as he said goodbye to his wife and baby. He is not allowed to leave Ukraine, but has to stay and fight. I think it should be a choice of individual men and women.

OP posts:
Onionpatch · 08/03/2022 07:05

To be honest, considering the war came with two weeks notice (or more) and has been going in for 10 days, it looks like the vast majority of men and women have stayed put.

It must be terrifying to be told you have to stay and fight and cant leave and i am not surprised some men want escape. Particularly if you feel the war wont be won or that it should have been prevented by diplomacy over the last few years.

GoodnessTruthBeauty · 08/03/2022 07:05

Studies have shown that women are much more successful at protecting and keeping children alive, especially small children. It makes sense that they care for the children but have the choice to fight if they wish. We have been blessed with peace. My parents were in cities being bombed during WW2 and were evacuated as small children. Both my granddad and great grandad were conscripted and fought in WW2 and WW1.

Rosieposie101 · 08/03/2022 07:05

I think it's absolutely disgraceful and making a horrendous situation even more unbearable, not only for the men having to fight but also for the women terrified for their husbands and children terrified for their fathers. Truly awful and unacceptable.

Unpopular37 · 08/03/2022 07:03

well said, @BoredToTiers !

Unpopular37 · 08/03/2022 07:02

**limited, not unlimited

Unpopular37 · 08/03/2022 07:01

@vickyc90

Honestly I would make it all men and woman who do not have children. I would also make it so those of limited benefit to society go to the front line firsts. So prisoners etc are used first, over a father with a good education and professional job as that who you need left to rebuild.

Interestingly both me and DH come from military families and none of them support national service

How the fuck would you decide who is 'of unlimited benefit to society'? Those who are in prison, or those who are physically/mentally incapable? Or will it be those you are predujuced against, because you clearly have criteria established in your mind... You have no knowledge of the circumstances surrounding someone's reason for being in prison, so why should you judge them to be cannon fodder. Let's hope none of your family ever have a brush with the law
TYbakedpotato · 08/03/2022 07:00

Mandatory conscription is awful.

War is worse. They're just reacting to the crisis they've been dealt. I can't judge Ukraine for that, especially when their president is actively leading the country from the front line and hasn't taken the offer to run away.

I don't think you can impose detailed criteria. I mean, if you said men between 18 and 60, with BMI below 30, who has time to weigh them all at the border when you're potentially about to get bombed? Something as basic as age and weight is easier to manage.

I can't believe it's 2022 and a war like this is going on, with no one intervening. The stories of civilians dying are just devastating, especially the ones of the little children.

This world is just terrible. Terrible.

CarBump2022 · 08/03/2022 06:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

longwayoff · 08/03/2022 06:54

You obviously have not grasped how serious this is for Ukraine and the rest of the world. It's not the time for gender wars and if you can't see what's coming you're probably lucky. Grow up.

Alisae · 08/03/2022 06:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post.

Flapjak · 08/03/2022 06:49

Also is the russian army mostly men? Juat wonder how it would play out if one army was mostly men and thr other 50/50.male/female

vickyc90 · 08/03/2022 06:48

Honestly I would make it all men and woman who do not have children. I would also make it so those of limited benefit to society go to the front line firsts. So prisoners etc are used first, over a father with a good education and professional job as that who you need left to rebuild.

Interestingly both me and DH come from military families and none of them support national service

Unpopular37 · 08/03/2022 06:47

@Jjjayfee

If it happened here would it not be fairer if men and women had to stay behind then?
Is this a wind-up or have you really not attempted to think about the two questions you have asked?
DDivaStar · 08/03/2022 06:46

It would be nice to give the choice and consider equality.

War is not nice its brutal.

malificent7 · 08/03/2022 06:40

I'm going to contradict a lot here and say that noone should be forced to fight. For example, if someone invaded the uk is it right that i fight if:

  1. I am a coward.
  2. I am a pacifist.
  3. I am not patriotic.
  4. I'd rather escape to a peaceful country and have a decent shot at life than battle against an insurmountable enemy and most likely die.
Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori.

Having said that they are all immensely brave whereas I'm a lazy coward!

ThinWomansBrain · 08/03/2022 05:04

I don't think Putin should be able to invade one country after another and take more issue with that.

IndigoC · 08/03/2022 02:47

I don’t think the state should ever coerce individuals into forced violent acts, male or female.

TibetanTerrah · 08/03/2022 02:33

@TibetanTerrah

That's all well and good but there are reports of men trying to 'escape' in the boots of cars and they're getting picked up and sent back.

If you think the UK wouldn't do that, maybe they would or wouldn't, if they wouldn't, just appreciate your privilege and leave it at that.

This is from Sky News earlier:

Ukrainian men try to escape country in car boots
Men have hidden in the boots of cars and jumped on trains in desperate attempts to flee Ukraine, the country's ministry of internal affairs has said.

In its latest update, the ministry said some men had also pretended to be foreigners or tried to bribe border guards.

Ukrainian men of fighting age are currently not allowed to leave the country and are being strongly encouraged to fight against Russian forces.

One man was discovered in the boot of his wife's Lexus at a border checkpoint in Luzhanka on the Hungary-Ukraine border.

Another was found hiding among possessions in the boot of a Mitsubishi car.

The man had then tried to pay the border guards,

Another man jumped on a train and tried to cross the border without passing border control, the ministry said.

Sorry my message was for @ChangeNameagain2
TibetanTerrah · 08/03/2022 02:32

That's all well and good but there are reports of men trying to 'escape' in the boots of cars and they're getting picked up and sent back.

If you think the UK wouldn't do that, maybe they would or wouldn't, if they wouldn't, just appreciate your privilege and leave it at that.

This is from Sky News earlier:

Ukrainian men try to escape country in car boots
Men have hidden in the boots of cars and jumped on trains in desperate attempts to flee Ukraine, the country's ministry of internal affairs has said.

In its latest update, the ministry said some men had also pretended to be foreigners or tried to bribe border guards.

Ukrainian men of fighting age are currently not allowed to leave the country and are being strongly encouraged to fight against Russian forces.

One man was discovered in the boot of his wife's Lexus at a border checkpoint in Luzhanka on the Hungary-Ukraine border.

Another was found hiding among possessions in the boot of a Mitsubishi car.

The man had then tried to pay the border guards,

Another man jumped on a train and tried to cross the border without passing border control, the ministry said.

Weatherwax13 · 08/03/2022 02:18

@PlanetNormal I think you should check your bearings. Because that's definitely not the planet you're on

BasiliskStare · 08/03/2022 02:12

@PlanetNormal - Seriously Morcambe and Wise are funnier than you

Have you read about the fall of Berlin & what happened to women there - or Bosnia ?

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 01:57

Well I suppose if some men prefer they can run away. But if the Ukrainians prevail such people might reasonably not expect to be welcomed back by those who stayed behind.

Why should they be if they won't try and protect their country?I realize that seems uncivilized to pampered individualistic westerners, but it's really what it comes down to, isn't it?

FarangGirl · 08/03/2022 01:48

While Ukrainian fertility is low, it's because a lot of women have one child and stop rather than very large numbers remaining childless. And the age at first birth in Ukraine is very young compared to western European countries - early 20s is normal. So a relatively high proportion of young women will already be mothers to young children.

In most countries of the world, mandatory conscription is only for men. Only a handful apply it to women as well.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/03/2022 01:12

Beats getting shot at, though, doesn’t it?

I'd rather get shot at than raped as part of genocide. And the Russians, historically, are famous for it.

And feminism, at least mine, isn't about equality. It's about freeing women from the patriarchy. War being part of the patriarchy. Any wars fought between two female leaders? Like, ever?

Chitchatchatter · 08/03/2022 01:05

Men are physically stronger and women are more generally caregivers. As has been said previously, rape is a weapon of war, the rape of the women of Berlin in the last war by Russian soldiers is a well documented example. Apart from the horror of the act itself, it's a way of demoralising and destabilising a fighting force or any post-battle resistance. There's also the aspect of getting the next generation away to safety should the present generation of men that are fighting not survive.