Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't think all men 18-60 should be forced to fight and not allowed to leave Ukraine. It should be the choice of individual men and women.

157 replies

Jjjayfee · 07/03/2022 22:17

I just saw a young father in tears as he said goodbye to his wife and baby. He is not allowed to leave Ukraine, but has to stay and fight. I think it should be a choice of individual men and women.

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 08/03/2022 08:39

@vickyc90 hell yeah. Actually we should send toddlers first to soak up some bullets, can always produce more. Then maybe people with disabilities and anyone with a swarthy complexion Hmm

Back in the real world and away from your Fourth Reich fantasy, the best soldiers are generally made by those with the most to lose. I think you might find your prisoners and other undesirables are pretty hard to convince that it's a cause worth dying for.

sala7 · 08/03/2022 08:37

Oh fgs. If you’re being attacked by armies of men with tanks and heavy machinery and weapons, you’re hardly going to send women to deal with that are you?

To put it this way for you OP - if you thought you were being burgled in the night, who would go down first - you or your husband?

It’s all very well to pretend biological and gender differences don’t exist in the safe bubble of a privileged society. But when it’s about survival, men will inevitably take on certain roles and women others. You don’t even need to be in a war - if you grow up basically living hand to mouth off the land, there are physical tasks that it’s just more efficient for men to do, so other tasks fall to women. You don’t have the luxury of standing around, pontificating in MN fashion - “ooh but is this sexist - are things 50/50?” You’re too busy surviving and keeping your children alive.

Trainbear · 08/03/2022 08:37

@PlanetNormal

It’s appalling sexism. Women are allowed to flee to safety but men have to stay and fight. As feminists we should call out such backward, patriarchal nonsense.
Surely as a feminist you mean that women should be allowed to defend their country too?
kingat · 08/03/2022 08:33

@CheshireChat

There's already human traffickers trying to lure Ukrainian women as well.
I have read reports in first few days from Poland that traffickers show up at the boarder offering transport. They now register who every person leaves with.
SmallPrawnEnergy · 08/03/2022 08:31

@PlanetNormal it’s IWD, shouldn’t you be off with the rest of your ilk on Twitter complaining that there’s no IMD? Which there is obviously, but you’re clearly a bit hard up when it comes to brain cells.

FarangGirl · 08/03/2022 08:29

@vickyc90

Honestly I would make it all men and woman who do not have children. I would also make it so those of limited benefit to society go to the front line firsts. So prisoners etc are used first, over a father with a good education and professional job as that who you need left to rebuild.

Interestingly both me and DH come from military families and none of them support national service

OMG! Are you serious?! You're dabbling dangerously with eugenics there. Next you'd suggest the disabled should go clear minefields with their bodies since they are 'of limited benefit to society' Surely this is parody?!
ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 08/03/2022 08:25

If only children were sent away during a war, how could they hope to return to their homeland when the war is over and their parents and adult family are dead?

Surely, they need at least one parent left to look after them and take them home in the future, otherwise what was the point of the war? The whole population should have just left as soon as they were invaded if they weren't planning to go back.

That makes no sense and isn't what the Ukrainians have done.

forinborin · 08/03/2022 08:22

‘Er, only when it suits us, thanks. Definitely not when it might involve getting shot at, which sounds horrid. So we’ll leave that to the men.’
Incredible that you throw this criticism at Ukraine, which had one of the highest female participation in armed forces in the world, and not just tokenistic - there's a female general, for example. Of course, the situation that is ridiculed by the Russian propaganda. And the language evolved to include a "sister-in-arms" term, used by women and men.

GroggyLegs · 08/03/2022 08:22

Women in war isn't equal. Women are at a disadvantage in the services.

Physically were less strong.
Rape is used as a weapon.
Body armour is made for men.
The guns provided are made for men.
Sexual assault & harassment in mixed barracks
Coping with periods.
And that's without the other social stuff e.g. being needed to repopulate, caring responsibilities.

Women WILL stay, women WILL be in support roles, but don't kid yourself that a woman on the battlefield is 'equal opportunities'.

She's in an arena made for men & at a disadvantage.

BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 08:16

@Ponoka7

None of that equals a push for gender equality - it’s just women in their feminine roles having more power in specific societies as compared to others societies. Norman times were hardly an example of gender equality pre industrial revolution, cmon.

It’s like the difference between being ruled over by the Taliban and not being able to go anywhere without an escort and not being able to show your face - as opposed to being a woman in Victorian England. One is more impressive than the other but neither have anything to do with equality.

Porcupineintherough · 08/03/2022 08:13

The truth is that only societies where people are prepared to fight for their patch get to have a country - and often not even then if a bigger army comes along. Women are always asking why men are so violent, well this is why. So that they are prepared to fight off other men to protect what is "theirs".

BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 08:10

@godmum56

That’s an easy justification for modern times - the much simpler and more obvious explanation is that men are both much better at fighting (on the whole) and women are inclined to avoid it.

It’s not like there have been meetings in olden times where sending women to battle has been discussed and decided against because they bear children - it’s much simpler than that, it’s just natural gender instincts playing out.

forinborin · 08/03/2022 08:08

I imagine the majority of them stay behind voluntarily. No one is forcibly sending men to die on the front lines in Ukraine. There's no reason to give a gun to someone who doesn't want it, there are more volunteers than weapons at the moment, Ukrainians are coming back home from all over the world. Plenty of childless women and women with adult children stay behind too.

Ponoka7 · 08/03/2022 08:06

@BigOlDingleSlinger69
"That’s the same reason there was no push for gender equality until society was relatively safe "

What society are you talking about? Women in other cultures, way before the industrial Revolution took part in decision making (early politics). In Norman times sex equality was higher than in later years, for example. But sex equality would vary around the world and within tribes. Look at the Egyptian example compared with what was happening elsewhere at the time. The difference in sex equality within religions. Sex equality starts with a right to life, which is denied many girls and then it goes on a scale.

I know it's often denied on here and in RL, but male bodies are more efficient fighting machines and as said, on average women keep vulnerable people alive more efficiently during a crisis.

@vickyc90, you think that it's the professionals that rebuild war torn countries? The world can supply professional input etc what's needed is grunt workers, those with building skills and people who can keep those people fed and clean up after them. Professionals being needed are way down the list, unless medically trained.

itsallbeyondshit · 08/03/2022 07:58

I understand if you have kids, but no way would I leave my boyfriend here to fight on his own

supermoonrising · 08/03/2022 07:47

@MrsTerryPratchett
War being part of the patriarchy. Any wars fought between two female leaders? Like, ever?

This is why some people don’t take feminism seriously. Throughout history, women in positions of power have been every bit as bloodthirsty as men.

bumblingbovine49 · 08/03/2022 07:46

@DickVanDyke26

As a mother of a 10 year old son, this is my worst nightmare.
It gets worse when they are 17 b
supermoonrising · 08/03/2022 07:40

@BigOlDingleSlinger69
*Of course your right but the reality is Gender equality is an artificial construct which was only remotely possible after the industrial revolution. As soon as there’s even the slightest breakdown in society things start to revert to what they always were in terms of gender roles.

This is what makes the whole “men have always oppressed women” absurd - whenever there’s any kind of breakdown in the industrialised well functioning society it becomes clear that gender roles are just something naturally followed when they are needed, not forced.*

Pretty much. Which is also why historically men have always preferred male leaders, too. If someone is going to tell me to prepare to go and fight and probably die, I expect to see them (ie another man) doing the same. In modern times, that’s symbolised by Zelensky’s action of “staying to fight” which raises the morale of the male fighters and has women worldwide gushing about his heroism.

bumblingbovine49 · 08/03/2022 07:38

@Jjjayfee

If it happened here would it not be fairer if men and women had to stay behind then?
Women are fighting in Ukraine but they do have a choice . It is men who don't have a choice but actually the rules say if a man has 3 children or more under 18 they can leave too. I imagine if they are the sole carerer for children they might be able to leave as well though I am not sure . The rules are about making sure there are enough people to fight whilst their vulnerable citizens are also taken care of

As for conscription , a lot of men might choose to leave ( I don't blame them at all) but if they did Ukraine would have fewer fighters. The government knows people need a nudge sometimes to be brave in such dangerous circumstances. I know that if I had a choice I'd try to get to safety but if not I'd try to fight rather than hide a d many will feel the same .

godmum56 · 08/03/2022 07:35

sorry, I mean of course "it needs less men than women"

godmum56 · 08/03/2022 07:34

[quote karcar]@LibrariesGiveUsPower
Plus, I can't speak for the Ukraine but at least here the majority of caring responsibilities are with women. Children and the elderly. [/quote]
not just caring responsibilities.....its a very very very old concept...I mean first settlements old. In order to keep a civilisation going with its belief sets, genes and so on, it needs more men than women. One man can impregnate many women but one woman can only usually bear one or two children at a time and it takes 9 months to make one and many years for it to grow up....so you protect the women and send the men....same with horses, you don't send your mares into battle unless its essential and you ear the bulls first if you need meat......I said it was an old concept.

spotcheck · 08/03/2022 07:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes a deleted post

BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 07:30

Of course your right but the reality is Gender equality is an artificial construct which was only remotely possible after the industrial revolution. As soon as there’s even the slightest breakdown in society things start to revert to what they always were in terms of gender roles.

This is what makes the whole “men have always oppressed women” absurd - whenever there’s any kind of breakdown in the industrialised well functioning society it becomes clear that gender roles are just something naturally followed when they are needed, not forced.

You can see that in the upset reactions here - despite the belief in equality here, the idea that should it be truly dangerous instead of desirable, women will take on the same roles as men - is a offensive idea to most of Mumsnet.

That’s the same reason there was no push for gender equality until society was relatively safe - the truth is gender equality is only desirable to most women when the amount they gain outweighs the amount they potentially lose and there’s a vast safety net to support them in it. It’s a phony equality basically.

DickVanDyke26 · 08/03/2022 07:28

As a mother of a 10 year old son, this is my worst nightmare.

DDivaStar · 08/03/2022 07:21

@vickyc90

Honestly I would make it all men and woman who do not have children. I would also make it so those of limited benefit to society go to the front line firsts. So prisoners etc are used first, over a father with a good education and professional job as that who you need left to rebuild.

Interestingly both me and DH come from military families and none of them support national service

You can't start using complicated rules in a war zone.